Coverage of the Schulte murder and the first trial, in the New York Sun.
These articles are available on newspapers.com, but are labelled as 'New York Herald', distinct from 'The New York Herald'.
AN AGED MISER MURDERED.
----------
THE ROBBERS LEAVING OVER $20,000 ON HIS BODY AFTER ALL.
----------
Believed to Have Been Followed by Tramps to a Lonely Swamp – There Attacked and Killed while His Servant Walked a Little In Front – Stories of the Man's Singular Life.
In February, 1877, a German, John Henry Schulte, accompanied by a young man who acted as his interpreter, went to South Norwalk, and after a little looking around, purchased of Major George Hoyt eight acres of land, on which stood a good frame house. It was situated two miles west of South Norwalk, on what is known as Roton Hill. Mr. Schulte paid for the property $5,000 cash, which, it was then noticed, he took from a leathern belt which he wore around his body, beneath his clothing. There was at the time living on the farm the family of Stephen F. Waring, and leaving them in charge, the new owner went away to Germany, it is said. He did not return to America until August last, and it was October before he went to his farm near South Norwalk. He brought with him plans for a fine building which he talked of erecting on the property, but instead of making any move in that direction he settled down in his house, occupying one room, in which he took his meals, which were prepared by the Waring family, while his servant, William Bucholtz, attended to him and accompanied him most of the time.
Soon Schulte got the reputation of being an eccentric miser. He was very quiet, spoke little or no English, went out very little, and was said to carry much money on his person. It was said that he was from Cologne, where he had much real estate, and where a wealthy brother resided. He occasionally visited New York city, always alone, and it was rumored that his object was to receive remittances of money from Germany. So his uneventful life went on until Friday last. Early that morning he started from his home, telling his servant that he was going to New York on the 7 o'clock train, and directing him to meet him at the 4 o'clock train in the afternoon. William obeyed. but his master did not come. He waited until the 6:11 train, and then Schulte arrived, carrying with him a package of hams and a valise. The nearest way to his house from the depot was straight down the railroad track about a mile and a half, and then up through a cedar swamp, and across some fields, by a narrow footpath. Directing William Bucholtz to go on in advance with the hams and the valise, the old man started down the track. What followed is described by William, who told his story through an interpreter. for he can speak but little English.
"I was about seventy-five feet in advance of Mr. Schulte." he said, "and had just reached the stone wall that separates the swamp from the farm, when I heard him call out loudly twice. I put the hams on the stone wall and turned to go back. As I did this two men sprang out at me from each side of the path. One of them struck me with something on the cheek and cut me. I then turned and ran toward the house, which was about 350 yards away, calling loudly for help. I heard the sound of voices back by Mr. Schulte, but could see no one. One of the men followed me about fifty yards, but I outran him, and reached the house. I stumbled into the back door, out of breath, crying out. 'Sammy, Sammy, I think tramps have killed Schulte.'”
“I heard some one calling out." said Samuel Waring, Mrs. Waring's son, a young man of 20, who, with his mother and two sisters, were alone in the house. "and the next moment William came rushing In, his face pale and the blood running from a cut in his cheek. He said: 'Oh, Sammy! Oh, Sammy!’ and seemed badly frightened. I said ‘Where's Mr. Schulte?' 'Oh, he's dead, he's dead.' answered William, and then he said the tramps had cut him and chased him, and that he was afraid Mr. Schulte was killed. I thought they might come to the house, and so I held the door. William went and got his pistol, and in about twenty minutes we took a lantern and went to the nearest neighbors, Mr. Allen's and Mr. Dingey's, and alarmed them. Then we went to the swamp and found Mr. Schulte lying on his back in the path dead. We did not touch him but hurried to the village and told the authorities."
Great bodies move slowly, and country officials are no exception to the rule. Constable Dayton was the first authority informed. Taking it for granted that the old German was dead, he informed Justice W. T. Craw, who acts as Coroner. Justice Craw then proceeded to impanel a jury, and by 9 ½ o’clock the authorities were ready to go to view the body. It was 10 o'clock before they reached the lonely swamp. and let the light of their lanterns shine on the body of the old German. There was no doubt about it being a case for an inquest, for there was a terrible gash in the back of his head evidently made with an axe or hatchet. It was over four inches long, and penetrated to the brain. It was enough to have caused instant death, yet back of his left ear was another wound. It looked as though some muscular arm had driven the head of a hatchet through the skull. No man with such a wound could live. Near the body lay the dead man's hat, an old green felt hat. with a gash in it where the hatchet had cut through it. Scattered around were several newspapers, some violin strings, memorandum books, an empty money bag, and a bloody chamois-skin bag. These had evidently been taken from Schulte's pockets. His watch was gone, as was a big pocketbook, which the neighbors say he carried in his coat breast pocket, and which was usually crammed full of money. Robbery had undoubtedly been the motive for the murder. The limp body was carried to the house, and then the clothing was removed. In the inner pocket of the vest was a package of papers tied with a string, the whole looking worn and dilapidated. At first it was thought best not to examine it; but one juror, more bold than the others, suggested that it could do no harm. Within a time-worn envelope were found twenty 500-mark bills, three 100-mark bills: five packages, each containing ten 1,000-mark bills, and one package containing twenty-two 1,000-mark bills – in all 82,300 marks, German money, or $19,587.40 in our money. Besides this there were four $100 bank notes. ten $50 and others of small denominations – in all $939. That old package contained $20,526.40, and the murdered man had laid three hours in the lonely swamp with it in his pocket.
The dazed jurors left two of their number, Edward Burger, one of the special detectives of the place, and F. A. Tolls, to guard the body. There was some talk of arresting the servant, Bucholtz, but it was thought that he could not escape, marked as he was with a long gash on his left cheek. At dawn yesterday Burger and Tolls visited the swamp. They found there an old pair of red flannel drawers and a new pair of canvas overhauls. Thirty feet from the pool of blood that marked where the old man had fallen they found a pistol, one of the old "bull-dogs." It was lying in the brush, as though thrown there. Afterward a piece of an old shirt, evidently used to wipe blood from something, and a hickory stick spotted with blood were found. This was all. There was absolutely no clue to the murderer or murderers. The only man on whom suspicion could be thrown was the servant. He had made no attempt to get away, and seemed dazed by the murder of his master.
State Attorney James A. Olmstead hurried down from Stamford, and Sheriff Stanford from Bridgeport. The former suggested that Bucholtz be put in charge of an officer. This was done. At 11 o'clock the inquest was begun in the Council chamber, Bucholtz being the first witness. He is a stolid-looking young German, with light hair and blue eyes. He was neatly dressed. A long strip of courtplaster covered the scratch on his face. He looked and acted like an innocent man, and told a straightforward story. He said that he was born in Germany twenty-four years ago, and journeyed to this country in August, 1878. He stopped at the Sonne Hotel in Pearl street and after being there three or four weeks became acquainted with Schulte, who was then attended by another young man. Schulte didn't like his servant, and, discharging him, hired the witness. Whenever he walked out with Schulte he was always ordered to go in advance of him. About six weeks ago a friend suggested that he had better carry a pistol, as his master might be attacked. Witness did buy one, but did not have it with him when the attack was made. Mr. Schulte never carried firearms. He had a gun at home and carried a stiletto. He then told the story of the murder as told above, and then the inquest was adjourned, Bucholtz in the mean time to be in the custody of Detective Burger.
Mrs. Waring, a comely, rosy-faced woman, said: "Mr. Schulte was a very nice, quiet man. I should think he was about 60 years old. William says that he was once married. He could speak little English, but studied hard, and was improving. He bought all his own provisions, and William would bring down what he wanted cooked, and then take it up to him. Every day after breakfast he played the violin for some time. Then after dinner, he walked out if the weather was fine. He had a photograph machine, and he took a photograph of the house, and one of William, too. He drew and made beautiful sketches. None of us knew that he had much money."
