These are The New York Sun's reports of William Bucholz's second trial in Bridgeport, in February and March of 1880. These have been transcribed, sometimes manually and sometimes automatically, and then hand-checked. Please let me know if you see any errors.
These come from newspapers.com, and on that site are labeled as 'New York Herald', as distinct from 'The New York Herald', which is the actual Herald.
A SECOND FIGHT FOR LIFE.
----------
WILLIAM BUCHOLZ AGAIN ARRAIGNED ON CHARGE OF MURDER.
----------
The Scene In Bridgeport Yesterday - The Great Struggle to Impanel a Jury – Few Exceptions Taken by Counsel for Defence.
Mr. William Bucholz, charged with the murder of Mr. John Henry Schulte, walked into the Superior Court room in Bridgeport, Conn., yesterday afternoon, and took his seat in the prisoners' pen, near the desk of the Sheriff. Mr. Bucholz resembles an Alsatian or a French Canadian. He has large gray eyes, a prominent nose, a slightly retreating forehead, a square jaw, and a ruddy muddy complexion. His dark hair is combed back. His shoulders are broad, and his large hands and thick wrists give evidence of more than ordinary strength. He is neatly dressed, and has an icy demeanor. Mr. Bucholz was convicted of the murder of Mr. Schulte, but was granted a new trial because of remarks favorable to his interests dropped by a juryman before the close of the trial.
Mr. Schulte was a wealthy German bachelor, living on a farm near South Norwalk, and Mr. Bucholz was his servant. The old bachelor carried $78,500 on his person. He was murdered while walking home through a patch of woods along the railroad with his servant from the depot at twilight on. Dec. 27. 1878. Mr. Bucholz asserted that they were attacked by tramps, and that he was compelled to fly for life. Robbery was undoubtedly the motive for the murder, for when the body was found over $55,000 was missing. Mr. Bucholz was charged with the crime, and duly committed and indicted. He was convicted on the testimony of one of Allen Pinkerton's detectives, who, under the guise of a fellow prisoner, partly won his confidence, and recovered $55,000 through revelations that he swears were made by the accused. The most of this money was found hidden in a stable.
Judge Dwight Loomis of the Supreme Court ascended the bench yesterday afternoon at 2 o'clock. After prayer by the Rev. J. S. McNellie of the Congregational Church, Sheriff Sanford made his announcement opening the regular term of the Superior Court. A respected citizen of the Land of Steady Habits then pleaded guilty to beating his wife and was fined $10. District Attorney James H. Olmstead of Stamford, Nelson Taylor, Jr., of South Norwalk, his assistant, and Gen. Wm. Randel Smith of Norwalk and Charles F. Bollmann of New Haven, counsel for the prisoner, then consulted with the Judge as to the hours for holding court and as to the summoning of extra panels of jurors. The first trial had been so fully reported, and had excited such universal interest, that much difficulty in selecting a jury is anticipated.
"The Clerk may issue a summons for thirty-six additional jurors to be drawn from boxes in the various towns." said Judge Loomis at the close of the conference. "and I think Bridgeport, Norwalk, and other localities near the scene of the homicide may be omitted."
“We make no objection to Bridgeport, your Honor." said Gen. Smith, on behalf of the prisoner. He had tacitly agreed to the omission of Norwalk and towns adjoining.
“We think that prima facie more about it is known in Bridgeport and Norwalk than in towns more remote." Judge Loomis remarked, “Can the extra jurors be summoned by to-morrow morning?"
Mr. Olmstead said that deputy sheriffs could visit the towns immediately and give notice to the constables, who could draw the names from the boxes, so that the jurors could appear in the morning.
Chief Justice John Park, who presided over the great Hayden trial, then took a seat at the side of Judge Loomis, and requested the clerk to call the panel. This was done. The remainder of the afternoon was spent in an effort to secure a jury. The prosecution used three peremptory challenges out of twenty, and the defence one. Four of the panel were excused by the Court as incompetent. Orville H. Hull, a farmer of Prospect, said that he had read a part of the report of the trial in the Bridgeport Farmer, but he had formed no decided opinion. He had no bias against the prisoner. He had never talked with any of the witnesses, and did not think that he had ever expressed an opinion. Questioned closely by Gen. Smith, he admitted that he might have expressed an opinion in his family.
“Would you probably change your opinion if you heard in court the same evidence that you have read?" Gen. Smith inquired.
The question was ruled out, and the General asked the Court to note an exception. Mr. Hull was questioned long and closely. He admitted that he had formed an opinion based on the supposition that what he had read was true, but he could not remember whether he had expressed it or not. Thereupon Gen. Smith said that he thought it the duty of both the District Attorney and the Court to secure the prisoner an impartial jury, and that the doubt, if any, should inure to the benefit of the prisoner. He challenged to the favor. The Court overruled the challenge, and the defence challenged peremptorily, after taking an exception.
The court adjourned to 9 o'clock this morning. A singular feature of the trial is the fact that Mr. Bucholz remains cooped in the pen near the Sheriff's desk, where he has little or no opportunity to confer with his counsel. At the former trial his counsel asked that he be allowed to sit within the bar at their side. The request, they say, was refused, on the ground that it "was not customary in this county." This action is in marked contrast to that in the Hayden trial, where the accused kept his own notes, and coached his counsel every five minutes. The attendance yesterday was small.
A SECOND FIGHT FOR LIFE.
----------
ELEVEN JURORS SELECTED FOR THE SECOND TRIAL OF BUCHOLZ.
----------
Men who Read the Reports of the Testimony, Formed and Expressed Opinions Thereon, and who Require Evidence to Remove their Impressions, Accepted – Law Points.
Mr. William Bucholz, charged with the murder of Mr. John H. Schulte, sat in the prisoners' box of the Superior Court in the Town Hall at Bridgeport, Conn., yesterday morning, reading the Staats Zeitung. His large eyes, heavy eyebrows, light moustache, and icy demeanor attracted the attention of all who entered the courtroom. The struggle to secure a jury for the second trial of the accused was resumed. Nearly every talesman examined had read portions of the reports of the former trial, and had formed and expressed opinions or impressions as to the guilt or innocence of the prisoner, based upon the supposition that the reports were true. Some thought that it would require evidence to remove the Impressions derived from reading the reports, but nearly all seemed confident that they could try the case on the evidence without bias or prejudice. The Court invariably ruled in accordance with a decision of the Supreme Court of Connecticut on the application for a new trial in the case of the State against Wilson. Wilson murdered Capt. Willard, a warden of Wethersfield prison, who, he claimed, had maltreated him. He called the Captain to the door of his cell, and through the grating of the door stabbed him with a knife fastened to a cane. He was tried and convicted. Among other facts his counsel based an application for a new trial on the fact that two jurors were accepted who said that they had read the account of the killing in newspapers, and that, assuming the newspaper reports to be true, they had formed opinions as to the guilt of the prisoner. One of the two talesmen told his family that, if the newspaper report was true, a horrid murder had been committed. He said that he supposed the report was true, and both men acknowledged that it might require some evidence to remove their opinion of the prisoner's guilt. Questioned by the Judges and prosecution, one talesman said that his impressions as to the prisoner's guilt related to the act of killing, and not to the nature and degree of the crime. He said that he had no bias or prejudice against the prisoner, that he had formed no settled opinion of his guilt, and that he believed he could try the cause fairly, and render an impartial verdict upon the evidence given in court, uninfluenced by any previous opinion. He added that it would require no direct evidence to remove his opinion of the prisoner's guilt, but only a failure on the part of the State to show that the newspaper reports were true. On this showing by the counsel for Wilson, the Supreme Court of Connecticut decided that the two jurors were properly impanelled.
Judge Loomis also read the following extract from the opinion of the Supreme Court in the same case:
In the case of the State vs. Potter, where a person summoned as a talesman had formed an opinion based on reading a printed confession of the accused. Judge Williams adopted the principle that the expression of opinion formed even from a personal knowledge of the case, and not out of any ill-will to the party, is no cause of challenge. Where a juror has a settled opinion in a case and has declared it, he ought not to sit: but while it is a mere impression arising from facts supposed to exist, of the truth of which he has formed no opinion, or where the opinion is upon a point so free from doubt as to lay no foundation for dispute, there can be no ground to infer hostility or prejudice, and so the juror must be considered indifferent.
The ruling of the Court throughout the day was in accord with these decisions. Gen. Smith endeavored to stem the tide by quoting the following extract from the decision of the New York Court of Appeals granting Greenfield a third trial because jurors were impanelled on the second trial who had formed opinions based on reading reports of the testimony taken in the first trial:
How can it be determined or assumed that the mind which has already yielded to the force of facts presented to it through the medium of sworn witnesses, and has formed an opinion thereon, will, on a second hearing of the same facts through a like medium, come to a different conclusion, or even so far command itself as to calmly and judicially weigh them again in the balance of a fresh and unbiased judgment? Can that mind be unbiased in the second pondering of the same testimony which has already caused it to preponderate and settle to or toward a conclusion? We think not, and are of the opinion that the challenge to the favor should have been sustained.
Gen. Smith said that this decision was made in the teeth of a statute of New York providing differently. Judges Park and Loomis thought they would stand by the decision of the Supreme Court of Connecticut in preference to the decision of the Court of Appeals of New York.
During the day Gen. Smith took three exceptions to the ruling of the Court. The first was taken on a ruling declaring Jesse R. Benedict a competent juror. Mr. Benedict said that he had read printed reports of the trial, and had formed, but not expressed, an opinion. He thought, however. he could try the case on the evidence, without prejudice, though he still held his opinion. Then Gen. Smith challenged him to the favor on the ground of doubt as to whether he could act impartially. The Court overruled him, and he was forced to challenge Mr. Benedict peremptorily.
The second exception was taken on a ruling of the Court as to the competency of Charles Hoyt, Jr. Mr. Hoyt had read reports, supposed that they were true, and had received therefrom an impression that he thought it would require evidence to remove, but be felt entirely unbiased, and thought he could decide according to the evidence.
The third exception was taken on a ruling of the Court in the examination of James N. Lake. Mr. Lake had read newspaper reports of the detective's evidence in the first trial, and had said that if the report was a true one he believed the man guilty. He could not tell whether he believed or doubted the report. Gen. Smith then asked the following question:
If you should hear the statement made on the stand by a witness whom you believed to be truthful, do you think you could come to any other conclusion?
District Attorney Olmstend said that the question ought to be what the juror thinks now, and not what he is to think in the future. Gen. Smith replied that, if with the same factors the juror should come to the same conclusion, the case was obviously prejudged. The Court ruled the question out, and, to the astonishment of all, the defence accepted Mr. Lake as a juror. Eleven jurors had been impanelled when the Court adjourned. Their names are:
WILLIAM D. GREGORY, Farmer, of Wilton.
VICTOR H. RUSSELL, Farmer, of Greenwich.
FREDERICK B KNAPP, Farmer. of Greenwich.
GEORGE S BATES, Farmer, of Darien.
JAMES N. LAKE, Farmer, of Newtown.
EDWIN P. WHITE, Farmer, of Ridgefield.
EDWIN MOREHOUSE, Farmer, of Wilton.
THOMAS T. BRISTOL, Farmer, of Brookfield.
HENRY I. BRONSON, Farmer, of Huntington.
CHARLES BEARD, Farmer, of Huntington.
FERDINAND W. BURT, Farmer, of Ridgefield.
During the impanelling of these jurors Mr. Bucholz sat in the prisoners' box, twenty feet from his counsel, staring at the talesmen with his large eyes, and having no voice in their selection. The Rev. Mr. Hayden and Mr. Jesse Billings, Jr. sat at the side of their counsel during the selection of the jurors in their case, and their lawyers accepted no man without consulting them. The following is a summary thus far:
Jurors declared incompetent by the Court: 13
Peremptorily challenged by Prosecution: 10
Peremptorily challenged by Defence: 10
Jurors accepted: 11
Exceptions taken by the Defence: 5
It is understood that Mr. Frank Bischoff, an important witness for the prosecution, doing business in this city, has refused to appear at this trial. In the first trial Mr. Bischoff testified that he gave Mr. Schulte gold in exchange for bills in the Ottendorfer building on the day of the murder. Among the gold pieces was one with a hole in it. Mr. Bischoff told Mr. Schulte that he could wear it as a charm on his watch chain. Pinkerton's detective, who claims to have won Mr. Bucholz's confidence while assuming the part of a fellow prisoner, testified that the accused told him where he had buried some money, and that on digging at the spot indicated he found, among other coins, the perforated gold piece. This coin was identified by Mr. Bischoff.
A SECOND FIGHT FOR LIFE.
----------
CONDUCT OF MR. BUCHOLZ BEFORE AND AFTER THE SCHULTE MURDER.
----------
The Story of a Former Servant – How Mr. Bucholz Got Into Mr. Schulte's Employ – Scenes in a German Hotel in Pearl Street – The Story of the Night of the Murder.
Mr. William Bucholz entered the prisoners' pen in the Town Hall at Bridgeport, Conn., yesterday morning at 9 o'clock, and was forced to remain aloof from his counsel during the day. He lost himself in the columns of a German newspaper while the last juror of the twelve that are to pass upon life or death was being selected. The chosen citizen was Mr. Bradley Hull of Weston. It is a jury of farmers. In appearance it compares favorably with the jury in the Hayden trial.
The prosecution, as is the custom in Connecticut, made no presentation of their case. Mr. Siegfried Gruenwald, the first witness, was called within twenty minutes of the opening of the court. He is a pink-cheeked Hebrew boy, with a long, white, womanly neck, a prominent nose, and tightly curling black hair. He speaks English very imperfectly. The services of an interpreter were required. Mr. Bucholz leaned forward in the prisoners' box, with his hand to his ear, and listened intently to the questions and answers that were made in German. Mr. Gruenwald's testimony is given in narrative form.
