A new trial of William Buchholz, for the murder of John H. Schulte, at Norwalk, Conn., in December, 1878, will begin at Bridgeport next Tuesday. His former conviction of murder in the first degree was set aside for improper conduct of a juror.
THE SHULTE MURDER TRIAL.
BRIDGEPORT, Conn., Feb. 17, 1880.The second trial of William Bucholz for the murder of H. Schulte, at Norwalk, December 27, 1878, commenced to-day. Chief Justice Park presided, with Judge Loomis as associate. At the hour of adjournment no jurors had been obtained. An extra panel has been summoned for Wednesday morning.
THE BUCHOLZ MURDER TRIAL.
At the morning session of the Bucholz trial the cross-examination of Mrs. Waring was concluded without eliciting anything of importance.
Victor Rohe testified to the efforts of Bucholz to borrow money from him after entering Schulte's service.
The next witness called was R. S. Hineman, confined in jail here on a charge of forgery. He swore that during a conversation with Bucholz in jail the prisoner said to him, "If it hadn't been for Stark, the detective, they would never have known I did it." These words he made a memorandum of and produced the memorandum in court. Bucholz also said, "The detectives were not so smart as they might have been, or they would have found $6,000 more; Hineman swore that he made arrangements with Bucholz to escape from jail, and that Bucholz said if he would help him to get out they would get the money and go to Europe; Hineman made an attempt to escape, while painters were employed at the jail, by tearing up a sheet, making a pair of overalls with it, and smearing them with paint, intending to slip out with the painters when they quit work, but the attempt failed; he then told Bucholz that he had friends in New York who would send him saws to cut the window bars, and he (Hineman) would escape in that way, and then aid Bucholz to do the same; Bucholz said that he would disguise himself by dyeing his hair, and that in Germany they had a way by which one could change the color of his eyes. The cross-examination of the witness commenced by the question :-- "What is your name?" The witness declined to answer, explaining that his answer would prejudice himself in the case for forgery against him soon to be tried. The Chief Justice ruled that he must answer. The witness then gave the name of John W. Willis as his true name. Successive questions, none of which he answered without the ruling of the Court that he must do so, brought out the fact that he is the son of a well known man in St. Louis and that he has no business or settled place of abode. He claims that he is known in New York, Cincinnati, St. Louis, Chicago, Louisville and San Francisco. When asked for his residence in New York he said that he stayed at one time with a friend in a boarding house on Gramercy Park, two doors west of Samuel J. Tilden's residence. He refused to disclose his sister's name, saying that she was the wife of a present member of Congress. The Chief Justice ruled that the witness need not answer the question until he had an opportunity of consulting his counsel during recess. Counsel for the defence objected to such consultation, but the Chief Justice replied that that was a matter which lay within the discretion of the Court to decide. A recess was then taken until two o'clock.
Hineman, or Willis, was brought here from Utica, N.Y., on a requisition to answer to a charge of forgery upon the First National Bank of this city, and is now awaiting trial.
Upon reassembling, the question as to the name of witness' sister was renewed without eliciting the desired information. Pending the decision of the Court the past record of Willis was made the subject of a lengthy cross-examination. He admitted a series of forgeries, amounting to $5,400, on the Philadelphia National Bank five or six years ago, for which he served three years in prison and then was pardoned. He afterward visited Baltimore, New York, Chicago and Louisville; was arrested in Utica and brought from that place here. Although mentioning the names of parties highly connected in those places as persons knowing his name, history and family connections, he studiously avoided reference to any person familiar with his record since he left prison, two years ago, and was finally sustained in his refusal to disclose the name of his sister by the ruling of the Court, to which the defence excepted. Witness offered to give the name in private to counsel, provided it was not disclosed in court or given to the reporters. General Smith refused to accept the terms proposed. The court room, which had been hitherto comparatively deserted, was crowded during the afternoon session. The Court adjourned until Tuesday next.
THE SCHULTE MURDER.
----------
BUCHOLZ' TRIAL CONTINUED -- A FELLOW PRISONER OF THE ACCUSED TAKES A DECIDED STAND.
