Coverage in the New York Herald of the Johann Heinrich Schulte murder and the initial coroner's inquest. These reports are mostly hand-transcribed, so please report any errors you find.
Murdered by Tramps
South Norwalk, Conn., Dec. 27, 1878.A terrible murder was committed on Roton Hill, near the town of Norwalk, at about half-past seven o’clock this evening. The victim was Mr. Shulte [sic], a wealthy gentleman, residing on the Hill. It is believed the murder was committed by tramps, who were informed that Mr. Shulte carried a large sum of money on his person, and had concealed in his house nearly $50,000, and was in the habit of having large sums so concealed, in preference to the safety of bank vaults. The murder was committed near his own residence, and his servant, William Buchholz was also attacked at the same time. The murdered man’s head was cut open with a hatchet, and a small would, apparently made with a knife, was found under the left ear. Great excitement prevails at present.
Who Killed Him?
—
Progress of the inquest on the body of John Henry Schultz [sic] – Attacked in the dark by four men – Testimony of his servant.
(By telegraph to the Herald)
New Haven, Conn., Dec. 28, 1878.The jury of inquest impanelled last night to consider how John Henry Schultz [sic], who was murdered Friday night while returning to his home accompanied by his servant, William Buchhols [sic], came to his death, made little progress. Buchols was only partly heard, and this afternoon the jury adjourned to Tuesday forenoon. Buchhols told his story in a straightforward way. He said that he had worked for Schultz only a few months. He became acquainted with him at some hotel in New York and solicited employment, Schultz’s former servant having left him to return to Germany. His duty was to do chores and accompany Shultz when required so to do, and he was always to walk ahead of Schultz. When Schultz reached Norwalk from New York, Friday night, it was about six o’clock and was dark. Schultz and Buchols walked along the railroad track for about two miles and then turned across lots.
In going through a forest near Schultz’ house Schultz stopped and handed his satchel to Buchhols, who continued on until Schultz called him by name twice. Before he could go to the rescue Buchhols was attacked, his face was cut and he saw two men near him and two others were near Schultz. He could not hear what they said, and started for the house on a run, calling for help. He was pursued for some distance by one of the men. Arriving home he fell down with fright and fatigue. When the neighbors reached Schultz he was dead. No doctor had been called. Buchhols claimed to be ignorant of Schultz’ money affairs. Schultz was retiring, peaceable and had no friends or acquaintances in the vicinity. A man named Deysenhoof some time ago told Buchhols that two men would attack him, but he dismissed the matter without asking Deysenhoof who the men were.
The jury heard his story thus far and then went to the forest where the tragedy was enacted.
Samuel Warren [Waring] said that Schultz and Buchhols were both quiet and inoffensive, and were on good terms, as far as known, and neither was known to have an enemy. It appeared that the murder must have been for money. Schultz disposed of 15,000 marks for greenbacks in New York on Friday, and the money received is missing. A search brought to light a pair of red flannel drawers, which had been worn, new white overalls, a pistol and pieces of glass, which were scattered toward South Norwalk proper. Buchhols said he never saw any of the articles before. The hatchet with which Schultz was killed has not yet turned up. Two physicians made a post-mortem examination and concluded that the cut on Schultz’s head was made by an axe or hatchet blade, and that the puncture in the throat was made by the handle of the same instrument. Both blows were terrific – one crushing through the skill – and death would have followed either one. State Attorney J. H. Olmstead came here to assist the jury this morning, and the postponement to Tuesday was made to accommodate him. Extra police officers have been hired to hunt for evidence. Witnesses will be called from New York, and the hearing cannot end Tuesday. Mr. Olmstead refuses to be interviewed on this theory, saying it is too early in the case.
The Schulte Murder Mystery
---------
Peculiarities of the victim – His wealth and eccentricities – The search in the woods where the homicide occurred – clews found.
The startling theory is now advanced here that there was a conspiracy for the purpose of murdering John Henry Schulte, who was killed while going to his home at Rotan Hill [sic], about two miles from South Norwalk proper, last Friday night. It has come to light that he was even more wealthy than had been supposed. It has also been learned that he was highly accomplished and had an acquaintance with four languages, namely, German, Italian, French and English. A careful search yesterday through the woods wherein the murder was committed resulted in the finding of another revolver, a package of German tacks and a bunch of keys, all of which were stained with blood. Although the search was long continued the axe or hatchet with which the fatal blow was struck was not revealed, but the belief remains that it is somewhere in the vicinity. A fall of snow last night prevented the resumption of the search to-day, and will effectually bar it for several days. The revelations of yesterday and what has been discovered by a reference to the letters and effects of the late Mr. Schulte have furnished grounds for work to the detectives, who have been employed specially at the suggestion of State Attorney Olmstead. The pistol found yesterday was of an unusual pattern and of a German make. It was undoubtedly handled b some person connected with the crime. It and the keys and tacks were found in a lot adjoining the woods, a stone wall intervening. Schulte had no pistol, and the one which the servant, William Buchholtz, said was his (Buchholtz’s) sole weapon was found in his room, where he said it was. It is rumored that Buchholtz has recently loaned to a fellow countryman here the sum of $200, which, considering that he received only $3 per month for his services, would in itself be sufficient to attract attention to him. An official said to-night that he was convinced that Buchholtz did not tell or would not tell all he knew. Since the hearing Saturday he has been under the charge of Constable Dayton. He has talked freely and been interviewed by a detective, but what he told the detective has not been learned. Constable Dayton told a reporter “if he is the guilty man, he’s a shrewd one” One of the members of the Coroner’s jury answered, “He’s a cool one.”
One of the keys of the bloodstained bunch fits the lock of an iron chest which contains a quantity of gold French coins, and the chest was deposited by Mr. Schulte in the savings bank the morning before he went to New York. The keys were undoubtedly taken from his person after he was struck. The authorities have received a letter from Bischoff, the broker in the Staats Zeitung building, with whom he had business transactions Friday. Mr. Bischoff writes that he sold German marks and received $359 therefor, taking in payment three $100 bills, and other money. Of this sum Schulte was robbed, and there is thought to be a chance that a memorandum of the large bills may have been preserved, and may help to form a clew for the discovery of the murderer or murderers. A careful translation of the letters and papers of Mr. Schulte has been made. Their contents reveal a rarely methodical man. All the letters written by Mr. Schulte were preserved in copy by him, to secure himself against his servants, neither of whom received more than $3 per month. Schulte had elaborate contracts drawn up In these it was specified that the servant should always walk just so many paces in front him (Schulte); should always accompany him when desired, and should on all occasions regard him as his superior. Even trifling sums paid the servants were recorded, and from an indorsement it appears that the day before the murder Buchholtz was paid twenty-five cents. In the few Buchholtz had received there is contained no allusion to any unpleasant feeling harbored by any one against Schulte.
There are deeds showing large real estate transactions. One deed is given by two German counts, and convey to Schulte 300 acres of land, situated in three different towns. A memorandum shows that in one town near Cologne Schulte had thirty-one tenants. He had other large transactions, and had loaned his brother (his sole relative as far as can be ascertained) the sum of $10,000. He left his address with Bischoff, in New York, and wanted that gentleman to notify him if he learned of a farm of about 300 acres for sale, as he wished to move farther South. Mr. Schulte was a decidedly eccentric man, and in each trunk in his room there was found an inventory of its contents. This forenoon one of the jurymen went to New York to send word to Schulte’s brother of his untimely end. There was no will left, which is rather strange, considering the care Schulte had over all, even his most minute interests; and the money has all gone into the hands of an administrator.
A discovery of interest has been made, that the servant who was discharged by Schulte some months ago, and who Bucholtz testified had returned to Europe, is still in New York. There was a disagreement between this servant and Schulte. The $17,000 in money found next to Schulte’s skin had been pressed tight together, as if it had been worn that way for a long time. That Schulte always carried large sums, it now appears was known to several, which knowledge was rather dangerous to a man of Schulte’s lonely habits, his only weapon being a stiletto. All kinds of theories are exciting the people here. It is said that several persons are suspected, and may be taken after the inquest, which will be resumed to-morrow morning at ten o’clock.
Crowner’s Law.
-----------
Investigation of the Schulte and Furniss Murders
-----------
The Norwalk Mystery Deepens
-----------
How Palmer Killed the Courageous Policeman.
-----------
The Harlem Bridge Mantrap.
-----------
A Verdict Rendered Against the Gate Tender.
-----------
The mystery surrounding the foul murder of Johann H. Schulte, who now proves to have been a man possessed of at least $250,000, deepens as the investigation progresses. The court room where the inquest was held to-day was crowded to suffocation by citizens and others who never knew that such an eccentric individual was living in their midst, and whose extraordinary taking off by an apparently well laid plan has excited their curiosity to the very highest pitch. The authorities of the city of Norwalk, at a loss to know what to do with teh murdered man’s body, though not as to his money, which they safely lodged in the First National Bank, yesterday afternoon sent the following cable despatch to Germany :--
Dec. 30, 1878.
Freidrich W. Schulte, Grossen Holthausen, near Dortmund, Westphalia, Prussia :--
Johann Heinrich Schulte has been murdered. What shall be done with his body? Answer at once.
THE MAYOR OF SOUTH NORWALK.
To this the following reply was received by Cable this morning :--
To the Mayor of South Norwalk, Conn., U.S. :--
I beg of you to see to it that the body of my brother is properly forwarded to Barop Station, near Dortmund, so as to insure its safe arrival. I further request you to inform me at once, by cable, whether his effects have been secured, and how much has been found of the large amount of specie which he took from here; also who is the murderer of my brother.
FREIDRICH WILHELM SCHULTE,
Grosen Holzhausen, bei Barop.