"I am employed in a barber shop in Brooklyn," he said. "I came to New York on Sept. 27. 1878, as a servant to Mr. J. H. Schulte. He engaged me at Dortmund, in Germany, after advertising in a German newspaper. I made a written contract to come to America with him. I entered his service on Aug. 3,1878. I first saw him from a month to six weeks before that. I lived in a town forty minutes away from his residence by railroad. On arriving in New York, we went to the Sonne Hotel, on Pearl street, between Elm and Centre. I saw Mr. Bucholz there for the first time, and got acquainted with him. I told him that I intended to leave Mr. Schulte because he was a queer man. I also told him that he was rich. Mr. Bucholz said that he thought I was foolish to leave Mr. Schulte's service, and added that he would like to take my place. He said he would do different from me. I cannot tell how much money Mr. Schulte had. He carried a great deal in envelopes in his side coat pockets. I saw him open a black trunk in the hotel and take out a bag of gold coins. He gave me one of the coins in payment for my services. I know that he had some thousand-dollar bills and notes of a smaller denomination. Some of it was American money, but the large bills were German.
"I left the Sonne Hotel." continued Mr. Gruenwald, "about the 1st of October. Mr. Schulte was not there when I left. I did not see Mr. Bucholz on that day. He understood that I was going to leave Mr. Schulte, but did not know at what time. [Here the witness identified Mr. Schulte's watch, guard, and bunch of keys.] I next saw Mr. Schulte at Philip Kraus's barber shop, where I was employed, at 434 East Fifteenth street, New York, on Dec. 27. 1878 [the day of the murder]. I had written asking him for reemployment. He came to see me about it, with an empty black travelling bag rolled under his arm. He wore a red handkerchief about his neck. a brown coat, light pantaloons, a green felt hat, and boots of a red color."
District Attorney Olmstead here tried to elicit testimony calculated to show that Mr. Bucholz knew that his employer was visiting Gruenwald with the purpose of reemploying him. The defence objected, and the Court ruled it out as not coming within the law. The witness then identified two pocketbooks that were carried by Mr. Schulte. One was dry and stiff, as though it had been kept in some damp spot. He said that Mr. Schulte kept his most valuable bank notes in it. The other was a long black pocketbook, with black tape wound around it. Mr. Gruenwald said that the old man always carried these pocketbooks in his coat-tail pockets. The murdered man's hat and coat were also identified. A bunch of trunk keys, two canvas bags for coin, three colored silk handkerchiefs, a small tin box of cartridges, and a paper box filled with hobnails were also identified as the property of Mr. Schulte. There was a stain, apparently, of blood on the handkerchief worn on the day of the murder. The witness qualified his testimony concerning the tin and paper boxes by saying that Mr. Schulte either owned them or boxes that very much resembled them.
Here Gen. Smith said that, as Mr. Bucholz was not allowed to sit with his counsel, he requested that the witnesses should be asked to speak so loud that he could understand what was said. The District Attorney then exhibited a canvas bag splotched with spots of sealing wax, and Mr. Gruenwald said that he had seen one resembling it in Mr. Schulte's possession, apparently filled with money. On cross-examination he said that he knew that Mr. Schulte had a brother in Germany, and no other relatives.
"Were you in his service when his life was attacked in Germany ?" Gen. Smith inquired.
"I object," said the District Attorney. "There is no evidence that his life was attacked."
"Very well." said Gen. Smith; "then we'll put it in another form. Were you in his service when four or five men, among whom was his nephew, shot into his bedroom?"
Mr. Olmstead indignantly objected, and charged that the question was only asked for the purpose of affecting the minds of the jury.
Chief Justice Park ruled it out, and Gen. Smith said that he would prove the attack if he was allowed to do so.
The witness said that his duty as a servant was to accompany Mr. Schulte when he went out, look after his luggage, and sleep in the same room with him. He could not say that it was for the purpose of protecting him. They came to New York in the steamer State of Virginia. He told Mr. Bucholz and three or four other persons in the Sonne Hotel that Mr. Schulte was in the habit of carrying large sums of money on his person. He had a yellow pocketbook and a money package in a newspaper, with a cord around it, in the side pocket of his vest or coat. He had a bag filled with specie in the pocket of his pantaloons. The yellow pocketbook contained American bank notes. There were notes of a small denomination, and he saw at least one fifty-dollar bill among them. He used the pocketbook when making purchases. At times the witness saw him counting his money, but never in the presence of other persons. He had told several men in the hotel that he was going to leave the service of Schulte.
Mr. Frank Just testified that he drove an express wagon for the Sonne Hotel. Mr. Bucholz was a guest at the house six weeks before the arrival of Messrs. Schulte and Gruenwald. He saw Mr. Schulte making purchases at odd times with money taken from the yellow pocketbook. He took him to the depot in the express wagon when he left the hotel and went to Norwalk [where he had bought a farm, and where he was murdered. – Rep.] Mr. Bucholz asked the witness whether he could accompany him to the depot. He replied, "Yes," and they went together on the front seat of the wagon. Mr. Schulte sat behind them. Mr. Bucholz asked him what had become of Gruenwald, and Mr. Schulte replied that he had left him. Mr. Bucholz then asked for the place. The old man smiled, and said, " You wouldn't want to go for the wages you would get." The next inquiry was concerning the wages. Mr. Schulte answered that he only paid three dollars a month. "I'll go for that," said Mr. Bucholz. "It's better than to stay here getting into debt." The old man then asked him why he came to New York, and he replied that he was on his way to Australia, where he had friends. Mr. Schulte then said. " Well, I’ll return next week and let you know what I will do." Mr. Bucholz said that he would go with him that minute if he would take him. "Very well," replied Mr. Schulte, "you can come and see the place, and see how you like it. If it suits you you can come back next week and get your things."
Otto Schwelsky, an employee of the Sonne House, said that he was present when Mr. Schulte paid his bill. Mr. Bucholz was sitting near the door when he went away. He turned to the witness, saying "I'll try to get along with him." and followed him to the street. Mr. Bucholz had a trunk brought from Germany and marked:
ADELAIDE via NEW YORK.
The trunk was still at the hotel. Soon after the murder a Mr. Berger paid thirty-five dollars due for Mr. Bucholz's board. The witness received from him two twenty-dollar notes, and returned five dollars in change. He afterward gave the notes to a man who said he was sent for them by the German Consul. The bills were marked with figures in ink.
Mrs. Amelia Waring of Norwalk. whose family lived in the house with Mr. Schulte, near where he was murdered. testified that she first saw him in August, 1877. He bought the farm and boarded with her a week, after which he returned to Germany. He came back on Oct. 2, 1878, with Wm. Bucholz, whom he said he had hired.
"I cooked his meals," said Mrs. Waring. "He usually ate supper between 4 and half past 4, and we saw very little of him after that. He retired to his room about 6. He never left the house after sundown. When he went out William generally accompanied him."
"What sort of a walker was he?" Mr. Olmstead inquired.
I never saw him at any walking match, and don't know." said Mrs. Waring. "One rainy day he went to the store and returned in quick time. William usually left the house with him. Mr. Schulte always went ahead, and William followed him. On their return William had the lead. They seemed to get along together without much trouble. One day, however, I heard loud talking between them about the contract up stairs. William came down with the document in his hand. I asked him what was the matter. He said that under the contract Mr. Schulte claimed that he had a right to kick him, and he replied that if he kicked him he would not stay with him a moment longer. William visited New York once or twice before the murder. One day after that Mr. Schulte asked me whether William had told me that he was to leave him on the 20th of January. He stood on the stairs and William was near by. William replied, ‘Yes, Mr. Schulte. that's all right.’
"On Friday morning. Dec. 27. 1878," Mrs. Waring continued, "I sent Mr. Schulte's breakfast up stairs, and he ate it. On coming down he gave me the key to his room. This was contrary to his custom. He usually hung the key on a nail in the sink room. William had preceded him down stairs, and had gone through the kitchen up to his own room. Mr. Schulte had told me before this that he was going to New York. I may have told William, but I am not positive. I asked Mr. Schulte when he would be back. He replied. 'At 4 o'clock or in the evening. Meantime William had again come down stairs, He did not accompany him to the depot. As Mr. Schulte walked off I heard him talking to William, who must have been standing in the door. William stayed home the most of the day, reading. He went to the Five Mile Run and back with me. He left the house in the afternoon between 3 and 4 o'clock. My daughter was going skating. She asked him to go with her.
He said: 'I thank you, lady, but I must go to meet Mr. Schulte.' I spoke about going with him, but changed my mind and said that I would lie down. He replied. 'Oh. come on. It will do you good.' He went off through the woods toward the railroad, the way he usually went to the depot. I heard the up train go through at 6:30. After that I heard the down train running into the depot. The schedule time is 7:45 [surely this must be 6:45]. A few minutes afterward I heard my daughter shout to her brother, 'Sammy, Sammy. William is calling you.' I opened the door, and William fell in on the floor. He had a satchel in his hand. He lay on the floor some moments. Sammy asked him two or three times, 'Where is Mr. Schulte? What's the matter?' He finally gasped. 'He is being murdered, or he is dead in the woods – tramps!' He began to weep. He said he would get his pistol and shoot them. Sammy said he would get Mr. Schulte's gun and kill them. William replied, 'I go with you. I no afraid.' He was then sitting on a chair. He went to a cigar box and got his pistol, and then fell on the floor in a fainting condition. I got some water and wet a towel to bathe his head. He partially revived. I asked him whether he felt able to go to the neighbors with us for help. He answered: 'Oh, yes. I go with you, Mrs. Waring.' We went around the house to see whether the coast was clear, and then went to the house of the nearest neighbor, Mr. Allen. As I entered the house I looked at the clock. It was twelve minutes after 7. I told Mr. Allen what had happened, and said I had come to get some help. He asked where the young man was, and I said out doors. When I went out William stood near the stoop with his hand to his face. Afterward he came in with Sammy, and sat down. He seemed to be dazed. I gave him Mrs. Allen's camphor bottle, and after a spell the three went out together."
"I next saw them at our house at 10 o'clock, when Mr. Schulte's body was brought up. William was silent. I said: 'Will you go to bed?' He replied: 'I can no sleep.' I told him to go up stairs with Sammy and sleep on the floor in my room. He thanked me and went. In the night I got up to put some coal on the fire, and saw that he was awake. I asked him the matter. and he answered: 'I can no sleep.' In the morning he arose a little after 6 o'clock. He went to Norwalk about 8. Mr. Berger. the constable, afterward took a pair of pantaloons from his room."
Mrs. Waring identified the pantaloons, but failed to identity a shirt and an axe that were shown her. On cross-examination Gen. Smith tried to elicit a conversation showing that the arrangement between Messrs. Schulte and Bucholz under which they were to separate on Jan. 20 had been rescinded, but the Court ruled the question out because it did not come within the rule of evidence. Gen. Smith took an exception. The court then adjourned.
A SECOND FIGHT FOR LIFE.
----------
WEAVING THE WEB OF CIRCUMSTANCES AROUND WILLIAM BUCHOLZ.
----------
A Contumacious Witness Sent to Bridgeport Jail for an Indefinite Period – Particulars of the Discovery of the Body of Old Mr. Schulte – Mr. Bucholz’s Ominous Silence.
Mr. William Bucholz took his seat within the prisoner's box in the Town Hall, Bridgeport, Conn., at 10 o'clock yesterday morning and faced a goodly array of ladies. As the jury filed into their seats he scanned each face, and began to bite his lips. District Attorney Olmstead called Mr. George H. Graff as his first witness. Mr. Graff was conducted to the stand by a police officer. The great eyes of the accused were turned full upon him. The witness was a beardless boy, apparently about 19 years old. He had a troubled face. He was slouchy in dress and manner, and marched to the witness stand with evident unwillingness. He came from Bridgeport jail, where he has been confined for the last four months for stealing a boat. The examination continued as follows:
Q – Has Bucholz talked with you about the murder of Schulte? A (with eyes bent down) – I have conscientious scruples against testifying against him.
Q – We don’t ask you now what he said. We simply ask you whether you had a conversation with him? A – I don’t like to betray the confidence of a friend.
Q – Has he conversed with you about the murder? A – He’s treated me like a gentleman, and I can’t betray him.
Q – I only ask whether he has talked with you? A – Yes, he’s talked with me.
Q – Has he talked with you about the murder? A – I have conscientious scruples against testifying in a case where life and death are concerned.
Chief Justice Park – You must answer the question. A (with downcast head) Mr. Bucholz always treated me like a friend, and I don’t think that it’s right for me to say anything about this.
District Attorney Olmstead – The Court says that you must answer. A (in a low tone) – But I decline to answer.
Q – Well, I’ll ask you another question. Did you say anything to Bucholz about killing the old man? A – It might affect my case, and I ain’t agoing to say anything about it. [Mr. Bucholz rolled his large gray eyes toward the witness.]
Chief Justice Park – The question must be answered.
Witness – I decline to answer it. Mr. Bucholz has always treated me like a gentleman, and I’ll treat him like one.
Q – The Court decides that you must answer, sir. Did you say anything to him about killing the old man? A – You must get somebody else to answer that question. You must not use me.
Q – Do you know Mr. Hineman, the Kentucky forger who testified to conversations with Mr. Bucholz? A – Yes, sir.
Q – Now, sir, did you say anything to Bucholz about the murder? A – I didn’t want to come here, and I don’t want anything to do with this case.
Chief Justice Park – You must answer the question, or be punished.
Witness (walking from the stand) – You must excuse me, I will not betray confidence when it will have such an effect.
District Attorney Olmstead – Take the stand again, sir. Do you understand the Court?
Judge Loomis – Do you understand that you will be punished if you refuse to answer? A – You must excuse me. Mr. Bucholz is my friend. I won’t injure a friend.
Chief Justice Park – Commit this witness to jail for contempt, and hold him until the further order of the court.
