Articles from the New Haven Morning Journal and Courier in February and March 1880, covering William Bucholz' second trial for the murder of Johann H. Schulte.
I transcribed these with a combination of automation and eyeballs, so please let me know if you find any errors.
The Second Trial of Buchholz.
It is probable, although not certain, that the second trial of Buchholz for the murder of John H. Schulte will come on at the term of the Superior Court, which commences at Bridgeport in the Iatter part of this month. New evidence will be introduced on both sides, imparting to the case additional interest. The defense refuse to say what new matter they will introduce and the State Attorney is likewise reticent regarding the new evidence for the State. Both sides seem confident of making out a better case than before, although the State's case was strong enough to secure a conviction and therefore would seem to be in less need of strengthening than the other side. Among other things which Buchholz' counsel are preparing to introduce at the new trial, is a map of the scene of the murder and the whole ground which includes the course followed by Buchholz and Schulte in their walk from the depot to the Warings' house.
Buchholz's New Trial.
The counsel for Buchholz – General William Randall Smith and Charles F. Bollman – have been notified that Judge Loomis has secured a Superior Court judge to sit with him on the first day of the February criminal term for Fairfield term, and try the case. Court will be opened Tuesday, February 17, at 2 p.m.
Buchholz's New Trial.
The trial of William Buchholz for the murder of John H. Schulte at Norwalk, in December, 1878, has been arranged to commence on Tuesday next. It is understood that both sides will introduce new and interesting evidence.
Buchholz Again.
---------
The Second Trial of the Schulte Murder Case.
William Buchholz was placed on trial for the second time at Bridgeport yesterday afternoon to answer to the charge of murdering John Henry Schulte at South Norwalk, Dec. 27, 1879. The first trial last September resulted in a verdict of murder in the first degree and the sentencing of the prisoner to hanging. His counsel prepared a list of exceptions upon which to ask the Court of Errors to grant a new trial, but had no need to present them, as the disclosure of the fact that one of the jurors had been talking about the case during the trial, enabled them to get the verdict set aside on this ground. New evidence is expected at this trial. The court room was nearly filled with spectators yesterday. Chief Justice Park and Judge Martin are the judges who hear the case. The Farmer says: "The sheriff had previously been directed to immediately summon an extra panel of 36 jurors, as it was feared a jury could not be selected from the regular panel of 18. Buchholz was not put to plead, his plea of not guilty at the former trial being considered sufficient. His appearance has not materially changed since his last visit to the court room. The first two jurors examined acknowledged that they had formed an opinion and were excused. The third was challenged. It was regarded as certain by the lawyers that the selection of a jury would occupy all the afternoon."
The Buchholz Trial.
----------
His Second Trial for His Life – A Jury Obtained – The Trial Begun.
The 12th man for the jury in the Buchholz trial was obtained yesterday morning. The jury are: William D. Gregory of Wilton, Victor H. Russell of Greenwich, Frederick B. Knapp of Greenwich, George S. Bates of Darien, James N. Lake of Newtown, Edwin P. White of Ridgefield, Sherman Morehouse of Wilton, Thomas P. Bristol of Brookfield, Henry I Bronson of Huntington, Charles Beard of Huntington, Ferdinand W. Burt of Ridgefield, Bradley Hull of Weston.
At 9:15 the oath was administered to the jury and the indictment read.
The first witness called was Fried. Gruenwald, who through his interpreter, Mr. Gerbich, of Bridgeport, testified that he came to this country with John Henry Schulte from Germany, arriving September 27th, 1878. He made a contract with Mr. Schulte in writing to accompany him to this country as a servant, the paper being signed by both the witness and Mr. Schulte. On their arrival in New York they went to the Sonne Hotel. The witness testified that he and Buchholz had had some conversation together at the hotel about Schulte. He had told Buchholz that Schulte was such a queer man that he did not want to go with him. Buchholz said he wished he could go in his place and he would make it different with him. The witness had said in the presence of Buchholz and others that Schulte had a great deal of money, but the witness could not tell how much. The witness saw Schulte take some gold out of a trunk and he gave him ten marks at the time. He also saw a large amount of German money in the trunk. With it was some American money and 1,000 mark bills, and also a bag containing gold. The witness left Mr. Schulte about the first of October. The witness was here shown a watch chain which he thought resembled that worn by Mr. Schulte. The witness next saw Mr. Schulte on December 27, at 419 East Fifteenth street, New York. He wore on that day a brown coat, green hat and light pants. The clothing taken from Schulte was shown witness and identified, as also were two leather pocketbooks and two canvas bags, one of which witness said Schulte carried change in.
The witness was cross-examined and Frank Just was called. He drove an express wagon from the Sonne Hotel at the same time that Schulte boarded there. He had seen Schulte have a pocketbook and he took Schulte and his trunk to the depot when Schulte left to go to South Norwalk. Buchholz went along, and on the way the driver heard Buchholz make a bargain with Schulte to become his servant, in place of Gruenwald, who had left the situation. The court at this point took a recess until 2 o'clock.
Buchholz' New Difficulty.
----------
That New Evidence – How He Confided in Another Associate in Durance Vile, Who "Gives Him Away" – The Unfortunate Schulte's Money – Interested Court Room – A Spicy Cross-Examination.
The Buchholz case at Bridgeport took on a new interest yesterday. The proceedings had been dragging along with a repetition substantially of the old evidence given at the former trial until yesterday morning, when, after Mrs. Waring had finished her testimony and Victor Rohe had testified, a young man of rather good appearance was put upon the stand, who answered to the name of R. S. Hineman and who had been brought from Bridgeport jail to the court. He proved to be another confidant of Buchholz, to whom Buchholz, while they were prisoners together, had told important secrets. The witness was in Bridgeport jail confined on a charge of forgery, and last November was brought from Utica, N.Y., on a requisition. He was confined in the next cell to Buchholz, and Buchholz talked to him about the case several times. The conversation was all voluntary on the part of the accused. Witness heard Buchholz tell a hall man that he thought witness was a detective. It was a standing joke. They called me a detective. I guess I'm dubbed that now. I told Buchholz I wasn't any detective, and sent him copies of the Farmer containing something about my case and other matters. When I had potatoes, I took them in his cell and cooked them, and we ate them together. We cooked steaks together and other things. Every Friday we had codfish balls. I told him if I could only get out of the jail I thought I could get him out. He said I would never regret it if I did. I said I thought I could get some saw and cut the cell bars; I knew ladies who would bring them to me. He said he'd fix me if I would only get him out; that he'd take me to Germany and Paris and all around, and we'd be gentlemen and have a good time. I said it would require a good deal of money to do all this. He said that would be all right. I told him I had lady friends who would do a great deal to help me out, and that I knew of places in New York where a man could hide for a month or so and keep out of the way. Buchholz spoke about a young lady. He said she was in the country somewhere and spoke as if he was engaged to her. He said she didn't know anything about the case; she didn't see the papers. I told him if I could get out I would send back to the jail and try and get him out with saws. By and by there were some painters who came to the jail and worked painting the jail. The witness tore up a sheet to make pants of and Buchholz sewed them up. Buchholz told the witness he would give $6,000 in cash to get out of jail. Buchholz also said to the witness that they were not so very smart or they would have found more money, This was said in a conversation about Mr. Somers, the detective, when talking about the manner in which he got into Buchholz' confidence. Witness, in reply to the State's Attorney, said he meant to worm it out of Buchholz where the money was all the time. Buchholz said he would not tell him where the money was, as he was afraid if he, the witness, should get out first and know where the money was he would be in witness' power. Buchholz said he would fix him well if he would get him out. He did not mean to kill him, but simply to keep him out of the way. He told him that Stark's evidence was the only evidence there was against him, and if it was not for him he would be all right. He proposed that witness should go to New York and find Stark and get him out of the way until after the trial.
State Attorney Olmstead – "Did you make any memorandum of what Buchholz said to you at the time?"
The witness – "Yes, I have two with me."
The witness read them. They were to this effect:
"If it hadn't been for the son of a – of a detective they would never have known I did it, and they wouldn't have got the money. I would have been a free man if I had had time to get away.
"If the detective had been smart he would have got more money."
The witness said that he took down the memoranda from one to three hours after Buchholz made the statements. He did it so as to have something to bind Buchholz so that he couldn't go back on him.