Mayor Quintard and Selectmen Charles B. Smith, who are acting as administrators of the murdered man’s effects, were cogitating as to an answer to the above despatch, when Mr. Gustav Wolfram, representing the Imperial German Consul in New York, made his appearance here, and after showing the proper credentials at once made the necessary arrangements to take charge of the remains and forward them to Germany with the North German Lloyd steamer which sails on Saturday next. The Consul representative showed Mayor Quintard the following despatch, received by him in New York this morning :--
Dr. Julius Schumacher, General Imperial Consul, New York :--
The Mayor of South Norwalk, Conn., has just telegraphed me that Johann Heinrich Schulte has been murdered, and asks what disposition shall be made of his body and to answer at once I have ordered that the remains of my brother – the owner of baronial estates (Rittergutsbesitzer) – Schulte, who has been residing in South Norwalk during the past few months, be sent to Barop, near Dortmund. I trust that you will cause the deceased to be identified, and give official notice of his death to Mr. Knippscheld Hagen (Amtmann) in Westphalia. The necessary expenditures are at your disposal. I beg of you to see to it that the body reaches here in good order. My brother has taken a great deal of specie with him and I request that measures be taken to secure all these effects. Please send answer by telegraph.
FRIEDERICH WILHELM SCHULTE
Land owner in Grossen Holzhausen, bel Barop.
That the effects were all secured became at once evident to the German Consul’s representative; that all of the money found on the body, and which the murderers had not discovered, amounting in all to about $20,000, which had been securely hidden in Schulte’s undershirt pocket, had since been deposited in the First National Bank, in addition to the specie found in the small iron chest which the murdered German kept at the office of J. M. Layton, who acted as his real estate agent in this city. The money found on his body and which now is in the bank consisted of seventy-two bank notes of 1,000 marks each, twenty notes of 500 marks, three notes of 100 and $939 in United States greenbacks, the remainder of the money, or rather the amount which he received in exchange from Bischoff, the German banker in New York, having been stolen, along with the gold watch on which his name was engraved. The made a total of 82,000 marks (in paper) found on his body, now in the bank, and by the advice of the administrator, the specie found in the iron chest, being 100 gold pieces, each 20 francs, was added to the special bank deposit.
At the suggestion of Secretary Wolfram an inventory was subsequently taken of the contents of the iron chest, and as most of the documents, legal and otherwise, were in German, considerable time elapsed before the administrators could get an accurate list of these contents. In order to get an approximate estimate of the murdered Schulte’s wealth the following list was prepared, which includes the deeds and acknowledgements found in his chest :--
Certificates bearing the stamp of district government of Dortmund, in Rhenish Prussia, dated July 15, 1877, acknowledging deposit of… 498,544 Marks
Certificate of sale of ninety-five acres of land to Rhenish Railway for which the above amount had been received.
Mortgage on property near Dortmund, dated January 22, 1869… 10,000 Marks
A list of interest due him on various properties in Germany for the year 1878 – amount of interest at 4 per cent – 8,000 marks… 200,000 Marks
Memorandum of shares of Rhenish railway stock… 40,000 Marks
Total marks: 748,544
Value in American dollars… $187,138
Twenty franc pieces found in chest… 500
Greenbacks found on his person… $939
Amount now in bank by order of administrator… 20,000
Deed of farm near Norwalk… 5,000
Total value: $213,577
Mr. C. W. Smith, one of the administrators, after even this partial list had been made up, said to the representative of the German Consul :-- “You would not have thought on looking at his place and the manner in which he lived that he was worth all this money. He seemed to have lived for money only. He had a small, miserable iron bed, on which he even did not have a pillow, using some sort of satchel to rest his head upon. But few of us knew him around here; he attracted but little attention, and what could have induced a man possessed of such an estate to purchase such a form and live in such a style surpasses my comprehension.”
Various other papers of a private character were found in the chest, and the German Consul’s representative requested the administrators to keep charge of all of them until further orders.
While this examination of Schulte's effects was progressing Judge Craw and State Attorney Olmstead were actively engaged in penetrating the mystery. William Buchholtz [sic], the servant, who was with his master a few minutes before he was laid low in death, was in the court room under the surveillance of an officer, but of all the witnesses he was the coolest and most stolid. He gave his testimony in excellent German, showing him to be a man beyond the ordinary run of Germans of that class; and often when at the dictation of the State’s attorney the interpreter would ask him a question which he had previously answered in part he would say with vigor, and often in an angry tone, “I have already told you so before.” For four long hours he quietly submitted to being badgered by the State’s Attorney, but in not a single instance did he contradict himself. He was astonished at nothing, not when his own pistol was shown him, not even when the two pistols found in the lot adjoining the farm were suddenly placed before his eyes. Not even the three spots of blood on one of the pistols moved him in the very least. From beginning to end he told his story apparently with entire self-possession, even acknowledging that he left the Sun Hotel, in Pearl street, New York, where Schulte had engaged him, without paying his board bill of $35, though he did have plenty of money in his possession.
“I have not paid him yet,” said Buchholtz; “but I will pay him.”
“But why did you not pay him?” asked the State’s Attorney.
“Because Schulte told me that we were going to California one of these days, and I thought, being in a strange land, I might get sick, and I would hold on to the money I had. I had about $250 when I came to South Norwalk. The reason I wrote to Germany for more money was because I intended to go to Australia. This was before Schulte spoke to me about California.”
When asked whether he knew the man who acted as Schulte’s servant before he was engaged, he said that he did not know him, never heard his name, thought he was engaged in a barber shop At a later stage of the proceedings the State’s Attorney laid before the jury the following letter received this morning from New York :--
New York, Dec. 30
Mr. Stephen H. Waring :--
I have been a servant of Johann H. Schulte from September 3, 1877, till August 2, 1878. I have read in the newspapers that the police are looking for me, and hence desire to acquaint you with my whereabouts, as I came here from Germany with Mr. Schulte. He visited me on Friday last, December 27, at about eleven A.M.
I request that you hand this to the authorities and have me called as witness. My address is No. 436 East Fifteenth street.
SIEGFRIED GRUNEWALD
Coming back to the night of the murder, the witness [Bucholz] said that the man who followed him to the top of the hill wore heavy black whiskers, and all he remembered was that he said “Greenhorn,” and, also, “I’ll catch you another time;” his accent sounded to him as if it was that of a Frenchman; think the man was armed with something to which a wire was attached; he had something in his hand which he could not tell; all the conversation he had with Schulte when he met him at the Norwalk depot was in reference to the O’Leary and “Sport” walking match [more here]; Schulte told him he had no time to visit Gimore’s Garden; they drank a glass of beer at Davis’ Hotel, then left together, he carrying the hams and Schulte the satchel; never spoke any more to him until he heard his name called, he walking ahead some distance; when about to turn around he saw one man at his right, another at his left and then received himself the wound across his face.
Mrs. Waring, the lady who kept house for Schulte, testified that on the afternoon of Friday Buchholtz dressed himself to meet Schulte at the depot; Schulte had only been three times to New York – twice he went by boat, this time by rail; all the time he lived with her Schulte never went through these woods at night; we took supper at five, and generally went to bed at six; Friday night was the first time he ever went through these woods; the first she knew about something being wrong was when Buchholtz came staggering into the kitchen and he stammered, “He is murdered;” thought Buchholtz was dead, but giving him a glass of water he recovered from his fright.
Samuel Waring, the son of the former witness, described the scene in the woods where the dead man was found, and the fear which beset them all before proceeding on their search.
At this stage the inquest was adjourned till Saturday morning, the State’s Attorney being anxious to hunt up more witnesses so as to prove the conspiracy that existed to draw the old gentleman out on that particular night, the manner in which one of the cedar trees was made into an ambush being relied upon by the prosecution to show that the entire affair was deliberately planned by parties who knew that the old man was to pass through those woods on that fatal Friday night.
[The remainder of the page covers unrelated cases]
The Schulte Murder
----------
Alleged Attempt to Kidnap a Witness in New York – Overzealous Connecticut Officers.
Yesterday morning Mr. Robert Illing, one of the detectives of South Norwalk, arrived in this city to hunt up witnesses for the Schulte inquest, which is to be continued there this morning. The detective came by orders of the State’s Attorney, J. H. Olmstead, and after a little delay proceeded to the residence of a man named Victor Ruhe [Rohe in other reports], in Broome street, near Chrystie, who, it is alleged, is a friend of Schulte's servant, Buchholz, now under arrest on suspicion of knowing more about this mysterious murder than has yet been told. Officer Illing showed Ruhe a letter from Buchholz, which, he thought, contained some allusion to money matters bearing on the case. Ruhe denied that it had any such bearing, but consented to accompany the Connecticut detective to Earle’s Hotel, in Canal street, where he was stopping, and, after discussing the relations existing between Bucholz and himself, Ruhe expressed his readiness to at once present himself before Mr. Olmstead, the State’s Attorney, and the other authorities having charge of the investigation. Both then left the hotel, Ruhe preparing to leave the city at once and the detective proceeding to the telegraph office to communicate with the State’s Attorney.
An hour or two later the Connecticut officer called at the Ruhe residence, in Broome street, and had a long interview with Mrs. Ruhe. The latter was also requested to accompany the officer to Earle’s Hotel, which she did the more willingly as she expected to find her husband there. Hardly, however, had she reached a room on the second floor of the hotel when Officer Illing quietly locked the door on her, but attempted to pacify her by saying that it was “all right.” Mrs. Ruhe did not think it “all right," and remonstrated with the officer, who, she said, had not the least right to detain her. She was perfectly willing to give all the information in her possession about Buchholz, but she was not going to leave her residence unprotected during her husband’s absence. Her explanations and entreaties apparently made no impression upon Officer Illing, and he kept her under lock and key at Earle’s Hotel. Seeing that there was no prospect of immediate release she raised an alarm, which soon brought the hotel attendants to her apartment. She insisted upon the police officer being called at once, and, her story being straightforward, she succeeded in having her newly found guardian turned over to one of the blue-coated members of the “finest force in the world.” She charged Officer Illing with an attempt at kidnapping, and had him arraigned before Judge Otterbourg at the Tombs Police Court. The Police Justice saw by the documents in possession of Officer Illing that he was duly authorized to secure witnesses for the Schulte inquest, but informed him that he was not proceeding in order. The detective produced a telegram from Mr. Olmstead telling him to bring on Mrs. Ruhe if he could, and, in order to secure even-handed justice to the State of Connecticut as well as the person of Mrs. Ruhe, the Tombs magistrate endeavored to cut the Gordian knot by referring them all to the District Attorney’s office. It was after business hours, however, at the District Attorney’s office, and the party in charge could not see “what right they had to hold the woman.” So all marched back again to Judge Otterbourg, and finally proceeded to the office of the Superintendent of Police.