Mr. Graff was then marched back to jail. Miss Sadie Waring, a blooming miss, neatly dressed, and a refreshing contrast to Mr. Graff, was the next witness. She testified that she was the daughter of Mrs. Amelia Waring, whose family lived in the house with Messrs. Schulte and Bucholz, and corroborated the testimony of her mother as to the scene on the night of the murder. The accused fainted as he fell in the door. When he recovered her brother Sammy asked him where Mr. Schulte was. He replied, “Dead, dead, down in the voots!” On cross-examination she said that the relations between the two men always seemed to be friendly and pleasant. William was quiet and cheerful, and never morose. The witness felt confident that he entered the house on the night of the murder, about five minutes after the 6:48 train went up. When asked concerning Mr. Schulte he said, “He’s down in te voots, dead, dead!”
Q – Didn’t he point toward the woods and say: “He’s down in te voots, dare, dare,” instead of “dead, dead?” A – I think not.
Q – Are you positive? A – I am not. I think, however, that he said “dead, dead!”
Q – Did he not say that Mr. Schulte had been attacked? A – I think not.
Q – Did he not use a word that sounded like the word “attacked”? A – He used a word that sounded like it, but I can’t repeat it.
Q – What other words did he use? A – While seated in the chair, after his first fainting spell, he turned to my brother and said: “Come, Sammy, I can no stay here and leef poor Mr. Schulte down in te voots.”
Miss Annie L. Waring corroborated the testimony of her sister Sadie. She was positive that the accused said: “Down in te voots, dead, dead.” when questioned concerning the whereabouts of Mr. Schulte. Mr. Bucholz was out of breath, and spoke English very imperfectly. She was equally positive that Mr. Bucholz came to the door of the house give minutes after the passage of the train due at Norwalk at 6:48. She recognized the whistle of the locomotive, and heard her brother say: “There goes the quarter to 7 train.” She was in the habit of using the trains as a means of determining the time. She was then questioned as to the time between the appearance of the accused at the house after the killing and the arrival of the party at the house of Mr. Allen. She said that the scene had been reenacted since then in the presence of the District Attorney and other witnesses. Gen. Smith objected to this testimony, on the ground that Mr. Bucholz’s absence threw it beyond the pale of the law. The Court ruled against him, and he took an exception. Miss Annie said that she stood on the floor about the length of time that her mother said that Mr. Bucholz lay insensible. Gen. Smith took a second exception to this testimony.
John W. Wills, alias R. F. Hineman, alias J. S. Hamilton, the Kentucky forger, was recalled. He said that in all their conversations in Bridgeport jail he had no trouble in understanding what Mr. Bucholz said.
Gen. Smith – Can you speak German? A – No, sir.
Gen. Smith – Have you the indictment against this man, Mr. Olmstead?
The District Attorney – I haven’t had the time to look it up.
Gen. Smith – Then we will defer this cross-examination until you get it.
Mr. Olmstead – I’ll keep the witness here.
Gen. Smith – He’ll probably be well kept until we get through with him.
Mr. Wills retired in the custody of an officer. Samuel Waring, brother to Sadie and Annie, was called. He corroborated the testimony of his mother and sisters up to the time they went to neighbor Allen’s for help.
“I told Mr. Allen,” he continued, “that Mr. Schulte had been attacked down in the woods, and asked him to go down with us. He sent me to a neighbor’s for a lantern. I went to Tom Ireland’s. William Bucholz went with me. Ireland had no lantern, and we returned to Mr. Alen’s. I afterward borrowed a lantern at Mr. Hoyt’s. William remained at Mr. Allen’s. When I got back Mr. Allen, Mr. Dingee, Mr. Allen’s nephew, William, and myself started for the woods. We had two lanterns. I went ahead, and William was right behind me. On getting over the fence at the path reading through the woods I said, “I see a bundle here.” William replied, “All right.” Two of three hams tied in a bundle were lying on the north side, three or four feet from the path. They were ten or twelve feet from the path. By the light of the lantern we saw something dark lying near the path, a little further on. It was the body of Mr. Schulte. His head lay near an ant hill, and his feet toward the railroad track. There was blood on his face. The inside pocket of his coat was turned out. I saw some papers and a book with a black cover near the body. [He identified the book. It is a dictionary with a pocket.] William did not go near the corpse. I stepped over it and picked up the dictionary. I asked Mr. Allen what we had better do. He replied, “Leave everything as you find it.” I replaced the dictionary. William vouchsafed no explanation as to how the old man was killed. We stood over the body four or five minutes, and then returned to the house, taking the bundle of hams with us. I put my gun under the stoop, and we all went up to Mr. Allen’s residence. William and I then started for Norwalk after a Coroner. When we arrived at Mr. Hoyt’s barn some one shouted, ‘Hold on! Tom Ireland’ll go up with you.’ I said to William, ‘Wait a minute.’ There was another barn a hundred or more feet below us. We stood in the road between them. [It was near here that Mr. Schulte’s watch was found some time afterward. – Rep.] William was walking to and fro with his hand to his face, and I was knocking my feet together, for it was pretty cold. Ireland and his brother soon came. I think that Ed. Hoyt also went with us to Norwalk. We crossed the platform at the depot and went around on the side set apart for the New Haven train. Through the window of the gentlemen’s room I saw Charley Jost, a policeman. I went in and told him what had happened. William was with me. Up to this time he had made no effort to explain the death of Mr. Schulte. I told Charley Jost that William could talk German, and asked him to talk with him. They conversed in German, and we started for Mr. Taylor’s office. At the crossing we met Mr. Pelham, the Chief of Police, who accompanied us to the office. Several persons talked with William, and we went to Mr. Carr’s office, where a Coroner’s jury was secured. Mr. Stilson, the foreman, told me to take William down to his office, get a plaster put on his head, and follow them to the spot where the body lay. We went to his office, and Mr. Baxter, a clerk, placed a plaster on William’s cuts. They conversed in German. We hurried down the railroad track, ??ing that we might overtake the jury. We overtook some boys, who told us that the jury had gone around by the road. When we got to the path that turns into the woods I saw somebody coming with a lantern. It was Dr. Pardee. A stranger was with him. I conducted them toward the body. William was still with us. Dr. Pardee held his lantern well up in front, and was the first to discover the body. No one touched it until the jury came. William said not a word. The jury was on the ground within five minutes. Dr. Pardee examined the dead man’s head by the light of his lantern. ‘There’s the wound,’ said he, pointing to the back of the head. ‘Let’s look and see whether there are any more.’ He moved the head a little one side, and found a hole behind the dead man’s ear. The body was then carried to the house and deposited on the floor of the sink room. William and Mr. Spitzer sat at the table talking German. Mother called me upstairs. Up to bedtime William had said nothing to us as to how the old man was killed. He slept with me that night. We arose in the morning together, and went down stairs.”
The witness then identified and described the finding of the axes. One was found standing against the chopping block, and the other in the cellar. “When I last saw the former,” said the witness, “it was in the barn.”
The cross-examination was long and exhaustive. It was mainly concerning apparent discrepancies between Mr. Waring’s testimony on this and the former trial. On cross-examination in the former trial he spoke of finding a black pocketbook near the body. He denied this, and explained the seeming inconsistency by saying that he at first mistook the dictionary for a pocketbook. He swore positively that he saw no pocketbook near the body. He insisted that William said, “Schulte is down in te voots, dead, dead,” but acknowledged that he (witness) had afterward told three different persons that the old man had been attacked down in the woods. He did not know what caused him so to say.
John Dingee, a gray-headed gentleman, corroborated Mr. Waring’s story as to the discovery of the body. He said he saw Samuel Waring pick up the dead man’s hat, dictionary, and a little canvas specie bag. He advised him to leave them as he found them, and Samuel did so. The dead man’s waistcoat was partly unbuttoned, and his coat and overcoat were thrown open. “No one touched the body but myself,” said the aged gentleman. “I put my hand on Schulte’s heart and found that he had ceased to breathe.” Mr. Bucholz carried the package of hams to the house. On the way up he dropped his handkerchief, and asked Mr. Dingee to pick it up. He did so, and returned it to him. Mr. Bucholz did not offer to explain Mr. Schulte’s death. The court then adjourned.
Detective Taylor yesterday received the following letter:
Franks’ Detective and Collection Bureau.
Principal Office, 521 Chestnut st.
Branch Agencies in all the Principal Cities of the U. S. and Europe.
Phila., Feb 22, 1880.
Detective Taylor – Dear Sir. In looking over The New York Sun of today, I find you have a young man named John W. Wills as a witness in the Bucholz murder trial. I was reading the cross-examination of Mr. Wills. I will now state to you that his answers in reference to this city are correct. I had charge of his case in reference to the forgeries on the Philadelphia bank. He boarded, as he says, in Arch street, above Tenth, at the time of his forgeries here, for I went there the day after he left for the West. I had his trunk detained at St. Louis, but he never called for it. What he states in reference to Baltimore is correct. It was there he was arrested and brought to Philadelphia. And his statement in reference to his family is correct. His father is a man of high standing, but John W. Wills, a find young man when he entered the store of Ashbridge & Co., fell from the company he kept – fast young men and depraved women. I made inquiries of the antecedents of his family when he was here, and they stood very high. You tell John that Mr. Chatham of the bank is dead. I give you this to let you know, however bad Jack may be, he is telling the truth in many things I know of. You ask him whether he knows Capt. Franks of Philadelphia, who had his case in charge here at the first outset.
I remain, most respectfully, yours,
Wm. D. Franks
The prisoners in the Bridgeport jail are reported as showing much bitterness toward Mr. Hineman. He is confined in his cell during the general hours of liberty in the corridors.
A SECOND FIGHT FOR LIFE.
----------
STILL WEAVING THE WEB OF CIRCUMSTANCES AROUND WM. BUCHOLZ.
----------
The Finding of the Murdered Man's Watch – The Ambush In the Cedar Tree – Bloody Rags – Two Revolvers Found In the Woods – A Lost Hairbrush – Mysterious Overalls.
Mr. William Bucholz faced another array of ladies as he sat within the railing of the prisoners' pen in the Town Hall of Bridgeport, Conn., yesterday. It was the sixth day of his trial. His long ulster and soft felt hat hung near the window at his back. He spent much of the time in reading the Staats-Zeitung. Mr. Selazon Allen [Dilazon Allen], the neighbor to whom the Waring family and the accused went for aid on the night of the murder, testified that after their arrival he heard Mr. Bucholz groan and saw him put his hand to his face. He saw two or three scratches there, but did not think they amounted to much. He noticed that there was a rent in his pantaloons as he sat on a chair in his house. They all went down in the woods to look for Mr. Schulte. They had two lanterns. In getting over the stone fence at the beginning of the path through the woods he saw three or four spots of blood on the stones. It was about sixty feet from where they found the body. As they reached the body he heard Mr. Bucholz say: "My God, he is dead!" He could see the accused, by the light of the lantern, stooping toward the body. He saw Samuel Waring pick up a book and some papers, turn them over to Mr. Bucholz, and heard him say, “You had better take them." The witness took them from the prisoner and threw them over to the north side of the body. [Mr. Waring said nothing about this in his testimony. – REP.] On the way back from the body, either Mr. Waring or Mr. Bucholz picked up the bundle [of hams]. The witness said that it had better be left behind. "It belongs to me, and I am going to take it," the man answered. [Both Waring and Dingee assert that Mr. Bucholz picked up the package.]
Mr. Allen testified that he returned to the Waring House before the body was brought up. Mrs. Waring showed him the satchel that Mr. Bucholz carried when he fell in at the door. She said, "See the blood on the floor, where he fell in." He saw traces of blood on the floor, and also saw a clearly defined bloody footprint near the door. The blood was dark in the center and fresh on the edges of the print. "While we were talking," said Mr. Allen, "there was a knock at the door. I said. 'They are coming with the body. What shall we do with it?' Mrs. Waring replied. 'Take it in the back door.' They brought it around through the sink-room and took it up stairs. The waistcoat of the dead man was open to the bottom button."
On cross-examination, Mr. Allen said that he drove to Norwalk on the evening of the murder to meet the 6 o'clock train from Danbury. He returned on the arrival of the train, put out his horse, and had been in the house from twenty to twenty-five minutes, when Mrs. Waring came. He went out ten or fifteen minutes after her arrival, and saw Sam Waring and the accused for the first time. He met them in the road, returning from Ireland's. Samuel then went to Mr. Hoyt's for a lantern. and Mr. Bucholz went back to the house with the witness. "He seemed scared and excited," said Mr. Allen. "I asked him concerning his wounds, and he mumbled something that I could not understand." The witness acknowledged that he had testified at the former trial that he saw the bloody footprint on a piece of carpet near the door. He was satisfied, however, that it must have been on the floor. When they arrived at the body Sam Waring said, "See the book and papers."
Q – Did you not at the former trial say that he said "See the books and papers?” A – He might have said so. I saw no more than one book. Sammy may have picked up another, but if so it was not among the things that he passed to Mr. Bucholz.
Q – Did you not say at the former trial that while standing at the body Mr. Bucholz was "rather bending down a little. It was dark. and I wasn't watching every motion?" A – I might have said so. [The object seems to be to show that Mr. Buchulz might have stolen the pocketbook at that time, and still be guiltless of the murder.]
Q – Did not Mr. Bucholz express a willingness to go after the officers after the discovery of the body? A – Sammy asked him to go, and he said he would.
Samuel and Thomas Ireland and Edward Hoyt substantially testified that they went with Samuel Waring and Mr. Bucholz after the Coroner, and that the accused on the way had an opportunity to throw the Schulte watch, if it was in his possession, near the hickory tree where it was found on March 15, 1879. Mr. Hoyt said that he was on a load of hay near by when Gustav Hedstrom found the watch. It lay on the street side of the fence, under the branches of a hickory tree that stood in the lot. He thought that the party stopped near that tree while on the way after a Coroner. The watch lay between some stubs of nettles, four or five feet from the path parallel with the road. It appeared clean and bright. He saw it shine before Hedstrom picked it up. He shook it to see whether.it would go or not, and it ticked. There was no snow on the ground on Friday, Dec. 27, the day of the murder. A great many people passed over the path within four or five feet of the spot where the watch was found in the two succeeding days. He thought that it snowed on the following Tuesday. The snow had just melted off when the watch was found. In summer the nettles at that spot are very thick, but he could not tell how thick they were at the time of the murder. They were broken down when the watch was found.