He said to witness when talking about getting out of jail under a disguise that he could color his hair and change the color of his eyes, and wanted witness to ask Dr. Phillippi, who was also a prisoner in the jail, if the eyes could not be colored, but not to say that he wished to know. Buchholz said they could change the color of the eyes in Germany. The witness had received two notes from Buchholz. Witness first told of this conversation between himself and the accused to Detective Taylor. He read from two memoranda the words spoken by Buchholz, the entry being made a few moments after the conversation was had. Witness told Taylor of this in order that he could get bail.
Cross-examined – He said he was born in the State of Kentucky. When asked his name he refused to tell until ordered by the court. The court decided that he should give his name. He then gave the name of John W. Wills. He said he was known in New York, Chicago, St. Louis, San Francisco and other places by that name. He was asked who he knew in New York. This he refused to tell on the ground that it would criminate him in other matters. The State thought the witness should have the benefit of his counsel in order to ascertain his rights, and said he had been sent for. Mr. W. O. Wildman appeared as his counsel, but the counsel for the defense objected to his giving the witness any instruction in the presence of the court and jury. The court sustained the defense and instructed the witness to give the names of the parties in New York. Witness then gave the name of one Burns who was studying medicine. He could not tell whether he was there now or not. He also knew one Harry Hart in Philadelphia, a wealthy and respectable man. Also one Wiley of the same place, a son of a clergyman. He could not tell where his father and mother lived at the present time, as he had not had any communication from them in about a year. When asked what he had been doing during the past year he replied, "I have been buying stocks, &c., in company with Frank Camp." When asked where he was, he replied: "I would like to know myself." He was then asked where he lived. He replied: "Next door to Mr. Samuel J. Tilden. When asked as to whether Camp ever speculated with Mr. Tilden in stocks he replied, "I suppose he did. I don't know whether he did or not." He was asked if he had any brothers or sisters. He replied, "I have a sister," but he refused to tell her name when asked. He was asked when he made the memoranda as to what Buchholz said. He couldn't tell the date. He said he made the one in regard to the money in order to show them to Buchholz when they got out, so that he would act square with him. He said he stopped at the Paisley House in New York prior to his going to Utica, where he was arrested, but could not give the date or under what name he registered.
Buchholz' face was deeply flushed when this witness first took the stand, and seemed very much surprised. He kept his eyes upon the witness during all of his testimony and paid the strictest attention to every word he said.
The Buchholz Case.
The Buchholz case at Bridgeport is resumed to-morrow morning. Heineman the forger's examination was concluded Friday afternoon and the testimony of the jailer, Mr. Wells, was taken before the adjournment. Heineman or Wills admitted to having served a term in Pennsylvania State prison for a series of forgeries amounting to $5,400 on the Philadelphia National bank, made five or six years ago. He was finally sustained in his refusal to give the name of his sister. He was pardoned out of prison after serving three years.
The Buchholz Case.
----------
A Prisoner Witness Who Would Not Reveal a Secret Conversation with the Accused – Persisting, He is Held for Contempt – The Other Witnesses.
The Buchholz trial was resumed in Bridgeport yesterday morning. There was quite a sensation in court occasioned by George H. Groff, a prisoner in the Bridgeport jail, who it is alleged has had some conversation with the accused relating to the murder of Schulte. He took the witness stand and said he got acquainted with Buchholz while in jail, but he had conscientious scruples about testifying against a fellow man. He was told that unless he answered the questions put to him by State Attorney Olmstead he would be punished by the court. Still he absolutely refused to say a word against the accused, fearing it might tend to criminate himself. Chief Justice Park, after seeing that the man was determined not to testify, ordered him committed to jail for contempt of court until he was ready to answer the questions put to him, or until further orders from the court.
Miss Sadie Waring, daughter of Mrs. Amelia Waring, in whose house in South Norwalk Schulte lived, testified to hearing Buchholz calling out "Sammy, Sammy," while he was in the woods near the house on the night of the murder, and to the fact of his coming into the house with a satchel in his hand in a fainting condition. She said he was a quiet, peaceable man, and that he and Schulte got along together without quarreling.
Miss Annie Waring, a sister of the former witness, testified substantially the same as her sister.
John H. Wills, with several aliases, the alleged forger who appeared against Buchholz the other day, was again called to the witness stand and stated that he had no difficulty in understanding what Buchholz was saying to him and that he did not understand German.
Samuel Waring, of South Norwalk, testified in corroboration of his mother and sisters.
The Buchholz Case.
-----------
His Second Trial for His Life – Getting at the Routine Evidence – Wills, the Young Forger – His Relatives – Honorable Family Connections.
The Buchholz hearing at Bridgeport yesterday was devoid of anything sensational. The testimony of the men who went into the woods and found the body of Schulte was taken, and they were cross-examined at much length with meagre results. Robert Pinkerton was present, waiting to testify that Stark, the detective, is in his employ. Stark is the witness who gave away Buchholz at the first trial, having been a fellow prisoner with the accused on a pretended offense. Graff, who refused to betray Buchholz's confidence to the court Tuesday, and was committed for contempt, was not brought down to the court room yesterday. He was a prisoner before, and simply went back again to his old quarters, but a bread and water diet, it is reported, was in prospect for him to punish his contumacy. He is awaiting trial on the charge of stealing a boat. The detectives report him to be not an innocent, simple hearted man, but a rascal who was feigning honorable motives. Samuel and Thomas Ireland, Edwin Hoyt, Gustave Hadstrom and Franklin A. Tolles also testified yesterday at the morning session.
State Attorney Olmstead had a letter yesterday just received from Franks' detective bureau, corroborating Wills, alias Hineman, as to his having served a term in Pennsylvania prison for forgery. The letter further says :
His father is a man of high standing, but John W. Wills at one time a fine young man, when he entered the store of Ashbridge & Co. fell from the company he kept, fast young men and depraved women. I made inquiries of the antecedents of his family when he was here and they stood very high. You tell John, Mr. Chatham of the bank is dead. I give you this to let you know however bad Jack may be, he is telling the truth in many things that I know of. You ask him if he knows Captain Franks of Philadelphia, who had his case in charge here at the first outset. I remain, most respectfully yours.
WM. D. FRANKS.
The Buchholz Trial.
----------
Dr. Treadwell the Expert – Finding Blood Stains.
The only feature of the Buchholz trial yesterday was the expert testimony of Dr. J. R. Treadwell, of Boston, which related particularly to blood stains and the distinguishment of the blood of one animal from that of another. He stated that he had made a specialty of the study of blood stains for the past six years, which had occupied his attention from four to five hours a day. He claimed the difference between corpuscles of a man's blood and that of a fowl's could be distinguished as readily as a chair from a desk, or a cabbage from a turnip. On February 14, 1880, he made an examination of spots upon the axe alleged to have been used by Buchholz, but with no satisfactory results. The corpuscles were affected by rust and were shriveled up. This, however, was generally the result upon primary examinations. Subsequent examinations produced striking results, as follows: First spot – (On right side of blade when held in front of the examiner with the edge held downwards, close to edge,) found the round and flat corpuscles of mammalian (human) blood, as distinguished from the oval corpuscles of the blood of fowls. Found nothing else he was sure of. Three separate examinations were made. Second spot – (Right side of blade, one and one-half inch from edge,) found both kinds of blood, mammalian and fowl. In answer to a question, the doctor said the fowl blood was more affected by the rust, and therefore was nearer the iron than the human blood, and consequently went to show that the fowl blood was on the axe first. He made examination of some fifteen other spots of blood with substantially the same result as above stated. The witness thought the wounds described on the head of Schulte could have been made with an axe in the hands of another, and the injured person might walk a mile under some circumstances. He identified a pair of pants (Buchholz's) which were shown him, as a pair from which he removed a quantity of material and tested it. He made eighteen slides, and obtained satisfactory results from sixteen of them. He found mammalian blood, but no chicken blood. The witness identified another pair of pants, called the "army pants." He said he found in the materials taken therefrom dark-colored masses, similar to those found mixed with blood on the butt of the axe. On the cross-examination of the witness, conducted by General Smith, witness said that corpuscles of blood were a good deal smaller than the head of a pin. In a cubic inch there were about 80 million corpuscles.
The Buchholz Case.
----------
Gathering the Toils – Schulte's Money – Buchholz and the Saloon Keeper – The Identification of the Bills.
Paul Hirscher, a South Norwalk saloon keeper, was the first witness yesterday morning in the second trial of Buchholz for his life, in progress in Bridgeport. By him a portion of the money of the murdered man was traced to Buchholz. He was handed $200 in twenty-dollar bills by Buchholz the day after the murder, with the request to keep it for him until after the inquest. He was requested to reply, if asked about it, that he received it some weeks before. Subsequently Buchholz begged witness to keep dark and not give him away, and told him he might keep the money for his trouble.