Mr. Walling was in his best of moods, listening patiently to the story of the Connecticut officer, who was actually under arrest at the time, and then paying careful attention to Mrs. Ruhe’s statement. Mr. Illing again showed his authority to act in the premises, the telegram he had received from Mr. Olmstead, and asserted his right to secure his witnesses. Superintendent Walling soon disabused his mind of this theory, saying Mr. Ruhe could go to Connecticut if she liked, but she could not be compelled to go as matters then stood.
“But why not go?” said Superintendent Walling to the lady.
“Because I have money and other valuables in the house, which I do not want to leave alone while my husband is away,” said Mrs. Ruhe.
The Superintendent gave orders that an officer of the Tenth precinct be specially instructed to watch over the Ruhe dwelling in Broome street during the lady’s absence. She was informed of this order, when she said, “No, I wouldn't go anyhow now, not until I consult my husband.” The Superintendent told her that she could act as she pleased in the matter; that under no condition would he permit her to be forced into leaving the city, but that if she desired to go she could have her house amply protected. Detective Rogers was here summoned by Mr. Walling, and his orders were to accompany Office Illing and see that no harm be done to Mrs. Ruhe; also to inform the Captain of the Tenth precinct to place an officer in charge of Mrs. Ruhe’s house whenever she was about to leave for Connecticut. The charge against Officer Illing for “alleged kidnapping” was not pressed, and he was permitted to leave for South Norwalk. It was stated last evening that both Mr. and Mrs. Ruhe will present themselves at the South Norwalk inquest to-day.
The action taken by the Connecticut authorities in securing the attendance of Mr. and Mrs. Ruhe is based upon testimony elicited from Buchholz on Tuesday last, when he underwent a four hours’ examination at the hands of Mr. J. H. Olmstead, the energetic State Attorney. Having been asked why he went to New York on December 23 and 24 Buchholz testified :--
I went to New York on December 23 to buy an overcoat; did not buy one, because I could not find my friend, Mr. Victor Ruhe; I don’t know how long Ruhe has been in this country; he does not speak English perfectly; he lives in Broome street, two blocks east from the Bowery; the number is in the three hundreds, I forget the exact number; his wife was at home when I called; I have not seen Ruhe since; I went down the Bowery and looked at some stores; the next day (24th) I could not find my friend home either; his wife was home; I talked to her for some time; I went nowhere else.
The Shulte Murder.
----------
Tightening the coils around alleged conspirators – Buchholtz locked up – Unravelling the mystery before the Norwalk jury – Letters to the Rohe Family.
The coffin containing the mortal remains of the murdered Johann Schulte was sent to the care of the German Consul General in New York, last evening, and this morning Mr. Charles B. Smith, one of the administrators of the estate, returned to Norwalk and reported to the authorities that he had discharged his trust and that the North German Lloyd steamer Donau was then about to sail with the remains for Germany. The sacred duties attendant upon this shipment having been duly performed by the Norwalk authorities, they set about in earnest in fathoming the mystery which thus far has surrounded this foul murder. In order to accommodate the throng anxious to hear every word that could be elicited from the witnesses cited to appear at today’s session of the jury, the inquest was held in the new council chamber, but even there the room was entirely inadequate to accommodate the crowd. While the State’s Attorney and his subordinates were consulting as to the next mode of procedure a scene occurred at the City Hotel between Mr. Victor Rohe and Mr. Illing, the amateur detective who yesterday attempted to kidnap Mrs. Rohe in New York. Mr. Rohe was about ready to proceed to the court room when he said to Mr. Illing, “Who gave you the right to take my wife from my house? Had I been at home I would have made you suffer for it. I have come on willingly to South Norwalk to tell all I know about Buchholtz and you had no right to force my wife to come.”
Mr. Illing apologized to Mr. Rohe, explaining that he meant no harm, but that his wife became unduly excited.
Before the inquest was regularly under way Mr. Olmstead, the State’s Attorney, informed the New York correspondents that at no time had he given orders to force Mrs. Rohe’s attendance and that he only advised her coming to South Norwalk if she was willing to go.
William Buchholtz, Mr. Schulte’s servant, was again placed on the stand and stated that he only knew a few words of English, which he had mastered since his arrival in this country. A memorandum book here was shown him in which were written the following words :-- “On 20th January, 1879, I will leave Schulte.” Witness stated that these words were not written by him, but he did write the same words in German in another part of the book, and wrote it without attaching any meaning to it; never had any quarrel of consequence with Mr. Schulte, but he had told Mrs. Rohe in New York that once he had some trouble with Schulte at the dinner table; at that time he held Schulte by the collar, but had never held a pistol before him; also told Mrs. Rohe that Schulte had two pistols, one of which he always took to bed with him; he knew this fact from Grunewald, Schulte’s old servant.
Grunewald was here led into the room, when Buchholtz repeated the statement that he had told him about the old man’s pistols. Witness here stated that the reason why he could buy a pistol in the Bowery and not an overcoat without speaking English was because he understood the value of a pistol and not of a coat. The State’s Attorney here caused to be read the following letter :--
South Norwalk, Jan. 2, 1879.
Dear Friend Rohe – You surely have heard from the newspapers of the very unfortunate position in which I find myself now. Yes, with broken heart I must tell you that I am near to despair, and for that reason I would like to see you and talk to you if possible.
Should somebody call on you and ask about me and endeavor to ascertain how I became acquainted with you, say it through your brother, and tell your wife that I never said anything to her about money when I visited there. Under no condition say anything about money which I ever loaned to you some time previous. When I was with you last I intended to purchase an overcoat and wanted you go with me. Burn this letter. Kindest regards. Yours truly, WILLIAM BUCHHOLTZ.
Buchholtz acknowledged the letter to be in his handwriting. The reason he did not want them to speak about the money was because he did not want people in Norwalk to know about it. In reply to the question how he had so much money in his possession and was ready to buy Christmas presents for numerous persons, while he only earned $3.25 wages per month, witness answered that he was not alone dependent upon Mr. Schulte for his money.
The following letter, also in German, was next submitted as evidence to the jury :--
Norwalk, Nov. 22, 1878.
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Rohe – I intended to write you some time ago, but I could not, because I did not know when I would come back to New York. I then intended to bring you a little barrel of cider. I will not meet you on Wednesday, 27th inst. I will leave here in the morning, so that I’ll meet you at about noon. You need not pay for the cider; it is sent to you with my love. When I mentioned it to my friends here they said :-- “Buchholtz, why did you not tell us before that your friends in New York want some cider? You’d had a chance to send it to them long ago.” I have to add only another word. I have had a “conflict” with Mr. Schulte, but we are not nearly on the old terms again. Hoping that this letter will reach you in good health I close my letter, and remain, with heartiest compliments, always your friend, WILLIAM BUCHHOLTZ.
The witness became exceedingly nervous when these letters, one after another, were handed to him. He seemed to look over them very carefully, till the prosecution had to tell him that all they wanted was to identify the handwriting. A small hairbrush was then shown him, which he at first did not recognize, but admitted that he had one like it. The State’s Attorney warned him not to disturb the little brush, but finally told him, “Pull out that hair and see if it is not your own hair.” Witness was somewhat nonplussed, but said he could not swear that it was his own hair, and still it might be.
The State’s Attorney – Now, then, how came this brush to be in the open lot near the shingle on which you were practising, and near the pistol found there on the night of the murder?
Buchholtz replied, “I have no idea hot it came there.”
“Now, then, Buchholtz,” continued Mr. Olmstead, “did you ever tell this Grunewald that he was a fool to leave a rich man like Schulte; that if you’d been there you’d made things work differently, and would have taken the old fellow’s coat and rain off with the money?”
Buchholtz – I never told Grunewald so.
In reply to questions affecting his previous career witness said that he never was a servant in Germany, he was an agricultural student; never worked for wages; studied at the royal domain of Hoch Schweigel; was supported first by his parents, then by his uncle, and the reason he went to work for such low wages with Schulte was because he thought it a good opportunity to study the country, as Schulte had promised him that he would not have to work hard.
Siegfried Grunewald, Schulte’s old servant, here took the stand, and swore that at the Sun Hotel, in Pearl street, New York, he made up his mind to leave Mr. Schulte, because he was so exceedingly eccentric; he would scream in the middle of the night, thinking that somebody was after his money; witness left him because he was really afraid; it was then that Buchholtz told him he was a fool to leave Schulte, and that he ought to have taken his money and run away with it; witness, though he had slept with him in Hamburg for three days, had accompanied him on the voyage hitherward and slept with him at the hotel, where he at any time could have taken his money, refused to sleep longer in the same room with him; in fact, some of the people in the hotel had urged him to leave Schulte and look for another place; subsequently he regretted this wrote Schulte a letter, telling him that he had been prevailed upon to run away, but he was anxious to return to his old place and work faithfully for him; on the morning of the murder Schulte called upon him at this place in East Fifteenth street, and it was there agreed that he should return to his old employer on the 20th inst.; saw nothing more of him on that day; next heard that his old employer had been murdered; Schulte used to carry his money in a black pocketbook; also in a yellow book, and his valuable papers in a package tied with strings; the fold was kept in a bad, which was locked in a large trunk; witness then denied the statement made by Buchholtz, that he had told him about the old man’s pistols.
Victor Rohe, the next witness, asked permission of the jury to make a statement. He found fault with the sensational report in a morning paper in regard to his wife, and trusted that his business reputation should not be smirched by careless reports in connection with this case. He then testified that Buchholtz at one time asked him to place $80 for him in a New York bank, but as some of the banks were not in such excellent condition at the time he soon returned the amount to him; Buchholtz had told him once that he had a difficulty with Schulte, when the old man went for his pistol, and Buchholtz put his hand on his arm, asking him what he meant; Buhholtz subsequently bought a pistol in the Bowery, as he had been warned that the people of Norwalk knew about Schulte’s money, and they might be attacked one of these days. In conclusion witness stated that Mrs. Rohe would come to Norwalk to testify whenever she was wanted.