In the Bucholz trial to-day the first witness was George H. Graft. He testified that he was an inmate of the jail; he knew Bucholz, having been acquainted with him there. He was asked by the State Attorney whether he had ever heard Bucholz say anything about the murder of Schulte, or his money, and he replied, "I have conscientious scruples about testifying against the man, a fellow prisoner whose life is at stake." Bucholz had "treated him like a gentleman," he said, and he declined to say anything about the matter.
The Court said :-- "Witness, you must tell what was said between you in this matter, if anything!"'
Witness wished to be excused from saying anything against a man who was friendly to him. He did not wish to testify on the ground that it might tend to criminate himself.
The Court again said :-- "You must tell what was said between you."
Witness replied :-- "I decline to tell." Witness was then asked whether he had said anything to Bucholz about the killing of Mr. Schulte, and replied, "I decline to tell." The State appealed to the Court, saying they had information that Bucholz had talked to witness about the matter, and thought they ought to have the entire benefit of the conversation between witness and the prisoner.
Judge Parks asked witness if he declined to give the conversation they had. He replied, "I do." The witness was sentenced to be confined in jail until he decided to answer the questions or until further order of the Court.
Sadie Warring was next called and testified that she never knew Schulte by any other name than John Henry Schulte; never heard the prisoner and deceased quarrel together and thought the men were always on good terms; heard Bucholz say when he first came to the house on the night of the murder, "Come, Sammy, I cannot stay here when poor Mr. Schulte is down in the woods getting killed."
Annie Warring, a sister of the former witness, testified to the State Attorney and others coming to the house last fall and going through the same scenes that were enacted by the witness and her family on the night of the murder. The object of the State was to prove that Bucholz had sufficient time to commit the crime and hide the instrument which was used in the commission of the deed, and also to hide the money subsequently found by Detective Stark, and reach the house at the time he did.
Sammy Warring testified to hearing Bucholz call his name; wanted him to go down in the woods when Schulte was killed; witness and Bucholz went after the neighbors when the body was found; before reaching the spot where the body was found witness saw a bundle of hams; called Bucholz's attention to it and he said "All right;" the bundle lay about ten feet from the path near the fence; witness found a book near the body of Schulte, also some papers: in examining the body he found an inside pocket of the coat turned out; witness said, he, in company with others, went to South Norwalk and notified the Coroner and returned to the body, where he waited till the jury arrived; witness helped to carry the body to the house; Bucholz said nothing on the night of the murder as to the manner in which Schulte was killed.
On cross-examination witness said Bucholz seemed very much excited when he reached the house and gave the alarm that night; witness did not remember saying on the former trial that he saw a pocketbook lying near the body; did not see Bucholz have a pistol in his band while near the scene of the murder.
Redirect – On being questioned as to what he referred to on a former trial, when he testified about a pocketbook, witness, pointing to the memorandum book offered in evidence in the morning, replied, "To this."
John Dingee testified that he saw the former witness pick up the book referred to; he saw nothing else lying near the body except a small canvas bag, which he identified as Schultz's money bag; witness saw no one else put hands upon the body while there.
The court room was crowded with ladies during the afternoon.
THE SCHULTE TRAGEDY.
----------
CONTINUATION OF THE BUCHOLZ TRIAL – SUSPICIOUS FOOTPRINTS IN A KITCHEN – THE PRISONER AND THE PISTOL – BRUSHING AWAY A THEORY OF THE DEFENCE.
At the Bucholz trial to-day John Dingee was cross-examined. The witness did not see the bundle testified to by Sammy Warring yesterday; saw Warring pick up the book and hat; witness told him to put them back where he found them, that he had no right to remove the articles until after the inquest; witness did not see any one touch the body while lying in the woods; saw no blood on the ground near the deceased.
Delason Allen testified that the Warring family and Bucholz came to his house and said that Schulte and Bucholz had been attacked down in the woods: witness saw blood on Bucholz's face, which he found came from a few scratches; went with others to the scene of the murder; on reaching the stone fence, about sixty feet from the body, witness saw spots of blood on the stones; when witness reached the body he saw Bucholz, who was ahead, stoop over the body and exclaim, "My God, he is dead!" Witness saw on the kitchen floor of Warring's house spots of blood; the marks resembled footprints such as would be made by the tap of the sole of a boot; this was before the body was brought to the house.
The witness was cross-examined closely in regard to the time Mrs. Warring and others came to his house for his assistance. He said that he saw Bucholz have a pistol in his hand that night and cautioned him about handling it.