"I found the watch," testified Gustav Hedstrom, "under the big hickory, near the barn. Ed Hoyt and I were carting hay. Ed told me to pick up a stick to drive the horse. I had a pitchfork in my hand, and used it in pitching up the sticks at the side of the road until I could find one that suited me. I saw something bright and hallooed to Ed. 'There's a watch.' I picked it up. It was among the brush and leaves under the tree, about two feet from the fence and ten or fifteen feet from the road. The footpath was between the road and the fence. The watch lay on some leaves."
The watch is a small open-faced gold watch, with an old-fashioned cylinder escapement. The cap bears the following inscription:
One of the four screws over the barrel containing the mainspring bristles with rust. A tiny speck of rust also appears upon a large screw on the inside near the stem. Gen. Smith wound the watch, and it ticked quite merrily. He then passed it to the jury.
Franklin A. Tolles identified two pair of pantaloons that he had taken from Mr. Bucholz's room on Monday and Wednesday after the murder. He found what he took to be blood stains near the left knee of the first pair [worn by Mr. Bucholz on the night of the murder]. Gen. Smith objected to the expression of the witness's opinion concerning the stains. He was overruled and took an exception. Mr. Tolles testified that he took the second pair of pantaloons because Mrs. Waring called his attention to light spots on them. On the day after the murder he saw Officer Berger pick up a short loaded pepper-box revolver, about thirty feet from where Mr. Schulte's body was found. They also found a large torn rag, stained with blood, ten or twelve leet south of the path. It was frozen stiff. [It was evidently part of a shirt. The District-Attorney called the jury's attention to the yoke.] The witness also identified a coat, waistcoat, and shirt which he said he had taken from Mr. Bucholz's room on Monday, after the killing. He also identified a money-bag that he had picked up fifty or sixty feet from where the body was found. [The bag was identified by Mr. Schulte's former servant as similar to if not the very one carried by the old man before he went to Norwalk.]
Mr. Tolles described an ambush made in a small cedar tree about six feet from the path, discovered on the day after the murder. On one side some of the branches had been cut away and woven into the branches on the other side, forming a screen that would hide a person from the sight of any one who was passing along the path. On cross-examination he said he was a member of the Coroner's jury. A Mr. Illing accompanied him to the room of Mr. Bucholz when he took the clothes. Illing was a sort of a self-appointed detective. He was now in Germany. He had been acting as an interpreter before the Coroner's jury. Gen. Smith laid a pair of white overalls neatly folded before the witness, and asked him whether he had ever seen them. He replied that Sammy Waring had found them wrapped in a copy of the New York Herald in an open space in the woods about forty feet from the spot where the body was found.
The District Attorney adjured the witness to handle the overalls carefully, as he did not wish the creases where they were folded erased. Thereupon Gen. Smith shook out the overalls and passed them to the jury. They seemed brand new, but there was a grease spot on one leg. Mr. Olmstead called the jury's attention to the cost mark, which had not been removed. [It will be observed that these overalls were put in the case by the defence.] The witness said that he and Officer Arnold found an axe leaning against a chopping block in the Waring yard on Sunday afternoon. There was a blood stain about an inch and a quarter from the edge. The blood had trickled down to the edge in two streams. A feather as large as a shilling piece adhered to the stain. The quill part alone was bloody.
Officer George N. Arnold testified that he saw no feathers on the axe. There was also blood near the butt, and the handle showed the marks of bloody fingers. The witness also saw the cedar screen mentioned by Mr. Tolles.
Mrs. Waring corroborated Mr. Tolles's testimony concerning the prisoner's pantaloons. She said that Mr. Bucholz alone had access to his room, and from that fact alone she reckoned that the clothes in his room were his property. Orlando Bartram testified that at the request of the District Attorney on Feb. 10, 1880, he took the pantaloons and axe to 328 Tremont street, Boston. Dr. J. B. Treadwell [the corpuscle expert of the Hayden trial] had them in his possession three hours and a quarter.
George C. Stilson, foreman of the Coroner's jury, said that he left his office with the jury at 9:05 on the night of the murder. They went directly to the woods, and found the body as has been described. Dr. Pardee, Mr. Pitzer, and others were there. The body lay on an incline, with the head at the foot of a very large ant-hill. The jury grouped themselves around it, and Dr. Pardee examined the wounds. "I picked up some papers," said Mr. Stilson, "a German diary and a book, and took the watch guard from the dead man’s neck. The key was there, but the watch was missing. The papers were written in German. I also picked up copies of the New York Herald, the Norwalk Sentinel, and several other newspapers. The pocket of the dead man's coat was turned outward. I saw no pocketbook. I told the jurors that the wounds showed that the man had been murdered, and called their attention to the fact that the body had been robbed. I then told them to carry the body to the house. I saw Mr. Bucholz there when I gave these orders. I think no one touched the body up to this time but Dr. Pardee. The body was taken to the house by lantern light, and carried up stairs. The door was then locked, and the body was stripped. Dr. Pardee and the jury were present. A memorandum of all that was found was taken. From the right side of the waistcoat we took a foreign envelope containing about $20,000 in German money and $939 in greenbacks. The money was enclosed in a cloth dotted with red sealing wax. We also found some fiddle strings and pens. [The articles were identified by the witness.] The corpse was then washed, and two jurors were detailed to watch it."
The witness described the ambush in the cedar tree. He saw the footmarks of some one who had stood beneath it. The tree was cut down by some unknown person within two weeks. "On Saturday afternoon," continued the witness, "a shingle was found standing in the stone wall between the spot where the body lay and a hickory tree. It had been perforated with bullets. There were the marks of bullets on the stones, but only one bullet was found. On Sunday afternoon the bootblack at the depot told me that he had found something in the woods, and that they wanted me to go down and get it. I went down, and found a second revolver lying close to the north side of the fence running parallel to the path. It was about 2 o'clock, There were many persons there. The path at that point ran about three feet from the fence. A box of hobnails lay two feet from the pistol. A bundle of keys was found in the weeds seven paces north of it. I also picked up a small hair brush [about four inches long and an inch wide] near the revolver. There were light hairs on it. [Mr. Bucholz has light hair, and has acknowledged that the brush is his.] While Mr. Bucholz was detained as a witness, sometime afterward, he came into my drug store, and said that he wanted to buy a pocket hair brush about the size of a nail brush without a handle. I asked him whether he had one. He said that he had had one, but that he had lost it.
After identifying the articles found on Sunday, Mr. Stilson said that the jury broke open the dead man's trunk after the corpse was brought from the house. He identified a box of cartridges that was taken from the trunk. The ragged piece of shirt was shown him. He said that the blood stains were much more plain when he first saw it, soon after it was found. He saw no grease spot on the white overalls when they were first unrolled.
On cross-examination Mr. Stilson said Mr. Illing [now in Germany] brought the rags before the jury. [The prosecution claim that they were used in wiping the blood from the axe.] Mr. Bucholz asked for a pocket hair brush in from three to seven days after the murder. He did not say where he had lost it, and the witness did not let him know that he had found it. The articles found on Sunday were about 200 feet from the body. Probably three hundred persons had been searching the woods on Saturday and Sunday. A record of all that had been taken from the body was made by the Coroner's clerk, but since then the record had disappeared and he could not get trace of it. He remembered that a letter in German was taken from the body. It was dated "New York, Dec. 18." The $20,935 was placed in the savings bank, and afterward turned over to the administrators. A memorandum of the bills disappeared with the Coroner's record. The witness did not know whether any of the greenbacks had ink marks on them. [An unpaid board bill of Mr. Bucholz in the Sonne Hotel in this city was afterward paid with such bills.]
Mary Downey testified that while at Mrs. Waring's house between the 13th and 20th of October, 1878, she saw Mr. Bucholz pay Mrs. Waring $160. He had a large roll of bills left, and asked Mrs. Waring to keep it for him, as he was going to a German ball. [This is new testimony. Its object awaits development.]
Charles Bosch, a gunsmith, testified that the cartridges found Mr. Schulte's trunk fitted the revolvers found in the woods.
James M. Lane, one of the Coroner's jury, described the carrying of the corpse to the house. He said that Mr. Bucholz assisted after the body had crossed the fence. He was directly behind Mr. Bucholz, and knew that he had no opportunity to explore the dead man's pockets. The court then adjourned.
CALLING NAMES IN COURT.
----------
A VERY ANIMATED SCENE IN THE BUCHOLZ TRIAL AT BRIDGEPORT.
----------
The Prosecuting Attorney and Gen. Smith, for the Defence, Hotly Confronting Each Other – All about a Little Axe Unexpectedly Produced in Court – A Fainting Witness.
At the trial of William Bucholz in Bridgeport, yesterday, Dr. J. R. Treadwell of Boston, whose expert testimony in the Hayden trial let in a flood of light upon the community with regard to the scientific properties of blood corpuscles, was the first witness. The prisoner's eyes were very bright, feverishly so, and he showed a painful interest in every question asked by his counsel or by the State's Attorney. Dr. Treadwell stepped briskly upon the stand. On the floor beside the witness stand were two pairs of trousers, each of a dark pattern, a rusty axe, and two rags. All of these things the Doctor had examined.
He said that for six years he had made the microscopic examination of blood stains a specialty. During that period he had worked steadily for nine months in every year, and for four or five hours in each day, in analyzing clots of blood, old and freshly shed. He rarely had much difficulty in ascertaining the nature of the blood submitted to him for examination. He could tell human blood from that which came from the veins of brutes, and, for the most part, was able to distinguish between the blood of animals. He was able to do this by observing microscopically the shape and size of the corpuscles. He had studied various authorities, but in making examinations he preferred using his own tests. The difference between the blood of a man and that of a fowl was very marked. Under no circumstances would he be likely to confuse them. "Why," he said, smiling contemptuously when the State's Attorney labored to make this point emphatic, "I could no more mistake them than I could confuse the taste of the turnip with that of the cabbage." The jury were shown photographs of blood corpuscles from men and from chickens. Gen. Smith, for the defence, objected strenuously to their being put in evidence, but he was overruled, and took an exception. The Doctor explained to the jury the difference between the corpuscles, as represented in a magnified form in the pictures. The shapes, he showed, were very different.
This line of examination was preliminary to asking the Doctor to give the results of his tests as applied to the rusty axe that lay beside the witness stand. He took it up, and the defence at once objected on the ground that he had not examined the axe when the stains upon it were freshly made, but after they had been imbedded in rust. The objection was overruled and an exception taken. The Doctor pointed to certain spots, both on the handle and the blade, hardly distinguishable to the inexperienced eye, which he said were stains of human blood. In their turns he raised the two rags which had been found near the body of the murdered man, and the two pairs of trousers which had been taken from Bucholz's room, and on all of these he said he had found blood spots, the corpuscles of which he had found to be the same as those clinging to the axe.
"Are those the only articles that were sent to you for examination ?" asked Mr. Olmstead.
"I think they are all," replied the witness, wiping his lands with his handkerchief, as he dropped the larger of the two rags to its former place on the floor.
The State's Attorney took from the table a small paper parcel, which, since the opening of the court, had attracted the suspicious attention of the lawyers for the defence. He unfolded it, and exposed a small axe blade, rustier, and, apparently, older than the one already submitted to the jury. He handed it to the witness.
"Were you asked to examine that?" he inquired.
The witness recognized it at once.
"Yes," he said, "that was sent to me with the other things. I had forgotten it."
Gen. Smith objected to the production of the axe, and Mr. Olmstead said he did not at present propose to offer it in evidence, but he wished to identify it as the article that was sent to Dr. Treadwell for examination.
"After I have done that," he said, "I shall offer it to the defence for them to put in evidence if they see fit."
"Oh, we don't want it," said Gen. Smith. "We know nothing about it."
"Yes, you do," replied Mr. Olmstead. "You know a great deal about it."
Gen. Smith sprang so quickly to his feet that he nearly knocked his chair down. With the apparent desire of removing every incumbrance from his way, he seized it with his left hand and flung it some feet behind him. His face was flushed, his frame trembled with excitement, and his whole bearing was that of a very angry man.
“What is that you say, sir?" he asked, hotly, taking a step toward the State's Attorney.
"I say," replied Mr. Olmstead, as he abstractedly placed a chair between himself and Gen. Smith, "that you knew all about the existence of that axe blade. You might have produced it if you had seen fit. There is no use in your getting excited about it.”
Gen. Smith turned grimly to the Court. "I desire to say, your Honors," he said, "that the statement of the prosecuting attorney is an utter, entire, and complete falsehood;" and, with an action that was very suggestive of shaking his fist in Mr. Olmstead's face, he sat down.
The State's Attorney rose.
"Your Honor," he said, addressing the Court, "I have no reply to make to that. My duty to the State prevents me from noticing it, and if Gen. Smith can derive any satisfaction from making such a charge I leave him to do so."
The axe blade was not offered in evidence, but the passage of words between the lawyers did not end there. At recess. but before the Judges had left the bench. Mr. Olmstead lingered near Gen. Smith, as though he thought the latter might make an apology. Such a course of action, however, was evidently very far from the mind of the counsel for the defence, for turning suddenly and threateningly upon the State's Attorney, he said:
"I am here now Mr. Olmstead, if you want me.”
Mr. Olmstead smiled contemptuously, and, without a word of reply, sauntered out of the court room, while Gen. Smith approached the bench and complained bitterly to the two Judges of the treatment he had received while discharging his duty toward his client.
The efforts of the cross-examination were directed to show that Dr. Treadwell was not competent as an expert. He admitted that Dr. Woodruff had questioned his ability to discern any difference between the blood of a dog and that of a man. He had heard of mistakes being made in this particular by skillful microscopists, and had even understood that certain vegetable substances had been mistaken for human blood; but he was satisfied that with his tests no such errors were possible.