Mr. Dellazon Allen, who lives about seventy-five rods from Mr. Schulte’s place, described the excitement near there on the night of the murder; witness and Mr. Dingee got a lantern want waited for Buchholtz and Waring to come up; finally they saw one approaching and found Buchholtz leaning with his head on the fence, growling piteously; thought he would faint; wanted to know how seriously he was hurt, when he saw a little scratch under his left ear and blood on his cheek; all then went along the dark path; Buchholt was about ten feet ahead when they reached Schulte’s body; Buchholtz said, “Mein Gott! Mein Gott! he is dead!” he had a pistol in his hand and told him to be careful with it.
Samuel Waring here testified that the pistol which fell from Buchholtz’s pocket at the time he came in the house was picked up by him and kept in his (witness’) pocket.
Buchholtz, upon being recalled flatly contradicted this witness, stating he had his own pistol in his hand and it could not be in Waring’s pocket. The other pistol (belonging to Schulte, on which are three spots of blood) was here shown him and he said, “I never had that pistol in my possession.”
Mr. Olmstead – Did you not throw this pistol over the fence in the open lot?
Buchholtz – No, sir; I had my own pistol; I had given it to Warning that evening, but I got it back from him.
Mrs. Waring, mother of Samuel, said she told her son to put Buchholtz’s pistol in his pocket when he fell in her house, and her son did so.
Mr. Olmstead – Now, Buchholtz, don’t you remember that you had this pistol (Schulte’s) instead of your own that night?
Buchholtz – No, sir.
Mr. Allen, upon being recalled, said he could not tell exactly which pistol Buchholtz held in his hand when he saw him.
The further investigation was here adjourned till to-morrow morning, when Mrs. Rohe will be examined. Other witnesses are being hunted up for the purpose of showing that the German land owner was the victim of a conspiracy, concocted ever since his return to this country in October last. Officer Halleck, who has been exceedingly active in this case, is believed to be ont he track of some foreigners who will be wanted before the case is closed.
Immediately after the adjournment State Attorney Olmstead proceeded to court and obtained a regular warrant for the arrest of William Buchholt, charging him with being concerned in the murder of Johann Schulte. This movement created considerable surprise, in so far as the accused had willingly surrended himself the day after the murder, attended regularly all sessions of the jury and had peremptorily refused counsel, because, as he said, he had nothing to conceal, and would take care of his own case. Mr. Charles B. Stillson, the foreman of the jury, having taken charge of the box containing the loaded pistols and other deodanda found in the open lot, the warrant was handed to Officer Dayton, who took the accused in charge and placed him in the lockup. The State Attorney subsequently stated to your correspondent that he considered it his duty to keep Buchholtz in a safe place.
It is stated to-day that 5,000 marks, known to have been in possession of Mr. Schulte but not on his body, have not as yet been accounted for. There is a disposition among the administrators to convert all of Schulte’s foreign specie and bank notes now in the Second National Bank of Norwalk into American money; and one of the bank’s officers proceeded to New York to-day to conclude negotiations in regard to these funds. Mayor Quintard, one of the administrators, stated that this action was taken so as to increase their responsibility, but the amount, somewhat over $20,000, would remain in the bank without interest until duly authenticated agents should appear, to take the matter off their hands. It is understood that the German Consul will soon be in possession of the proper power of attorney from the murdered man’s brother in Germany so as to enable him to relieve South Norwalk of this pecuniary burden.
The Schulte Murder.
----------
Who Detained the Wealthy German in New York?
----------
Marked Bills in Buchholtz’s Possession
----------
He Offers a Bonus for False Swearing and Has Plenty of Money After the Murder.
----------
Mrs. Rohe’s Testimony.
----------
The investigation of the circumstances surrounding the mysterious murder of John Schulte, the wealthy miser, has now progressed sufficiently to make it apparent that a conspiracy was concocted to kill him on that fatal Friday after Christmas, and that during the day the old German, who never before had returned home after dark, was purposely detained in New York after he had exchanged his German marks at the banking office of Bischoff, in Tryon row. Where was he between one o’clock on that day and the time when he took the train for South Norwalk, and in whose company was he? For what purpose did Buchholtz, the prisoner, proceed to New York on the previous Monday and Tuesday, and in whose company was he?
Mrs. Rohe, whom an amateur detective endeavored to kidnap in New York last Friday, was the first witness sworn to-day. She is an intelligent, delicate looking woman, born in this country, of German parents, and was dressed in full mourning. She stated that after Buchholtz had given her $80 to deposit in bank she did not care to keep for him, as the Manhattan Savings Bank had just been robbed; she reeturned him at once $40; she insisted upon him taking it all back, but he would not, as he said she could keep it better for him than he could himself; two weeks later, on a Sunday morning, he suddenly appeared and wanted the other $40 to buy himself a pistol and other things; witness urged him not to buy a pistol; he said he needed it, as he was often attacked when out at night with the Waring girls, some of the young men of the town being jealous owing to his keeping company with them; on the day before Thanksgiving Buchholtz showed witness the pistol, left it on the bureau and told her not to touch it as it was loaded; the same afternoon he told witness of a difficulty he had with Schulte at dinner, because he had put his fork in another plate; words arose between them, when Schulte finally kicked him; Buchholtz then took hold of Schulte and threw him over a trunk, telling him, “I’ll show you if you have a stupid boy before you; see what you can do to me now;” Buchholtz told all this with much gusto, and the same evening asked for a loan of $20, but she did not give it to him; on the 23d of December he came again and asked her husband for the loan of $30; he looked very sad on that day and said he was anxious to buy Sadie Waring a muff for a Christmas present; did not say a word about an overcoat.
Mr. A. E. Austin here appeared for the first time as counsel for Buchholtz, and took a seat next to his client.
Paul Harcher, a saloon keeper in South Norwalk, testified that the morning after the murder Buchholtz came in his saloon alone; he was rather excited; he said, “Isn’t this a terrible affair?” He did not know what to think of it; held a handkerchief up to his face, saying, “I got a scratch, too;” Buchholtz then called witness aside and said, “Here is $200, my money; I want you to keep this for me till I make my report at the Coroner’s inquest; if anybody asks you, say that I gave it to you, some time ago;” witness asked how he got it, but he said it was his own. (Part of the money shown to the jury.) These bills burned in witness’ pockets, and he was anxious to be rid of them; after the first session of the jury Buchholtz came to him and said, “My friends are going back on me; I hope you wouldn’t, but be sure and say that you received the money some time in November or October;” on Saturday afternoon last Buchholtz told witness if he wanted more money he could have it, and promised to give him one-tenth of the amount if he would speak about the matter as he desired him to do; in the same afternoon Buchholt informed him that he had received $250 more money from Germany, and the nexxt morning came in and showed him a new ulster he had bought; then asked witness if he could change a fifty dollar bill, but witness could not; the same afternoon (yesterday) Buchholtz went to a livery stable, got a coach and they drove to Westport, when, after speaking to his future plans, he said that witness could have more money, but told him that he did not want it; witness also reminded him that it was very hard for him to swear to a lie as he desired him to do; this morning, again, before the inquest began, Buchholtz told witness he was rather afraid of to-days’s investigation, and hoped he would not go back on him, telling witness it made no difference whether he said he had received money in November or December; referring to the day of the murder, witness said that when Schulte came to his saloon after leaving the depot he acknowledged that he had been delayed in New York.
The State’s Attorney having taken possession of $140 still in possession of the witness, the remainder having been paid out, called the attention of the jury to the fact that these twenty dollar bills were all marked in ink. One twenty dollar bill of the Gallatin National Bank, city of New York, thus :-- 380 | 140; one greenback twenty-dollar bill, marked 380 | 156; one national bank note of Newburg, 380 | 156; one national bank note of Newburg, 380 | 158; one greenback, 380 | 159; one New York State National Bank of Albany, 380 | 168; one greenback, 380 | 170; one greenback, 380 | 180. At the suggestion of the State’s Attorney, telegraphic despatches were at once sent to New York to detain any bills marked in the same style, and the representatives of the press were requested to publish these figures, so that any one possessing bills of any denomination marked in ink in the same style might notify at once Mr. J. H. Olmstead, State’s Attorney, at Stamford, Conn. The prosecution hope to prove by this that these bills, thus given for safe keeping, came from Mr. Schulte.
Buchholtz was here informed by the State’s Attorney that he need not answer any questions, but if he desired he might say where he got the $200. He said that in November last he gave Mr. Schulte the money he brought from Germany for safe keeping; he asked for the money about Christmas; Schulte then had no change in small bills and gave him his money on that Friday afternoon when he returned from New York; he had never noticed the figures on the bills and gave the money to Harcher, because he did not want to carry it; the reason he advised him not to say that he had just given it to him was because he feared people might think he had robbed Mr. Schulte, who had just been murdered; as to his promising Harcher one-tenth of the money he thought the laborer was worthy of his hire if he had been willing to tell his story the way he wanted him to.
Mr. Paul Harcher here stated that Buchholtz, when he gave him the money, did not tell him that Schulte had paid him the previous day.
Miss Sadie Waring testified as to Buchholtz’s movements. On the night of the murder he went for his pistol which was in a box in the family room; he kept many of his things there.
The State’s Attorney – Did he pay any attentions to you?
Miss Sadie (blushing) – No, sir.
Mr. Olmstead – Do you know of any reason why he should give you a muff and collar?
Miss Sadie (still blushing) – No, sir.
Mrs. Waring here testified that Schulte had told her that Buchholtz would leave him on the 20th of January; the latter said in accordance with a contract between them Schulte claimed he had the right to kick him, and he would not submit to that. (Laughter in court).
Charles Bosh, an expert gunmaker, here took hold of two old pistols found in the lot, on one of which are streaks of blood. He was instructed to examine the cartridges found in Mr. Schulte’s iron chest and see whether they fitted the pistols. After various manoeuvres with the weapons, frightening in no small degree the officers and attendants in the court room, he declared that the cartridges as found in the chest belonged to the pistols, thus establishing beyond a doubt the fact that these pistols found near the body belonged to the murdered man.
The inquest was then adjourned till Saturday morning next, when the State’s Attorney expects to close the case. Dr. Pardee, who made the post-mortem of the murdered Schulte, told your correspondent to-day that on the day after the murder he took the plaster from Buchholtz’s face, and, instead of finding a serious wound, saw mere scratches, which any one might get from small underbrush. His theory is yet that the old man was killed by means of a hammer, and this hammer has been missing ever since from the Schulte homestead.
