Coverage of the first trial of William Bucholz for the murder of John Henry Schulte, in the New Haven Evening Register, September and October 1879.
As an evening paper, the Register occasionally reprinted articles from the previous day's third edition, along with the current day's article. In those cases I've kept all the articles, even when they overlap.
This paper has a surprisingly large number of errors in it -- spelling errors, grammar errors, structural problems in the paper itself. As a rule I've tried to keep this as written, but I couldn't help myself from fixing some of the more egregious and unambiguous errors. Of course other errors might be mine, so please contact me if you see any mistakes.
The Norwalk Gazette says: "Last week an old, dried up and almost unrecognizable outside cover to a large breast pocket book was discovered sticking into the stone wall near the place of Schulte's murder. It is not positively known yet that it was the property of the murdered man, but it is quite certain that it has been placed in the wall since the murder."
THE SCHULTE TRAGEDY.
----------
TRIAL OF THE ALLEGED MURDERER.
----------
Continuation of the Proceedings at Bridgeport To-Day – A Mass of Testimony to Prove the Murder and Finding of the Body.
BRIDGEPORT, September 10. – To-day is the second of the trial of William Buchholz, the young German who is charged with having murdered Johan Henry Schulte, a German miser who was killed in the woods below South Norwalk depot on the night of 27th of December in a very mysterious manner. The accused during the hearing occupied a seat in the prisoner's box and listened very attentively to the story of the tragedy as detailed by the witnesses. He was very neatly and plainly dressed and acted rather like an interested spectator than a man who was on trial for his life. The interests of the state rest in the hands of State's Attorney Olmstead and Nelson Taylor. jr., and the accused has his rights looked after by General William Randall Smith, C. F. Ballman of New Haven and A. E. Austin of South Norwalk.
Thus far the trial, which State's Attorney Olmstead has promised shall be one of the most exciting and interesting that has ever taken place in the state, has been a very commonplace affair, all of the witnesses examined thus far having been called to show that Schultz was murdered, that Buchholz was with him on the night of the murder, and gave the alarm. The sensational accounts in the case will appear later in the hearing and the state's attorney promises they shall be decidedly sensational and tend to fix the guilt on the accused to a certainty. There has not been a very large attendance in court thus far and but little interest is manifested in it, judging by this fact. The principal features of the court-room are the striped shirts that Gen. Smith of the counsel for the defense wears so gracefully, the number of gray beards who crowd the space allotted to the members of the bar and reporters, and the presence of a tow-headed young limb of the law, who has a pair of eye-glasses jauntily pinched on his nose, and who in the intervals between reading the papers he borrowed, passed his time in sleeping, his attitudes creating much amusement by the lookers-on.
Annie Waring, a daughter of the woman with whom Schulte lived, was the first witness called, and testified that Schulte had never been out of the house after dark, and that all of his habits were strange and peculiar. Detective Bergher, who figured prominently in the preliminary hearing at South Norwalk, was called, and read from a diary which had belonged to Buchholz, the sentence: "I will leave Schulte on the 20th of January, 1879."