The room in which the miser lived – for he was undoubtedly a miser – was on the second floor. It was small and poorly furnished. An iron bedstead stood in one corner, In the other was a huge and ancient chest, in which was half a kit of mackerel, some butter, flour, and potatoes. Two small trunks stood near. One was nearly full of books, most of them guide books, some of them dictionaries. A good violin and some music were also there. There were many papers, all written in German. They were locked up with the money. On the little table where Schulte ate his lonely meals stood three bottles of Rhine wine. These were the contents of the valise that he brought back from New York on Friday. A handsome double-barreled breech-loading German fowling piece leaned against the wall. It had not been used.
There was little clothing in the room, but on a nail hung a bathing suit and a Turkish fez.
"He was a great man for bathing," said Samuel Waring. "He'd go in every day, when it was pleasant, and only a month ago he went in one warm day."
Among the papers found on the body was a sort of receipt. It was marked Staats Zeitung Building. Then there were figures, evidently made in computing the value of 1,500 marks in United States money. The paper bore the stamp "Henry Bischoff. Dec. 27, '78." It was thought that he had, on the day of his murder, exchanged 1,500 marks for its equivalent in our money. If so, then the robbers got over $357 anyway.
Schulte was tall and well made, with thoroughly German features. He wore a heavy mustache and goatee, and his thin hair was cropped short.
SOUTH NORWALK'S MYSTERY
----------
PROOF THAT THE MURDERERS GOT AS MUCH AS $800.
----------
Another Pistol and a Bunch of Schulte's Keys Found in the Search on Sunday – What Is Said by Mr. Henry Bischoff, the Banker.
The place of the murder of the old German, John H. Schulte, who, on Friday evening was killed near his home in South Norwalk, robbed of some of his money and left in a lonely swamp with over $20,000 on his body, for over three hours, was visited by hundreds of curious persons on Sunday. They tramped over the adjacent swamp and fields, searching carefully for some clue to the murderers, for few of them seemed to think, as did State Attorney Olmstead, that the old man's servant, William Bucholz, was the guilty man. If he is guilty his actions belie the fact thoroughly. The active searching of the multitude resulted in the finding of a pistol, a bunch of keys, and a box of hob-nails, such as are used in the soles of heavy shoes. They were all found in the field between the place of the murder and the dead man's house, and were blood-stained. The pistol was of modern make, and had evidently been dropped by the murderers. It is the second pistol that has been found. The other was an ancient pepper box. William Bucholz's pistol was found in the house. He did not carry it the night of the murder. The finding of the two pistols intensifies rather than dispels the mystery: for the old man was killed by blows from an axe or hatchet, one made with the edge, the other with the head. The keys that were found proved to have belonged to Schulte: for they fitted bis trunk and chest. The hob-nails had evidently been bought by him. They are such as are much used by Germans.
Mr. Henry Bischoff is a German banker, doing business in the Staats Zeitung building. He yesterday said to a Sun reporter:
“I first saw Mr. Schulte about fifteen or sixteen months ago. He came here and exchanged marks for United States money to the value of $5,000. That was probably the money with which he bought that farm in South Norwalk. After that he sometimes came here to exchange marks, but never in large amounts. All his money seemed to be in marks – bank notes, you understand. On Friday, the day on which he was murdered, he was here about 11 o'clock and exchanged 1,500 marks, receiving $352.50 in return. The money was paid him in three $100 notes, ten $5 notes, and $2.50 in silver. We also gave him the memorandum which was found on his body. An hour or two after I saw some one walk into the office whom I thought a beggar. Mr. Schulte walked peculiarly, with his head down, his hands clasped in front of his waist. He looked like a beggar. He went to the correspondence window and was directed around to the front desk. I am near-sighted, and, thinking he was a beggar, put a few coppers on the desk. He paid no attention to them, but spoke to me. Then I recognized him and spoke to him, calling him by name. He said that he wished that I would give him large notes for $500, and he took from an old, long, black pocketbook two packages of $250 in small notes. I gave him four $100 greenbacks. He had the $350 which we had paid him in exchange for marks, for the description of the money found in the inside pocket after his death does not agree with the money we paid him. So he must have had $850 at least in the old pocketbook, which the murderers got.
“Then," continued Mr. Bischoff, "he began to talk with me about his property in South Norwalk. He said that he was disappointed in it, that the climate was bleak and cold, and he expressed a wish to sell out and go South. I gathered from what he said that he had lived in Kentucky. He asked me about Virginia, and my advice about buying a farm near Norfolk. I told him that farms were low there, but that there was some danger from the disorganized condition of society. He said that he was a single man. and that he did not mind that condition of affairs. Then I told him that the State of Virginia was about to go into bankruptcy. He comprehended perfectly what the effect of that would be. In fact, he was an excellently educated man. He was remarkably intelligent, and talked well on any subject. He gave me his address, and desired me to let him know if I heard of a farm of 200 or 300 acres for sale in Virginia. I telegraphed to the Mayor of South Norwalk, telling him what I knew. This morning he was here. and we telegraphed to Schulte's brother, Fred. W. Schulte, Grossen, Halthausen, Westphalia, Germany, asking him what disposition should be made of the money."
At the Sonne Hotel, in Pearl street, where Schulte stayed last fall, the young man in charge said: "Mr. Schulte reached here on the 27th of September last in the steamer State of Virginia. He had with him a boy Siegmund Grunwald, who acted as servant. But the boy would not stay with him: for the old man was very queer. He slept little at night, and called the boy up often. The boy was afraid of him, and refused to go to South Norwalk. He is now somewhere in the city learning the barber trade. William Bucholz was stopping here at the time, and Schulte got him to go with him. I'd have gone myself if I had not been obliged to keep my position here. Schulte paid William only $3 a month. I asked him how he could work for that sum, and he said that when he had spoken about it to Schulte, the old man had said: 'Never mind, you stay with me. When I am dead you will be rich.' Bucholz is a nice fellow. He has friends in the old country who are well off. There is a money letter here for him now. He wrote me last week that he would have been here after his mail before, but that Schulte was getting ready to go to Germany, and wouldn't let him leave him."
The papers in Schulte's trunks in his room show that he owned considerable property in Westphalia.
WHO KILLED MR. SCHULTE?
----------
WHAT FACTS WERE ELICITED AT THE SOUTH NORWALK INQUEST.
----------
Bucholz, the Murdered Man's Servant, Completing his Story – The Waring Family's Testimony – Some Telegrams – The Estate.
SOUTH NORWALK, Dec. 31 . -- The Council Chamber here was thronged to-day when the inquest into the death of the old German, J. H. Schulte, who was killed on Friday evening last, was resumed, and Wm. Bucholz, the servant of the dead man, took the stand again. He is a well-educated young German, who served four years in a regiment of hussars, and then came to America. He bears the suspicion that rests upon him with equanimity, and if guilty of the horrible crime, is as mild a mannered man as ever cut a throat. The wound on his left cheek has nearly healed, and is composed principally of court plaster. I have not been able to find a man who thinks him guilty.
Resuming his testimony, Bucholz said that Schulte paid him 23 marks a week or two before his death. There was one ten-mark gold piece. This he had exchanged for United States money for his own use.
Here it may be well to say that Mr. Henry Bischoff, the banker, in the Staats-Zeitung building, who, on the day of the murder bought 1,500 marks of Schulte, says that in making the exchange he gave Schulte 100 marks in seven gold pieces. Three of them were twenty-mark pieces, and four were ten-mark pieces. One of the latter had a hole through it, right over the Emperor William's head. One of Mr. Bischoff's sons remembers this, from the fact that he joked with Mr. Schulte about it, telling him that he could wear it on his watch chain as a charm.
Bucholz gave a detailed account of the murder. After he and his master quitted the depot, they walked down the railroad track, the former in advance. carrying the package of hams. Schulte carried a satchel. Arrived at the path that leads from the railroad to the house across the cedar swamp and the farm, Bucholz took the valise also, and walked on some distance in advance of the old man. He had just reached the stone wall which separates the swamp from the farm as he heard Schulte cry out, as though in fear:
"Bucholz! Bucholz!"