Dr. L. J. Sanford, of this city, testified Thursday, after Dr. Treadwell, the expert on blood stains, got through. He testified, among other things, that human and fowl blood, examined under favorable circumstances, showed marked differences. Blood to penetrate freely into a woolen material must be fresh. Blood would begin to become a little dense two minutes after it had left the veins.
Following him came Paul Hirscher, above spoken of, who, as to his story that Buchholz asked him to keep that money affair a secret, said: The second Saturday after the murder Buchholz came in my store looking pale and worried. He said he hoped I wouldn't go back on him, and that if I came to testify about the $200 that he gave me I would say he gave it to me some time before the murder. He said I could have the money and give him one-tenth or ten per cent. Another time I asked him what he meant and he said: "You can keep that money, you can use it, and I can let you have the money I received to-day from my sister; I got $200. from my sister to-day." He said he expected to board with me when the coroner's inquest was over. During the other trial of Buchholz I sat next to him one day and said to him: "I understand the authorities have been informed you did not get any money from your sister." He said: "That's all right; I know about it." I asked him what he meant and he said she didn't send him any. The witness further testified that Buchholz talked seriously of going off to Germany and hinted at taking witness with him. He would take him along sure if he (the witness) was a single man. Hirscher kept saloon, at the time of the murder, opposite the New York railroad depot. Witness was cross-examined to show that Buchholz and Schulte staid together in the saloon long enough, upon their arrival from New York the day of the murder, for the next train from New York to arrive, and for a man to get off from that train and follow Schulte and Buchholz and commit the murder.
Hirscher, who was a very quiet, positive witness, was succeeded by Charles Le Croix, a very lively Frenchman, who was called on to identify the $50 bill which was paid to him by Buchholz when he and Hirscher rode to Westport, which he did something after the following style:
Mr. Olmstead – "Do you recognize that bill?"
Le Croix – "That's de beel!"
Mr. Olmstead – "What bill?"
Le Croix – "National Bank beel."
Mr. Olmstead – "What bill?"
Le Croix – "Fifty dollar beel."
Mr. Olmstead – "Yes, I know; but what bill?"
Le Croix – "De beel dat Buchholz paid me."
He then described the visit of Buchholz and Hirscher to his place as already given by the latter.
Charles W. Smith, William A. Curtis and Dudley P. Ely, all of Norwalk, identified the $50 bill which was paid to Mr. Le Croix, it having passed through their hands.
Mr. Henry O. Koenig. the reporter of the New York Staats-Zeitung, testified that in Germany his given name was Heinrich, but here he was known as Henry. The correct English translation of Johann Heinrich is John Henry. This testimony is designed to forestall the expected claim of the defense that the indictment against Buchholz is defective in that the murdered man is called John Henry Schulte instead of John Heinrich Schulte. "I saw Buchholz," Mr. Koenig continued, "at the coroner's inquest at South Norwalk, and talked with him as a reporter. He told me that he received the $200 from Mr. Schulte just after leaving Hirscher's saloon, and that it was wrapped up in a paper." Other testimony confirmatory of the identification of the bills followed.
The Buchholz Case.
----------
Graff's Secret – Little Wool – Drawing to a Close.
Graff, Buchholz's fellow prisoner, who, when called to the witness stand some days ago to tell to the court what Buchholz had said to him about the case, declined to tell, refusing to "give Buchholz away," and who, persisting in his refusal, was placed in solitary confinement for contempt of court, changed his mind at last, and just before the court closed last week testified, but the testimony was a disappointment to the waiting assembly in the court room, it amounting to nothing, and the interest in Graff went down with a rush. The witness, who is only 19 years old and is in prison to answer to the charge of theft of a boat, testified to being a native of Venezuela and to speaking the German language; that he expressed to Buchholz a desire to get out of jail, and that Buchholz and he mutually agreed to help each other. Buchholz said he had given all his money to his lawyer, but offered his watch to Graff, desiring him to dispose of it and buy some saws with it to use to get out of durance vile with. This offer witness declined and nothing was done. Some time later, just after the Hayden trial was over, Buchholz and two or three other prisoners were sitting together talking, generally, about murder cases. They had been speaking in English, but Graff turned to Buchholz and said in German: "Buchholz, couldn't you have got the money without killing the old man?" "Oh, they can't convict me on that," replied Buchholz. "They would never have suspected me if I had not paid so much of the money to my creditors." Buchholz, the witness said, did not warn him of the probable results of repeating what he had said to him. "But,"' said Graff, "his looks spoke more than words." Once the witness asked Buchholz why he did not quit the country when he had the money, and the prisoner replied : "Why didn't you mention that before? Good advice always comes too late." He afterward told the witness that if he had not been arrested he would have gone to Australia.
During his cross-examination the witness said he had no friends in this country and no particular home, and had at one time lived with General Beauregard and worked on his farm. He had traveled through Texas, New Mexico and the South and had lived in New York a short time, but had no acquaintances there. He had also traveled about selling medicines.
The witness was then asked by Judge Park if he had repented of his refusal to testify. He replied : "Yes, Your Honor. I did not know what 'contempt of court' meant until I looked in the dictionary, and my friends told me what it was."
Judge Park said: "Well, George, inasmuch as you have repented and have apparently testified in full to your conversations with the accused about the case, we will release you from further confinement on this charge."
Walter C. Quintard testified to going to the Warring house after the axe, which he kept in his possession until the former trial.
Cross-examined – He could not tell the date of his visit at the Warring house.
Sheriff Sanford, Deputy Sheriff Bartram and Henry Bartram testified to the custody of the axe since the former trial.
George C. Stillson testified that he received seven twenty dollar bills from Paul Herscher. Witness was shown bills which he identified.
David Dayton testified to going to the scene of the murder. Saw the body of Schulte, also saw a book and some papers lying around. He said he saw a package taken from the inside, right hand vest pocket. This package contained about $20,000. It was handed to Mr. Stillson, foreman of the coroner's jury. He said the pocket on the left side of the coat was turned out. The witness then identified the clothing taken from the body. He saw no blood come from the body when it was being taken to the house.
Cross examined – He said he was under the impression that the body was rested upon the fence while being taken to the house. He said Mr. Berger took the package containing the German marks from the body. He was confident the package was wrapped up in paper. He said so far as he could remember, everything taken from the body was handed to Mr. Stillson.
The court then adjourned until half past 2 this afternoon. The evidence will probably be all got in this week.
About 30,000 words are taken by the court stenographers at the trial. The testimony on Wednesday amounted to about 45,000 words. The testimony is taken by Mr. F. G. Fowler of Bridgeport, assisted by Mr. W. S. Gompf of Springfield and Mr. Charles W. Thayer of Norwich. They employ three professional lady type writers from New York, who transfer their copy to print for the use of the court and counsel. The work done occupies the greater portion of the twenty-four hours during the days of the trial.
Buchholz lived in Hanover, and there is nothing to indicate that he ever met Schulte or even heard of him until he met him at the Sonne Hotel, New York. His counsel believe him honest in saying that he was on his way to Australia, where he had the promise of employment. His uncle was very wealthy, and died in January, 1879, the month after the murder, leaving $200,000, part of which went to Buchholz, and has furnished money to aid him in his fight for his life. But for this legacy General Smith and Mr. Bollman would have been compelled to work for nothing. Mr. Bollman allows Buchholz a certain amount of money a week, and he lives quite like a king in jail compared to most of the prisoners. He keeps himself confined in his cell, while the others are at liberty to go about the corridors, and cooks his meals upon a little gas stove. Many of his fellow prisoners believe that he still has a large share of Schulte's money, and this opinion may have accounted for the efforts made by Heineman, Graff and others to gain his confidence and regard. During the trial Buchholz takes dinner at O'Connor's restaurant, surrounded by Sheriff Sanford and a few deputies. He eats down stairs and his counsel eat in the ladies' room up stairs. Buchholz smokes a cigar after dinner while on his way to the court room.
The Buchholz Case.
----------
Tenth Day of the Hearing – Gathering in the State's Evidence.
In the Buchholz case at Bridgeport yesterday – the tenth day of the trial – Benjamin Ayres was again upon the stand, being cross-examined. He had, with others, "timed" the distance of Schulte's last walk. Witness was also the man who found the hatchet in the tree. This was on the last day of the former trial. An article in the Norwalk Sentinel, headed "That Hatchet," inspired by the witness, was read in court. Some time was spent on the hatchet subject.