The next witness and one whose examination direct and cross occupied nearly two hours, was Sam Waring, one who testified in relation to the news of the murder which Buchholz brought to the house, the actions of the accused and the search for a discovery of the body. Waring was first made aware of something unusual by his mother calling to him, and subsequently by Buchholz himself calling "Sammy, Sammy." He went to the door and Buchholz, looking very terrified, came into the room, and as he came in dropped a satchel on the floor, and then told him that Schulte and he had been attacked and Schulte murdered. Buchholz wanted assistance to go and look for the body. Waring accordingly got a gun and pistol, giving the latter to Buchholz, and as they got ready to go Buchholz seemed to be overcome and fell from his chair in a sort of half fainting fit to the floor. When they got ready to start Buchholz seemed unwilling that Waring should accompany him, though he said nothing of the kind. After leaving the house they went to Mr. Alling's [Allen’s], a neighbor's, Mr. Ireland's and to other places, giving the alarm and summoning a party. At Alling's they got a lantern and then with others went to the woods. On arrival there saw the ham that Schulte had been carrying lying on the ground, a lot of papers scattered about, and a book that looked like a small dictionary. When he saw the body there was a red handkerchief about his neck which partially covered his face. One of the pockets of the deceased was turned inside out. Everything was left as witness and his associates found them, and he and Buchholz started for Norwalk to notify the authorities. On the way to the town Buchholz had no conversation of any consequence with him, and they hardly exchanged a word, saying nothing whatever about the murder. Neither did Buchholz allude to the wounds on his face, until they got to South Norwalk, when he went into Stillson's drug store and had the wounds dressed by being bound up with plasters. Even then he gave no explanation as to how he received the wounds. The witness then identified the clothing found on the ground and in the bundle as belonging to Schulte the murdered man. The cross-examination which was long, tedious and uninteresting, as it developed no new points on the case, which were of importance, and if the General, who is doing the cross-examination continues to pursue such a course, the dramatic trial which Mr. Olmsted expects will be considerably marred by his examinations. Points brought out in this examination, which are considered of importance, are the facts that a Mr. Ireland, who was applied to, to go and assist in the search refused to do so for some reason unknown. Mrs. Waring was the one who notified the Allens that Schulte had been murdered in the woods, when Buchholz and the Waring family went up to Allen's to notify him. There was also shown a pair of drawers which had been found in the bushes near the locality where the murder was committed, and which have not yet appeared in any of the hearings. Those are supposed to have belonged to Schulte. Late in the cross-examination Waring admitted that while he was handling Schulte's body and while he and Buchholz were on their way down town, Buchholz did talk to him occasionally, but it was in such broken English that he could not understand fully what it was. The witness made a number of contradictory statements as to whether he touched the body when he first found it or not, though he was rather inclined to think that while he was bending over he might have touched it on the breast.
Dudley P. Ely, ex-mayor of Norwalk, and connected with the First National bank, was called a little out of the regular order, as he was unwell, and anxious to return home. A $20 bill was shown the witness, which was taken from the clerk of the court. This was identified by him, as having been received December 31, 1878, in the evening, from Paul Hercher. This bill was marked by him on that evening "D. P. E.", and by that he recognized the bill, which went out of his hands only into those of the grand jury. On the cross-examination it came out that the money was given to him by Mr. Hercher for rent, among other moneys. This bill was marked 380-110, which was what called Mr. Ely's attention to the bill. It will be remembered that this was the manner in which Schulte's money was marked.
Delazon Allen was the next witness and testified to the visit of the Warings to his house on the night of Schulte's murder, informing him of the crime that had been committed. He started out with a party to find the body, and ten rods from the house met Sammy Waring and Buchholz running down to meet him. Buchholz, when he arrived at the house, appeared exhausted, leaned his head on his arms, groaned and appeared faint, calling for water. Buchholz, when he came into the house by invitation, sank down into a chair. Witness examined the wounds on Buchholz's face, and found a number of scratches of no depth, from which blood had flowed, but at the time of the examination it was perfectly dry, and did not seem to be of such a character as to warrant so much fuss, as the witness thought. After Buchholz had somewhat recovered the party went to the spot where the body was found.
THE SCHULTE TRAGEDY.
----------
THE THIRD DAY OF THE TRIAL.
-----------
Tell-Tale Footprints in Blood in Mrs. Waring's Kitchen – Tracing Schulte's Money into the Possession of Buchholz – Weaving the Web of Evidence.
BRIDGEPORT, September 11. – Our report yesterday closed with Edward Hoyt on the stand. He had testified to finding a silver watch under a tree on the highway to South Norwalk, which was Schulte's property and which it is supposed was thrown where found, by Buchholz on the night of the murder.
On the cross examination witness stated that the party certainly stopped under the tree where the watch was found, he thought to await the arrival of Tom Ireland to reinforce the party. He did not see Buchholz throw anything on the ground, though Buchholz might have done so, as it was too dark to see.