Bucholz dropped the hams and turned to go back, and a man appeared on his right, a few feet away. Then he heard a noise on his right, and as he turned, a large man with a bushy beard struck him in the face with something, he did not know what. Judging from the scratches on his face, it was a bundle of wire. The blow made "the fire flash from his eyes," he said. Then he turned, and, jumping over the stone wall, ran up the path leading to the house. The man chased him, but did not catch him. He heard him call out, "Greenhorn," and "I'll catch you another time." He thought the man spoke through his nose. Getting to the house he fell and fainted away. As he came to, young Sammy Waring was holding the door. The witness then got his pistol and asked Sammy to go back to the swamp with him. Sammy got his shotgun, and they were about to go, but were prevailed upon by Mrs. Waring and her daughters to go with them to a neighbor's.
Bucholz was asked about his pistol. He said he bought it because a man named Deysenroth had told him that he would be attacked. The pistol, keys, and box of hob nails found on Sunday in the field near the stone wall were shown him. He knew nothing about them, except that the keys looked like Mr. Schulte's, and that the nails were such as Schulte used.
Augustus Deysenroth was the next witness. About two months ago, he said, he met Bucholz with the two Waring girls, walking down the railroad track. A few minutes later he saw three young men standing by the track, one of whom said, "We're going to fix that greenhorn to-night." The witness therefore went back and told Bucholz what he had heard, and advised him to buy a pistol.
Here the Waring family was brought into the room. It consisted of Stephen F. Waring, who works in Newark at the hat trade, and who was there until Saturday, when he came home in response to a telegram from his family : Mrs. Amelia Waring, a good-looking, self-possessed woman : her two daughters, aged from 15 to 20, and her son Sammy, a voluble youth, just come to man's estate. The whole family was sworn wholesale by Coroner Craw, all standing and holding up their right hands, while he repeated the oath. Then Mrs. Waring testified that Mr. Schulte gave them the rent of the house and fifty cents a week for cooking the food which he provided. Describing Bucholz's appearance in the house after the murder, she said that she heard him calling, then the door was opened and he staggered into the room and fell. Then he rolled over, got up, and went for his pistol. He then said “Come, Sammy, I go to Mr. Schulte.”
"What's the matter?" asked Sammy.
Bucholz answered, "He's murdered in the woods." Witness saw blood on Bucholz's face and shirt bosom, and asked him where he was hurt. He put his hand to his head. Then he started to go out, tottered, and fell at full length, the pistol falling out of his hand. Witness spoke to him, and gave him water, after which they all went over to the neighbor's, Mr. Allen's.
The most important part of Mrs. Waring's testimony was that Mr. Schulte always went to bed early, usually not later than 6 o'clock in the evening. He never went out in the evening, and was never in the habit of walking from the railroad to the house by the swamp path after dark. This dissipates the theory that the murderer or murderers knew his habits and lay in wait for him, and suggests that he was either followed from New York or was killed by some one who knew that he had not returned on the 4:18 train, as he expected, but had come instead on the 6:11 train. And yet there is the fact that a little cedar tree standing by the path and between the spot of the murder and the railroad was found next day to have evidently been prepared as a sort of ambuscade. Branches from adjacent trees had been cut and broken off, and thrust into the cedar in such a way as to form a thick screen, behind which a man could stand and not be seen by any one coming up the path.
Sammy Waring was the last witness. He told a rambling story of his part in the affair, and ended by saying that he usually slept in the same room with his mother, there being two beds in the room, and that on the night of the murder Bucholz slept with him, and seemed to sleep well. Attorney Olmstead then asked that an adjournment be taken until Saturday next.
The telegram that was sent to the dead man's brother, Frederick W. Schulte, Grossen, Halthausen, near Dortmund, Westphalia, Germany, read:
Johann Henreich Schulte has been murdered. What shall be done with the body?
[Signed] The Mayor of South Norwalk.
An answer in German came yesterday from F. W. Schulte, saying:
I beg of you to see to it that the body of my brother be properly forwarded to Barop Station, near Dortmund, so as to insure its safe arrival here. I further request you to inform me at once by cable whether his effects have been secured, and how much of the large amount of specie which he took from here has been found, and who is the murderer of my brother.
A telegram was also received from F. W. Schulte by the German Consul in New York, asking that the body be embalmed and sent to Germany at once, and repeating in substance the despatch sent here. Mr. Gustav Wolfram, the Secretary of the Consul, came here this afternoon to inquire into the case. The body of the murdered man will be sent to New York on Friday, and shipped by steamer for Germany on Saturday.
Mr. W. C. Quitard [Quintard], the Mayor elect of this place, and Charles W. Smith have been appointed administrators of the estate of Schulte. They do not have to administer upon a worthless estate, for in addition to the $20,000 found on the dead German's person, other valuable property has been discovered. In a little steel box which he left with Jacob M. Layton, a real estate agent here, who acted as Schulte's agent for his farm, were found 100 20-franc gold pieces – $500. Among his papers was found a mortgage against his brother for 10,000 marks on property near Dortmund, dated Jan. 26, 1869. There was also a receipt for 498,544 marks deposited on July 15, 1877, with what Secretary Wolfram calls "The Royal District Court," Dortmund. Also a memorandum of 40,000 marks' worth of Rhenish Railway shares : a receipt for 95 acres of land sold to the Rhenish Railway in August, 1877 : a list of various sums of interest due him in 1878, amounting in all to nearly 9,000 marks. Other papers and letters from his brother showed that he owned much land near Dortmund. The farm which he owned here, and for which he paid $5,000, is probably worth half that amount. So it appears that the old German was worth about $200,000.
A Scene in Earle’s Hotel.
-------
What Is Considered a Clue to the South Norwalk Murder.
-------
Mrs. Rohe’s Screams for Help – Accused of Knowing Something about the Schulte Mrder – Her Husband Taken to Norwalk.
The piercing screams of a woman excited the inmates of Earle’s Hotel yesterday afternoon. Clerks and guests hurried to the room whence they were heard, and found there Charles Illing of South Norwalk, Conn., and a young German woman, Mrs. Rohe of 317 Broome street. Illing on the night previous took a room in the hotel, which he occupied alone. At 9 o’clock yesterday morning he took Mrs. Rohe to the hotel, and asked for a room with a fire in it. Objection being made by the clerk, he said that she was to be a witness in a lawsuit, and would not stay over night. The room was furnished, and he went to it with her, and remained there until her shrieks brought the household to the door. No explanation was offered by either Illing or Mrs. Rohe, and the two went out together excitedly conversing. All that could be then gathered from Mrs. Rohe was that Illing had tried to lock her in the room.
The two walked down Canal street. Within a short distance they met Officer Frank Crowley of the Mulberry street police station, to whom the woman appealed for protection, telling him that she was afraid of Illing. The latter told the officer that he was authorized to detain the woman as a witness in the case of the murder of the old German, J. H. Shulte in South Norwalk. He showed a telegraphic message from District Attorney Olmstead ordering him “to detain the woman until further orders,” and said he was a special detective empowered by the District Attorney to investigate the Schulte murder. Officer Crowley took Illing to the Tombs Police Court.
Before Justice Otterbourg, Illing said: “I am a piano teacher by occupation and a German by birth. Immediately after the discovery of the murder of Mr. Schulte I went to work on the case. There was so much excitement in South Norwalk over the tragedy that every resident felt impelled to work upon the clues. From the first I suspected Bucholz, the servant of the murdered man, of being implicated. I heard that Schulte had charged him with robbing him, and learned that, although Bucholz had no money of his own, he had a few days before the murder lent $200 to a friend. I shadowed Bucholz, and he told many contradictory stories. On Wednesday night he hinted that he had a friend named Rohe at 317 Broome street. He said that Rohe, Schulte, and himself came to this country together last August. I told Detective Bergholz what the servant had told me and together we agreed to get a letter from Bucholz to Rohe, and then journey to this city. I took down in shorthand all I heard about the murder. To-day Detective Bergholz was here and he took Rohe with him to South Norwalk. I then called on Mrs. Rohe. She was very much excited, and did not wish to speak about the case in her house. I invited her to Earle’s Hotel. On the way she asked many questions about Bucholz, saying that if he did kill Schulte he ought to be killed himself. In my room I took down all she had to say about Bucholz, and then asked her to wait until I could telegraph to South Norwalk. She consented, but became frightened and began to scream.”
