Coverage of the murder of Johann Heinrich Schulte, and the trial of William Bucholz, in the National Police Gazette.
Bucholz, the Alleged Murderer.
[With Portrait.]
William Bucholz has been convicted once of the murder of his former employer, John Henry Schulte, and a second jury is now hearing testimony whether or not he shall meet the same fate again. Schulte was an old German miser living on a farm near South Norwalk, Conn., and the crime of which Bucholz stands accused was committed on the night of December 27, 1878. He and Schulte left the railroad station at South Norwalk together about twilight that evening. They were returning to the farm, and to get there they had to pass through a short stretch of woods. Schulte was a bachelor, was reputed to be very wealthy, and likewise known to carry all of his money with him, having no confidence either in savings Banks or iron safes. On this occasion he had $78,500 with him, and when his body was found the next day over $55,000 of this was gone, so that robbery was plainly the motive for the crime.
Bucholz being the last person seen with Schulte, and supposed to be thoroughly conversant with his habits, was arrested. He told a plausible story to the effect that they were attacked by tramps while passing through the bit of woodland, and that he fled for his life, leaving old Schulte to their mercy. As Bucholz is physically a powerfully built man, this explanation made but little impression. There seemed no way to getting testimony sufficiently clear to convict him, however, and almost in despair the authorities turned to Pinkerton’s detective agency for help. An employee named Clarke was detailed to try and secure Bucholz’s confidence in the guise of a fellow prisoner and the plan was successful according to Clarke’s testimony. Nearly the whole of the missing $55,000 was recovered on information given, as Clarke claims, by Bucholz, who confided its whereabouts to Clarke in the belief that the latter would put it in a safer place than it then was in – a hole in the ground being a stable.
It was the detective’s testimony that convicted Bucholz on the first trial, and the second would not have been granted but for some unguarded remarks made by one of the jurors in the hearing of a number of persons after the rendering of the verdict. The case has aroused almost as great an interest in Connecticut and outside of it as that of the Rev. Mr. Hayden, and the trial room at Bridgeport is crowded daily.
Bucholz is a stolid, persistent-looking man, and appears to have courage enough to carry out any plan he may have determined upon, without regard to consequences to others. He has large gray eyes, that appear at times absolutely pitiless. His broad shoulders and thick large wrists indicate his great strength.