Sam Ireland, whose rich brogue as well as his name indicates his nationality, told of the summons he received to go in search of the body, and how he followed the crowd a part way to where the body lay and from there going to the town of South Norwalk to notify the authorities of the murder, in response to a request made either by Buchholz or Sammy Waring. On the cross-examination this witness contradicted Hoyt by saying that he met the crowd at a barn before they reached the tree where the watch was found, and that they then continued from there to the spot where the body lay without stopping at the hickory tree, as Hoyt had said they did.
Tom Ireland also told the story of the summons he received to go and join the party who were looking for the murdered man. The story is the same that all the rest have told, that Buchholz was nervous and excited and had blood on his face. When he came out of the house he saw Buchholz standing in the path about twenty yards from the tree under which the watch was found. He seemed to be coming down from the direction of the tree where the watch was toward the party who were going in search of the body. Sam Waring called to Buchholz to wait for them and they caught up with him where he was standing alone in the middle of the road between the two barns.
Gustavus Headstrom testified to finding the watch while he was at work haying for Mr. Hoyt. It was lying but three or four feet from the highway and about the same distance from the trunk of the tree. Snow had been gone from the ground for not over a week when the watch was found.
Paul Hercher, who keeps a saloon opposite the depot in South Norwalk, testified to an acquaintance with both Schulte and Buchholz, and told some of the stories that Buchholz had told of troubles he had had with Schulte. One one occasion the two had a quarrel during meal-time about the victuals, which resulted in Schulte's drawing a pistol on him. At another time Buchholz had interfered in a quarrel which Mrs. Waring and Schulte had had over coal. Buchholz told witness that Schulte had a large amount of money, which he kept in a trunk in his room. Buchholz had told witness that owing to quarrels between them Schulte had said he should discharge him (Buchholz). Witness then detailed the visit of Buchholz to his saloon on the day of the murder, while he was waiting for the arrival of Schulte from New York. When he found that Schulte would not be up from New York until 6:11, Buchholz said, "Well, it will be quite dark then. I am sorry I did not bring my revolver with me, for the tramps that hang about the house are very annoying." Buchholz continued by saying he had been accosted by them a number of times and had paid a considerable tribute to them in cigars and tobacco. When Schulte reached Norwalk he went into the saloon kept by witness and drank some beer. Buchholz was called in and was invited to drink by Schulte. After this the parties went down the railroad track toward Schulte's home. The morning after the murder Buchholz came into the saloon of witness at 8 o'clock and talked with witness about the murder of Schulte. Buchholz showed the wounds on his face and said he thought the wounds were made by the ends of twisted wire. As Buchholz turned to go out of the back deor he asked witness the name of the man who had warned him to be careful of the tramps near Waring's. Witness followed Buchholz out of the door, in response to a wink and motion of the head which Buchholz made. Once out of doors Buchholz handed witness a roll of bills, $200, requesting witness to care for it until the accused could make his report to the coroner. Witness made a remark imparting that the money must have been given to Buchholz by Schulte while the two were on their way to the scene of the murder. To this Buchholz said nothing. Hercher took the money, all $20 bills, and got one of them changed at the depot. Witness on the following Wednesday gave Buchholz $40, as he wished it to go to New York and pay a bill at the Sonne hotel. The $140 remaining was given to G. C. Stillson, who was foreman of the coroner's jury. On Saturday night, the day after the murder, he received the $20 bill which has been shown (in court) by Dudley P. Ely, on Wednesday morning, from Buchholz, in payment of a bill, and that particular bill, which was marked with a private mark "880-110," he gave to Mr. Ely. That mark made him look at the bills which Buchholz subsequently gave him, and all of them had this private series mark, the first of the class marks being "380." Buchholz got $40 from him, in order to get a money order, which he claimed was waiting for him in the Sonne hotel, New York city. Before Schulte's death, Buchholz had told witness that Schulte owed him money, and would go to New York about Christmas, and get some large bills changed and then pay him what he owed. Just after that Buchholz came to him and tried to borrow some money so he could go to New York and get some money from a man to whom he had given $600, for the purpose of having it banked. A