Mrs. Rohe, who is a pale, delicate woman, and who was dressed in deep mourning, was overcome with nervousness. She had heard her husband speak about the Schulte murder, but she knew nothing about it. She had received a littler from Bucholz, or, at least, her husband had. Her husband had gone with an officer to South Norwalk. Mrs. Rohe beefed Justice Otterbourg to allow her to go home, as she was afraid some one might take advantage of her absence to enter her apartments.
Justice Otterbourg instructed Officer Crowley to take Mrs. Rohe and Illing before the District Attorney and to let him adjudicate upon the case. That official having gone from his office for the day, Justice Otterbourg sent them both to Superintendent Walling. Justice Otterbourg sent a note to Chief Walling advising that Rohe’s apartments be searched, as the Justice believed that from Mrs. Rohe’s anxiety evidence could be found that might lead to some important developments in the murder case.
Before Superintendent Walling, Illing showed a commission from the State Attorney in Connecticut authorizing him to secure Mrs. Rohe as a witness in the Schulte case. The superintendent decided that it was not sufficient to take Mrs. Rohe out of the State. Mrs. Rohe expressed a decided objection to going, and was therefore allowed to go home.
Illing was very much crestfallen at his failure to get Mrs. Rohe to South Norwalk. He professed to have extorted from her some vey damaging admissions relative to her husband’s intimacy with Bucholz and the sudden wealth that enabled Bucholz to give her husband loans and presents. He also intimated that the letter written by Bucholz to Mr. Rohe contained a number of cautions as to what Rohe should say when questioned concerning his intimacy with Bucholz, or any money that Bucholz might have had. He was decidedly of opinion that the evidence of Mr. and Mrs. Rohe would go far toward criminating Bucholz. He returned to Norwalk to report the failure of that part of his mission requiring the presence of Mrs. Rohe, but elated that her husband had been induced to go to South Norwalk.
Mrs. Rohe was found last evening with a neighbor. No attempt had been made to search the premises, and she had locked up the room herself. Her story was that a detective induced her husband to go out yesterday morning to translate a letter. She had not seen him since, and supposed that he had been kidnapped. She said that Illing had told her the detectives would take her away, but that if she would go with him he would protect her; that he showed her the letter written by Bucholz, but, as it was written in German, she could not read it; that Illing plied her with numerous questions as to Bucholz and his relations with her husband, most of which she could not answer; that she knew but little of Bucholz, the servant, and nothing of Schulte, the murdered man. Bucholz journeyed to this country in the same ship with her husband’s brother, who took her husband down to the hotel in Pearl street where Bucholz and Schulte were stopping. After that Bucholz used to go [to] their rooms, at 317 Broome street, and talk with her husband. Bucholz came and brought some cider on the day before Thanksgiving. After Buchholz went to South Norwalk with Schulte he came once or twice a month, and always pretended that he had money, though she knew nothing of his giving money to her husband, or of his ending money or giving presents. She had never seen Schulte, and positively averred that so far as she knew her husband knew nothing about the murder. The last time she saw Bucholz was about Christmas Day, or a day before, when he came to the house, and, she believed, walked with her husband to the place where the latter was working as a confectioner. She showed a beautiful sugar ornament for a cake which her husband had made to amuse a friend’s child, similar to other ornaments that he had made for cakes during the holidays. She had never heard her husband talk about Schulte or his wealth, and admitted having said to Illing that if Bucholz killed Schulte he ought to be killed himself.
JOHN H. SCHULTE'S MURDER.
----------
TRYING TO DETERMINE WHO IT WAS THAT COMMITTED THE CRIME.
----------
The Man Servant who Accompanied him into the Swamp where his Dead Body was Found Telling his Story – What Victor Rohe Said – The Letter about the Money.
SOUTH NORWALK, Conn., Jan. 4. – The attempt made by Charles Illing, an amateur South Norwalk detective, to persuade Mrs. Victor Rohe of 317 Broome street, New York, to come here as a witness in the Schulte murder inquest and his failure to do so added interest to the already interesting case; for, although the old German has been dead more than a week, this was the first attempt at an arrest, or anything looking like an arrest, that had been made.
John Henry Schulte was killed on Friday, Dec. 27. He went to New York on that day, sold 15,000 marks to Henry Bischoff, the banker, in the Staats Zeitung building, and exchanged $500 in small bills for five $100 bills. He ordered his servant William Buchholz, to meet him at the depot at 4:18 in the afternoon, but did not return until the 6:11 train. Then, according to Buchholz's story, the two walked down the railroad track about a mile and a half to a point opposite Schulte's house, and there taking a path that leads through a swamp and across the fields to the house. While in this swamp and walking some distance ahead of Mr. Schulte, Buchholz heard the old man call him. He turned and was attacked by two men, one of whom struck him in the face with something that scratched it. Buchholz then ran, and was pursued a little way. He reached the house, alarmed the family and some neighbors, and a party going back to the swamp found the old man dead, with two terrible wounds in his head, one made with a sharp instrument, cutting through his old felt hat and making a broad and deep gash through the skull into the brain: the other evidently made with an instrument like a hatchet or hammer head, the blow striking behind the left ear and fracturing the skull. Either wound would have caused death.
The old man's pockets had been rifled. His watch and money were gone. A blood-stained canvas bag was found near the body, and a little way off an old "pepper box" pistol. Afterward another old pistol was found in an adjoining field, together with Schulte's keys, all blood-stained. In the dead man's inner vest pocket were found marks and greenbacks amounting to nearly $20,000. A search of his effects showed that he had $500 in gold in a box, and that he was possessed of property in Germany to the amount of about $150,000. His brother Frederick W. Schulte of Grossen Halthausen, near Dortmund, in Westphalia, Germany, was telegraphed to, and answered directing the German Consul to send the body to Germany.
The inquest was held under the management of State Attorney J. H. Olmstead, who, evidently considering the servant, Wm. Buchholz, as the man most likely to be guilty, directed all his attention to him. Up to Tuesday evening there seemed to be nothing that implicated Buchholz, who told a straight story, that was corroborated by all the other witnesses. In his testimony of Tuesday he said that he went to New York on the 23d of December to see his friend Victor Rohe, who lived in Broome street. On this hint detectives were sent to New York to see Rohe, and Mr. Charles Illing, a blond haired. blue eyed, faultlessly dressed little German of this place, went to see what could be done with Mrs. Rohe. The detectives found Victor, and he consented to come here with them. Illing found Mrs. Rohe, persuaded her to go to Earle's Hotel, where he so alarmed her that she ran shrieking from the room, and appealed to an officer for protection. Before Superintendent Walling, Illing said that Attorney Olmstead had telegraphed him to detain the woman until further orders, and he had been endeavoring to do this. This telegram saved him from arrest, and Mrs. Rohe was permitted to go home.
This morning, in the City Hotel, Rohe and Illing met, and for a moment it seemed that the amateur detective was about to be chastized. Rohe fiercely took him to task for interfering with his wife, and bestowed upon him several choice epithets in choicer German. The amateur detective did not seem to relish this.
These facts tended to fill the little room in the new Court House, where the inquest was held to-day, with a very expectant throng, many of whom were Germans, for although Buchholz had made few acquaintances here, his quiet bearing and evident honesty have made him many since the murder.