Edwin Hoyt and Gustave Hedstrom testified to finding the watch identified as being Schulte's under a tree on the 5th of March, 1879. On being cross-examined, Hoyt said that when found the watch was as bright as at the present time.
Franklin A. Tolles identified the pantaloons taken from Bucholz's room in Warring's house; saw several spots on the left leg near the knee; thought they were blood spots; dark spots, supposed to be blood, were on the shirt; found the pistol thirty feet north of the body (pistol identified); a piece of the shirt was found about fifteen feet north of the body.
On cross-examination Tolles testified that he found the axe in the barn attached to Warring's house; saw blood on the blade, with feathers adhering; the axe was standing against a block, on which there was blood; saw feathers on the ground near.
George C. Stillson, foreman of the Coroner's jury, testified that when they reached the body they saw that the watch had been taken from the chain and the pockets turned out; he called the attention of the jury to the fact that the body had been robbed; when the body was taken to the house it was searched; found in the pockets a package of German marks, amounting to $20,000 in American money; also about $939 United States money. Witness found the day after the murder a pocket hairbrush, with light hairs in it; a few days after Bucholz came to his store and wanted to buy one, saying he had lost his and wanted to get another.
Mary Downey testified that she saw Bucholz give Mr. Warring, about the 13th of October, previous to the murder, $160 in greenbacks, which he wanted her to keep for him; when he was going away he took the money from a large roll of bills, which he put back in his pocket.
Cross-examined – He made no effort to conceal the money.
Charles Lane testified that Bucholz helped to carry the body of Schulte; he was on the same side with him, Bucholz being ahead, and could not reach the skirt pocket of Schulte's coat from where he was; saw Bucholz's hand all the time; did not let go the body.
The defence claimed, on the former trial, that Bucholz robbed the body on the way to the house.
THE NORWALK CRIME.
----------
FURTHER TESTIMONY IN THE BUCHOLZ TRIAL – MICROSCOPIC REVELATIONS DESCRIBED BY MEDICAL EXPERTS.
The cross-examination of James M. Lane was resumed this morning as follows :-- Bucholz helped to carry Schulte's body, he (Bucholz) walking on the right side of the body.
On the re-direct examination Lane said he noticed no blood dripping from the body while it was being carried to the house; did not see blood spots on the ground between the place where the body was found in the woods and the house the next day or subsequently.
Dr. Joshua B. Treadwell, of Boston, testified that he had made blood stains a study for the past six years. He experiments principally to determine the difference between blood corpuscles of different animals. The corpuscles of a fowl's blood are oval, and of human blood round.
Witness was shown an axe, offered in evidence. He identified it as being the one brought to him for examination.
The defence objected to the evidence of blood on this axe, on the ground that the axe had lain in a barn for nine months after the murder, and an opportunity had been given any designing person to manufacture evidence against the accused. The objection was overruled.
The witness stated that on the 11th of the present month he moved portions of the material on the axe; made several tests of particles taken from the blade of the axe and found both chicken and human blood corpuscles; in portions from the head of the axe only human blood was found: the action of the rust on the spots demonstrated the fact that the human blood on the axe was more recent than the chicken blood; the witness removed eighteen particles from a pair of pantaloons; on sixteen of them were human blood spots which had an upward tendency and were imbedded in the texture, proving the blood to have been fresh, not clotted, when it came in contact with the garment. The witness said the spots were more numerous on the left pantaloons leg; he only found five on the right pantaloons leg; spots could not have been made while carrying the body as described by other witnesses; witness examined ten particles from five spots on a portion of the shirt; in three tests he found human blood, and no other kind; he also found a dark substance, such as was found on the axe; he could not tell what it was.
On cross-examination the witness said that he had made tests of blood corpuscles during the past seven years, and had examined blood stains in several murder cases, the last one being the Hayden case, in New Haven. He said the action of the rust on the blood corpuscles tended to change the shape of them, and also to destroy them.
Dr. L. J. Sanford, Professor of Yale Medical College, New Haven, testified that he had made blood corpuscles a study for twenty-five years; there was a very perceptible difference between the blood corpuscles of human beings and those of fowls; he said blood must be fresh to penetrate the texture of woollens.