week after the murder Buchholz came into the saloon of the witness and stated that his friends were going back on him, and he hoped witness would not do so, but would say, if any one asked him when Buchholz gave him the money that it was in September, October or November. Buchholz told him if he would do so he would give him all the money that he (witness) had in his possession ($130), and one-tenth, or ten per cent, and then Buchholz laughed as though the matter was a jest, but would say nothing more. Witness afterward saw Buchholz and asked him what he meant by the ten per cent that he spoke of and Buchholz said that he had received $300 from his sister in Germany, which he would give witness if he would not give away the time when Buchholz gave him the money. A week from the Sunday after the murder the accused asked witness if Berque [Berger] (the constable) or any of his relatives kept horses, as they had bought a pile of hay down at Mrs. Waring's. On that day he offered to take witness to Australia with him, saying the cost of passage there would be only $300 or $400 each and the same amount to stay there. After the talk about the testimony in regard to the morning he had given witness. Buchholz had said to him, "Stick by me to-day, for I think it will go hard with me before the jury." Later the witness saw the prisoner in the superior court room in Bridgeport and he told Buchholz that the authorities had received a telegram from his sister, saying she had never sent him any money. Buchholz said he knew she hadn't. Again he saw him at the jail and told him about the finding of Schulte's watch under a tree where he (Buchholz) had stood on the night of the murder. Buchholz said he remembered standing at the tree while the party went to call Tom Ireland, but that he knew nothing whatever about the watch, nor how it came where it was found. He said he would come out all right at the trial, even if the watch was found.
On the cross-examination he said he had been in business in Norwalk since April, 1869, and that he continued in business until February of this year. At the time of his testimony before the coroner's jury there was a case pending against him in the superior court of that county. This case has been thrown out of court since that time. Witness acknowledged that when the case against him was thrown out, Mr. Olmstead had told him he did so because he had gone out of the business, had behaved himself pretty well, and had done some service to the state in serving as a witness in the Buchholz case. Counsel then made a long cross-examination covering the points already brought out in the direct examination, with no new features of any importance, This lasted until adjournment at 6 o'clock, and the cross-examination will be continued tomorrow.
TO-DAY'S HEARING.
BRIDGEPORT, September 11. – The third day's hearing in the Buchholz case attracted more interest than have either of the two preceding days, if the attendance in the court room can be taken as a criterion. The hearing is going forward more rapidly than it has hitherto, as the cross-examination is not covering so many unimportant points as on yesterday, when the impression went out that the defense was purposely dragging the examination, in order to gain time for some strategetic movement which it has been intimated they will make at the proper time to counteract the state's dramatic effect.
The first witness this morning was George C. Stillson of Norwalk, a druggist, who knew both Schulte and Buchholz by sight. An old brush was introduced in testimony which witness had found lying on the ground a short distance from where the body of the murdered man was found on Sunday after the murder. A map of the locality where the murder was committed was also introduced by the state, and another by the counsel for the defense, the latter being the more elaborate. After an examination of the maps Mr. Stillson resumed his testimony and said that shortly after the murder Buchholz came into his store and tried to describe a pocket hair brush such as he wished to purchase. From his description witness thought Buchholz wanted a brush similar to the one shown in court and which witness had in his possession at that time. Witness also found a revolver, a paper of tacks, a diary and a bunch of keys, which had belonged to Schulte and which opened his trunks and a safe which had been in his room at the Waring's house. In the trunk was found a box of cartridges. Witness also found a shingle standing against a stone wall, which had been used as a target to shoot at. During the cross-examination it came out that Schulte had on the night of the murder crossed over a brook before he reached the spot where his body was found. On the stepping stones in this brook which he had crossed on, there were seen by the witness several drops of blood which seemed to be comparatively fresh when he saw them, on the day after the murder. On the re-direct examination witness said he examined the wounds on Buchholz's face and found them to be very slight.