The prosecuting attorney several times objected to the witness being examined on intricate mathematical problems. Gen. Smith, he said, was justly proud of his proficiency as a mathematician, but he had chosen a very bad place to give an exhibition of his skill. But the counsel for the defence persevered. and finally ascertained that a cubic inch of blood contained 80,000,000 corpuscles, and a drop one-twenty-fifth of an inch in diameter was composed of between 5,000,000 and 6,000,000 corpuscles. It required great skill and care to take photographs of blood corpuscles, such as had been shown to the jury, and he (the witness) was not a professional photographer. He had practised medicine, both as a surgeon and a physician, for between seventeen and eighteen years. Any corpuscle would be affected for purposes of investigation by rust.
In his pre-direct examination the witness testified that the action of rust is to change the shape of corpuscles, and when any were found so changed, a scientist would pass them over, and confine his examination to such as were in good condition. The greatest difference between fowl's blood and human blood, and one much more trustworthy than even the difference of shape, is that the centre of a corpuscle of fowl's blood is convex, while the same part of a human corpuscle is concave.
Dr. Leonard J. Sanford of New Haven was next called. He said he had paid considerable attention to blood corpuscles for five or six years. Human blood and fowl blood, examined under favorable circumstances, showed a marked difference. The points of distinction were the same as those given by Dr. Treadwell. The State's Attorney asked what power a strong, healthy man would have to walk after a piece of his skull had been chipped out and the brain exposed. The witness thought he might walk for some distance. There would be no great flow of blood. It would spurt out at first, but probably it would soon begin to ooze slowly. The bleeding would be greater if the wound were made with a blunt instrument.
Blood to penetrate freely into a woollen material must be fresh. If he saw a woollen garment penetrated with blood he would say it was subjected to the fluid very soon after the latter had been shed. Blood would begin to become a little dense two minutes after it had left the veins. The witness did not think that, under favorable circumstances, there could be any difficulty in distinguishing between a fowl’s blood and that of a man. The age of the clots would make no difference, if they could be soaked and fully restored. The distinction was easily made and could be done by an experienced microscopist every time.
Paul Hirscher was the next witness. He had known Bucholz, who told him of two disputes he had with John H. Schulte. On the first occasion the quarrel was about the sale or ownership of some grain. In the course of the dispute Schulte drew a pistol, and Bucholz said he was obliged to take the weapon from him to avoid being shot. On another occasion Schulte complained that his coal was disappearing very fast, and accused the landlady, Mrs. Waring, with taking it. Bucholz took Mrs. Waring’s part, and Schulte discharged him. After his discharge Bucholz told the witness that Schulte was a rich man. He said: “He has lots of money in the bank.” On the Tuesday before Christmas Day of 1878, Bucholz said that he had given a friend of his some money to put in a bank for him. He now found that he could not draw his deposit for thirty days, and he wanted to go to New York to get some money from his friend, whose name he did not mention. He borrowed from the witness sufficient to pay his fare to the city.
While Mr. Hirscher was giving this testimony his face was growing very pale, and he frequently sipped the water from the glass before him. He was standing up, and his body swayed slowly backward and forward. When the State’s Attorney put the question, “Did you see Bucholz the day before the murder?” there was no answer, and in another minute the fainting witness had fallen, face down, against the rail of the stand, and thence rolled to the floor. He was carried into the Judge’s room, and, while a recess was taken, the windows were thrown open and the court room ventilated.
After the recess the witness was unable to resume his place on the stand.
WILLIAM BUCHOLZ'S FRIEND.
----------
THE RELUCTANT TESTIMONY OF THE WITNESS WHO FAINTED.
----------
Conversations in Jail – Bucholz Talking about Escaping from Custody – The $20,000 that was Found on the Murdered Man's Body.
The black marks that have been deepening around William Bucholz's eyes were very apparent yesterday, as he took his seat in the Bridgeport court room. He was, as usual, neatly dressed, and he paid the closest attention to the evidence. Yet, haggard as his appearance was, he looked more at ease than Paul Hirscher as he went upon the witness stand. Mr. Hirscher is the witness who on Thursday fainted, and he did not seem yesterday to have entirely recovered. He was once a warm friend of Bucholz, and he was very nervous when he first went upon the stand to testify against him. He was able yesterday to tell all he knew, but he did so with apparent reluctance. He is the proprietor of a barroom in South Norwalk, and Bucholz was one of his customers.
Paul Hirscher testified that on the morning after the murder of Schulte Bucholz went to his saloon and showed him $200 in $20 notes. Before doing so he said, "Isn't it a terrible thing?" alluding to the murder of Schulte, whose body had been found. The witness replied that it was, and, in allusion to some story that had obtained currency with regard to Bucholz and Schulte having been attacked by tramps as they walked home on the preceding night, asked him whether he got hurt. "Oh, I got off with this," replied Bucholz, pointing to a slight scratch on his face. He then drew the witness behind a partition and showed him the money. The witness was surprised to see him in possession of so much, and said: "The old man must have given you this last night.” "Oh, no," replied Bucholz, hastily, "It is my own money." He did not say where he got it, but he asked the witness to keep it for him while he went to the Coroner's inquest. Bucholz owed Hirscher a bill for cigars, and he told him to take the amount due out of the $200. The witness did so, and changed one of the notes to pay his rent. He did not notice whether that note had any private mark on it, but the others were marked thus: 380 | 159. In the evening Bucholz again entered the barroom, bought some cigars, and gave the witness another $20 note similarly marked. He told the witness to keep all the money for him until he asked for it. Subsequently he sent two of the notes to New York, thus leaving seven in Mr. Hirscher's possession. When search was being made for Schulte's lost watch and money, Bucholz again went to the witness, and asked him to swear that he received the notes some three or four months before the murder. Hirscher refused to do so. Bucholz told the witness that he might keep the seven $20 notes. Mr. Hirscher kept them for some time, and then handed them over to the State's Attorney.
The notes were offered in evidence. They have been identified as the property of Schulte, and the State claims that they were taken from his person by the murderer. The mark 380 | 159 was a private mark used by Schulte.
After the arrest of Bucholz the witness went to the jail and told him that Schulte's watch had been found, and it was said that he, the prisoner, had been seen standing near the spot where it was discovered on the night of the murder. The prisoner said. "My watch is just like Schulte's," and he pulled out of his pocket a little open-faced gold watch, and showed it to the witness.
Charles La Croix, the keeper of an oyster saloon, identified a $50 note, marked like the $20 notes already shown, as one that he had received from Bucholz. Several other witnesses were examined to identify bills of various denominations, once belonging to Schulte, and having passed through the hands of Bucholz.
Edward Burgher testified that he had received two $20 notes from William Bucholz, with instructions to pay them to his former boardinghouse keeper in New York, and to bring away all letters that arrived for the prisoner, and especially one from his sister in Germany, which, he believed, contained money.
George H. Graff, a German lad, born in South America, said he was a prisoner in the Bridgeport jail with Bucholz. They were often together, and spoke in German so that nobody within hearing could understand what they said. The witness once asked Bucholz if he would like to get out of jail, and the prisoner replied that Graff was a fool to make such an inquiry. Graff then asked him some questions about his own affairs, but Bucholz said his counsel had instructed him not to say anything about himself to his fellow prisoners. The witness said: "If you will help me to get out of jail, I will help you. If I had any money I could get out." Bucholz replied that if Graff had spoken sooner he could have helped him, but he had given all his money to his lawyer. He offered his watch to Graff, and desired him to dispose of it and buy some saws, but the witness refused to take it, saying that he had one of his own. "Well," said Bucholz. "it doesn't matter. They couldn't keep me here long if I wanted to get out; but I shall wait for my trial. I shall get off, and then I shall come back and get you out." The witness thanked him, and the prisoner went on to say that when he was out of jail it would be necessary for him to disguise himself by dyeing his hair and getting a set of false teeth. Soon after the Hayden trial the witness, Bucholz, and two or three other prisoners were sitting together talking, generally, about murder cases. They had been speaking in English, but Graff turned to Bucholz and said, in German: "Bucholz, couldn't you have got the money without killing the old man?" "Oh, they can't convict me of that," replied Bucholz. "They would never have suspected me if I had not paid so much of the money to my creditors." Bucholz, the witness said, did not warn him of the probable results of repeating what he had said to him. "But," said Graff, "his looks spoke more than words." Once the witness asked Bucholz why he did not quit the country when he had money, and the prisoner replied: "Why didn't you mention that before? Good advice always comes too late." He afterward told the witness that had he not been arrested he would have gone to Australia.
David Dayton was again called to the stand, and he testified that when the body of Schulte was found it had on two coats, both open, and with one pocket turned out. A paper parcel was found in another pocket, and, on being opened, it was found to contain money, German and American, to the amount of nearly $20,000. It was given to the foreman of the Coroner's jury. The witness identified two coats shown to him as the garments that he saw on Schulte's body. The inner coat, an old black frock, was stained with blood. The witness said it had been taken off, rolled up, and placed under the dead man's head. The wounds were bleeding slightly, and the blood rolled upon the coat. The witness described the bringing home of the body.
The trial was adjourned till Monday.
A MURDERED MAN'S WATCH
----------
FURTHER TESTIMONY IN THE TRIAL OF WILLIAM BUCHOLZ
----------
Using the Counsel's Cranium for Purposes of Illustration – Ascertaining Beyond Question that One Witness Climbed a Big Tree.
The rest of Saturday and Sunday did not seem to have improved William Buchold's appearance as he took his place, yesterday, in the Bridgeport court room. Before the court was opened he called one of his counsel to him, and spoke to him long and earnestly. What the lawyer said in reply evidently encouraged him, for his bearing grew more animated.
"Dr. Pardee, will you take the stand?" said the State's Attorney. "Mr. Clark, will you be good enough to bring those bones here?"
The bones, several small ones which Dr. Pardee had taken from Schulte's skull, were placed upon the bench, and the witness proceeded to explain the particulars of their removal, illustrating his remarks with half a skull which the State's Attorney placed in his hand. One bone that he had taken from behind the left ear, the witness said, would have been fractured by an instrument penetrating half an inch. The Doctor had examined the marks on Bucholz's face after the murder of Schulte, and found them superficial. There were two scratches, each about a quarter of an inch long and skin deep.
In the cross-examination a difference of opinion arose between Gen. Smith and Dr. Pardee as to whether the latter, in explaining the nature of Schulte's wounds, should illustrate with the lawyer's head or with his own. Gen. Smith objected at first to allowing his head to be used, but on the doctor's representation that he could not explain satisfactorily with his own head the lawyer submitted, and the witness, putting a finger behind Gen. Smith's left ear, showed where some blunt instrument had entered Schulte's skull. The witness denied that a judgment for a large amount of money, obtained against him sometime ago by one of the lawyers for the defence, in any way affected his testimony in the case on trial.
Adolph Orlich, a South Norwalk jeweller of thirty-seven years' experience, said he had examined the small open-faced gold watch that had belonged to Schulte. It was 18 karats fine – the best gold used in the manufacture of watches. The case was very tight, and if it had lain under the snow for three months, or until the snow melted from over and around it, the water would not have penetrated the case, and the gold would not have been tarnished.
The defence strenuously objected to this testimony, claiming that, however experienced the witness might be as a jeweller, he could not be an expert on questions concerning watches that had lain for a quarter of a year under the snow. The testimony was, however, admitted.
Under cross-examination the witness said that if the watch was boiled the water might penetrate the case, and if it was warm when submerged, the chances of cold water soaking in would have been increased. When the witness had retired, it was discovered that the oath had not been administered to him. He was recalled, and, having been sworn, testified that all the evidence he had previously given was true.
Gen. Smith objected. As counsel for the defendant in a capital case, he said, he would not allow any evidence to go before the jury that had not been sworn to in the regular way. Judges Loomis and Park consulted for some minutes, and the result of their deliberations was that the witness had to repeat his entire testimony. He said, in addition, that he had once fallen into the water with his own watch in his pocket, and the instrument was submerged for about three minutes. As soon as possible he had dried it carefully, and he found that no water had penetrated the case, and the works were not in the slightest degree injured.
John Reid, a Bridgeport jeweller, corroborated the preceding witness's testimony. He had examined Schulte's watch and found a little rust just under the keyhole. He believed that the mark was caused by a vapor, and no water had penetrated. He thought the watch was watertight. It was 18-karat gold, and if it lay under the snow for three months he would not expect to find it at all tarnished.
Being cross-examined he said that if the watch were subjected to a temperature below freezing the cold would probably contract those parts of the case coming directly together, cause them to separate a little, and allow sufficient moisture to enter to rust the steel works. With the help of a powerful magnifying glass the witness showed the jury two little spots of rust, which he said had not been introduced when the watch was being wound, but were the results of moisture that had oozed in through the hole.
J. P. Warner, a Bridgeport jeweller, corroborated the testimony of the two preceding witnesses as to the fine quality of the gold in the case of Schulte's watch, and its ability to resist moisture. He thought, however, that if the snow became slush, and the watch lay in it, the case would be penetrated almost as quickly as though it lay in water. If a watch was immersed in water for from fifteen minutes to an hour the fluid would get to the works.
Dr. Byron W. Munson went on the witness stand, holding in his hand an entire human skull, divided into segments held together by springs and wires. With this he explained to the jury the precise location of the wound behind the left ear, which had caused Schulte's death : and his twelve hearers attempted more accurately to follow his description by tracing imaginary lines upon their own skulls with their forefingers.
Benjamin M. Ayres testified as to a trip he had made with the State's Attorney and some other companions from the South Norwalk railway station to Mrs. Waring's house, where Schulte and Bucholz formerly lodged, stopping at certain places and doing certain things that, the prosecution claims, the murderer of Schulte stopped at and did, and timing himself at the various points.
The rest of the day was taken up by Gen. Smith in a rigorous cross-examination, intended to ascertain the witness's object in climbing a tree on the trip he made with the State's Attorney. No progress was made, and when the court adjourned the simple fact that the witness had, indeed, climbed a tree was alone established.