F. G. Fowler, of Bridgeport, was called. He said he was accidentally in Norwalk on the day the experimental walk between the depot and the Warring house took place, and went with the party. Witness said he would call the gait a brisk one, it being 124 steps per minute. The witness corroborated the former witness in regard to the time taken in going from one point to another.
Mary Downey, of Norwalk, was next called. She said she lived in what is called Whistleville. She worked nearly up to Norwalk village and always went down the track in going to and from work. She worked on the day of the murder. She stopped on the track to talk with a Mr. Richards, and while she was talking Buchholz and Schulte passed her. She spoke to Buchholz and said good evening. They then passed on. Buchholz was a short distance ahead of Mr. Schulte. The witness said she stopped there talking some five or six minutes. She then went home, and when she reached the house she saw it was twenty minutes to seven. After she had reached the house she washed and fixed her hair, after which she heard the quarter before seven train go by.
Cross-examined – She said when Buchholz and Schulte passed her Buchholz was carrying a large bundle and Schulte a satchel.
Edward Brown, an inmate of the Bridgeport jail, was next called. He testified he had seen both Buchholz and Hineman together in Hineman's cell. Buchholz was sewing on a pair of overalls which they were making from a sheet. This was in November.
Cross-examined – He could not tell the time of this occurrence, but said it was just before Thanksgiving. Witness thought they were making overalls, as they were shaped like them. He said painters were at work there at the time. The witness said he was not in the conspiracy with Buchholz and Hineman to escape from jail.
George C. Stillson testified that it snowed on the Sunday after the murder and remained on the ground until the next March. Witness said he saw the wounds on Buchholz's face on the night of the murder.
Cross-examined – He thought they were not deep enough to cause much inconvenience from smarting.
Charles T. Crow, the next witness, said he was clerk of the coroner's jury and took the testimony of Buchholz as given by him when making his statement before them. The witness then read the statement of Buchholz as taken at the time and published at the time of the former trial. After witness had read a portion of the statement, the noon hour having arrived, the court took a recess until 2 o'clock.
The Buchholz Case.
----------
Stark the Detective – Commencing His Story – Cooking and Conversing – The Story Broken Off – Other Evidence.
In the Buchholz case at Bridgeport yesterday, at the opening of the court, Stark, alias Somers, the Pinkerton detective, began his story of his life in the Bridgeport jail, and his intimacy with Buchholz there and its results. Before the important part was reached he gave way to allow others whose time was pressing to testify. Stark told his method of getting into jail so as to "pump" Buchholz. After he had been in jail, in the next cell, five or six weeks, he gained Buchholz's confidence. They cooked over the same stove. They got to talking over the case and Stark obtained from Buchholz a statement as to how the murder occurred, Buchholz saying that there were two men who attacked Schulte. Buchholz became alarmed at articles published in the papers and imagined that from the tone of the articles and the allegations made some new evidence had been discovered against him. Witness saw an article in the Staats Zeitung regarding the letters from his sister containing money. Buchholz said he never told any one about this. Witness said Buchholz came to his cell one day and said that he had heard that Schulte's watch had been found. He seemed very much excited and said he did not go that way that night and did not know anything about the matter. He thought it would be a hard matter for them to identify the watch, as they would be compelled to send to Germany. This would be expensive and take time.
At this point the State asked permission to introduce another witness who had just arrived from New York and was anxious to return. The defense objected, but the court overruled.
Franklin Bischoff was then called. This is the witness which the State had some trouble in getting to attend at this trial. He testified that Schulte came to his father's banking house on the 27th of December, 1878, and got some German marks changed for other money. He returned again in the afternoon and got a 100 mark bill changed. Witness gave him three twenty and four ten mark gold pieces, one of them had a hole in it. Witness was here shown the gold piece offered in evidence, which he identified as being the one he paid Schulte on that day.
Cross-examined – He said his mind was perfectly clear regarding these transactions.
Edward A. Wildman, conductor on the Shore Line express, testified to the time of the running of his train on the day of the murder, that train being the one that passed Mary Downey on that night.
Sig. Fred. Gruenwold [Sigfried] was recalled to identify the signature of Mr. Schulte.
Charles T. Craw was recalled to give the balance of Buchholz's testimony before the coroner's jury. The defense objected to the reading of this on the ground that Buchholz was at the time under arrest. The defense then called several witnesses on this point, as did also the State. They testified that Buchholz was held under restraint although the warrant was not served until Saturday, January 4, following the murder. Buchholz gave a portion of his statement after the warrant had been served, but had then been cautioned as to his right in testifying without the advice of counsel. The court after considering the matter decided to reject the statement made by the accused previous to his being cautioned as to his rights, as the prisoner was substantially under arrest although no legal arrest had been made. The witness was then allowed to read the latter portion of the statement which it is claimed Buchholz gave of his own accord, knowing that he was not compelled to do so without the advice of counsel. This was in regard to the $200 he gave Paul Herscher, and which Buchholz claimed Schulte gave him on the night of the murder.
Cross-examined – He said the testimony was taken through an interpreter. He might have left out some words. He abbreviated the testimony to some extent and took it as best he could in long hand. The court took a recess until two o'clock.
More About Buchholz.
----------
Stark the Detective's Story – Its Strong Points Against the Prisoner.
Stark the detective returned to the stand in the Buchholz case at Bridgeport, Wednesday afternoon, and completed his important story yesterday, which is substantially what he told before regarding what he elicited from Buchholz while a fellow prisoner on a pretended offense in Bridgeport jail. Stark said that Buchholz told him that he had agreed to pay his lawyers $1,500, which he thought not too much if he could get clear. One day Buchholz said if he could only get out he would go and lift Schulte's treasure. Buchholz became affectionate, and throwing his arms around the detective's neck expressed great desire to get out for an hour, that he might go and lift Schulte's gold mine, which he said was in his (Buchholz's) mattress. Could he but get out he would let Stark have not $500, but $5,000. The witness, after leaving the jail, visited Buchholz, and the accused drew a diagram of the Warring barn, where he located the Schulte treasure. Stark went, as directed, and found a pocketbook with $4,737 of American money in it, which he took to New York and which was opened by the German Consul General at Pinkerton's detective agency. The next day witness went to Buchholz, and representing to him that the Warring place was to be sold and the place turned topsy turvy, Buchholz told him where he could find another, the other pocketbook, which he said was "thick" and contained thousands. Stark, Mr. Pinkerton and an attache of the German Consulate went to the barn and found the money. Some time after that Buchholz told Stark, whom he then had some fear of, that he had no evidence of crime against him except the stealing of the money, and at one time told Stark he could have $10,000. Stark in the course of his answers gave it as his opinion that Buchholz killed Schulte. He said he went into the jail perfectly impartial; his instructions were to find out the truth of the Schulte affair.
Dr. L. J. Sanford next testified to an examination made by him of one of the bones of Schulte's skull in reference to giving an opinion as to the kind of instrument by which the wound was inflicted.
More About Buchholz.
----------
The State Rests – Evidence for the Defense.
After the testimony of Dr. Sanford, of this city, in the Buchholz case Thursday, the State rested. The first witness for the defense was Samuel Warring, who testified that the ax was used to split wood, and was taken away for three weeks after the murder. Charles I. Crow testified that he had walked from the South Norwalk depot to the place of the murder in twenty-five and one-quarter minutes. David Dayton said that during the fifteen days the prisoner was in his custody he had been always quiet and had never tried to escape. Franklin Tolles testified that the blood on the floor of Warring's house came from Schulte's wounded head, and that a coat under the head was soaked with blood.
The first witness yesterday morning was Mr. Edwin T. Strickland, of this city, conductor on the New York and New Haven railroad for thirteen years past. He testified about the time of his train the day of the murder at South Norwalk. Prof. Ellendorf, who gave Buchholz lessons in English, testified as to the latter's knowledge of the English language and that Buchholz's demeanor the day of the murder was cheerful and not strange or unusual. Several other witnesses testified as to minor matters.
Buchholz.
----------
Progress of the Evidence for the Defense.