Henry O. Koenig, a reporter of the New York Staats Zeitung, said that on the 6th of January, he had a conversation with Buchholz, in which the accused told him that the money given to Hercher, was some that Schulte had handed to him done up in a piece of paper, and that he did not know the amount, as he did not count it over for some time. The witness had, during the testimony, refreshed his memory from the memoranda he had made immediately after a conversation with Buchholz. This memoranda, it was found on examination, was printed slips of the newspaper he represented, and counsel for the defense moved to strike out all the testimony, but as Mr. Koenig remembered Buchholz's story independent of the notes, the evidence was admitted.
Siegfried Grümewald, a boy of 17 or 18, who came to this country as a servant of Schulte, met Buchholz in New York, told him that Schulte was a rich man and Buchholz told him he was foolish to leave Schulte and that if he (Buchholz) was in his (Grümewald's) place he would do different. Witness told Buchholz that Schulte carried his money in his coat pocket, and Buchholz then said he would like to go with Schulte, and if he did he would pursue a different course from that followed by the witness.
The witness whose testimony at the coroner's inquest had been so damaging to Buchholz seems this morning to be a very unwilling witness, and after Mr. Olmstead had tried in vain to get the old story out of him, he stopped questioning the witness through the interpreter and asked:
"Have you been talking with Mr. Bollman or Buchholz this morning?"
"No, sir," replied the lad, and a pause ensued.
Mr. Olmstead hesitated a moment and then asked: "Did you have a conversation with Mr. Bollman last evening after the court had adjourned?"
"Yes, sir.”
That settled it, and from this on he was treated by the state as an unwilling witness.
From the answers fairly wrenched from him it appeared that Buchholz once said to witness if he was in his (Grümewald's) place he would some night snatch Schulte's coat with the money in the pocket and get away with it. Witness identified the watch which had been found on the highway some distance from the scene of the murder. He also identified a cord and keys as the property of Schulte, which were usually attached to the watch. On the cross-examination witness stated that Schulte's wealth was generally known about the Sonne hotel in New York city, and people living there had advised witness to leave Schulte because of his singular habits.
Otto Schewetzky, bar-tender at the Sonne hotel, New York, knew both Schulte and Buchholz. The latter had a trunk at the hotel which was marked "Adelaide, via San Francisco," and he thought was so marked when it came to the hotel. At one time Berger of Norwalk gave to him a couple of bills which witness gave to the proprietor of the hotel. The lines were marked with figures in ink. The question: What were these figures was objected to by the counsel for the defense, and while the judges were considering its admissibility the witness was withdrawn by the counsel for the state.
Lester C. Smith was called to identify a small iron box that was produced in court, which was found in Schulte's safe in the office of the Norwalk savings bank. Mayor Walter C. Quintard of South Norwalk one of the executors of the estate of the murdered man opened the box, and a paper was taken out which. was offered to show that the box belonged to Schulte, and as a record of his accounts. The paper was in German, and before being produced the jury were required to retire from the room to await the result of the examination by the judges. General Smith objected to the introduction of a written declaration by a third party, it being evidence of a party who cannot be cross examined, and is therefore simply hearsay evidence. The court ruled that the proposed evidence was inadmissible as it was only a record of lands that Schulte had owned, and was therefore in the nature of hearsay evidence.
George La Croix of Westport testified that on the first Sunday in January the prisoner, in company with two or three others, came to his hotel. The party had some oysters and cigars which Buchholz paid for, giving him in payment a new $50, which bill he gave to Mr. Charles Smith, executor on the Schulte estate. The bill was produced in court and identified by the numbers on it by the witness. On the cross-examination he said he was induced to take the bill and change it by Hercher and Berger who motioned to him to take it and change it.
Charles W. Smith, executor on the Schulte estate, also identified the bill.
Yesterday’s Third Edition
The Schulte Murder.
----------
Charles W. Smith, executor on the Schulte estate, also identified the bill.
Edward Berger testified that he saw Buchholz pass a $50 bill at La Croix. He was then a detective in charge of the prisoner and was also a member of the coroner's jury. The prisoner was put into his charge on Saturday, the day after the murder, and witness slept with him in the Waring house that night, nailing up the windows in the prisoner's room.