In his cross-examination Dr. Sanford said the action of rust upon blood corpuscles has a tendency to destroy them; there was no difficulty in restoring dried corpuscles; he could readily detect those of a human being and of a fowl.
Paul Herscher testified that Bucholz told him that he had had several quarrels with Schulte; he told the witness he was going to leave Schulte on the 20th of January; also that the latter had plenty of money in his trunk.
The witness was taken with a fainting fit and removed from the court room.
Dr. M. S. Pardee, of Norwalk, testified that he examined the wounds of the deceased at the Coroner's inquest; he found one on the top and back of the head and another back of the left ear; the latter wound was between two and three inches deep and was two inches in length; in his opinion the latter wound caused death instantly. On cross-examination, witness said he thought the wound back of the ear could be made with the axe shown in court, provided the blow was made with the corner.
THE BUCHOLZ MURDER TRIAL.
----------
MORE MARKED MONEY TRACED TO THE PRISONER – EFFORTS TO BREAK JAIL.
At the morning session of the eighth day of the Bucholz trial Paul Herscher was recalled and testified that Bucholz came to his saloon, opposite the depot at Norwalk, at about four o'clock on the afternoon of the murder and inquired regarding the arrival of the trains, saying that he had come to meet Schulte; soon after the arrival of the 6:11 P. M. New York train Schulte came in and bought some lager. A few minutes later Bucholz came back; both had lager and then started home; the next morning Bucholz came to witness' place and gave him $200 in twenty dollar bills, asking witness to keep them for him; he told witness, if inquired about, to say that the money had been given him two months previously; Bucholz returned in the afternoon, looking pale, and told the witness that he hoped he would not go back on him when testifying before the Coroner's jury, but would say that he had given the witness the money some time ago; he told the witness if he would so testify he could keep the money and he would give him more in a few days; the witness, in company with two others, went to Westport on the Sunday after the murder and had some oysters together in a restaurant; Bucholz tendered a fifty dollar bill in payment; this bill bore ink marks in the corner, the same as were on the twenty dollar bills which Buchholz gave the witness a few days previously to keep for him. Several witnesses identified the fifty dollar bill.
Dr. B. W. Munson testified that he saw marks on a piece of skull (shown), which he had no doubt were made by a blunt instrument with an irregular edge; it might have been an axe or a hammer.
Henry Koenig, reporter for the New York Staats Zeitung, testified that Bucholz told him that the money he gave Herscher was given to him by Schulte after he left Herscher's saloon on the night of the murder.
Edward Buger testified that Bucholz gave him two twenty dollar bills to pay board at the Sonne Hotel, in New York. These are identified by two witnesses.
George H. Graft was recalled. It will be remembered that this witness refused to testify against Bucholz a few days ago, and was sentenced to solitary confinement for contempt of court. He expressed a willingness to testify to-day. When called he said he had conversed with Bucholz several times about escaping from the jail; they had talked the matter up together; Bucholz offered witness money to purchase saws to aid in escaping; witness asked Bucholz if he couldn't have got the money without killing the old man; he replied they could prove nothing against him; he would not have been suspected if he had not used so much of the money. The witness apologized to the Court for refusing to testify; he did not know the penalty in such cases. The Court released him from further punishment.
On the cross-examination the witness said he was a German and had no friends in this country and no particular place of residence; was in jail on a charge of boat stealing. Several witnesses testified regarding the custody of the axes found at the Warring house.
David Dayton testified that he was present when the body was examined during the inquest and identified the articles taken from the body.
The court adjourned till Monday afternoon at half-past two o'clock.
THE BUCHOLZ TRIAL.
At the Bucholz trial to-day Franklin Bischoff, of New York, testified that Schulte came to his father's banking house on December 27, 1878, at which time he exchanged German mark bills. The witness gave him in exchange four gold mark pieces, in one of which there was a hole. This piece was shown the witness and he identified it as the one he had given Schulte on that day.
The afternoon session was entirely occupied by the testimony of Detective Stark, which has already been published in full, as given on the former trial of the accused.
THE BUCHOLZ TRIAL.
BRIDGEPORT, Conn., March 4, 1880.At the Bucholz trial to-day Detective Stark resumed his testimony, stating, among other matters derogatory to the prisoner, that while in jail the accused said he would give the witness $10,000 of the money (subsequently found) in case he should get out, and together they would then go to Australia.