In the Buchholz case at Bridgeport Monday afternoon Henry Shibby testified. He was the witness who testified last week that Heineman, the alleged forger, had told him in the Bridgeport jail that he was going to testify against Buchholz in the hope that it would better his own case. He was hall man in the jail at the time that, as he alleges, Heineman made this statement to him, and had only just been released. When he took the stand he was somewhat under the influence of liquor and was very short in his replies to the State Attorney. "What did Heineman say to you?" was asked. "I told it all the other day," was the reply;
"if you want it again you had better read your notes." A few more answers of that sort brought out threats that the witness would be sent back to jail if he continued in his course, and he then changed his mind and repeated the conversation he had with Heineman. He went further than this and testified to still another conversation he had with the alleged forger. "Why didn't you testify to that before?" asked Mr. Olmstead. "Because," replied the witness, "I was not asked about it." "Were you not sworn to tell the truth?" "The court adjourned before I could tell it."
The witness said he could not remember whether he had ever told anybody that he had been arrested in England for stabbing his father.
Sadie Waring, recalled, corrected an error she made in her testimony about the ax. Other witnesses who weakened a little some of the minor testimony of the State were Nathaniel Bouton, Josiah Triston [Tristram] and Daniel L. Mallard, principal of a public school in Brooklyn, N.Y., who was in South Norwalk on the day of the murder. While walking on the track early in the evening he saw three tramps near a great rock, and one of them was trying to kindle a fire. They were all desperate looking characters. One of them had dark whiskers, and another lighter ones. The witness did not feel quite safe when he saw them, and he went back. One of them had on a pair of dirty overalls. He did not notice the clothing of the others. Mr. Olmstend asked the witness if it was not quite as likely that the three men thought he was a dangerous looking character as that they were such. He insisted that they were dangerous looking men; they impressed him as being men capable of committing a desperate crime. He thought one of the men averted his head when he saw the witness.
Stephen Osshader, of South Norwalk, testified that he was in the woods on the afternoon of the murder. He saw, near some rocks, three men who looked like tramps. While the witness was looking at them they put torn and dirty clothing over better ones. They spoke in a foreign language and broken English. One of them said he might as well be in South Norwalk as there, and he accordingly went away. This was between 2 and 3 o'clock in the afternoon. The men saw him, but continued changing their clothing, paying little attention to him.
At the opening of the court yesterday morning, General Smith said he desired to obtain a deposition from New York to show that a man giving a certain name sailed for Germany at a certain date.
Mr. Olmstead agreed to admit as evidence the printed list of the steamship company to show that N. Abel sailed for Germany on the steamship Oder, Saturday, May 10, 1879.
Nearing the End.
----------
The Buchholz Case –Argumenis Impending – The Case for the Defense.
The arguments in the Buchhoiz case are expected to commence to-day, and it is conjectured that the case will be given to the jury by Friday night or Saturday morning. The defense rested yesterday morning. The opinion is expressed that the defense has made out a stronger cass at this trial than at the first. Buchholz's lawyers will claim to have shown that Buchholz did not have time to murder Schulte and rob him and reach the Waring house at the time he said he did. They will also claim that they have shown that three suspicious looking characters were hovering about South Norwalk on the day of the murder. They were seen by many. During the day time they tried to appear like tramps, or workmen, or, at least, different than they really were, by putting on overalls. One pair at least was new. The day after the murder a pair of new overalls were found within forty feet of where the body lay. There is evidence to show that the men, or part of them, were Germans. It has been shown that a stranger who came from the part of Germany where Schulte resided, came to this country with a resident of South Norwalk named Illing, and was very intimate with him. The stranger was very mysterious. No one but Illing knew him; he came here in November and returned in the May following after the Schulte watch was found. Illing has lately disappeared and is said to be in Europe. The theory of the defense is that Schulte was killed by a party of four or five who supposed at the time they had secured all his money. Pocketbooks in his skirt tail pockets were, however, overlooked, and were subsequently taken by Buchholz.
The defense aver forcibly that the accused had not time to do the murder, give the alarm and then rifle the pockets, and that the robbery could not have been effected very well with people – the Warings – looking on.
Dr. Edward T. Ward, of Bridgeport, testified. He had, at the request of General Smith, examined articles in evidence, including an axe. He said in his opinion the cut was not made by the axe. He said he found the edges of the cut in the hat to be clean cut and could not be made by such an instrument in its present condition.
Dr. William E. Burke, of South Norwalk, was next called. He testified that he saw the wounds in Schulte's skull. He said the wounds were produced by an instrument more in the shape of the wound and not by an instrument like the axe.
Dr. Robert Hubbard, of Bridgeport, was next called. He said he had examined some of the exhibits shown in court and read some of the medical testimony. He was shown a piece of the skull and he said his impression was that it was removed by some other instrument than the axe, as the piece was partially cut and partially fractured. He thought it was more probably done with a thin and sharp instrument. He thought the cut in the hat was done with some sharp instrument, the edge of the cut being smooth. He said, assuming the wound in the head being of the size described, he could not see how it would be made with an instrument like the axe, but rather from an instrument like a hammer or hatchet. He said he had had no experience in the restoration of blood corpuscles to their normal size. He said there were some who were honest in the belief that they could be done, and there were many who believed they could not. As a rule it was regarded by the profession as a doubtful matter. He said in his opinion the wounds as described were not made by this axe. He believed it utterly impossible to determine the blood corpuscles of one animal from those of another. He said there might be two men of equal reputation that would differ on this point. In fact, there were some experts who differed on this point.
Gen. Smith at the opening of the morning session Tuesday offered in evidence a printed list of one of the European steamship companies containing the name of Mr. Arble [Moritz Abel] as having sailed on one of their steamers on the tenth of May last. The list was received and numbered among the rest of the exhibits. The court at 5:30 adjourned until 8 o'clock yesterday morning.
The first witness called by the defense was State Attorney Olmstead. He was called in reference to a card which was found in the memorandum book in Arble's satchel. The card bore the name of Illing. Mr. Olmstead said Tuesday, when the card was offered, that he presumed he was the only man this side of Germany that knew anything about the card. He was asked by General Smith if he sent Mr. Illing to see Mr. Arble. Witness replied that he did. Witness was asked if he had a memoranda of the articles taken from the body of Schulte at the coroner's inquest. He replied he bad not. Witness was then asked if he had any letters, papers or documents in his possession or control taken from Schulte's body, other than those offered in evidence? Witness replied : "I don't know as I have anything in my possession that belongs to Schulte's estate that is not in evidence, except the watch."
Albert Wintter, of Bridgeport, was next called. He said he was in Germany from September 26 to November 6, 1878. He sailed from Hamburg via steamer Gellert November 6. Witness saw on the steamer two persons that he afterward saw in Bridgeport. They were Detective Illing and Mr. Arble. He arrived in New York November 20. Witness said Mr. Arble gave his name as Mr. Arble, of Cologne. Witness saw Arble and Illing talk, smoke and drink together. Witness also talked with them. They appeared perfectly gentlemanly.
Other testimony, including rebuttal, mostly fragmentary, was offered by other witnesses.
Buchholz.
----------
Nearing the End of the Case – The Last of the Testimony – Dr. Treadwell on Corpuscles Closes – The Lawyers Arguing.
The last of the evidence in the second trial of Buohholz was taken Wednesday afternoon, and was by Dr. Treadwell, the expert on blood corpuscles, who figured in the Hayden case. He had made an experiment, having read in the papers that the axe upon which he found mammalian blood corpuscles had been placed in the fire of a kitchen stove. He was asked what effect heat upon steel would have with blood corpuscles of long standing thereon. Witness replied, "That would depend on the amount of heat the steel was subjected to." He said a bright red heat would tend to destroy them, but a dull heat would not affect them so but that they could be restored. He gave an illustration with a knife which he showed to the jury. He said he drew some blood from his toe, which he smeared on the blade of the knife. He then heated the centre of the blade to a bright red heat. He removed some of the matter from near the centre of the blade and restored some of the corpuscles. He had no difficulty in restoring those taken from the point and shank of the blade. Witness said he made this experiment because he saw by the papers that the axe he had previously examined had been heated. The witness was then asked by Mr. Olmstead: "From what you know about this case have you any doubt but that the blood found on the axe is human blood?" He replied, "Not in the least."
Cross-examined – He was asked by Gen. Smith: "How much do you get a day for this and what is your contract with the State Attorney?" He replied: "The contract was $2.50 for doing the work and $25 per day and expenses when called as a witness."