The inquest was begun at 10 o'clock, Attorney Olmstead conducting it, while Coroner Craw was on hand to administer necessary oaths. There was something new offered in testimony when Buchholz's diary was produced. It was written in German, with one exception, and this was when he had written out in a fair, round hand in English all the words of “Grandfather's Clock." It was explained that he had been taking lessons in English, and that this was one of his exercises. Buchholz acknowledged the book to be his, but denied that he had written one entry which translated read: "On the 20th of January, 1879. I will leave Schulte." He thought that perhaps some of the Warring family had written it. Afterward he admitted that he wrote it, but said that he wrote it as pure nonsense. He had never quarrelled with Schulte and never had any difficulty with him. He told Mr. Theile (the interpreter), and perhaps Mr. and Mrs. Rohe, that Schulte was in the habit of kicking him, and he told Mr. Rohe that he should leave Schulte some time, but had not said when.
"Did you say," the lawyer asked. "that the old man pushed you ahead of him, and that you had taken out a knife and said to Schulte that he would suffer for it if he did it again?"
"No, never." Buchholz replied.
"Did you not," Lawyer Olmstead continued, "tell Mrs. Rohe that you had a difficulty with Mr. Schulte about some coals that the Warrings had taken?"
The witness during these questions showed more discomfiture than he had at any time before. His face grew very red and his hands twitched. "No. not exactly," he said.
“Didn't you threaten that you would get a lawyer?”
"I said that if any one accused me of theft I would not let the accusation rest on me. I said nothing about a lawyer."
Then the question was asked if the witness had told Mrs. Rohe that he and Schulte had quarreled about eating, and that he had taken Schulte by the collar and held a pistol to his head, which Schulte pushed aside. The witness denied this. He had told Mrs. Rohe that Schulte had two old pistols. He had not seen them, but Grunwald, Schulte's former servant, had told him of them. The following letter was then translated from the German in which it was written:
DEAR FRIEND ROHE: You surely have learned from the newspapers of the very unfortunate position I am in now. Yes, with broken heart I must tell you that I am near to despair. For that reason I would like to see you and talk with you if possible. If somebody should call and ask you about me, how I became acquainted with you, tell them through your brother; and tell your wife that I never spoke to her at all about money matters. Under no consideration let her say anything about money that I ever loaned you some time previous. When I was with you last I intended to buy myself an overcoat, and wanted you to go with me. Burn up this lettor. Kindest regard.
JAN. 2, 1979. BUCHHOLZ
Buchholz acknowledged that he wrote the letter, and said that he asked Rohe not to speak of money matters, because he did not want it made public that he had loaned them money. He explained that he loaned $80, which he brought with him from Germany. Rohe returned it, and he had loaned it to Herger, a man in this place.
Here a little old hair brush was produced. It was found the other day near the spot where the keys and pistol were found. Nothing had been said about it, for Lawyer Olmstead wanted to be sure that it belonged to Buchholz, if possible, before producing it. Buchholz did not recognize it as his, but said that he had one much like it, but had missed it since the day of the murder.
"Did you," Mr. Olmstead asked. "tell Grünwald that if you were with Schulte you would put his coat on and walk off?" The witness said "No." It was the talk at the Sonne Hotel that Schulte was a rich man, and might be attacked. There were a number of young men in the hotel who spoke in this way. Bucholz then said that he attended a large agricultural college in Germany, where his parents supported him. Afterward he went to live with an uncle, who had no children. He hired out to Schulte because Schulte had said that he would go to California, and he wanted an opportunity to see the country and learn the language.
Slegfrund Grünwald, a chubby-faced German boy, was then examined. He first saw Buchholz in September in the Sonne Hotel. Schulte was there, and witness was his servant. Witness told Buchholz that he should quit Schilte’s because the latter thought he was after his money. Witness could get at the money any time by stretching out his hand from the bed. Buchholz told him to stay with Schulte, and said that he would be a fool if he didn't walk off with the money. Buchholz said this almost every day, and said that if he was with Schulte he would make a difference. Witness quitted Schulte because he became afraid of him, he was so queer. Persons generally advised him to quit so notional a man. He saw Schulte on the day of the murder. He had written asking him to take him back, and Schulte came to him on that Friday and said that witness could come back on the old contract on the 20th of January, and they would go to Virginia. Mr. Schulte carried his money in two black and one yellow pocketbooks, and he had gold in bags. Here witness identified the canvas bag found near Schulte as one of his money bags. He never told Buchholz that Schulte had two old pistols: never saw any such pistols.
Victor Rohe, when called, said, through the interpreter, that he came here of his own free will, and his wife would come, too, when she knew what was wanted of her. Here Lawyer Olmstead said that he did not telegraph to Illing to detain Mrs. Rohe, but that Illing had telegraphed to him that she would come willingly also, and asked if he should bring her. He answered to do so. Rohe then testified that Buchholz had asked him to put $80 in the bank. He had not loaned it. The banks were breaking then, so he gave the money back. Buchholz tried to borrow money of him, but he refused. Buchholz described the difficulty with Schulte as arising at a meal, when the old man got angry and made a movement as though to draw a pistol, and Buchholz caught him by the arm and stopped him. He knew little of Buchholz.
Dellazon Allen, an old white-haired man, who went with Samuel Warring and Buchholz to find the dead body, said that Buchholz appeared to be in great pain, but when witness examined his face he saw only a little scratch and a little blood. Buchholz carried a white-handled pistol to the woods. Witness saw it shine.
Samuel Warring said that after Buchholz got his pistol, and before they started for the woods, Buchholz fell and dropped his pistol. Witness picked it up and put it in his pocket, where it remained until after they had been to the woods. This testimony was different from what he gave on Tuesday.
Then Lawyer Olmstead, picking up the old pistol found in the adjoining field, asked Buchholz if he hadn't carried that. Buchholz said, “No." Mr. Allen said the pistol that Buchholz did carry was bright, and shone in the light of the lantern. Samuel Warring stuck to it that Buchholz's new silver-washed pistol was in his (Warring's) pocket, and Attorney Olmstead seemed bound to prove that Buchholz carried the old black pistol. Several of the jurors asked questions, showing that they sympathized with Buchholz and didn't like the way he was treated.
SCHULTE'S MARKED MONEY.
----------
TRYING TO TRACE IT TO THE MAN SUSPECTED OF HIS MURDER.
----------
His Explanation of How he Became Possessed of Some Bills that he Gave to a Friend on the Day of the Discovery of the Crime.
SOUTH NORWALK, Conn., Jan 6. – Further testimony was taken here to-day in the inquest concerning the death of the old German, John Henry Schulte, who was murdered on the evening of Dec. 27. There has been some dissatisfaction expressed here in regard to Lawyer Olmstead's course, it being said that he seemed determined to prove the servant Buchholz guilty. Mr. Olmstead has shown much energy in prosecuting the investigation, and if the murderer or murderers are discovered it will be largely due to his efforts.
Mrs. Victor Rohe of 317 Broome street, New York, the woman whom the amateur detective, Illing, tried to persuade to come here, was the first witness. She is a pale-faced, intelligent-looking German, but seemed much excited by this new experience. Illing tried to apologize to her and her husband, but his advances were very coldly received. She testified that she had known Buchholz since August last. About two weeks after he came here, to South Norwalk, he gave her $80, and asked her to have her husband put it in a bank. Her husband refused to do so. Soon after the Manhattan Bank robbery Buchholz came to New York and asked if she had put the money in the bank. She said that she had not, and at his request returned him $40. Two weeks afterward he came for the other $40, saying that he wanted to buy a pistol. She told him not to do so: that it was foolish. His answer was that he was often attacked when he went out with the Waring girls, and wanted it to defend himself, and also to protect Mr. Schulte when he was out with him. Buchholz described to her a quarrel that he had had with Schulte, in which he took the old man by the collar and threw him over a chest. Buchholz had then threatened to quit Schulte, but had been persuaded to remain. On this same day Buchholz wanted to borrow $20 of her husband. On the 23d of December Buchholz came again and wanted to see her husband, who did not come home. He gave her a note for her husband, which was a request that he would loan him $30. The next day he came again, but Mr. Rohe was not home. Buchholz seemed much disappointed at not getting the money. In conversation he said that Schulte had two old pistols, but they were not worth much. [Buchholz has repeatedly testified that he never saw Schulte have any pistols, and that he never saw the two old pistols that were found after the murder, one near the dead man, the other in an adjoining field.]