William Buchholtz, who is now regularly under arrest, handed the representatives of the press a lengthy statement in German, the concluding part of which is as follow :--
We lived together very contentedly, and I can truly say that I was very well contented with the treatment Mr. Schulte observed toward me. That sometimes things did not go as they might have gone he might be pardoned for, for he was old and queer. In this way it happened that one day when we had eaten our supper, and Mr. Schulte having been in a bad mood the whole day, he somewhat hurt my feelings in this, that he, as I put the remnants of the meals upon another plate without a fork, called me an “ill-mannered fellow.” which naturally I would not take quietly and a little altercation took place, during which Mr. Schulte thrust his hand into his pocket. Now, whether Mr. Schulte was going to take anything out of it I do not know. I took the plates and went down stairs, but was hardly down when he called me up again and asked “I surely would not go away? He had been vexed all day long and I must not take it up so seriously whenever in his bad mood he insulted me in any way.” Thus we lived along from day to day and had many a pleasant hour together. Often we spoke of the journey to California and of Germany; how things were so different here and everything so much dearer. In the last few days it was mentioned that he would make a journey for four weeks, and was going to hire another young man for this journey and that I should stay here on his farm; but where he was to travel I did not ask him and have not found out.
And now what changes may not be brought about in one’s life. One day perfectly happy, the next plunged into the deepest misfortune; thus it is with me at present. How could I have ever deemed it possible ever to come into the position of being watched by police surveillance? Still at this moment I am in this critical condition, but God will direct everything for the best, for whosoever trusteth in God has not built upon sand. Those who leave Him and rejoice in it, who forget the teachings of their parents and do not believe in the salvation of Christ, He shall put them away from Him as wind scatters chaff. Truth and truth alone shall conquer.
WILLIAM BUCHHOLTZ
The original image of the newspaper at the Library of Congress.
THE SCHULTE MURDER.
SOME OF THE MARKED BILLS TRACED TO THIS CITY – WHAT THE WEALTHY GERMAN SAID TO HIS BANKER THE DAY HE WAS MURDERED.
Yesterday a reporter of the HERALD called at the Sonne Hotel, in Pearl street, near Centre, in order to ascertain if the money paid there by Buchholtz, the German servant now under arrest in South Norwalk for alleged complicity in the murder of John Schulte, was marked in the same manner as the twenty-dollar bills which the prisoner had given to Paul Harcher for safe keeping. Mr. Kreiling, the proprietor of the hotel, being in Europe, Mr. Otto Swetzky, an intelligent native of Poland, answered in behalf of the proprietor. Mr. Swetzky said that he had received a telegram in regard to the bills from Connecticut authorities, and fortunately the bills paid to him by Buchholtz were still in his possession, and he did not intend to part with them for the present. They were marked, respectively, 380|167 and 380|135, showing that they belonged to the same pile which had been submitted to the scrutiny of the South Norwalk jury on Monday. "We did not," said Mr. Swetzky, "bother the young man for the money he owed us, but last week some one from South Norwalk came here and demanded Buchholtz's bill. He owed us about $35, and the man gave us two twenty-dollar bills and we gave him $5 change. When that testimony came out in South Norwalk I at once examined the two twenties and found they were marked as there sworn to by Paul Harcher.
An old German trunk, containing sundry articles belonging to the prisoner, was yet in the hotel, and he could have it any moment he asked for it. The trunk was directed to Adelaide, Australia.
Mr. Henry Bischoff, the banker in the Staats Zeitung building. in whose office the murdered man changed considerable foreign money on the last day of his life, was visited, and stated that Schulte came at eleven o'clock that morning and received $352.50 for his 1,500 marks. At about noon he returned, and Mr. Bischoff, who was very busy at the time and who is quite near sighted, considering him a beggar, left a few pennies with one of the clerks, telling him to give them to the old man. The "old man," however, proved to be Mr. Schulte, who said that he wanted large bills for small ones, and they gave him, among others, five one-hundred dollar bills. He remarked at the time, the weather being cold, that the climate did not suit him at all; he had lived in Kentucky before, where the weather was much more congenial to him. He then spoke of a farm which had been offered him in Virginia, and asked Mr. Bischoff's opinion about it, and added that he would not live another winter in Connecticut. While in the office Schulte had a hundred-mark bank note changed for ten-mark gold pieces. When counting the gold pieces young Bischoff noticed that one was defective, because it had a hole in it, and desired to withdraw it, but Schulte insisted upon retaining it for his watch. Mr. Bischoff said yesterday that the detectives considered this one of the clews which would enable them to reveal the mystery. He also spoke of 4,000 more marks which he wanted to exchange, and he was advised to keep them. After leaving his address on that day Mr. Schulte never returned.
"Now," added Mr. Bischoff, "I'll tell you how this old fellow made his money. Since the newspapers have talked so much about his murder a man has been in this office who knows all about him. Schulte, according to his story, was an ordinary well to do farmer in 1855, in Dortmund, near Cologne. At that time the Rhenish railway was built and the road ran clean through the estate of a nobleman. The latter, seeing his domain trampled upon by the authorities, in a state of frenzy offered his entire estate for sale, and the shrewd Schulte bought it for a mere song. He sold six plots of his newly acquired estate at once and the proceeds of these covered the purchase money for the entire domain. The remainder was clear profit to him, and he has disposed of part of it and cultivated the rest to the best advantage. As to his brother, nothing is known here except that among the effects found in the iron chest at South Norwalk appears a mortgage as security for 10,000 marks loaned to this brother some time ago."
A Crime of Two Continents
----------
The Schulte Murder Being Traced Back to Germany
----------
A Diabolical Conspiracy
----------
Extraordinary Revelation Discovered in the Old Man’s Diary
----------
Marked Bills Identified
----------
Remarkable Interest Taken in the Case by the German Consul General.
----------
The presence of the Imperial Consul General of Germany in this town to-day at once added renewed interest to the inquiry, adjourned since Monday last, in regard to the mysterious death of the “Rittergutsbesitzer” Johann Schulte, who was murdered near this place on the evening of December 27 last. Your correspondent had an interview with the Consul shortly after his arrival, but, being a lawyer, he very cautiously remarked that he only came here to watch the proceedings, that justice should be done to the accused Buchholtz [sic] and to see personally how matters were conducted. “The truth is,” said the Consul “that all persons yet mentioned in connection with the murder are Germans in the true sense of the word. They are not American citizens, and cannot even speak English. It is my duty, therefore, to see what there is in all these reports I have heard and read. They are not even naturalized citizens, and the German government punishes a German for having committed murder, no matter where the crime be located. I may possibly exceed my authority, but I know the government at Berlin will approve of the deep interest I take in this case.”
These words on the part of the first representative of Germany in New York, spoken in a lonely Connecticut borough, at once convinced your correspondent that there was more behind this murder of the old miser than has yet been revealed; and the theory, often before broached but never traced, was therefore closely followed up, and not many minutes elapsed before it became evident to all those who could read the German language that even in the old fatherland there existed deep-seated enmity toward the man who was killed without a moment’s warning in the grounds adjoining his farm at Roton Hill. Experts schooled in German chirography once more examined carefully the memoranda, diaries, statements and other books left behind by the murdered Schulte, and singular to say, it was soon ascertained that three days before Schulte embarked for America he was fired at twice on his own farm at Dortmund, in Westphalia, and the man charged with investigating the matter reported that the son of Schulte’s own brother, the very man who so anxiously telegraphed about the fate which had befallen Johann Schulte, was detected among those who made this unprovoked attack. The murdered man was an eccentric, queer individual, who made notes, not only of his expenditures, but of all events that occurred around about him. The following is a literal translation of a memorandum found yesterday in Schulte’s diary, written in German bearing on this subject :--
“On September 1, 1878 (Sunday morning), at seven o’clock, a man followed by four other persons, all having the appearance of hunters, accompanied by dogs and carrying their guns, fired into my (Schulte’s) former bedroom. Schulte (the writer constantly speaks in the third person of himself throughout his diary) was still in bed. These men repeated the same and fired again into that room. At about nine o’clock in the morning they went through the adjoining wood, and also to a potato plot near by, and made all sorts of movements, as if to give the impression that they were hunting; but there was no game anywhere. Mr. Becker has investigated this matter and inquired all he could about it, and he has ascertained that the son of Schulte (my brother), from Barup, Hanover was among the party.”
This having occurred on September 1, three days before he started for America from Hamburg, has naturally led to the suspicion that a conspiracy was concocted there and then to kill the old man, and it is presumed that this more than anything else has induced the German Consul General to take such deep interest in this case. “I do not, I assure you,” he said to your correspondent “report the murders of all Germans in this country. It is not my business, but there are peculiar circumstances surrounding this case, compelling me to watch it closely.” It was known in the vicinity of Dortmund, where Schulte had his farm, that he was to leave for America within three days; his habits of grinding down all those serving under or with him naturally must have created ill-feeling against him. It was also shown by the investigation of the old gentleman’s papers that his brother living in Grozen-Holhausen owed him the amount of 10,000 marks, which he had loaned him, and for which Schulte took a mortgage on his brother’s property. Among the effects overhauled during the past two days appears a letter from his brother, telling Mr. Schulte that he could not pay the interest on that mortgage, and praying him not to be hard on him. Placing this side by side with the memorandum in the diary above quoted, the authorities here think that there exists good ground for presuming at least that the conspiracy was concocted in Germany, especially since the name of the nephew has been mentioned in connection with the unprovoked attack made upon him in his bedroom at Dortmund on the morning of the 1st of September.
The Consul General, when questioned in regard to these matters, declined to give utterance to any ideas he had formed on this subject, but it is well known here that cable messages have passed to and fro between New York and Berlin in regard to this matter during the past few days. The private interview held between State Attorney Olmstead, of Fairfield county, and the Consul General at New York, on Thursday, adds to the importance of the clew which the authorities are now following up, and if I am not mistaken European detectives are today watching the arrival out of steamers having on board the three murderers, whose tracks the American detectives have thus far been unable to trace on this side of the Atlantic. The Consul General does not deny that he has communicated with this government, but he declines either to give the nature of his information or the language in which he has couched his suggestions and instructions. He certainly has taken an extraordinary interest in this case, which now appears to be a crime which the judiciary of two continents will have to solve.