The court opened at 9 a.m. yesterday, when Mr. Taylor, the assistant counsel for the State, proceeded in the opening argument. He first laid before the jury the duty which they were called upon, under their oaths, to perform. After reading from the authorities the definition of murder, he said there is no dispute between the counsel in this case but that a murder had been committed. He pictured out the relations between Schulte and Buchholz, and attached much significance to the fact that Buchholz took a lad's wages of Schulte. Buchholz presses his services upon the old man for the paltry compensation of three dollars a month. Schulte had previously had in his employ boys at this price, but when a full grown man offered his services for this, it shocked even old man Schulte's economical ideas. This one fact, we think, tends to show that there was a deep and well laid plan to accomplish this murder. Buchholz accompanies the old man to Norwalk, where they live together. On the day of the murder Schulte goes to New York, and Buchholz in the afternoon goes to meet him. They are seen going down the track together by Mary Downy. The next thing Buchholz reaches the Warring house and says Schulte has been attacked by tramps. The strongest part of the State's evidence is in the exhibits which they have introduced, the watch, pocketbooks, money and various other articles belonging to Schulte, the hair brush belonging to Buchholz. Two other articles, which of great importance, the old rag, which was found in the woods with blood spots upon it and the axe taken from the Warring house. The blood upon the axe, gentlemen, we think you will believe that it was what Dr. Treadwell told you that it was and that he found it there. We know that it had been heated to a certain extent, but he tells you that blood corpuscles can be restored even then, as he illustrated to you yesterday. Now, then, take some of the articles found. The money taken from the barn where it was hidden by the accused and recovered by Stark by a statement made to him by Buchholz. The possession of stolen goods is indicative of the person stealing it. What does the defense offer in rebuttal to break down this mass of testimony? They offer the tramp theory. It would not be strange that the several witnesses of the defense saw tramps on that day, as the tramp law was not then in existence and the country at the time was overrun with them. The defense will dwell at length on the time occupied by the accused in going from the depot to the Warring house. The lawyer now assailed this claim as fallacious and closed with an appeal to the jury.
At 11:05 Mr. Bollman began his argument on the part of the defense. He said he rejoiced and yet grieved at the closing remarks of the gentleman that preceded him, wherein he styled the prisoner at the bar as a murderer. That, gentlemen, is beyond the power of claim, until you, gentlemen, have brought in your verdict. I trust that you will seek diligently after the facts and truth in this case and judge accordingly. You will probably never be called upon again to the discharge of a greater responsibility. It is far better that ninety-nine guilty persons escape than that one innocent man should be punished. Circumstantial evidence, gentlemen, should be so completely connected in a chain as to leave no reasonable doubt in your minds that the prisoner at the bar is guilty of the crime, but if one link be broken or found to be defective, then the whole chain is broken and it falls to the ground. You must clearly find that the State has clearly proven that the blood of Schulte was shed by the hand of Buchholz before you can convict him of the charge of murder, and this fact must be proven as clear as the midday sun before you can bring in a verdict of murder in the first degree against the accused. The State has spent three weeks and brought a great number of witnesses to prove that William Buchholz was guilty of the murder, but we think that they have utterly failed in this attempt. They undoubtedly wished to make up in quantity what they lacked in quality. New York furnished Mr. Pinkerton, with his able detective Mr. Stark. Boston has furnished you Dr. Treadwell whose eyes are "full of blood." The jail has been emptied of its inmates to testify against the accused, and yet with all of this array they have utterly failed in proving that our client is guilty of this crime. You have heard the evidence of this array of witnesses ; take for instance the testimony of Dr. Pardee. "Why didn't the State employ a suitable physician and not rely upon Dr. Pardee, a man who could not remember the precise character of the wounds?" A man who measured wounds with his finger and "guessed at the distance." A man who allowed the body to be "sent to Germany before it had scarcely become cold." Gentlemen, you have heard the story of the detective Stark. Don't you believe that he obtained from this young man all that he knew about this case. Stark gained Buchholz's confidence and he innocently confided in him, we believe, all that he knew about the murder. He said to Stark, "Oh, how sad I should feel to think that you thought me guilty of the murder of poor old Schulte." Do these words strike you, gentlemen, as coming from the lips of a murderer? Now take the conduct of William Buchholz on the day of the murder. If he had planned the murder he must, as a matter of course, known in the morning that it was to have been done. Look at his deportment during the day. He remained at home and recited his lesson as usual. Mr. Ellendorf saw nothing unusual in his actions on that day. The noon hour having arrived the court took a recess until two o'clock.
During Mr. Bollman's argument Buchholz seemed deeply affected and at times burst out crying, occasionally sobbing so loud that he could be heard all about the room.
The Buchholz Case.
----------
The Lawyers and Their Pleas – The Prosecuting Attorney's Argument – The Legislature and the Closing Plea.
In the Buchholz case at Bridgeport, Thursday afternoon, although the weather was bad, there was a very large attendance, attracted, no doubt, by a desire to hear the arguments of counsel. As soon as the judges came in, Mr. Boliman arose and stated that during the recess he had heard on reliable authority that a bill had partly passed the Legislature to cut off the defendant in any case from being heard last, and that telegrams were passing between the Legislature and the court house. In this case, he should stop his argument there and sacrifice himself to the necessities of the occasion. Mr. Olmstead arose and stated that only one telegram had been sent to Hartford; he had asked if such a bill had been passed, and had received an answer that it had been passed by both houses, but had not been engrossed. General Smith arose and said he desired to be assured that the prisoner should have the right to answer the State Attorney's argument through his counsel. Mr. Olmstead replied that if the bill passed that afternoon he should not use the privilege, whereupon Mr. Bollman continued. He first took up the question of time, and said that he could prove that Buchholz did not have time to murder Schulte and rob the body. He devoted some time to this subject, and vigorously set forth the testimony about the three tramps, connecting the man Abel, who left for Germany, with the tramps. He next took up the testimony of Eli Savage, and gave it a brief review. Continuing, he stated that after Schulte and Buchholz were attacked the robbers were frightened away by Buchholz's cries, and while the body was being carried to the house Buchholz took the money from the coat tail pockets of Schulte's coat. He admitted that the defendant had done wrong – very wrong; but he hoped the jury would not brand a man as a murderer when he had only taken money – and that under great temptation. He touched briefly upon the medical testimony and the axe, and concluded by an appeal in behalf of the prisoner, depicting his lonely condition, and that he was in a strange land, ignorant of its laws and customs.
After a short recess State Attorney Olmstead began his argument for the prosecution. In opening he spoke of Buchholz kindly, saying that he pitied him, as he was alone and friendless, but we must also remember the old man Schulte, over 60 years of age, who was foully murdered by his servant, yes, a trusted servant.
Disclaiming earnestly any and all personal feeling against Buchholz, he stigmatized the murder as done by Buchholz, calmly, coolly and calculatingly, for "so many pieces of silver weighed against so many ounces of blood." He then drew a very telling picture of the murder. Judas-like the servant welcomed his master and they started off for home, Buchholz leading the way as usual. They came to the path, passed along, and when they entered the woods Buchholz was 75 feet ahead. When he reached the ambush he stepped behind it, seized his weapon and waited for his master. As the old man reached the spot he crept stealthily up behind him, dealt him a blow on the head, and as that did not kill Schulte he finished his fiendish work by another blow, which crashed in the poor old man's skull and killed him. Then the murderer fled to the house, rushed in and fell on the floor, saying, "He's down in the woods-dead, dead!" Mr. Olmstead here entered into a long exposition of the familiar old proverb "Murder will out." A great deal had been said, the State Attorney continned, about the methods employed by the State. Surely, every effort must be made to bring to justice the guilty parties, and the prosecution should not be condemned because it endeavors to reach this end in an unusual manner. Of course, no person saw the murder. In all his experience Mr. Olmstead never knew of a first-degree murderer who had witnesses to the deed. Homicides are the result of a sudden fury – done without thought; consequently, these cases many times have witnesses. But when a man premeditates murder he does not take witnesses with him. In every case some dependence must be placed on circumstantial evidence. If an agent of Schulte's brother came to this country to get possession of his money, why, after the murder, did he not take it, instead of leaving it for Buchholz? If tramps committed the murder, how did they know that Schulte had gone to New York? If they knew of this fact they must have been confederates of Buchholz, and he had informed them of Schulte's departure. Again, if the three men killed Schulte, why did they not take his money? Mr. Olmstead next stated that he would call attention to the evidence, and dissected the story that Buchholz told before the coroner's jury. It must be murder in the first degree or acquittal, he said. If not guilty of murder in the first degree, he is innocent; there can be no such thing as second degree in this case. He continued: "Buchholz came to this country intending to go to Australia, not to go up into a little country town to be a servant. Why did he go as a lackey for $3 per month? He was a cultured man, who had served in the German army, and he went with Schulte to rob him. They quarreled, and Buchholz was given notice to leave. It is denied that there was any quarrel; if so, why was notice to leave given? Mary Downey testified to seeing the prisoner give Mrs. Waring $160 to keep for him, and he had some bills left. Where did he get this? When he went with Schulte he had only $50. He undoubtedly stole money from his master, and that was the cause of the quarrel. Buchholz bought a revolver in New York; because, he said, Deisenroth had warned him against tramps. When the woods were searched, after the tragedy, a shingle was found, pierced with bullets. Had Buchholz been practising, and when he found his aim was so poor, abandoned it for a surer weapon? Buchholz knew that Schulte carried money, and that he was coming home late. If tramps knew anything of Schulte's habits, they were aware of the fact that he never went out after dark, and therefore they would not have prepared the ambush. On that afternoon the prisoner went out of the Waring house a few minutes before 3 o'clock, passed through the woods, and did not arrive at Pitzer's until 4 o'clock. This gave him time to prepare the ambush. Even if Schulte did come home at 4 o'clock, the sun would set by half-past 4, and Buchholz could make some little excuse that would delay them, and by the time they reached the ambush it would be dark."