Buchholz also told her that he was going to quit Schulte. When Illing came to her house, he had with him the letter from Buchholz asking that the Rohes say nothing about the money, and Illing pleadingly asked her not to tell that he brought it, for he felt very sorry for Buchholz.
Paul Hercher, a German, who is the proprietor of the Davis House, where Buchholz took his last drink of beer before starting down the railroad on the night of the murder, testified that Buchholz told him that Schulte's trunk must be full of money.
"On the Friday of the murder," the witness said, "while waiting for Schulte to come home from New York, Buchholz told me that he had often been annoyed by tramps who stopped him in the woods and asked him for tobacco. One in particular he remembered, a tall, ugly-looking fellow, who wore a silk hat with holes cut in it. Buchholz said, while waiting, that he was sorry he did not have his revolver with him, as it was growing late; and as it would be dark before they got home he felt uneasy. On the morning after the murder, Buchholz came into my place. He was excited, and said, ‘Isn’t that a terrible affair?’ I said, ‘Yes, what do you think about it?’ Buchholz said that he didn’t know what to think about it, and then called me to one side, and said, ‘Here’s $200. This is my money. I wish you would keep it until I make my report to the Coroner’s Inquest.’ I asked him how he got it. He didn’t answer me.”
The witness then produced seven $20 bills, which he said were the same that Buchholz had given him. He said that he had given $40 back to Buchholz, who wanted it to pay an old bill at the Sonne Hotel, so that they would send him a money letter that was there for him. The other $20 was in the hands of ex-Mayor Dudley P. Ely. Witness had given it to the Mayor, who said that he didn’t think there was anything wrong, because the money taken from Mr. Schulte was in $100 and $5 bills. Banker Bishoff says that he let Schulte have $800 in $100 bills on the day of the murder. Mr. Bishoff did not know whether Mr. Schulte had any more money or not with him.
The seven $20 bills were then examined by the jury. Each bill was marked with figures in ink, as follows: 380 | 140, 380 | 156, 380 | 158, 380 | 159, 380 | 168, 380 | 170, 380 | 180. Witness Hercher continued: “The bills were so marked when I got them. I didn’t know what to do with them. They burned me like fire. On Saturday noon last, Jan. 4, Buchholz came to me and seemed much excited. He said: ‘It seems my friends are going back on me. I hope you won’t, but will tell about that money that you received it in October or November. It won’t make any difference to you.’ I said that it was a hard thing for me to say so. He said: ‘You can keep that money if you want to, if you will do as I tell you, and moreover, one tenth –.’ He didn’t finish the sentence, but tried to laugh it off as if he was joking. That same afternoon he came in again and went out the back door. I followed him and asked him what he meant by ‘one-tenth.’ He gave me no answer. He said I could have money if I wanted it, for he expected to board with me after this investigation was finished; that he had received $250 from Germany in the letter which had been sent up from the Sonne Hotel.”
This was true. The letter contained one $100 and three $50 bills. He explained that the exchange was less in Germany than here. In these visits made by Buchholz and described by Hercher, Buchholz has been accompanied by an officer, for he is under arrest. The conversations were always carried on in German. The witness continued:
“Buchholz asked me to take a ride with him. I went. I asked him what he was going to do, if he got through the inquest all right. He said he should go to Australia and should take me along, as I was a straight man. I said it was an expensive journey. He answered that $200 would take a man there, and he would want $300 or $400 after he got there. I then said that it was a hard thing for me to go on the stand and swear to a lie. He said: ‘If you want any more money you can have it.’ He also asked me if any of Mr. Burger’s relations owned horses, for one of them bought the pile of hay near the Waring barn.”
That which the witness called hay is a pile of old straw lying near the path from the scene of the murder to Schulte’s house. Detective Burger has bought it, and will search it in hopes of finding the hatchet with which the murder was committed.
“This morning,” Mr. Hercher said, “Buchholz told me that he was afraid of the investigation today, and asked me not to go back on him in regard to the $200. I told him I didn’t know what would be right, ‘You needn’t be afraid,’ he said, ‘It will make no difference to you if you say that I gave it to you in either October or November.’”
Mr. Illing testified that on Saturday night last he was in the Davis House when Buchholz came in with Officer Burger and bought a box of cigars, offering a $20 bill. Witness asked him where he got his money, and he said: “Of course I got it from the old man.”
Here Lawyer Olmstead instructed the interpreter to tell Buchholz what Hercher had said, and then added that as Buchholz was under arrest he wouldn’t call him as a witness, but would give him a chance to explain if he wished to.
The prisoner calmly explained that the $200 was money that he had when he came from Germany. It was not the identical money. He gave it to Schulte to keep for him about the middle of November. The $80 that he let Rohe have was part of the same money.
“If you had $200, why did you want to borrow $30 of Rohe on the 23d and 24th of December?” Lawyer Olmstead asked.
The witness answered that he asked Schulte before Christmas for some money; Schulte answered that he had no small bills, but would get some in New York. On the Friday of the murder, after Mr. Schulte and he had left the Davis House and passed the depot on the way home, Mr. Schulte handed him the money wrapped in a piece of newspaper. He did not count it that night, but did next morning. Witness knew nothing about the figures in ink on the bills. He gave the money to Hercher because he did not want to carry it about with him.
“Why did you tell him to say that he got it in October or November?” the attorney asked.
“Because,” Buchholz replied through the interpreter, “Mr. Schulte had been murdered, and I was afraid it would throw suspicion on me if It was found on me.”
He further said that he did not tell Hercher that he would give him more money or one-tenth. He told him he would give him a little something, for he thought the laborer worthy of his hire, and he wanted to pay Mr. Hercher for his kindness to him.
A memorandum found among Schulte’s papers was presented by Charles Smith, one of the administrators of Schulte’s estate. It was in German and headed “American United States Notes,” and continued: “One hundred $20 notes: thirteen $50 notes : two $100 notes: gold, $205: open package, $400-$905; other package, $939.” In all, $5,299. The "other package," it is supposed, refers to the one found on the dead man's body, in which, besides 82,300 marks, there were $939 in greenbacks. On the other side of the memorandum were many figures, not unlike those on the $20 bills given to Hercher by Buchholz.
Lawyer Olmstead sent to the bank to obtain the $939. The Cashier returned with a few bills, saying that most of it had been paid out. One of the bills was marked with figures in ink.
Then Mr. Smith produced a small tin box. which he said he had never opened. It was marked "Ely's central fire cartridges." and was more than half full of cartridges. Charles Bosch, a gunsmith, tried the cartridges, of which there were two kinds. They fitted the two old pistols, in the chambers of which were other cartridges like those in the little box. This indicated strongly that the two old pistols were Schulte's. One was found near the body, the other not far from the path leading from the place of the murder to the house, and with it Schulte's keys, and an old hair brush that Buchholz admitted was very like one he had, but had missed since the day of the murder.
Lawyer Olmstead's theory is that Buchholz is implicated with others in the murder: that Schulte was detained in New York the day that he was killed, so that he might not reach here until dark, and that Buchholz dropped the pistol, the keys, and his own brush as he ran up from the scene of the murder to the house, to give the alarm.
The inquest in the case of SCHULTE, the murdered miser of South Norwalk, adds another chapter to the history of curious crimes. An old and needy-looking German, accompanied by his servant, neither of them able to speak English, buys an eight-acre farm in South Norwalk, paying the exorbitant price of $5,000 cash. He occupies a little room in the farmhouse, buys his own food, has it cooked by the tenants, and spends his days in playing the violin, sketching, experimenting in photography, and studying. It is his habit to go to bed early, and he is careful not to be out after dark. Soon it becomes rumored about that he has much money, and his servant, WILLIAM BUCHHOLZ, a well-educated young German, corroborates the rumor.