On cross-examination the witness testified that Bucholz, while in jail, told him he thought at one time he would return the money, or a portion of it, to Schulte's estate.
Dr. L. J. Sanford, of New Haven, was recalled regarding the marks on the piece of skull taken from Schulte, on which Dr. Munson testified last week that he found marks which he thought had been made by an instrument similar to an axe. Witness said they were of no account, and were frequently found in the human skull. Witness was shown Schulte's hat, in which was a cut. He thought the cut was made with an axe, as he found the same irregularities in the edge of the cut as in the edge of the axehead.
At the opening of the afternoon session the counsel for the State notified the Court that they rested their case.
The defence introduced Samuel Waring as the first witness. He testified that the axe was first taken from the house on the Saturday after the murder, and was returned at the end of two or three weeks. Witness said it was used by them to split wood; he also stated that he sawed the handle off and put the head of the axe in the stove for the purpose of burning the wood out of the eye, in order to put in a new handle; the axe was afterward taken away.
George C. S. Tilsen was next called, and with the aid of a map pointed out to the jury the places where the different articles were picked up while searching for evidence after the murder.
Franklin Tolles testified that he saw blood spots on the floor of the Waring house, which came from the wound in Schulte's head. Witness said that there was considerable blood on the coat, which he rolled up and put under the head of the deceased.
THE BUCHOLZ TRIAL.
BRIDGEPORT, Conn., March 5, 1880.During the morning session of the Bucholz trial, Julius Ellendorf, Bucholz's teacher, testified that he gave him instructions in English on the day of the murder; saw nothing unusual in his manner that day.
August Pitzer testified that he saw Bucholz and Schulte in Herscher's saloon, drinking beer together, soon after Schulte's arrival from New York; thought they remained there ten minutes; Bucholz told witness at the Warring house on the night of the murder that when Schulte was attacked he heard a cry of "Bucholz! Bucholz!" he looked around and saw two or three men, one of whom chased him.
Several witnesses testified that they saw Bucholz help carry the body to the Warring house; he had hold of the right shoulder of deceased.
T. M. Hoyt, of South Norwalk, saw an axe at the Warring house; there was blood, also a chicken feather on the blade, but none on the handle; he said it was the town talk that Schulte was a very rich man, and that he carried all his money on his person.
During the afternoon session Dr. William C. Burke, of South Norwalk, testified that he had made a careful examination of the grounds in the vicinity where the body was found the day after the murder and saw none of the articles afterward found; he examined the axe at Waring's house with a magnifying glass and saw blood and particles of chicken feathers on the head, also saw chicken heads lying around.
Miss Sadie Warring testified that the axe was taken away from the house the day after the murder and remained away two or three weeks, when it was returned.
Mrs. Warring testified to seeing the axe put in the stove to burn the handle out.
Henry F. Snibley, an inmate of the jail, testified he heard Hineman say he had hit upon a plan of testifying against Bucholz for the purpose of helping his own case; said Hineman told him it would not make any difference with Bucholz, as he would have to swing anyhow, and what he was going to testify against Bucholz he had made up himself. Witness said Hineman's object in testifying against Bucholz to get his own case put off until the next term of court. On cross-examination he said Hineman gave a prisoner who was released last week his watch, chain and $13 to purchase saws, with which to aid him in making his escape.
Hineman was called to the witness stand and denied that he had conversed with the witness regarding Bucholz's case, but admitted having conversed about making his escape.
The Court adjourned at half-past two o'clock this afternoon until Monday.
THE BUCHOLZ MURDER TRIAL.
The fourth week of the Bucholz trial began this afternoon.
The cross-examination of Henry F. Shibley, the witness who was on the stand at the time of the adjournment on Friday last, was resumed. He said Hineman told him he was going to testify against Bucholz in order to get his own case postponed until the next session of Court; said Hineman was writing down what he was going to testify; told witness he was going to say Bucholz told him he killed the old man.
David L. Millard, of South Norwalk, testified :-- I walked down the railroad track on the afternoon of the murder; I saw near a clump of rocks, a short distance from the point where the path leading to Schulte's house leaves the track, three men whom I took to be tramps; they were desperate looking characters; one wore a dark beard.