FOLLOWING IN HIS TRACKS.
----------
AN EXPEDIENT OF THE PROSECUTION IN THE BUCHOLZ CASE.
----------
Counsel for the Defence Taking the State's Attorney to Task – Attaches of the German Consulate Testifying as to the Money.
Gen. Smith, counsel for William Bucholz in his trial at Bridgeport on the charge of murdering John H. Schulte, created a sensation in the court room yesterday by accusing Benjamin M. Ayres, one of the State's witnesses, of manufacturing evidence against the prisoner, and implying that the State's Attorney was cognizant of the fact.
The witness testified that, acting under instructions received either from the State's Attorney or from somebody else connected with the prosecution, he walked from the South Norwalk railway station to Mrs. Waring's house, the road taken, the State claims, by the murderer of Schulte. The object was to ascertain how much time such a walk would occupy. The witness, still acting under instructions, made several short delays, and climbed a tree, from which, the prosecution avers, an axe stained with blood, and with gray hairs attached, had fallen some time previously. The prisoner, the State alleges, climbed the same tree and there concealed the axe with which he murdered Schulte. A boy who climbed the tree shook the axe from it, and it finally came into Ayres's possession.
The axe, which was produced by the State's Attorney, was some days ago shown to the jury. It was the cause at that time of a brisk wordy war between the counsel on both sides. The State's Attorney said that Gen. Smith knew all about it, and might have had it if he had desired, and that it had been in his power to hand it over to the prosecution. This statement Gen. Smith branded as false, and the dispute waxed decidedly personal. Yesterday, under the State's Attorney's examination, the witness testified that he had shown the axe to Gen. Smith four weeks before he brought it to the State's Attorney. The counsel for the defence had not advised him to give it to the State's Attorney, and he, the witness, had kept it in his own possession until told to hand it over to the prosecuting counsel. The witness, on the journey from South Norwalk to Mrs. Waring's house, stopped once to throw some small articles over a hedge, and on getting into the barn there was a short delay while he put his hand under the straw in two places, as though hiding something. Then the party had gone into Mrs. Waring's house.
F. G. Fowler, official stenographer of the court, said that he was one of the party that walked from South Norwalk station to Mrs. Waring's house. He took 24 steps per minute, and considered that he was travelling at a brisk pace. Every part of the journey was carefully timed, including a rapid run made by Ayres from the ant hill, where the murder was committed, to the barn attached to Mrs. Waring's house. Then one of the young women went up stairs and brought down a gun, after which she went to a closet and occupied as much time as it would have taken her to get a revolver, which was there on the night of the murder. These actions, the prosecution claims, were done by William Bucholz and Samuel Waring. Then the party waited while Bucholz was supposed to be lying fainting upon the floor. The time occupied in this experiment was based upon Mrs. Waring's recollection of the fact, and in the interim she said, "Why, William, what is the matter with you?" and made other remarks which she had uttered at the time Bucholz had entered the house, immediately after the murder of Schulte.
Charles T. Craw, clerk of the Coroner's jury, testified as to the story told by the prisoner at the inquest.
Some of this story was told by Bucholz while he was under arrest, and Gen. Smith objected to its being received in evidence, because the prisoner had not been cautioned of the danger of committing himself. He said there was some mercy in the law if not in the State's Attorney, and he did not wish to see the escutcheon of the State of Connecticut stained by the foul procedure proposed by the counsel for the prosecution.
The State's Attorney claimed that the prisoner had been warned after the arrest had actually been made, and that the mere fact of an officer having been instructed to watch Bucholz and see that he did not run away could not be considered an arrest.
After recess, Robert A. Pinkerton, Detective Stark, Paul Schmaeck, and Bernhardt Baedejer, clerks in the office of the German Consul-General, were in the court room. Mr. Schmaeck was called to the witness stand. They testified as to the money that was found buried under a woodpile near the Waring house. They had worked for an hour, when they unearthed seven gold pieces, and an old pocketbook containing 204 one-thousand mark notes and a passport made out in Schulte's name. These were taken to New York and given to the German Consul-General, who locked them up in the safe. One of the gold pieces had a hole drilled through it, and the State's Attorney drew the attention of the jury to the fact that they were all bright. In addition to the gold pieces and the German money, the State's Attorney put in evidence $4,737 in greenbacks of various denominations, which Detective Stark had found in the barn previous to the arrival of Mr. Pinkerton and the attachés of the office of the German Consul-General.
Henry Bischoff, a New York banker, testified as to money that he delivered to Schulte. The witness, however, was not at all confident in his identifications, and when an old-fashioned pocketbook was shown him, and he was asked if Schulte had put away the money received in such a wallet, he replied that the old man's book was very like the one placed before him, but he thought it was a little older, and contained more pockets.
Robert A. Pinkerton identified parcels of German marks and of greenbacks as those he had found under the wood pile.
The money – amounting in all to $53,017 – was packed up in Mr. Schmaeck's valise, and immediately taken out again to allow Detective Stark to identify it. This having been done, the defence expressed a wish to examine it, and the court adjourned to give them an opportunity to do so.
DETECTIVE STARK'S STORY.
----------
WILLIAM BUCHOLZ'S CONFIDENCES REPEATED TO THE JURY.
----------
A Tilt Between the Lawyers – How Schulte's Money was Found In Mrs. Waring's Barn – Threats the Prisoner did not Execute.
The old pocketbook which the State Attorney for Connecticut claims belonged to J. H. Schulte, who was murdered near South Norwalk, lay upon the bench close to the witness stand in the Bridgeport court room yesterday morning. Beside it were some papers, in which the money dug up in the barn attached to Mrs. Waring's house had afterward been wrapped. The prisoner yesterday watched the proceedings very closely and anxiously. His face was pale at first, but it reddened when Detective Ernest Stark was called to the stand: for the detective was sent to Bridgeport jail in the character of a prisoner, and alleges that he heard from Bucholz important statements concerning the murder of Schulte. Detective Stark's testimony was listened to with intense interest. The prisoner leaned forward in his chair, bit his thumb, and watched the witness narrowly with half-closed eyes. The latter said that, acting under instructions, he went to Bridgeport on Saturday, March 8, 1879, and, going to the Adams express office, he presented an order for a package of money. He was immediately arrested on a charge of forgery and attempting to obtain money under false pretences. He was in jail for about three weeks before he had any conversation with Bucholz. Then the latter showed him an article in a New York German newspaper about his case, and said he did not like it. The acquaintance was thus formed.
At this point the examination of the detective was suspended to enable several witnesses to testify as to whether or not Bucholz had been allowed to make his statement at the Coroner's inquest, while he was under arrest, and without being cautioned. The defence tried to show that he was actually under arrest when he first testified, and before he was cautioned, while the State's Attorney examined witness after witness to show that he was not arrested, though an officer had received instructions to watch him and not allow him to leave the State.
Finally the State's Attorney said that he knew of a circumstance beneficial to the prisoner which had not been brought out by the defence, and his sense of duty as a public officer induced him to state it. At the time Bucholz was telling his story before the Coroner's jury, he, the State's Attorney, supposed that the officer who was watching him had a warrant for his arrest in his pocket, to be used in case the suspected man attempted to escape. But, while he felt that he ought to make this statement, he still contended that all the testimony given by Bucholz at the Coroner's inquest was now admissible as evidence.
As the State's Attorney sat down. Gen. Smith, the prisoner's counsel, rose with fire in his eye. The statement made by the prosecuting counsel, he said, spoke more for that officer's candor at the present time than for his knowledge of legal principles when the inquest was held, or for his humanity and fair dealing. Knowing that Bucholz, a poor and friendless man, was actually under arrest, he put him on the witness stand before the Coroner's jury, and, without giving him the customary warning, allowed him to testify. For the evidence so obtained he cared nothing, but he hoped that two Judges of the State of Connecticut, one of them the Chief Justice, would not countenance any such procedure as the prosecuting counsel had indulged in: and he further hoped that, for the future, trials such as the one before the court would be conducted for the State by a very different class of State's Attorneys than the one now holding office.
Judge Loomis said that it was not the time or place for the Court to lecture or instruct the State's Attorney. He hoped that no more such recriminations would be indulged in. Gen. Smith apologized to the Court, and the State's Attorney spoke in his own defence. He said that he had done only what he conceived to be his duty. An abominable murder had been committed, and, as prosecuting attorney, he had conscientiously taken every legal means in his power to bring the perpetrator to justice. As regarded his action in the case, he was perfectly willing that any disgrace that attended it should be inherited by his children: but he had no sense of any injustice, inhumanity or wrongdoing having been committed by him.
With reference to his remarks on Tuesday, Gen. Smith says that in charging the witness Ayres with manufacturing testimony he did not intend to imply that the State's Attorney had been cognizant of the facts. Neither, he says, did he see the axe that the prosecution alleges was found in a tree near the place where the murder was committed until it was produced in court. All he knew about it was what Ayres told him when he offered the axe to the prisoner's counsel for a reward, which was refused.
After recess Detective Stark again took the stand. He said that Bucholz told him that he had agreed to pay his lawyers $1,500, and when the witness said he could have obtained counsel for a smaller sum, Bucholz replied that the money would make no difference if he could get clear. He offered to get bail for the witness and give him his liberty if he would give good security. Bucholz asked the witness to employ his counsel, and, after a formal interview. Mr. Baldwin agreed to defend the detective. Once, when Bucholz was complaining of being in jail, the witness said:
"I wish I was out for an hour. I would go and lift Schulte's treasure."
The witness did not reply, and before long Bucholz put his arm around the detective's neck and said, "Oh, how I wish I was out for an hour."
"Why, what would you do?" asked the detective. “Would you go and lift Schulte's treasure?”
“Yes," said the prisoner. "I would go to his gold mine. It is in my mattress. If I could get out I would let you have not $500, but $5,000.”
He described Schulte's wounds, which, he said, were made with an axe. He said there was a secret trap in Schulte's room between the windows. It opened when a spring was touched, and in it was a tin box containing $60,000. The witness looked doubtful, but finally said that if what Bucholz said was true he, the witness, would at once try to get out on bail. The prisoner said it was all true, that the money was there in cash, but that all the greenbacks were marked. The detective replied that he could erase all the marks with acids.
About that time the witness was taken sick, and on May 15 he was released on bail. Afterward he visited Bucholz in jail. He told Bucholz that he would be obliged to leave Bridgeport before the trial. The prisoner became uneasy and offered the witness $500 if he would attend to some matters for him. The prisoner then asked the witness to get for him $700 that he had put away. One pocketbook was in the barn. He described the place, and drew a diagram of it, saying that it would not take the witness more than a minute to get it. The witness went to Mrs. Waring's barn. He put his hand through a hole in the floor and pulled out a pocketbook. He took it to New York, and the German Consul-General opened it at Pinkerton's Detective Agency. It contained $4,737 in American money.
The next day the witness returned to Bridgeport and told Bucholz that he had found the money, but had not been able to remove the marks which Schulte had put upon it, but that he had borrowed $350 from a friend, and this sum he was willing to lend him on his note.
When the witness told him that Schulte's place was going to be sold, Bucholz became very nervous, and said:
“But they won't turn the Warings out, will they?"
The witness said that whoever bought the place would certainly turn the whole establishment "upside down, " and Bucholz replied:
"Then the other pocketbook must be found."
He said this other pocketbook was thick, and there were "thousands" in it, and he told the detective where to find it in the barn.
He frequently accused the witness of being a spy, and called him "Vidocq." He said: “If you are a detective you have me now: but it will do you no good, for I have the means of destroying myself in jail."
The witness laughed at him, and told him he need not commit suicide, for he would not be betrayed. The witness went with Mr. Pinkerton and an attache of the German consulate to the barn, and found the money. On one occasion, expressing his fear that the witness was a detective, Bucholz said that if he saw his companion appear on the witness stand to testify against him he would hurl a chair at him. At another time he declared that, under such circumstances, he would rise, make a statement, and then stab himself with a knife.
At this point the prisoner sat quite still in his chair. He stared at the witness, but made no sign of carrying out either of his alleged threats. The court adjourned before the detective's testimony was finished.
DETECTIVE STARK'S METHOD.
----------
HIS PURPOSE IN WINNING WILLIAM BUCHOLZ'S CONFIDENCE.
----------
The Evidence for the State all in and a Beginning Made by the Defence – Some Testimony about an Axe that the State Discredits
A very gloomy look was in the face of William Bucholz yesterday, as he sat behind the prisoner's rail in the Bridgeport court room while Detective Stark completed his testimony as to the finding of Schulte's money in Mrs. Waring's barn and the statements made to him in the Bridgeport jail by the prisoner.
Under cross-examination the witness said that Mr. Pinkerton instructed him to call at the express office in Bridgeport and ask for a package of money, for which he gave him an order. He was told that when he asked for the money he would be arrested. He had no doubt that the officer who arrested him and the Judge who committed him supposed that he was an actual criminal. He was not especially anxious to obtain such evidence as would criminate Bucholz, but wanted only to learn the truth. When the intimacy between the detective and Bucholz had increased, the latter said he was half inclined to return Schulte's money to his heirs, or hand it over to the authorities. Most of the plans for manufacturing evidence to clear Bucholz originated with the witness, the prisoner consenting. The detective proposed "fixing" the jury who tried him, and Bucholz told him to do so. Bucholz more than once said that if he found that the witness had deceived him he would commit suicide. He once told the witness that he feared he had spoken too freely to him, and added that he had been half disposed to tell his counsel what he had done. The detective advised him not to do so, saying that if his lawyers heard that he had been making confidential statements to a fellow prisoner about the large amount of money at his disposal, they would take it all for themselves.