On Friday, Dec. 27, the old man comes to this city, ordering his servant to meet him at the South Norwalk depot at 4 o'clock. But instead of returning at four, he comes two hours later. Then the two start down the railroad, the nearest way home. An hour later the servant rushes into the farmhouse, his face bloody, and evidently much frightened, saying that SCHULTE has been attacked by tramps in the swamp, through which they were walking on their way home. The neighbors assemble, and, going to the place, find the old man dead, with two horrible wounds in his head. His pockets have been rifled, nothing of value apparently being left. Yet when the Coroner searches the body there are found 82,300 marks and $939 in greenbacks in an inner pocket. Investigation shows that SCHULTE had at least $1,000 in his pockets, which the murderers obtained, and that he owned property to the amount of about $200,000 in Germany.
Suspicion points to the servant. And yet so coolly does he carry himself, so calmly does he explain away all suspicious evidence, that many people who hear the testimony think him innocent. State Attorney OLMSTEAD, pushing the investigation, claims to be drawing around him a chain of evidence that will show he was in this city on the 23d and 24th of December, planning with confederates the murder of the old man on the 27th; that SCHULTE was purposely detained here so that he reached his home after dark, contrary to his custom; that the murderers waited for him in the swamp, and while BUCHHOLZ led the way, stole up behind, brained him with a hatchet, took all the money they supposed he carried, while the servant, with a scratch on his cheek, gave the alarm after the bloody work was completed.
Meanwhile the body of the murdered man is tossing in the Atlantic on the way to his native land, where a brother lives; the servant is under arrest, but not confined, and all South Norwalk asks. "Who killed Mr. SCHULTE?"
WAS IT SCHULTE'S MONEY?
----------
TRACING BILLS MARKED LIKED THOSE OF THE MURDERED MAN
----------
To the Possession of the Person Suspected of Having Committed the Crime – What was Found by One of the Jury near By – The Second of Recent Noted Connecticut Crimes.
SOUTH NORWALK, Conn., Jan. 11. – The Coroner's examination in regard to the murder of the old German miser, John Henry Schulte, on the 27th of December last, was continued here to-day. It has not yet come in as part of the testimony before the jurors, but there is in the hands of the State's Attorney, Mr. Olmstead, a diary which was found among Schulte's effects, and a leaf of it contains a passage, written in quaint German, of which the following is a translation:
On Sunday, Sept. 1, at about 7 in the morning, a man, accompanied by four others, with dogs and guns in their hands, fired into the former bedroom of Schulte. Schulte was then lying in bed. The party repeated the business at about 9 o'clock, and went then through the woods to a potato patch, in order to hunt where there was no game. Becker investigated the matter, and found out that the son of Schulte in Bardeck, Hanover, was among the party.
This curious passage, notwithstanding that it speaks of Schulte in the third person, is in the old man's own handwriting. It is disconnected, but it tells plainly enough of a former attempt at murder. At the time mentioned, Sept. 1, Schulte was at his home, near Dortmund, in Germany: he sailed from Hamburg a few days later, on Sept. 4. He had been toAmerica, and purchased the place in Norwalk, and returned to Germany only to make a short stay. The band, "with dogs and guns in their hands," knew the room in which he had been accustomed to sleep, and fired into it; but it was "Schulte's former bedroom" – that is, he occupied another room during his visit – and he escaped unhurt. Afterward he found this party, consisting of "a man and four others," pretending to hunt in a potato field, where there was no game: and subsequently a man named Becker, perhaps employed by the miser, investigated the matter, and found that one of the murderous party was a nephew of Schulte – the son of a brother who lived in Bardeck (or Barop, or Barby – the handwriting is very difficult to make out), in Hanover. But whatever may turn out to be the importance of this entry in the old miser's diary when it comes to be traced, no attention was paid to it in the examination yesterday, State's Attorney Olmstead going straight ahead upon the theory to which he has, from the beginning, so tenaciously clung, and which supposes that it was the young man Buchholz, who murdered his master for the money which he knew the old man carried upon his person.
The jury met in Dibble's Hall, which is a place a little larger than any that the jury has met in yet, but which, nevertheless, is not so ample that it would not have been more honest to call it Dibble's room. The spectators packed it readily. They showed a curious fringe of bronzed faces and wide-open eyes, as they pressed in about the small space reserved for those who took an active part in the case, and greedily absorbed every wonderful word that dropped from the lips of the witnesses. The jury sat in a row against one of the end walls of the room. It is no ordinary Coroner's jury, that allows itself to be instructed nonchalantly and without prejudice, but it is made up of men who work like beavers either with or against the State's Attorney, and any one of whom would gladly go twenty miles a-foot to gather a shred of evidence in support of his well-settled impressions.
Juryman Berger is a detective, and his zeal is such that he bought with money out of his own pocket a stack of hay which stood near the scene of the murder, caused it to be carted to his own barn, and picked it minutely to pieces to see if he could not find in it the hatchet with which the doctors say the old miser's head was split open. Another juror, it is said, is heart and soul opposed to the State's Attorney, whose handling of Buchholz he regards as persecution. Nearly every one who sits upon the inquest is a witness in the case. They are all familiar with it far beyond the point that the evidence has reached, and when Juryman Berger was called up to-day he coached the Prosecutor and led the examination of himself in the shrewdest possible fashion.
Alfred E. Austin was the first witness called. He is one of the two lawyers of Buchholz, the other being absent in New York. He is a young man, and it was proposed that his examination should go over until his more experienced associate should be present, but State's Attorney Olmstead promptly objected to that. This was not, he said, the trial of any one. Nobody was accused of anything, and therefore it was a solecism that anybody should have a lawyer. As for himself, he was only there, he said, on the part of the State to help on the inquest. It was decided that the examination of Mr. Austin should go on.
“Have you," the State's Attorney inquired in a tone that filled the young lawyer with the blushes of a great embarrassment, "seen any money of any sort or had in your hands any money of any sort belonging to Buchholz?" The young lawyer, blushing, wrote the question all out on a sheet of foolscap that he had on the table before him, said: "I cannot answer you, Mr. Olmstead," and then wrote down his own reply.
"Do you refuse to answer?" – and Mr. Austin wrote for a minute, said: "My mouth is closed, sir,” and wrote for a minute more. But the State's Attorney would not let the young lawyer rest there. He pressed him to know if he had had a retaining fee from Buchholz, and said that the money given as a fee might "have upon it the ear marks that would expose the guilty man." Mr. Austin begged that the State's Attorney would not take advantage of his inexperience, and then Mr. Olmstead impatiently rose, read a passage from "Greenleaf on Evidence," and asked the jury if the other should answer his questions, The jury promptly said he should, and then the prosecutor repeated his question, and Mr. Austin said he "Didn't know." Afterwards he said that Buchholz had not given him a penny for a retaining fee, and the State's Attorney drew a weary breath and let him rest for a while.
Jacob Turk was called. He said that he knew Buchholz. He saw him in upper Norwalk on Tuesday last, at about 3 o'clock. He didn't see any money with him, or hear him talk of money. The Prosecutor bent his eyes upon the witness sharply, when Mr. Austin spoke up and said that Mr. Turk was his interpreter with Buchholz, and what immunity applied to a lawyer applied also to the interpreter. Mr. Olmstead said that he had never known of a similar case, and desisted.
Charles Lacroix was called. He said he lived in Westport. He had seen Buchholz once. At this point Buchholz was brought in for identification. He was wrapped up in a large, new ulster, and carried his blue eyes wide open, looking full at anybody who looked at him. Lacroix said that this was the man whom he had seen in Westport. He had come there last Sunday, and had had some oysters and cigars at his place. In his company were Juryman Berger (a knowing smile from that juryman) and two others. He wanted to pay with a $50 bill. Lacroix refused to take this at first, but one of the others "gave him the wink," by which he knew it was good, and so he took it. Afterward he gave this bill to Mr. Charles Smith. (Mr. Smith here arose and passed a $50 bill to the Prosecutor.) That was the bill that Buchholz gave to him, Lacroix said, looking at it for a single instant, and then, as Mr.