Calmly, but attentively, did this representative of the German government watch the proceedings in the court room to-day when the investigation, adjourned from last Monday, was continued. The State's Attorney, Olmstead, called as a witness, first, Mr. Alfred E. Austin, who had announced himself as Buchholtz’s counsel. It will be remembered that Buchholtz was Schulte’s servant in this country and has been under arrest during the past week for alleged complicity in the murder. The first questions asked of Mr. Austin were whether he had received any money from Buchholtz as “retainer,” he being employed by him as counsel. It was intended to prove by this that the money thus paid over to his counsel was the same money (marked) that belonged to the murdered Schulte. Mr. Austin declined to answer any questions, and a long discussion arose as to the right of the witness to shield himself behind the prerogatives of counsel and decline to answer.
Charles Lacroix, who keeps an oyster saloon at Westport, Conn., said that on Sunday last Buchholtz, accompanied by Paul Harcher and Mr. Berger, came to his place; they all had some oysters; Buchholtz handed him a fifty dollar bill, and the bill had a private mark of 380-191.
William A. Benedict, salesman in a Norwalk clothing store, testified that Buchholtz purchased an ulster there; handed in payment a fifty dollar bill, which had since been paid over to another party.
Edward Berger (a member of the jury) was here sworn :-- Saw plenty of money in possession of Buchholtz; saw him give a twenty dollar bill to Paul Harcher, and $170 to Mr. Austin, his counsel, on Monday last; witness signed the receipt for said money as witness; he knew of another fifty dollar bill paid to Lacroix, the Westport saloon keeper.
The prisoner's counsel was here recalled to the stand in regard to the $170 paid him; whether this money was received in his capacity of counsel or as banker for safe keeping. The State’s Attorney claimed that if it had been received in the latter capacity witness must state the sort of money he had received; if as counsel, it was a privileged communication. Mr. Olmstead claimed that a man might rob a store, take the proceeds to his counsel and the latter might demand protection on the strength of its being a privileged communication.
Ex-Mayor Dudley P. Ely, president of the Central National Bank, identified a twenty dollar bill which came to him from Paul Harcher, marked 380-110. Various other witnesses through whom a certain fifty dollar bill had passed were here examined, and it was traced directly to Buchholtz, the prisoner. The State’s Attorney here produced a sheet of foolscap, marked on both sides by numerous figures, and which was sworn to as having been found in Schulte’s safe, and said to be in Schulte’s handwriting. It contained numerous figures, and among these were the very same private marks detected on the bills passed by Buchholtz at the oyster saloon in Westport and at the clothing store in South Norwalk. The State’s Attorney added, holding up the fifty dollar bills, “I want the jury to be satisfied that these bills were in the possession of Mr Schulte when this schedule was made out and written by him.”
Testimony was here taken in regard to the pistols, hairbrush, tacks and other matters found in the lot immediately after the murder. Among other things found was a brand new pair of unbleached muslin overalls, which no one could claim as property. The State’s Attorney requested that any one in New York having sold a pair like these, length thirty-two inches, on or about December 27, communicate with him on the subject at Stamford, Conn.
The Coroner’s investigation was here adjourned till Monday, 20th inst., so as to enable the State’s Attorney to gather more facts in regard to this mysterious murder. Buchholtz was subsequently arraigned before Justice of the Peace Bouton, and a regular commitment was made out for him. In the document drawn up by the State’s Attorney he is plainly charged with the murder of Johann Schulte, and by advice of the authorities he was subsequently removed to the Fairfield County Jail, at Bridgeport. During the reading of the document, which was drawn up like an ordinary indictment, Buchholtz, though not understanding the English language, looked pale and dejected, as if affected by its contents. Those who insist upon considering him a guilty man now claim that in the letters from Europe handed to him in court last week he did not receive $250 in American money from his sister, as he gave out to his friends last week. It is charged that while not being under surveillance of the officers he inserted into those letters some of the bills in his possession in order to show that all American bank bills coming from Europe had a private mark, and in fact that these marks were not Schulte’s but those of German bankers, who had sold these American bank notes – a fact not controverted by those who know the business of bankers abroad.
Before the German Consul’s departure from South Norwalk [he] had a lengthy conference with Mayor Quintard and Mr. C. B. Smith, administrators of the Schulte estate, to ascertain exactly the status of the effects and the administrators. He was anxious to know, not so much about the money which was in the bank, but about that which was missing. Mayor Quintard has advertised for the creditors (if any there be) of the murdered man and to exhibit these claims and if not presented within a certain time “they will be debarred a recovery.” The Consul General expects to be in possession of a full power of attorney from Schulte, the broker, in about eight days, when he will take renewed measures to investigate the various effects belonging to the estate. In the meantime he has sent an official report of the crime to the imperial government, leaving it to the judgment of the Berlin officials how to act in the premises.
The Schulte Conspiracy.
----------
On the Track of Alleged Foreign Murderers.
----------
Two Conspicuous Travellers.
----------
From Stamford to New Haven and Back to Europe.
----------
Interview with Buchholtz in Jail.
----------
The official investigation of the Schulte murder case before the Coroner's jury was not continued to-day, the State's Attorney explaining at the outset of the proceedings that the threads pursued by himself and assistants during the past week would lead to revelations which could not as yet be laid before the jury. The matter was in that condition that at the next sitting probably a tale would be unfolded justifying the necessity of to-day's adjournment. A secret consultation was then held between the State's Attorney and the jury, and measures were agreed upon to continue the private investigations, which have kept numerous detectives busy in Norwalk, in New York and also in Europe during the past week. In fact, the stormy weather on the Atlantic, causing so many steamers to make long passages, is the indirect cause of the present suspension of the Coroner's investigation, as every moment news is expected that one of the murderers has been arrested on one of the outward bound steamers. It must be remembered that since the German Consul's visit to South Norwalk he has zealously co-operated with the State's Attorney in using all the machinery at his command to ferret out the murderers of the wealthy German. Numerous cable despatches have passed between New York and Germany since the last adjournment when first suspicion was aroused that the crime might have been concocted in Germany, where old Mr. Schulte was the object of two murderous assaults a few days before his departure for this country, as stated at the time in the HERALD. When the jury met this morning it was expected that, as a result of these numerous telegrams, an arrest would have been made at one of the European ports, but the non-arrival out of the steamer on which one of the murderers is said to have taken passage is the actual cause of the delay.
The intervening time has, however, been well made use of, as the theory that the crime was concocted abroad has been closely followed with considerable success. This much is known, that on the night of December 27, when Schulte was murdered, two conspicuous looking foreigners reached the railway station at Stamford at about ten o'clock. They were out of breath when they arrived at the station, as if they had been running a long distance, and in broken English they inquired excitedly when the next train was to leave for New York. There were no more New York trains that evening, and they were so informed by numerous cabmen and hangers on, who always make a country railroad station their headquarters. Evidently disappointed, they walked up and down the platform of the Stamford station for some time, gesticulating and talking excitedly, and separating whenever they considered themselves noticed by those who happened to be at the station.
It should be stated that the place where Schulte was murdered is exactly six miles from Stamford, the entire distance between Stamford and South Norwalk being only eight miles. The murder was committed between seven and eight o'clock that evening, and even though unacquainted with the topography of the surrounding country some exertion could have brought the murderers to Stamford by ten o'clock. Soon after an eastern bound train reached the station, and these same individuals, instead of going to New York, took passage on this train. They did not go together in the same car, but took seats quite apart from each other. The shrewd conductor, however, who remembered the peculiarities of his passengers, now distinctly recollects that these men, both looking odd and awkward, did not hand over any tickets, but paid their fares in cash. They both got out at New Haven – it was Friday night – and remained there over Saturday. On Sunday morning one of them returned to New York on a New Haven train, and is believed to have taken one of the first steamers to Europe. The detectives thus far have not been able to trace the movements of his companion, whose track has been lost in New Haven. It was for the purpose of securing the arrest of the former, of whom an accurate description has been forwarded, that so many telegrams in regard to the Schulte case have been sent across the water during the past week.
In the meantime William Buchholtz, the accused servant of Schulte, remains in the Fairfield County Jail at Bridgeport. He was to have been arraigned before Justice Bouton this morning, but owing to a singular "misunderstanding," as it was called by the officials, he was not brought to South Norwalk, notwithstanding that a written order had been issued to produce his body in court this morning. The officer having received the order said that he considered the Sheriff now had charge of the prisoner, and the Bridgeport officials perhaps thought that if the Norwalk authorities wanted their man they might come for him. His absence from court created the more comment in so far as officers are not apt to "misunderstand" written orders. When the matter was talked over after the adjournment of the court it was given out on the authority of a juryman, that Buchholtz, who considers himself unjustly dealt with, made some very significant remarks when last week he was taken to the Bridgeport Jail. Upon taking the cars at this place for his lodgings in the Fairfield County Jail he said, "If ever I get back to Norwalk they'll not take me back to prison alive." Whether the fear of the authorities to bring him here, where he has many friends who consider him a persecuted man, is the real definition of to-day's "misunderstanding" remains a mystery. That he feels the terrible position in which he is placed is evident from an interview had with him in jail by his counsel. "Why," said he, "after having volunteered all the information in my possession about the murder, and having been permitted to walk around Norwalk for two weeks, should I now be placed behind bars in this cell. They have no more against me now than they had at the start." Whatever he may think of this is, however, contrary to the opinion of the State's Attorney, who considers it to be his duty to hold him for the present. Buchholtz has, however, ample counsel now, no less than three lawyers – Randall C. Smith, Alfred E. Austin and Charles F. Bollman, of New Haven – having taken up his defence.