Dr. Sanford was again called to the stand, and a small bone taken from behind Schulte's left ear placed in his hand. He had not seen it before, and he said it was the most brittle bone in the human body, and any blow hard enough to break the skull would be sufficient to displace it, drive it into the brain, or fracture it. Mr. Robert A. Pinkerton testified that Detective Stark worked in the Schulte murder case under his direction. Mr. Pinkerton held the lantern in Mrs. Waring's barn when the gold and paper money was dug up. It took about three-quarters of an hour to get down to the money. They unearthed the seven gold pieces first, and soon afterward came to a pocketbook containing 204 one-thousand mark notes, and a passport sealed up in linen. The witness was employed by the German Consul-General In New York, who was acting as attorney for Schulte's brother in Germany. He made arrangements with the agent for Adams Express Company in New York to telegraph to the Bridgeport office, giving instructions to those in charge to have the man who called for the package of money arrested. He told Stark not to talk too much, and to make some mystery about himself and his business. When he was taken to court he was to decline to answer any questions. He desired Stark to report everything he learned, whether it was favorable or unfavorable to Bucholz.
”The State rests," said the State's Attorney after recess. It was not expected that the case for the prosecution would close so soon, and the defence was hardly prepared to go on. Gen. Smith, however, called Samuel Waring, one of the State's witnesses, who testified that the axe was taken away from his mother's house the day after the murder of Schulte, and was kept away for three weeks. Then it was returned, and for a long time it was used for chopping wood. The witness sawed off the old handle. he said, and put it into a coal fire, where he kept it long enough to burn out the wooden stump, after which he inserted a new handle. He then gave it a thorough grinding.
The State's Attorney, contending that the axe was not put into the fire, and that the handle was never sawed off, cross-examined the witness very closely. The old axe handle was produced. It showed no indications of having been sawed off close to the blade, though a piece had been split off lengthwise. The witness looked at the handle, and said it was the one he had sawed, but he could not account for its present appearance. He thought it must have been broken and afterward split, but whether that was so or not he was positive that he sawed it. The State's Attorney passed the axe with its new handle to the jury, and asked them to judge by its appearance what amount of grinding it had received. He said the witness had told a story that was not true; that it was entirely different from his former statement.
Officer Frank Tole saw William Bucholz on the night of the murder sitting in the Justice's office. His hand was pressed to his face, which was wounded and bleeding. The witness attempted to talk to him, but found that he knew very little English. Bucholz went with the party who started to search for the body, and when it was found he helped to carry it home. The witness and Mr. Burgher remained in the room with the body all night. They folded up Schulte's coat, and put it under the dead man's head. In the morning the coat was stained with blood.
After the murder the prisoner was in the witness's custody for fifteen days. He was obedient, childlike, simple, and seemed to have no intention of trying to escape.
When the court adjourned yesterday the defence had examined no witnesses who had not previously been called by the State.
TRYING TO SAVE BUCHOLZ
----------
Testimony Regarding an Axe that May Greatly Benefit the Accused.
There was a more hopeful look in William Bucholz's face yesterday as he took his seat behind the prisoners' rail in the Bridgeport court room. His knowledge of the English language is not great, but he understood that the testimony of Samuel Waring, the first witness called for the defence, was favorable to his case. His counsel claims that if, as the witness alleges, he put the blade of the axe into the fire, and allowed it to remain there until the stump of the handle was burned out, it would be impossible for the experts to discover any corpuscles of human blood upon it afterward. The State's Attorney brands the whole statement as a falsehood.
Julius V. Ellendorf, who at the time of the murder was giving Bucholz lessons in the English language, testified that on the day of the murder he taught him as usual, and did not notice that there was anything indicative of excitement or disturbance in his appearance. He was attentive and studious, as he always was. Others who saw Bucholz on the night of the murder testified similarly.
The State recalled Samuel Waring, and cross-examined him very closely as to his treatment of the axe. In the main he adhered to the story he told on Thursday. The axe was taken away from his mother's house soon after the murder, and was returned, so far as the witness could remember, late in January, though it might have been early in February, or even in March. The handle was split when it was taken away, and on its being returned he broke off the handle as near the blade as possible, and sawed it off close down. He then put it in the fire, and allowed it to remain there a long time. When he took it out the charred stump fell from the hole. Then he went, with his sister Sadie, to a neighbor's house, where he ground the axe thoroughly, his sister turning the grindstone.
Guztav Pitzer, a South Norwalk barber, testified that his shop adjoined Paul Hirscher's saloon, and opened into it by two passages. On the afternoon of the day of the murder Bucholz went to his shop, saying he was waiting for Mr. Schulte, whom he expected by the train. When the old man did not come Pitzer invited Bucholz up stairs, and for half an hour the prisoner played with the barber's little girl, taking the child on his knee and amusing her. Then Bucholz went away, and soon afterward Schulte entered the liquor saloon, and called for some beer. While he was drinking it Bucholz came back, and was invited by Schulte to take some beer. The barber could see that they had two bottles between them. Schulte had two packages with him. One of them looked like a carpet bag, and the other was a package somewhat smaller. After a short time Schulte and Bucholz went out, and the witness did not see either of them again until he was told that Schulte was lying dead in the woods. The witness on the same night saw Bucholz sitting in the kitchen at the Waring House, resting his head upon his hand, and apparently crying. The witness asked him how the catastrophe occurred, and Bucholz said that as they were walking home, he some yards in advance, he heard Schulte cry out “Bucholz, Bucholz." He turned around and saw two men between himself and his employer. He ran back to render assistance, but one of the men advanced and struck him on the face. He then ran away, and the man chased him for a short distance. He was unable to catch Bucholz, however, and stopping he called out: "Never mind. I'll catch you yet, greenhorn."
The defence, so far, had examined witnesses to show that Schulte and Bucholz occupied so much time in Hirscher's saloon that it would have been impossible for Bucholz to have traversed the distance between the saloon and Mrs. Waring's house, committing the murder, and hiding the money in the barn on the way, in the time ascribed. They now called George B. Talmadge of South Norwalk, who was in Hircher's saloon when Bucholz and Schulte entered. He said they remained in the saloon about ten minutes.
I. Mortimer Hoyt testified as to the finding of the axe in Mrs. Waring's barn. It looked as though it had been used to cut off chickens' heads, being stained with blood, and having fowl feathers attached. The witness understood that Schulte always carried a large amount of money about his person, and this fact was very generally known. When he paid for the house in which Mrs. Waring lived, he took $5,000 from a bundle of bills in his belt and handed it over to the person from whom he made the purchase. Common rumor said that he was in the habit of carrying all the money he possessed in his pockets or secreted in his belt. Lewis J. Blake corroborated the testimony of the preceding witness as to the finding the axe, and its condition. He added that it was very dull. Dr. William C. Burke of South Norwalk also examined the blade of the axe immediately after the murder. He used a powerful magnifying glass, and looked for hairs. He found none, and he was assured that there were none there. There were dried blood and feathers, but nothing more.
Mrs. Waring was recalled by the defence, at her own request, to make certain corrections in her former testimony. She had originally been a witness for the prosecution, and, in view of that circumstance, the State's Attorney said it was a little remarkable that she should go to the prisoner's counsel with her explanation. He objected to her giving any testimony on the subject of the axe, and Gen. Smith, the prisoner's counsel, said the State's Attorney should not attempt, in a capital case, to impeach his own witness. The State's Attorney was about to reply, but Chief Justice Park said the Court did not care to hear any more recriminations between counsel. After some further very warm words between the lawyers, Mrs. Waring went on to corroborate her son's testimony with regard to burning the stump out of the blade of the axe. She saw him put it into the fire, leave it there some time, and take it out. When she next saw it there was a new handle in it, and her son and daughter were going out to sharpen it. Miss Sadie Waring also testified that her brother had put the axe in the fire, after sawing the handle off, to burn out the stump. The witness then went with her brother to a neighbor's house, and she turned the grindstone while “Sammy” ground the axe. He ground it for twenty minutes, and until two or three deep dents in it had been almost ground out.
Henry Frederick Shibley, a young man who had been absent from his native city for a period of eight months, and had just come from the Bridgeport jail, where he had been a prisoner, was the next witness. His testimony was a direct denial of the statement made in court by the prisoner Hineman, that there had been no conversation between him and the witness about Bucholz's case. Hineman, the witness said, had told him that he would testify against Bucholz, as it would help his case, and it would not hurt Bucholz, for "he would have to swing anyway."
Hineman, being put on the stand, said that he had played a good joke upon Shibley, and that was the cause of the latter's animosity against him.
The testimony of Shibley and Hineman caused some laughter, and the State's Attorney said:
"Persons who would laugh when a man is on trial for murder would laugh over their mother's grave."
The trial was adjourned until Monday.
WILLLAM BUCHOLZ'S DEFENCE.
----------
Three Men Near the Scene of the Murder Putting on Old Clothes Over Good Ones.
The trial of William Bucholz, accused of the murder of John H. Schulte, was resumed in Bridgeport, Conn. yesterday. Henry Shibley, the young Englishman whose direct examination was finished on Friday, was cross-examined by the State's Attorney, and he had a narrow escape of being sent to jail for refusing to answer questions. He could not remember whether he had ever told anybody that he had been arrested in England for stabbing his father, but he was not shaken in his testimony that Hineman, whose evidence was greatly adverse to Bucholz, had told him in jail that he intended to make such a statement with the view of bettering his own case.
Nathaniel Bouton testified that about a month before the murder of Schulte he saw a rag on the ground thirty feet from where the body was found. He was shown part of a shirt that had been picked up, stained with blood, near the same place, immediately after the murder, and he thought it was like the rag he had formerly seen.
Josiah Tristram testified that he was, soon after the murder, close to the place where, according to the prosecution, Schulte's watch was found, but he did not see the watch.
When Miss Annie Waring was asked by Gen. Smith what her brother Samuel did with the axe upon which several experts said they discovered corpuscles of human blood, she replied very promptly. "He put it into the fire." It was a coal fire, and the witness was sitting by the stove when her brother put the axe in to burn out the stump of the handle.
David Dayton testified as to a common rumor he had heard that Schulte always carried a large amount of money on his person. He was known to be wealthy, and it was generally supposed that he carried all, or nearly all, his money about him.
Daniel L. Mallard, principal of a Brooklyn public school, was in South Norwalk on the day of the murder. While walking on the track in the evening he saw three tramps near a great rock, and one of them was trying to kindle a fire. They were all desperate looking characters. One of them, he thought, had dark whiskers, and another lighter ones. The witness felt a little unsafe when he saw them, and he went back. One of them wore a pair of dirty overalls. The witness did not notice the clothing of the others, but he was emphatic in his assertion that they looked like dangerous men. It was about half past 3 o'clock in the afternoon when he saw them. He thought one of the men beside the rock averted his head when he saw the witness. They were about a hundred feet from the railroad track. The witness was cross-examined as to what in the faces of the men led him to suppose that they were desperate characters: but he could only say that they impressed him as being men capable of committing a desperate crime. Their countenances were very bad.
Stephen Oestrander of South Norwalk testified that he was in the woods on the afternoon of the murder. He saw near some rocks three men who looked like tramps. While the witness was looking at them they put on torn and dirty clothes over better ones. They spoke in a foreign language and In broken English, and one of them said he might as well be in South Norwalk as where he was, and he started in the direction of South Norwalk. This was between 2 and 3 o'clock in the afternoon. The men saw him, but they continued changing their clothes, paying no attention to him.
Gen. Smith received the following letter from New York, without signature, some days ago:
To Mr. Smith:
Deliver the enclosed letter immediately to State's Attorney Olmstead. Waring and another party in Jersey City were the murderers of Schulte. Bucholz stole the money. I have conscientious scruples against seeing Bucholz condemned. He is innocent with regard to the murder. He was stupid enough about Stark. Stark's life in this world will cease soon. He is stupid and more rascally than Bucholz and Waring. He stole $7,600. Tell the jury that Bucholz is not the murderer.
The letter to the State's Attorney was almost the same as the above. Both were written in German.
THE BUCHOLZ CASE CLOSING.
----------
State Attorney Olmstead Quoting Webster – Gen. Smith Yet to be Heard.
When the defence in the Bucholz trial, in Bridgeport, rested on Thursday, Bucholz did not at first seem to understand that, with the exception of the summing up, his case was closed. When he did comprehend the situation, however, the dark rims around his eyes grew darker. He compressed his lips tightly, and, resting his chin on his hand, he narrowly scanned the faces of the jury, as though trying to ascertain what impression the testimony had made upon them. Yesterday morning he walked with the most hopeful air that he has shown since the beginning of this the second trial. The long anxiety was almost over, and in a few hours, perhaps, he would be either a free man or a condemned one.
Mr. Nelson Taylor began the summing up for the State. He occupied but a short time, leaving the brunt of the argument for Mr. Olmstead.
Mr. Charles R. Bollman followed for the defence. Mr. Bollman is a German, but though not many years in this country he has mastered the English language so thoroughly that it is difficult to believe that he was not born here. He dwelt on the probability of Schulte having been murdered by tramps. He pointed out that the murdered man habitually carried a large amount of money about his person, and allowed that fact to be very generally known.
Mr. Bollman had not concluded his speech at recess, but when the court again met, he said he preferred to close his address where he had left it, because he understood that there was a prospect that a law would be passed during the afternoon by the Legislature which, if he proceeded, would deprive Bucholz of his right to be heard last.
The State's Attorney said he merely telegraphed to the Secretary of State regarding the law, and he had received a reply to the effect that it had not yet been engrossed. He was willing, however, to give the prisoner the privilege of being heard last.
Mr. Bollman then went on. He argued that Bucholz could not have had time to travel over the distance between Hirscher's saloon and Mrs. Waring's house, kill Schulte, and hide the money in the barn in the twenty-seven minutes which elapsed between his departure from the saloon and his arrival at the house. Unlike George Washington, Benjamin Ayres, having done mischief with his hatchet, could tell a lie, too. He charged that Mr. Schulte's watch was not thrown in the place where it was found, but that it, with the pistol and the hobnails, was "planted" there afterward. He claimed that the tramps took away the comparatively small amount of money found in a pocketbook in Schulte's dress pocket, supposing that there was no more. They neglected to search in the tail pockets of the coat, but Bucholz, knowing where the old man carried the vast amount of his money, took it out when he was helping to carry the body home.