Olmstead held it, the witness called off every one of the numbers that it bore. It was numbered A 6,183, and in common ink marks made with a pen were the other numbers 380 | 191. These, the date of issue, and half a dozen other distinguishing marks the witness had by heart. Charles Smith filled out this testimony by swearing that he got the bill from Lacroix in Westport.
Wm. A. Benedict, clerk in a clothing store, was called. He and Buchholz smiled and exchanged nods as he came in. He had seen Buchholz often, he testified. He had recently purchased a suit of clothes and an ulster in the store, and had offered in payment a $50 bill. Witness had subsequently given the bill to Mr. Chester F. Tolles in cashing a check. Following this bill, Mr. Tolles testified that he had given it to Mr. Hubbel. Mr. Hubbel testified that he had deposited it in the Central National Bank of Norwalk, and Mr. Wm. A. Curtis, cashier of that bank, produced a bill and said that it was the one that Mr. Hubbel had deposited.
Edward Berger, juryman. said he had seen money in the possession of Buchholz. He knew the denominations but not the numbers of the bills representing this money. He had seen Buchholz give a $20 bill to Paul Hersher and $170 to Henry Austin.
“This Austin here who claims he's Buchholz's counsel?" asked Mr. Olmstead sweetly.
Witness said that was the man. He saw Buchholz give him $170 on last Monday at noon. Witness signed the receipt as witness to the transaction. The money consisted of a $100 bill, a $5 bill, and a number of small bills. Witness also saw Buchholz give Lacroix a $50 bill, and he (witness) told Lacroix to hold on to it.
"Mr. Austin," the Prosecutor said, as a buzz of admiration went up at the shrewdness of Juryman Berger, "I want to call you again as a witness. Did you, on last Monday, at noon, receive $170 from Buchholz?"
The young lawyer looked at the Prosecutor who smiled encouragingly at him, and then, with a tender exhibition of reliance on the other's good faith, he answered: "I did."
Another bill was identified by ex-Mayor Dudley P. Ely and Paul Hercher as having come from Buchholz, and then the State's Attorney rose, and reading first the numbers on the bills, called off next the numbers from a private memorandum found among the effects of Schulte, and the numbers of the one and the numbers of the other were identical. During the reading there was a dead silence, which was followed by a sound as if the audience in Dibble’s Hall had drawn a long breath altogether. Buchholz regarded the Prosecutor all the time with wide open eyes. He could not understand the proceedings, and got no startling impressions.
Foreman Stillson after that explained where he had found half a dozen articles that Mr. Olmstead slowly lifted up one after the other. That revolver he picked up half way down between Schulte's barn and the place of the murder. That peculiar German pocket hair brush he picked up just over the other side of a stone wall from from the pistol. That paper of tacks lay two feet nearer to the spot where the murder was committed. The keys lay seven paces to the north; the book lay at the side of the corpse, and the money bag – "the bloody one," the State's Attorney unctuously said in distinguishing between two – the witness found close by the book.
Franklin Tolles, juryman, brought out a pair of unbleached twilled muslin overalls that he had found near the body of the murdered man, and also a pair of red flannel drawers which were rolled tightly together and stood on end at the foot of a tree. The overalls were new and bore on the waistband a check bearing, one below the other, the words: " Lot." "Length," "Waist,"and " No." The length mark only was filled out, and carried after it the number 32. The jury hope to find during the week the tradesman who sold this garment to Schulte.
The German Consul-General, Mr. Schumacker, was present at the inquest.
South Norwalk’s Mystery.
SOUTH NORWALK, Jan, 20. – The Schulte inquest was adjourned today, until Monday next. It is rumored that the State Attorney is waiting to hear from Germany, whence he expects important points, and, furthermore, that he is following two clues in New York. It is known that on the night of the murder two Germans entered the Stamford depot, six miles from the scene of the murder, about three hours after the murder. They were out of breath, as though they had been walking fast. They took a train for New Haven, getting into separate cars. One went to New York early the next morning. Buchholz testified early in the inquest that he had $250 when he hired out to Schulte, that he gave it to the old man to keep, that Schulte returned it to him on the night of the murder, and that the $200 which he (Buchholz) gave Hercher the day after the murder, asking him to say that he loaned it to him in November, was part of the $250. It is now said that it can be proved that Buchholz was enamored of a girl in one of the Chatham square saloons and that in one night he spent $40 or $50 there, and that he was there on other occasions. The cedar tree in the swamp, near which Schulte was killed, in whose branches other branches of cedar were woven, making a shelter behind which a man could conceal himself, has been cut down. No one seems to know why. Attorney Olmstead does not hesitate to say that he suspects Buchholz of having done the killing alone.
JOHN H. SCHULTE'S MURDER.
----------
Holding Buchholz on a Charge of Having a Guilty Knowledge of the Crime.
SOUTH NORWALK, Conn., Feb. 10. – The inquiry into the cause of the death of John H. Schulte, the old German who was murdered here on Dec. 27, came to an end to-day. State's Attorney Olmstead, who has been conducting the case, recalled Dellazon Allen, an old gentleman who was one of the persons who accompanied Buchholz, Schulte's servant, to the spot where the dead man lay after the servant gave the alarm. He testified that after he returned from the swamp he went to the Waring house, where Buchholz and Schulte had lived, and there he saw on the back kitchen floor, upon which Buchholz had fallen as he came running into the house, a footprint in blood, as if one had stepped in blood and then on the floor. It was more than 800 yards from the place where Schulte was killed to the house.
Some letters belonging to Buchholz were also read. One from his sister Johanne in Germany, well written, and full of good advice to the young man so far away from home. In it the writer said that they could send Buchholz no money. It was written on Sept. 17 last. The State's Attorney deems this important as showing that Buchholz had no money when he first went to live with Schulte in October, although he testified that he had loaned him $200, and in that way accounted for the money in his possession after the murder.
The jury returned a verdict to the effect that Schulte was killed by persons known to Buchholz, and that he had a guilty knowledge of the crime. Buchholz is locked up in Bridgeport awaiting the action of the Grand Jury. The German Consul-General has received a letter from Frederick Schulte, the dead man's brother, asking for a certificate of his death, and saying that he had with him bonds and money to the amount of $50,000.
New Hypothesis in the Schulte Murder.
SOUTH NORWALK, Feb. 13. – There is a theory that John H. Schulte, who was in New York on the day of his murder, was detained there by an accomplice of his servant Buchholz, so that he should miss the train that he intended to take and not arrive in South Norwalk till after dark. Hitherto the last trace of Schulte in New York was when he left the office of Mr. Birschoff in the Staats Zeitung building shortly after 2 o'clock in the afternoon. It is now ascertained that he went to the store of Genung & Trapp, commission merchants, at 214 Washington street, and bought some pork. Here he took out a large, dark colored pocketbook, displaying a large number of hills of large and small denominations. He left this store between 5 and 3 ½ o'clock. He carried his satchel under his arm, tied up with a string, so he must have afterward purchased the bottle of wine which he took home in the satchel. These facts show that he was detained by his business until it was too late to take the train which leaves the Grand Central Depot at 3 o'clock and arrives in this place at 4:18. The next train to South Norwalk was the 4:40, which was the one he took. These facts show that Schulte was not purposely detained in New York by an accomplice of Buchholz.
Buchholz Indicted for the Schulte Murder.
BRIDGEPORT, Feb. 26. – The Grand Jury this morning presented an indictment for murder in the first degree against William Buchholz for killing John Henry Schulte at Norwalk on the 27th of last December. Buchholz, who is ignorant of the English language, pleaded, through an interpreter, not guilty.
MERE MENTION.
Frederick Schulte of Hagen, Westphalia, the brother of J. H. Schulte, the old German who was murdered near South Norwalk, Conn., on the 27th of December, has offered a reward of 4,000 marks for the discovery of the murderer of his brother.
Where Schulte’s Watch was Found.
BRIDGEPORT, March 25. – State Attorney Olmstead has in his possession the watch of John H. Schulte, who was murdered in Norwalk. It was found in the roots of a tree, at a point where four men saw Buchholz stand after he had been to call the neighbors on the night of the murder.