The latter is a German, who can freely converse with his client, and in the preliminary proceedings before Judge Bouton this morning he showed at once that Buchholtz would have all the advantages that the law granted him. The State's Attorney proposed to go on with the case before the Judge, but Mr. Bollman refused to go on in the absence of the prisoner. His attention being called to the fact that the State of Connecticut ought not to be put to the expense of $15 or $20 to bring the prisoner on from Bridgeport, he claimed that it was a small matter where a man's liberty was concerned. If the case was to go on, he insisted that his client should hear all that the witnesses have to say, and should sit right there at his side, so that he could converse with him. Again, when subsequently Mr. Bollman was reminded of the fact that counsel even were not required to be present at an inquest by a coroner's jury, he very sharply remarked, "But the State's Attorney is here!'
"Yes," said Mr. Olmstead, "the State's Attorney is here of his own volition, without receiving a dollar of pay for it, and the State's Attorney will stay here to see this case through."
Mr. Bollman Insisted upon the prisoner being produced in court before going on, when Mr. Olmstead replied that they might be sure, if he did, he would not get out of the hands of the officers. Judge Bouton then adjourned the proceedings in his court to next Monday.
Buchholtz's counsel make the point that the complaint drawn by the State's Attorney, and upon which he was sent to jail, was dated back and not dated upon the day of his arrest. All the time that the prisoner was testifying before the Coroner's jury the complaint, though not served, was actually made out.
The prosecution maintain that they are justified in proceeding as they have done by the testimony now in their possession. "On the afternoon of the Schulte murder, while Buchholtz was waiting for his master," said Mr. Olmstead to-day, "he told Paul Harcher, of the Davis Hotel, that he wished Schulte would come, that he was afraid of tramps, but that if attacked by only two persons he could defend himself. Does it not look as if he was concocting a story? Then he has lied about his money, and what is more, as I go on with the case, it looks as if the old man was robbed of at least 25,000 marks, instead of $1,000 .”
In addition to these remarks of the state's Attorney Norwalk officers who have been hunting up new evidence in New York during the past week state that they can prove that Buchholtz has been very liberal with money ever since he was employed by Schulte, They have discovered a saloon in Chatham street, where he spent $40 in one evening. They have possession of a letter written him by a waitress, who assures him of her attachment, but complains that she is being continually watched by detectives, the very letter she was then writing being written in the immediate presence of the officers. Still, this would not deter her from communicating with him and expressing her sympathy for a true friend. The letter, being written in German, is now in the hands of a translator and will be laid before the Coroner's jury. Whether the girl is to be produced as a witness has not yet been decided upon, though it is not believed that Buchholtz ever confided any secrets to her and only passed his evenings in the saloon where she is employed whenever he visited New York.
Another remarkable incident in this mysterious case astonished the good citizens of South Norwalk to-day. It will be remembered that along the path followed by Schulte on the way to his farm stood a cedar tree, which had been fixed up in some sort of an ambush. Branches from other trees had been placed there in such a manner that two men could easily hide themselves, and it was near there that the body of the murdered man was found. The tree and the additional branches had been left undisturbed ever since the day of the murder. To the surprise of all it became known to-day that this tree has been cut down. It was not carried away. but simply cut. Who cut the tree down and for what purpose are questions which all Norwalk is now engaged in solving. Some of the citizens of this place are rather surprised that in the entire range of country scoured for evidence tending to clear up every detail of this mysterious murder, no attention has been paid to the vicinity of Whistleville. This is a place about two miles from Norwalk, called so because the locomotives always "whistle" when passing there, and containing along its outskirts quite a number of desperadoes, who have been the terror of this section of the county for a number of years past. A property owner residing near the Schulte farm told your correspondent this morning that, though Whistleville of course contained a large number of respectable citizens, there was a gang there noted for depredations and robberies well worthy the attention of the State's officials.
The Schulte Murder.
A reporter of the HERALD called upon Dr. Schumacher, the German Consul General, yesterday, to ascertain the nature of the communications which passed between his office and the Berlin government in regard to the Schulte murder case. While the Consul admitted that there has been correspondence on that subject he declined for the present to furnish it for publication. He called attention, however, to a paragraph in the Kölnische Zeitung, which stated that the murdered man took at least 45,000 thalers to America when last he visited his home in Germany. The Consul was of opinion that even this amount did not come up to the actual figure, and that future developments might show that the old miser had more money in this country than even the authorities of Norwalk have been able to discover.
A strong chain of evidence is being forged around Buchholtz, one of the supposed murderers of the miser Schulte. The production yesterday of the skull of the murdered man formed a ghastly spectacle.
The Schulte Murder
--------
Conclusion of the Investigation at South Norwalk.
--------
Verdict of the Coroner’s Jury.
--------
Buchholtz Held on the Charge of “Guilty Knowledge.”
--------
Interesting Letters From Germany.
After weeks of careful research and investigation the jury which was empanelled on the 28th of December last to ascertain all the circumstances and incidents surrounding the brutal murder of the wealthy miser Schulte have at last finished their labors by declaring that Buchholtz, the servant, is cognizant of all the facts connected with this crime. At the opening of this morning’s session Mr. Charles F. Bollman, of New Haven, the prisoner’s counsel, who had previously insisted upon his right to actively represent his client, even before a coroner’s jury, produced a copy of the New York Herald of January 26, showing that in the case of Madden, the murdered sailor, the accused (Smith) was represented by three lawyers. The report showed, he contended, that they were permitted to make prefatory remarks to the jury before evidence was taken; that they were there throughout the inquest and were enabled to guard the interests of their client. Furthermore, after the verdict had been rendered they caused the jury to change the phraseology of their verdict. He desired to know whether this was one of the precedents upon which the State’s Attorney relied for insisting that prisoner’s counsel had no rights which the prosecution was bound to respect.
The State’s Attorney – These three New York lawyers must have run away with that coroner’s jury.
Mr. Bollman – That is just what you are trying to do in this case.
The examination of witnesses being resumed, Mr. Alanson Allen [Dilazon Allen], a neighbor of the murdered man, was recalled. He testified that on the night of the murder, when coming back from the woods, being accompanied by Mr. Dingee, Buchholtz, Samuel Waring and his grandson, they walked along the footpath to Schulte’s house; white near the stone wall they found a bundle; Buchholtz or Waring picked it up; witness asked what it was, when he was told that it was their property; Buchholtz took the bundle and placed it on the steps in the rear of Schulte’s house; witness returned to his own house, and after the lapse of some time returned to Schulte’s house, accompanied only by his grandson; Mrs. Waring (the housekeeper) showed witness some blood stains on the floor; they were in the form of a footprint; witness was sure he saw a clear footprint of bloody stains; Buchholtz had then gone with others to Norwalk to notify the authorities, but had not yet returned [he had been home, however]. When witness was near the body at the place in the woods where the murder had been committed, he himself stepped into a pool of blood, but did not believe that the footprints in the house came from him; these bloody footprints led from the door to the middle of the room; witness also, by the light of his lantern, saw blood stains of the size of ten cent pieces on the stone wall before the body was carried home; when in the Schulte house witness had a conversation with Mrs. Waring in regard to the bundle picked up by Buchholtz and left on the back steps; the bundle smelled as if it contained hams.
It will be remembered that the murdered man is known to have bought in New York that afternoon three bottles of Rhine wine and two hams or shoulders – the wine was in a satchel and the hams were packed up in a paper bundle. The authorities here appear to be at a loss to know where Schute purchased these things, notwithstanding the fact that they have instituted careful inquiries in regard to this peculiar incident, which seems to have caused considerable delay during his stay in New York that afternoon.
After Mr. Allen’s testimony had concluded the State’s Attorney called Mr. Charles Illing on the stand, the young man who, at the outset of the investigation, caused considerable sensation in New York by his over-zealous attempt to secure the attendance of Mrs. Rohe. It was claimed in Norwalk to-day, however that though Illing might have been indiscreet in New York at the time, he has done more toward unravelling the mysteries connected with this case than all the other detectives officially employed by the State. Mr. Illing laid before the jury a letter (written in German) received by Buchholtz from his sister. It will be remembered that the prisoner claims to have received $250 from his sister since his arrival in this country, thus accounting, as he stated, for the large amount of money in his possession. The following translation of the letter from this sister read before the jury to-day throws some light on this subject :--
My Dear Brother – After long waiting we received your kind letter, and are happy to know that you arrived safely in New York. We have always continued to think of you, often with tears and sighs. Not a day has passed but we said, “Where can William be now?” It is, indeed, a sad experience to be separated in this manner, but it cannot now be changed. We must be satisfied with our fate. We will not lose courage, however Who knows but it may be for the best of your interests? Have confidence in God and he will protect you.
We cannot, I am sorry to say, comply with your request to send you money. We would have told you so by telegraph, but that would have been too expensive. We have also written to our uncle about it, but have received a negative answer from Julius.
What will you do now? that is the question. Can you not find something to occupy yourself with in New York till the yellow fever has entirely abated in the South? You are strong and know all sorts of work, and nobody knows you there. I don’t know how matters are situated there. You must know best how to get along. You know if I could I would help you. I would do it at once, and so would also Berthold; but, unfortunately, we are not in a position to do it.
[The writer here writes about family affairs, and about a dream she had, seeing her brother on a grand estate in Australia, filled with tropical fruits and flowers.]
Be ever diligent and do your utmost to get along. Trust in God and He will lead you eventually into the haven of peace and happiness. Your loving sister, JOHANNA.
After the reading of the above letter, which was readily translated for the information of the jury by Mr. Konig, a representative of the German press in New York, Mr. Illing submitted another letter written by one Dorothea Karge, who informs Buchholtz that she has given birth to a child which resembles him considerably. The letter is full of endearing terms and overflowing with affection for the prisoner.
Both of these letters were taken by Officer Berger out of Buchholtz’s trunk in Schulte’s home at Roton Hill, and, at the conclusion of their reading the State’s Attorney announced that he had no more testimony to offer. Coroner Craw then instructed the jury to carefully go over all the evidence, deliberate without passion, and he would be in readiness during the afternoon to receive their verdict.
Just as the jury were about to withdraw Mr. Randall C. Smith, one of the counsel for the defence, demanded the right to be present in the jury room, in so far as he saw that the State’s Attorney was to be on hand.
Mr. Olmstead – I have been invited by the jury to be present and assist them in their deliberations.