As the lawyer closed his address with an eloquent description of Bucholz's unfriended position, the prisoner, for the first time in all the long trial, broke down. He covered his face with his handkerchief, leaned forward, and sobbed convulsively.
The State's Attorney, in opening his address, read an extract from a speech made by Daniel Webster in the prosecution of a man who had murdered his master. It fitted the case admirably, and created a deep impression. Then he described the murder as he supposed it to have been committed. Bucholz composed himself, and listened stolidly, but there were many moist eyes in the court room.
After the State's Attorney had finished reading from Webster's speech, Gen. Smith tried to get hold of the book, but Mr. Olmstead deliberately pushed it beyond his reach.
"If, as the defence seems to claim." said the State's Attorney. "Schulte's brother in Germany, who knew how much money the murdered man was in the habit of carrying about his person, sent to this country an agent to kill his relative and steal his money, why, I ask, in the name of common sense, did not that agent take the money instead of leaving it for William Bucholz?"
The State's Attorney had not concluded his argument when the court adjourned.
PLEADING FOR BUCHOLZ.
----------
Gen. Smith Presenting the Points in Favor of the Accused Man.
The Bridgeport court room was more crowded yesterday than on any day since the commencement of the second trial of William Bucholz. The prisoner listened with dogged insensibility to the closing argument of the State's Attorney, but with keen attention to that of Gen. Smith, who followed. Gen. Smith held up the piece of blood-stained linen that was found near the place where the murder was committed.
"The case for the prosecution," he said. "is as rotten as this rag, as dirty, and as flimsy."
Speaking of Dr. Treadwell, the eminent New England expert in blood corpuscles, he said:
"My God, gentlemen, if men are to be hanged on account of what Dr. Treadwell doesn't know, which of us would be safe?"
He argued that all the articles implicating Bucholz in the murder of Schulte being found in the line of his flight was owing simply to their having been placed there designedly by the real murderer, to throw suspicion on an innocent man. He believed that Schulte had been killed by a blow from two or three telegraph wires twisted together, such as young Savage had seen in the hand of a tramp on the railroad on the night of the murder. He declared it to be impossible that Schulte's watch could have lain close to a public path, with persons passing close to it every day, and yet not have been discovered for months. It had been cast there, he said, a few hours before it was found, by persons interested in the conviction of Bucholz. Otherwise, he asked, how was it possible, despite the testimony of experts, that it could have sustained no rust and no signs of the effects of moisture. He ridiculed the idea of an axe retaining blood corpuscles after seven months of steady use, and criticised Dr. Treadwell and Mr. Olmstead, the first for his testimony, which the lawyer said, stamped him as an ignoramus, and the latter for the manner in which he had conducted the prosecution. When Dr. Treadwell went on the stand and swore that a blood corpuscle seven months old, submitted to a heat sufficient to make a steel blade red, would not be injured beyond recognition, he destroyed all chance of his ever being employed as an expert again. The farce of analyzation of blood corpuscles never went further.
With regard to Bucholz’s possession of the money, the lawyer said, as his associate had said before, that his client had simply stolen it from the pocket of the dead man as he was helping to carry it home. The argument was not finished when the Court adjourned.
Flowers for Bucholz.
Gen. Smith closed his argument in favor of William Bucholz, at Bridgeport, yesterday morning, with a bitter arraignment of the methods used by the prosecution to secure the conviction of the prisoner. At the close of his argument the sympathy for the prisoner, which, to some extent, has been manifest throughout the trial, found vent in the presentation to him of a bouquet of flowers, which one of the ladies, in behalf of the others in the court room, presented to him. There was rather a bewildered expression on his face as he took it, but he smiled and bowed, and a slight manifestation of applause was quickly suppressed by the court officers. Gen. Smith closed shortly after 12 o'clock, and Chief Justice Park deferred charging the jury until Monday morning.
FAILING AT FIRST TO AGREE
----------
THE BUCHOLZ JURY SPEND THE NIGHT IN THE JURY ROOM.
----------
Bucholz's Appearance on the Day his Case was Given to the Jury – The Charge of the Chief Justice – A Throng Around the Court.
No change was apparent in the bearing of William Bucholz as he entered the Bridgeport court room yesterday morning. He was dressed, as usual, with unexceptionable neatness: and if, as some said, his face was a little paler than ordinarily, it is at all times so nearly colorless that the increased pallor was hardly observable. Long before the irons were removed from the prisoner's hands, the throng in the court room was so dense that it was not easy for a person arriving late to get in, even by the rear door, which is supposed to be for the exclusive use of members of the bar. Bucholz, as he entered, looked with some surprise on the throng. Several persons saluted him, and he returned their salutations with evident pleasure. The sympathy felt for him by the majority of the people present, and especially by the ladies occupying the reserved seats near the rear entrance, was unmistakable. It did not find vent in any more floral offerings, such as the handsome bouquet which the ladies presented to him on Saturday: but it was sufficiently marked to afford the prisoner undoubted gratification.
Chief Justice Park began his charge to the jury shortly after 10 o'clock. His voice is very low and somewhat husky, so that, though a breathless silence prevailed in the court room, those in the galleries and at the rear could hear nothing. The jury listened attentively, and at first Bucholz made an effort to catch every word. As the time passed, however, and point after point of the large volume of evidence for and against the accused man was dwelt upon with an exactness that was a little tiresome, he seemed to lose much of his interest, and, leaning his head upon his hand, either sank into a reverie or gave way to drowsiness. The Chief Justice drew the attention of the jury to the fact that tramps of a suspicious appearance had been seen prowling about the place where the murder was committed, shortly before the body of Schulte was found: but he also reminded them that on the two preceding days large bodies of the same class of persons had passed through the neighborhood. He paid but little attention to the circumstance that a man coming from Schulte's native place in Germany had been in Bridgeport and South Norwalk just before the murder, and had disappeared mysteriously and without paying his board bills immediately thereafter.
The Chief Justice closed at 1 o'clock, and a recess of an hour was taken. The crowd in the court room thinned rapidly and Bucholz was quickly handcuffed and taken to the restaurant where he has dined since his trial. The jury were locked up in their room and served with dinner, and the lawyers and such of the spectators as remained in the court room discussed the merits of the Judge's charge, which was about as non-committal as it is possible for such an address to be.
At 2 o'clock the court room was again thronged; but Bucholz had not returned, nor were the Judges on the bench. The jury were deliberating, and the persons in the court room, beginning to realize the fact that a verdict was not likely to be arrived at very speedily, relaxed their attitudes of attention, settled themselves in more comfortable positions, and began to chat freely. Shortly before 3 o'clock a knock on the inside of the jury room door summoned a court officer, and after a brief whispered conversation, the axe with which the murder is supposed to have been committed was passed in. A bone from Schulte's skull was also sent in to the jury, and a quarter of an hour afterward Gen. Smith, coming into the court room, learned what had been done during his absence, and objected to the informality of the proceedings. Judge Loomis was summoned, and under his instructions the exhibits were brought out of the jury room, examined by the lawyers for the defence, and sent back again. The stir in the court room caused many persons to believe that the jury were about to come in, and those having Bucholz in charge brought him to his seat behind the prisoner's rail. His eyes were bright, and there was some anxiety expressed in his face; but in a few seconds he understood that his fate was not to be immediately decided, and he resumed his wonted attitude of composure.
At the end of another hour the jury asked to be allowed to examine a map of the locality in which the murder of Schulte had been committed. It had a table of distances marked upon it, and had been prepared by Mr. Bollman of counsel for the defence. It had not been marked as an exhibit, and on this ground the State's Attorney objected to its being sent in. After some wrangling between the lawyers the Court decided that the jury could not see it. Another wearisome delay followed. The throng in the court room grew smaller, nearly all the ladies going home, but they returned in the course of a couple of hours. The Judges went off the bench, and the lawyers either retained their seats or lounged in an anteroom. The court room grew dark and the gas was lighted. Bucholz put on his spectacles and read books and newspapers, or examined a map until after 6 o'clock, when he removed his glasses, leaned back in his chair and rubbed his eyes as though weary with reading. Nothing further had been heard from the jury. and hopes of a speedy agreement became fainter.
Shortly after 11 o'clock Chief Justice Park and Judge Loomis returned to the bench. The court room was still thronged, for a rumor had spread that the jury had agreed. They were summoned, and the foreman said that they had failed to arrive at a verdict. The Chief Justice announced a recess until 8 o'clock this morning: and Bucholz, with a disappointed look, held out his wrists for the irons.
Bucholz's Fate Still Undecided.
BRIDGEPORT, March 16. – The jury in the Bucholz case is, perhaps, the most amicable body of men who ever met to agree or disagree upon a case where a man's life or death depends upon the issue. They have now been in their room nearly thirty hours, and they have been heard from but twice. On the first occasion they wanted a map that was not given to them, and at 6 o'clock this evening they asked for a broom, which was sent to them to enable them, Mr. Bollinan of counsel for the defence said, to sweep up the ballots from the floor. Up to a late hour they were not heard from again.
THE BUCHOLZ JURY STILL OUT.
----------
Receiving a Supplemental Charge, Against which the Defence Protested.
BRIDGEPORT, March 17. – After the adjournment of the court on Sunday night, nothing was heard from the jury in the Bucholz case until 8 o'clock this morning, when they asked to be brought into court. They had been deliberating for forty-three hours, and a verdict was hardly looked for. Chief Justice Park and Judge Loomis were quickly summoned, however, and Bucholz and his lawyers were soon in court. The prisoner was pale and seemed a little nervous, but he smiled and grew more hopeful when one of his counsel spoke encouragingly to him in German. The jury were then marshalled into the court room, and an exceedingly dissatisfied body of men they seemed to be. They were tired out, and undoubtedly not on the best of terms with each other. Moreover, they had not agreed upon a verdict, and the foreman, on being questioned by the Chief Justice, rather snappishly gave it as his opinion that there was no earthly possibility of their coming to an agreement at all. The Chief Justice then delivered what seemed to be in the nature of a second charge. He instructed the jury for more than half an hour, and his remarks appeared to Gen. Smith to be so unfavorable to the prisoner that he protested firmly, and demanded to be heard. The Chief Justice, however, refused to listen to further argument, and sent the jury back to their room until 2 P. M. When the court convened at that hour the situation was unchanged. The jury, fortified by dinner, were not yet disposed to agree, and a recess was taken until 8 o'clock.
9 P. M. – The jury have now been out fifty-six hours, and apparently there is but little hope of an agreement. To-night the court room was thronged more densely than at any other time since the opening of the trial. The jury sent word to the Court that they had not agreed, and Chief Justice Park adjourned the court until 8 o'clock to-morrow morning. The jury are supposed to stand seven for acquittal and five for murder in the second degree.
WILLIAM BUCHOLZ, the young German charged with the murder of old JOHN H. SCHULTE, the South Norwalk miser, has again escaped hanging. After his first trial the jury, after long deliberation, found him guilty of murder in the first degree. A new trial was granted, on the proof that a juror talked of the verdict that would be rendered. While the case was in progress yesterday the jury in the second trial, after deliberating sixty-eight hours, agreed to disagree. The talkative juror bids fair to cost Connecticut a deal of money, but he may be the means of saving the young German's life.
THE BUCHOLZ JURY DISCHARGED.
----------
Nine for Murder In the First Degree – A Date Fixed for a Third Trial
At 9 o'clock yesterday morning the Bucholz jury, at Bridgeport, after sixty-nine hours of deliberation, were summoned into court. They had made no demand to see the Judges since Tuesday morning, and it was generally understood that they had not arrived at an agreement.
When they were marshalled to their places yesterday they looked terribly tired, and some of them seemed ready to fall asleep in their chairs. They obeyed the order of the Clerk to rise as their names were called, and when they were all standing they were asked if they had agreed upon a verdict.
"We have not," said the foreman, emphasizing the last word, and with his eyes half closed. “And we don't think there is the least chance of our agreeing.”
The Chief Justice inquired whether they had any questions to ask, but none of them exhibited any curiosity. On the preceding morning a juror had asked Chief Justice Park what he thought of the testimony of Dr. Treadwell, the expert on blood corpuscles, but he had failed to obtain any satisfaction, and he was not disposed to try again.
"Gentlemen, you are discharged," said the Chief Justice. “Mr. Sheriff, take charge of the exhibits.”
Instantly State's Attorney Olmstead was on his feet. He asked that before the court adjourned it should appoint a week from next Tuesday as the day for the third trial of Bucholz. Detective Stark, he said, who was the prosecution's strongest witness, was about to start for South America, and unless the trial was hastened his testimony might not be forthcoming.
Gen. Smith deprecated in strong terms this application. If it were granted, he said, it would deprive the prisoner of at least one of his present counsel, for he (Gen. Smith) did not feel that he could conscientiously proceed at the time named. There was much important evidence for the defense that had not yet been placed before the jury, but which, if reasonable time were allowed, would probably be forthcoming. It would, however, be impossible to procure it as soon as next Tuesday week. Evidence required by the State's Attorney could be promptly collected, he having the Treasury of the State of Connecticut at his control, and a retinue of paid assistants to aid him : but the defence was almost voluntary, and had no money to spare.
After some consultation between Chief Justice Park and Judge Loomis, the latter set down the day for Bucholz's third trial as Tuesday, April 18, 1880, at 10 o'clock.
All conjecture in the court room as to the standing of the jury proved to have been wildly erroneous. At no time had Bucholz any chance of being acquitted. Ballots were cast sixty-three times, and when the jury were discharged they stood nine for murder in the first degree, two for murder in the second degree, and one for acquittal. Those in favor of a verdict of murder in the second degree based their decision upon a statute of the State of Connecticut which provides that, when the circumstantial evidence convicting a prisoner is not as strong as the testimony of two eye-witnesses a second-degree verdict may be rendered. It could not be ascertained upon what grounds the juror for acquittal based his decision.