Stephen Ostrader, of South Norwalk testified that while out hunting on the afternoon of the murder he saw three men near the rocks described by the previous witness; heard them talking together, but could not understand what they said; they were putting old clothes on over their own, which seemed to be good ones. Witness said he was about one hundred feet from them; they wore their hats pulled down over their eyes; one had dark whiskers, the other sandy.
Court adjourned until nine o'clock Tuesday morning.
THE BUCHOLZ TRIAL.
BRIDGEPORT, Conn., March 11, 1880.At the morning session of the Bucholz trial Nelson Taylor, Jr., began the opening argument on the part of the State, occupying an hour and three-quarters. He was followed by Charles Bollman on the part of the defence, who occupied the time until half-past three o'clock, when a short recess was taken. At four o'clock State Attorney Olmstead began the closing argument for the State, and shortly after the court was adjourned until nine o'clock to-morrow morning. The State will probably occupy all the morning session to-morrow and will be followed by General Smith closing for the defence. The charge will probably be given on Saturday morning.
NO VERDICT YET.
----------
THE JURY IN THE BUCHOLZ CASE OUT ALMOST FOUR DAYS – PROBABILITY OF ANOTHER DISAGREEMENT.
The interest in the Bucholz case as it draws toward the close does not diminish in the least. The jury retired for deliberation at one o'clock on Monday afternoon and nothing was heard from them until nine o'clock this morning, when they signified their desire to make a report to the Court. Chief Justice Park and Judge Loomis having taken their seats upon the bench directed the Sheriff to inform the jury that the Court would hear their report, whereupon twelve haggard and careworn men filed from the jury room and took the seats which they had left forty-five hours ago. The prisoner eagerly scanned their faces, evidently in hopes of catching some ray of encouragement.
"Gentlemen of the jury," said the clerk, "have you agreed upon a verdict?"
The Foreman – We have not.
Chief Justice Park – Is there any question that you wish to ask of the Court?"
Foreman – I don't know of any.
Chief Justice Park – What is the possibility of your coming to an agreement?
Foreman – I don't think there is any; I know there is none.
The judges then held a short consultation together, after which Chief Justice Park gave them some further instructions, dwelling principally upon the point of time. "The question of time," said the Court, "seems to be in this case somewhat uncertain, and the jury must arrive at their conclusions on this point from a full consideration of the evidence. You must remember, gentlemen, that a man intending to commit such a crime has every motive for being as expeditious as possible." Speaking about the time consumed by Bucholz and Schulte by their visit to Herscher’s saloon opposite the depot on the arrival of Schulte from New York, the Judge said, "You must remember that when a man is in a hurry it takes him but a very short time to get a glass of beer.”
General Smith, counsel for the accused, arose and asked the Court to instruct the jury that in the event of a reasonable doubt about any part of the evidence, they should be instructed to give the prisoner the benefit of the doubt.
Judge Park replied, "This is not a charge. In the charge the jury were told that they must be convinced of the guilt of the accused beyond a reasonable doubt before they returned a verdict. But this must be a reasonable and not an imaginary doubt."
General Smith resumed his seat apparently greatly disappointed at the last remark of the Chief Justice.
Judge Park said :-- Have any of the jurors any question to ask the Court?
Juror Merehouse asked what weight they were to give to the expert testimony of Dr. Treadwell?
Judge Park said :-- You must judge from the appearance of the witness when giving his testimony whether he was testifying honestly and conscientiously, or whether he appeared like a willing witness anxious to tell all that he knew, and, perhaps, more.
Foreman Gregory then asked if the jury could bring in a verdict in the second degree?
Judge Park replied, "Certainly; that is a question of fact left entirely with the jury." Judge Park then urged upon the jury the importance of rendering a verdict, saying that the case had already had one trial. The present trial had been a long and expensive one, and should they disagree it would necessitate another trial, which would probably be more expensive as well as taking a much longer time, and in that case the jury would be compelled to render a verdict from the same evidence and from the same facts they now had before them. The jury were then requested to retire for further deliberation.
The court resumed its sessions at half-past eight o'clock this evening, and the jury reported, through the Sheriff, that they were yet undecided as to a verdict. The court then adjourned until to-morrow morning, and the jury were again locked up for the night.