Mr. Smith – This is a most unusual proceeding. This man, Buchholtz, has been arrested on a bench warrant, even before the jury has rendered a verdict. The usual way is for a jury to hand in their evidence to the State’s Attorney, who can then act upon it; but in this case the State’s Attorney has caused the arrest of Buchholtz, and he has not even had a preliminary examination. His hands are tied, as he has been locked up in Bridgeport. His mouth is gagged, because he is a stranger in the land and does not speak the English language. It is evident to me that the State’s Attorney is determined to convict this man of a crime that is certain death to him. All I come here for is to see that this foreigner shall have fair play and be protected while on our soil by the broad mantle of justice; that is all we ask.
Mr. Olmstead – I did not ask to be present at the deliberations of the jury; I was only requested to be on hand.
The foreman of the jury here announced, through Coroner Craw, that the jury had determined to get along without the presence of the State’s Attorney, thus excluding the prosecution as well as the defence from their deliberations.
While the jury were out several groups of persons, among whom were numerous excited Germans insisted that Buchholtz was quite innocent, a New York Teuton remarking that he knew that Buchholtz would on his trial be able to prove an alibi. Then again it was stated that a German saloon keeper had disappeared from New York the day after the murder, and that the determination to punish Buchholtz for a crime evidently committed by parties as yet unknown would be resisted with all the legal lore that could be obtained in and outside of Connecticut. It came out incidentally during these excited discussions that, notwithstanding all the precautions taken by the State’s Attorney, the prisoner has been visited in jail during the past two weeks by several of his Norwalk friends, who have kept him well posted as to the progress of the proceedings. What occasioned most comment, however, was the singular manner in which a letter from Schulte’s brother, received last week and intended for the German Consul in New York, had been addressed When the news of the murder first reached Germany the Consul General received at his office, in good order, a lengthy cable despatch direct from Frederick Wilhelm Schulte, at Grossen Holthausen. The letter just received was addressed to the Consul at South Norwalk, instead of New York, but it was at once transmitted by Postmaster Dunning to New York, the Consul acknowledging receipt of the same by return mail.
It was near four o’clock when the jury announced that they had agreed upon a verdict. It is conceived in the following terms :--
Fairfield County, ss., Norwalk. – The undersigned jurors, being duly empanelled and sworn to inquire of the cause and manager of the death of Johann Heinrich Schulte, whose death was suggen and untimely, and the cause and manner of which was unknown, having viewed the body of said deceased and considered the evidence given to us, do on our oaths say that said Johann Heinrich Schulte came to his death at said town of Norwalk, on the 27th day of December, A. D. 1878, by two separate wounds on the head, each of said wounds penetrating the brain, inflicted with some unknown instrument in the hands of soe person or persons known to William Buchholz, and we do find that said William Buchholz has a guilty knowledge of said crime, whereof we subscribe our names.
Dated at Norwalk, the 10th day of February, A. D. 1879.
George C. Stittson, Foreman.
Charles T. Craw, Clerk.
R. H. Rowan, James M. Lane, Franklin A. Tolles, Edward Burger, Jurors.
------------------
Upon inquiry at the office of the German Consul General Schumacher it was ascertained that he had received a letter from Frederick William Schulte in answer to a cable despatch that he sent announcing the murder of his brother, the late J. H. Schulte. There is nothing in the letter that throws any particular light on themurder, and after asking for a certificate of the death of his brother the writer states that J. H. Schulte probably had with him bonds and other securities to the value of about $50,000. The letter was some time getting to the Consul General, as it was addressed, “Mister Mayor Schumann.” The Consul partially explains the faulty address, as he understood that the Mayor of Norwalk had also telegraphed for instructions and the brother evidently got confused and mixed up the two addresses.
THE SCHULTE MURDER CASE.
The Grand Jury have been in session here since Wednesday last taking testimony in the case of William Buchholtz, who is charged with the murder of the wealthy German named Schulte, at Norwalk, on December 27. A large number of witnesses have been examined and they will probably finish by Tuesday next. The general impression is that they will bring in a true bill against Buchholtz. Should that be the case his trial will probably come off on the latter end of the present term of court.
FOUR THOUSAND MARKS REWARD.
Information has been received from Europe that Wilhelm Schulte, of Hagen, brother of the German miser, Johann Schulte, who was killed near South Norwalk on the evening of December 27 last, has offered a reward of 4,000 marks for the arrest and conviction of the murderer. Should Wilhelm Buchholtz, Schulte's servant, now in Bridgeport jail as an alleged accomplice, be convicted, there will be quite a scramble for the reward, as many Norwalk detectives claim to have fathomed the mystery which may lead to the young German's conviction
THE SCHULTE MURDER.
TIGHTENING THE COILS AROUND BUCHHOLTZ – EVIDENCE GATHERED BY THE DETECTIVES – THE PRISONER'S "MONEY LETTERS."
While William Buchholtz pines in a Connecticut prison and hopes to be able to prove himself innocent of the charge of having murdered the German merchant Schulte last December, the detectives of Connecticut and New York are gathering the evidences on which they expect to be able to fasten guilt upon him. Mr. C. Illing, who is attached to the State Attorney’s office in Connecticut, and who has worked night and day on the case in conjunction with Detective Von Gerichten, of this city, thinks he has evidence which cannot fail to bring the crime home to the accused. Mr. Illing has secured witnesses who will testify that between the 29th of September and the 3d of October, 1878, Buchholtz was almost penniless. Indeed, that was his condition almost as soon as he reached America, for among the written evidence against him is a letter written by himself on September 5, 1878, to Mr. Mettenleiter, a countryman, asking for financial help even to the extent of $5 or $8 to pay his board and rent at the Sun Hotel, Bridgeport. He thanks Mr. Mettenleiter in this letter for similar favors before, and promises to return his kindness, with interest, in the future. It will be remembered that the accused man claims to have had $150 when he arrived in this country from Europe August 17, 1878, but the barkeeper at the hotel named Otto is ready to swear that Buchholtz owed his house $35 for board on October 3. Buchholtz also claims that he received from his sister in Hanover, on November 29, two letters which contained $250 American money and five coins besides, but Detective Illing has the sworn statement of the Post Office authorities in this city that no such letters ever passed through the New York Post Office, for the reason that gold or silver coin is unmailable matter between Germany and the United States, and all letters containing such coin are by law stopped at the office of mailing, and Postmaster James thinks it is hardly possible that such letters as contained the coin could have left Germany in the manner indicated. The post office authorities are satisfied that no such letter or letters passed through the office here. Such a letter, Mr. Illing says, was handed to Buchholtz by Mr. Burger, a detective of South Norwalk, Conn., after the preliminary investigation was over. Neither the State Attorney nor any one else looked at the letter, and two hours later Buchholtz had bought himself an overcoat, for which he paid with a fifty dollar bill. This bill was afterward recognized as Buchholtz's, because it was marked with German figures. The next day (Sunday) he changed another fifty dollar bill in an oyster saloon. This is the money that Buchholtz alleges he got from his sister. But with this money letter there came another from a young woman of his acquaintance, telling him about the marriage of a female friend of his. This letter was handed to Buchholtz in this city by Mr. Decker, a post office employe, on November 29, but was returned the same day and was remailed to Mr. Schulte. The other letter, containing the money, was kept back by the barkeeper of the Sun Hotel to repay himself the debt due by the accused, which at the time amounted to about $50. So that the money which Buchholtz declares he got from his sister he did not receive. And yet he had money at the times indicated.
It was shown in the HERALD before that Buchholtz had been in New York on the 23d and 24th of December, and the opinion of detectives Illing and Von Gerichten is that at that time he arranged with some German friends in this city to aid in committing the crime three days later with which he is now charged. There was due on one of Buchholtz's letters fifteen cents, but this sum cannot be traced through the Post Office. A letter mailed by Buchholtz to “Helen Buchholtz, 3 Seifeilt street, 3 B Linden, near Hanover,” has been traced also. This sister Helen was a daily visitor at the house of the female from whom Buchholtz claims he received money; but the detectives think it strange that the sending of so much money was never mentioned apparently by one to the other and not referred to by either in their epistles. The persons implicated with Buchholtz in the murder are undoubtedly Germans, and it is difficult to get at correct information concerning the case from any of them. Mr. Illing thinks he knows the accomplices and will shortly have one or more arrested. Mr. Kreiling, proprietor of the Sun Hotel, arrived here from Europe yesterday, and was interviewed by a reporter, but he did not know much about the case and absolutely nothing about the money. He is willing to go to Bridgeport to testify to what he does know, however. Detective Illing believes the money letter is a "put up job" to throw the police off the track, but he thinks they have the right man and the evidence to convict him. Mr. Illing, who has been in this city for the last three weeks, left for Connecticut last evening to report progress to his Chief. The trial of Buchholtz takes place in May.
THE SCHULTE MURDER.
THE MISER'S GOLD WATCH FOUND – AN IMPORTANT LINK IN THE CASE AGAINST BUCHHOLTZ.
While Mr. Hoyt, a farmer, living near Roton Hill, the home of the murdered John Henry Schulte, was bringing home a load of hay yesterday the horses shied, compelling the laborers accompanying the wagon to retire behind a hickory tree along the road. While standing there one of the laborers, a Swede, picked up a gold watch within a few feet of the tree. This watch has since been handed over to State's Attorney Olmstead, and he says it tallies with a description he had a short time previously received of the murdered Schulte's watch. There appears to be no doubt that the watch found is the one belonging to Schulte. Mr. Olmstead has also ascertained that on the evening of the murder four men saw Buchholtz, Schulte's servant, who is now in jail, standing under the tree where the watch was found, while he was waiting for Samuel Waring, who had gone to arouse the neighbors. Mr. Olmstead appears to be satisfied that he has now conclusive evidence to prove that Buchholtz committed the murder.
State Attorney Olmstead, of Stamford, Conn., who was in New York yesterday, expressed his annoyance at the statements made by Detective Illing which were published in Sunday's HERALD. From these the impression would be left on the mind of the reader that Illing was acting under Mr. Olmstead's authority in working up the case. On the contrary, Mr. Olmstead asserts that he has never recognized him in an official capacity, given him directions or consulted with him, excepting when Illing arrested, in this city, Mrs. Rohe. Illing telegraphed him that Mrs. Rohe was willing to go to Norwalk, and Mr. Olmstead telegraphed in reply that if she was willing to bring her on by all means.