The court here adjourned to Friday at 9 a. m. Resuming his argument, he took up Buchholz's story and dissected it, and then scouted the medical experts who had flouted Dr. Treadwell's evidence. He alluded to the articles found at the scene of the murder, and then went into a calculation to show that Buchholz had ample time for the deed. When Buchholz went to South Norwalk he only intended to rob Schulte, but when the old man went to New York, and he, having received notice to quit, knew that this would be the last chance of being out after dark with Schulte, the spirit of murder entered his heart. When Buchholz borrowed $2.65, he told that his master owed him $200, but could not pay him, as he had only large bills; while the banker testified that Schulte went to New York and had small bills to the amount of $500 changed to large ones. Mr. Olmstead then gave some attention to the giving of $200 to Herscher by Buchholz, and his request that Herscher should say he gave it to him before the murder. He defended his course in using a detective to ferret out the crime, and quoted authorities to justify his action, after which he reviewed Stark's testimony and the finding of the hidden money. Continuing, he said that if Buchholz robbed the body he killed the old man. According to the prisoner's own story he was 75 feet ahead, and turned to go back, when he was attacked, and then he immediately ran to the house; consequently, he had not time to get the money then. Mr. Olmstead next demonstrated by testimony that Buchholz had no chance, when he returned to the body or when he helped to carry it to the house, to take the pocketbook. At this point the court took a recess to 2 p. m.
The Buchholz Trial.
----------
The Arguments Concluded – An Adjournment Until To-Day – The Accused Hoping for Acquittal – A Disagreement Expected.
General Smith concluded his argument for the defense in the Buchholz murder trial at Bridgeport on Saturday soon after 12 o'clock noon. It was supposed that the charge to the jury would immediately follow and that the case would be given to the jury, but such was not the case. To the surprise of nearly every one in the court room Chief Justice Park ordered the court adjourned until Monday at 10 a. m. Before excusing the jury the Chief Justice cautioned them not to converse with any one regarding the case during the interim. There appears to be a prevailing opinion that the jury will disagree, although some think that a verdict of murder in the second degree may be found. Public opinion appears to have undergone a considerable change since the last trial. Before the first trial began nearly every one said Buchholz was guilty, and when the jury returned a verdict of murder in the first degree the opinion was that it was just. On the first trial the attorneys for the accused tried hard to present a reasonable defense, but with all their ingenuity they made but little headway, and when the detective Stark went on to the stand and told the jury that Buchholz had told him where the dead man's money was secreted, and that he had actually found fifty or sixty thousand dollars, their weak defense was entirely destroyed. The defense that Buchholz stole the money but some one else killed Schulte had no weight with the jury, and a verdict of murder in the first degree was given.
In the second trial the State has given the case to the jury in a somewhat different form than on the last trial. The testimony of Heineman, the alleged forger, to corroborate Stark was new. So was the expert testimony regarding the blood corpuscles found on the Waring axe. Whether these additions were additions which helped the prosecution remains to be seen.
The defense at the present trial has made much over the presence in Norwalk at the time of the murder a of a German named Abel. He stayed there but a short time, and there is nothing to show that he did anything out of the way. This the defense claim is the strong point against him. He came over from Germany on the same steamer with Illing, the amateur detective who had much to do with working up the case for the State. He came from Westphalia and a neighboring town to that in which lies the Schulte estate. The inquest was held across the way from Abel's boarding house, but he did not attend it. This is sufficiently suspicious for the defense to build a theory upon. He was the man who managed the job of killing Schulte. He paid the hired assassins who did it. They failed to get the money. Hence he was unable to pay his board. Again the defense rely upon the fact that a pair of new overalls were found near the scene of the murder. Many Norwalk people watched the movements of three suspicious men the day of the murder. They kept close to the railroad tracks, and were seen to put on overalls, apparently to disguise themselves, as their clothes were otherwise better than those worn by the average tramp. After the murder two men – they answer the description of two of the three – boarded Conductor Hunt's train at Stamford and rode to New Haven. They were out of breath when they took the cars, and the conductor thought they were worthy of surveillance. But the testimony upon which the defense rely to acquit Buchholz if he is acquitted, or which will result in a disagreement of the jury if such a result is attained, is the testimony of the boy Eli Savage, which in brief was that his attention was called to the men by a Mr. Wilcox. His curiosity was excited and he looked them over. At night he started for home, going around by the railroad tracks. He stepped one side to allow the train which brought Mr. Schulte from New York to pass. Something white fluttered from a window. Presumably it was a piece of paper. One of the men whom he had suspected before came to the spot and bent down. Perhaps he picked it up. Then he joined the others in the trio. The boy overtakes them and they ask what train that was, and try to gain from him some information regarding the night trains. Then they go down towards the woods where Schulte was murdered. Soon after Schulte and Buchholz pass by going in the same direction. The testimony of the Savage boy was the feature of the trial. Stark's testimony was tame as a sensation because old. Heineman's story made but little impression. It proved nothing that Stark didn't prove – that Buchholz was a thief.
The defense puts forward other claims concerning testimony, which have been indicated during the week in testimony and by argument. The case is now substantially all with the jury. Neither side has yet requested the court to make any particular points in delivering the charge to the jury.
Waiting for the Verdict.
----------
The Buchholz Trial – Charge of the Chief Justice – The Case Given to the Jury About One O'clock P.M. – Locked up for the Night.
The jury in the Buchholz case were charged by Chief Justice Park yesterday morning. Judges Park and Loomis entered, the jury filed in, the clerk called the roll and the chief justice rose. The court room was packed. Intense interest was evinced.
Judge Park premising spoke of the case, its character and importance. The truth had been carefully sought. This was no place for vengeance nor for passion, neither for weakness or mistaken tenderness. The jury were appealed to to remember that duty was to govern. The chief justice then defined the different degrees of murder. This, he said, appeared to be a case of willful and premeditated murder, committed for the sake of robbery, and if that is so, it is a case of murder in the first degree. Who did the deed? No one saw the transaction. Circumstantial evidence comes into play. Judge Park read from printed slips ample explanations of the difference between circumstantial and direct evidence, following them up with the reading of authorities.
He said that in the law it made no difference as to the guilt of the accused whether he was alone in the commission of the deed or had a confederate. A case of circumstantial evidence tried in New Haven county was alluded to. Here the main evidence was a piece of steel that was found in the murdered man's skull and which fitted a nick in the knife of the accused. An extract from Wharton on criminal law was read to the jury to show that cases of conviction of innocent men, which may be read to the juries, should not frighten them from rendering a verdict of guilty.
At the request of the defense a number of charges were made: That juries were the judges of the law and fact. It is the province of the court to state its opinion on points of law and then submit both to the jury without any direction as to how the verdict shall be formed. Every man is presumed to be innocent until proven guilty. The burden of proof is upon the State. It is necessary for the State to make out a case of probable guilt and then call upon the prisoner to disprove it. In every case a good and sufficient indictment setting forth with certainty what it is proposed to prove is required. The name of the deceased is a material point. A mistake in the spelling is not material provided the sound of the name as given in the indictment is not different from that under which the deceased was known during his life. The deceased must be so described that there will be no possibility of mistaking him for any one else. The state claims that Johan in German is the same as John in English. If you find that the name in the indictment is the English of the name of the deceased, and that it was impossible to mistake him for any one else, there is no variance between the proof and the indictment. The facts used in an endeavor to show the innocence of the accused need not be as conclusive as those used in showing his guilt. By reasonable or rational doubt is meant when there is something that prevents an abiding conviction. It does not mean absolute certainty, nor an imaginary doubt. It means a doubt that the party entertaining it can give.
It is claimed that Buchholz was among those who knew that Schulte carried large amounts of money in his possession. He knew that he went to New York, and what train he was coming back upon. It is claimed that he was seldom out after dark, and that he was seldom away from home. He had about $70,000 upon his person the day of the murder. More than $50,000 of it was subsequently found to have been in the possession of the accused immediately after the murder. Some $20,000 was found upon the ground near the body. It is evident that the motive in the case was not malice, it was gain, and we should naturally expect that whoever did the horrible deed at all events got what he did the deed for. And who had the treasure afterward?
It is said that some $18,200 in bills with Schulte's mark upon them were traced to the accused. It is claimed by the defense that the money was given to him by Schulte on the night of the murder. That the prisoner had given him the money to keep when he first entered his employ. The State claims it was absurd that the deceased should have given the accused the money while on the way home in a dark night when he had only to wait a few minutes and both would have been home.
Judge Park then advanced the claim of the defense as to how Buchholz came into possession of the money when carrying the body from the woods, and said that the State claims this to have been impossible. The public prosecutor claims that it is improbable that the accused went away after the murder, leaving that large sum of money, which could have been found in a moment, and then return. "Go away," repeated the judge, "leaving that large sum of money – seventy thousand dollars – and then return," said Judge Park, slowly.
The prisoner has confessed to taking the money to Stark, but did not tell the detective – his best friend as he considered him – how he got it. But would he, knowing that he was suspected of murder, have told how he got it, if he was guilty of the murder. The defense claim that he did not act like a murderer. When he was going to the depot wanted Mrs. Waring to go, and did not have murder in his his heart then, think the defense. The State think that if Mr. Schulte had come up from New York on that day he would not have been murdered. The judge referred to many other points in the testimony, in most cases giving the strong points of the State. It was thought to be nothing against Abel that he stopped in a hotel a few days.
Chief Justice Park talked about two hours and a quarter. He concluded at one o'clock and a recess was taken for dinner until 2 p.m. The jury then retired and ate dinner in the court room.
The Jury Still Out.
The jury are reported to have asked for instructions at 7 o'clock. Later in the evening having given no further sign they were locked up for the night. Much interest prevailed in Bridgeport last evening over the case.
Still Waiting for the Verdict.
----------
The Jury in the Buchholz Case – Again Locked Up for the Night.
The people of Bridgeport found that the Buchholz jury were still deliberating yesterday morning. At 1 o'clock they had been out 24 hours, with nothing heard from them except that on Monday, after having been out three hours, they sent to the court a request for the map of the vicinity of the murder, which was denied them, it not having been sworn to under oath as perfect and correct. The jury were so informed. The jury have fifty-five exhibits before them for inspection. Buchholz sat during the latter portion of the afternoon busily engaged in reading a book handed him by Mr. Bollman, his counsel.
The spectators remained in force until between 5 and 6 o'clock, when they began dropping out one by one, and at 6 o'clock scarcely fifty remained. Soon after the supper hour the court room began to fill up with spectators, and at 8 o'clock every seat in the room was filled, and there was much talking and buzzing. Supper was taken in to the jury at about 9 o'clock. At 10 o'clock the court adjourned until 8 in the morning. Jailer Wells took the prisoner in charge and removed him to the jail for the night.
The jury were served with breakfast at 7 a. m. At 9 o'clock the court adjourned to the Court of Common Pleas room below, on account of the session of the Supreme Court of Errors, which came in at 9 o'clock in the Superior Court room. There were two courts in session yesterday in the room below, both being open at the same time, the Superior Court and the Court of Common Pleas. The most noticeable feature of the case is that although the Superior Court was in session in the Common Pleas room, the jury occupied their room above and the prisoner was kept under guard in the library room, so that the three most important bodies in the case were widely separated. At 1 o'clock the court took a recess until 2 o'clock. The general impression is that their deliberation will result in a disagreement.
The Jury Again Locked Up.
The jury were again locked up for the night at about 9 o'clock last evening, nothing new having been heard from them.
The Jury Still Out.
-----------
The Buchholz Case – A Hopeless Disagreement Reported – The Court Addresses and Sends Them Back – Locked Up Till Morning.
The jury in the Buchholz case at Bridgeport, upon the opening of the court yesterday morning, signified their intention of coming in to make a report. At half-past eight the judges having arrived the court was opened and the jury were notified and immediately filed into their seats, looking quite careworn and weary from the protracted session. Some five minutes elapsed before the arrival of the prisoner. He bowed to the judges as he took his seat and then scanned the faces of the jurors. The clerk called the roll, each juror rising as he answered to his name. The clerk then inquired:
"Gentlemen of the jury have you agreed upon a verdict?" The foreman replied, "We have not."
Judge Park – "Is there any question that you wish to ask of the court?"
Foreman – "I don't know of any."
Judge Park – "What is the possibility of your coming to an agreement?"
Foreman – "I don't think there is any. I know there is none."
The court then held a short consultation together, when Judge Park addressed the jury and briefly rehearsed some of the strong points of his charge.
Gen. Smith then asked the court to charge the jury in reference to any doubt they may have that they give the prisoner the benefit of it. The jury were so charged.
Mr. Morehouse, one of the jurors, then asked what weight they were to place upon the testimony of Dr. Treadwell.
Judge Park said: You are to decide the credibility of the witness by his appearance upon the stand, whether you believe what he says or not, whether he is a willing witness, is bound to tell all he knows and more too, or whether he is careful and guarded in his testimony, telling only the facts as he believes them to be.
Foreman – Have we the right to bring in a verdict in the second degree if not in the first.
Judge Park – Certainly, that is a question of fact left entirely with the jury.
The jury then retired and the court took a recess until a quarter before 2 o'clock.
After the noon recess, word was brought to the judges by the sheriff that the jury were no nearer an agreement, and the court ordered a recess till 8 o'clock. The room was then cleared.
The Jury Still Out.
By the midnight train we receive the news that the jury were again locked up last evening for the night. It is now generally expected that the jury will again report a hopeless disagreement, and that the court will be obliged to discharge them.
Editorial Notes.
The net result of the two trials of Buchholz is highly encouraging to those who intend or may hereafter intend to commit murder. Connecticut justice, as administered by juries in murder trials, is almost invariably a farce.
Buchholz's Third Chance.
----------
The Jury Finally Dismissed – A Wearied Party – Sixty-Eight Hours of Contention and Fifty-Eight Ballots – Time for Another Trial Set Down.
The Buchholz jury at last came in not to return to the jury room. Amid great suspense in the court room, which was crowded, with an eager throng, they reported to the court yesterday morning an utter failure to come to any agreement and were called in and discharged. They had been out sixty-eight hours and looked weary and chafed.
One report says the jury came the nearest to an agreement Wednesday afternoon, and that they then stood nine for murder in the first degree, two for second degree and one for acquittal. Previous to Judge Parks's second charge the state of the balloting was variable enough. Fifty-eight ballots were taken. The first of all stood, it is said, ten for first degree, one for second degree and one for acquittal. The jury were out 68 hours. Buchholz was looked at with great interest to see how he would take the news, no doubt very agreeable to a man in his unenviable situation. To the general disappointment he manifested no particular emotion, nor was any marked facial change exhibited. This was too disappointing to such as had looked for something dramatic. He had evidently pretty much made up his mind that the jury wasn't going to hang him, and that he was going to have another bout with the law. He has been an object of some interest to some of the fair sex of Bridgeport, and bouquets were sent him with gilt-edged cards attached at both of his trials. There have been many hundreds of spectators attracted to the court room at both trials, and whether Buchholz in his third trial will draw as well remains to be seen. The prosecuting attorney, Mr. Olmstead, wanted another trial right away. General Smith wanted a little breathing spell, and besides was on the track of new evidence. The indefatigable Mr. Olmstead pressed, however, for an early date, and gave as one reason that he feared one witness would have to be let off soon to go to South America. Finally the date of commencing the new trial, which the court had ordered, upon motion was fixed for April 13.
They Took a Ride.
The jury consoled themselves for their confinement in the interests of justice by coming to an agreement of one kind. In this they all joined heartily. It was to pay a visit to the jail together. They were driven up to the institution at about two o'clock in one of Bridgeport's famous big busses. The jailor showed them around and they stayed about an hour surveying the institution.