Franklin A. Tolles testified to finding a pistol, which looked like a pepper-box, lying a short distance from Schulte's body on the day after the murder. A pair of pantaloons found in Buchholz's room were shown and witness testified he discovered blood on the legs. They were taken from Buchholz's room two or three days after the murder.
Victor Rohe, a New York confectioner, first met Buchholz in August of last year, the day after his arrival from Europe. Three weeks afterward Buchholz asked witness to loan him some money, on the strength of a promise to repay him when he received a remittance from Germany. Buchholz had spoken to witness about a difficulty he had with Schulte some time after he went into Schulte's employ, about the domestic affairs, in which Schulte thought Buchholz had not used him exactly right. The last time he saw Buchholz before the murder was on the day before Thanksgiving when he tried to borrow $20 or $25 from witness, who did not however, give it to him. The cross-examination was conducted by C. F. Bollman, who elicited from the witness the fact that Buchholz at one time gave him $80 to put in the bank. Buchholz came to this country with a brother of the witness, but witness knew nothing of the statement that the prisoner had $300.
This closed the testimony during the morning session, and the court then took a recess for dinner, preparatory to the long afternoon session.
At the afternoon session, A. E. Austin, of the counsel for the defense, was called by the state, and said he had been retained by the defense, and appealed to the court to be protected and not compelled to testify, as he knew nothing of the case except what he learned as an attorney. Mr. Olmstead asked the witness if he had received money from Buchholz. The witness refused to answer, and there was a lively dispute between Mr. Olmstead and Mr. Smith, the former insisting that he had a right to know if Buchholz had paid him any money, while the latter held that as counsel for the defense the state had no right to demand of him any of the confidential communications he may have received from his client. The state claimed that if the prisoner had given to the witness $10,000 or any other sum, and counsel for the defense claimed that the prisoner could not obtain immunity, by the counsel claiming it was a retainer.
Ernest Stark of Philadelphia, one of the Pinkerton detectives, said he first became acquainted with Buchholz in the jail in Bridgeport, and had made certain confessions and admissions to him, though at the first conversation he made no admission that was connected with the murder. Witness said he had known Buchholz three weeks or so before the two made any reference to the Schulte matter. He is still on the stand testifying, and this confession is to be the sensation of the trial. It is understood that it will certainly prove Buchholz's guilt. The detective said that Buchholz had talked very freely with him about the money he had in his possession which bore Schulte's marks and which had been in Schulte's possession on the day of the murder. At this hour he has not told how Buchholz got possession of it, but will do so later.
Second Edition
BUCHHOLZ'S TONGUE
----------
LEADING HIM TO THE GALLOWS.
----------
A Story Stranger Than Any Romance Told by a Detective – Locked in Jail With Schulte's Murderer He Wins His Confidence, Worms Out His Secret, and Recovers the Stolen Money.
BRIDGEPORT, September 11. – Emile Gaboriau, the great French novelist, whose stories all hinge on the work of detectives, and all of which are very cleverly constructed, finds a rival on this side of the big pond in States Attorney Olmstead, of Fairfield county, who is now slowly unfolding one of the most wonderful stories in relation to the unearthing of crime that this country has ever had. Gaboriau's work is that of a wonderful literateur, who depends on a vivid imagination, joined with marvellous descriptive capacity and a facile pen. His detectives are the creatures of his brain. Mr. Olmstead writes his novel in open court, and his detective wit his story of real life, is a thing of flesh and blood, who calmly tells from the witness stand a story that has perhaps no equal in all the books of romance. In a novel it would read splendidly. In real life it seems too strange to be true. And yet at every step of the tragic story of murder for hope of gain, rise the naked facts undisputable which stare William Buchholz in the face, and throw over him the shadow of the gallows, apparently bringing the fatal noose more and more to the man about whom the web of circumstantial and positive evidence is closing, like a net-work, from whose narrow meshes there can be no escape. As Ernest Stark, the detective, stands in the witness stand telling this seemingly fatal story, with a face perfectly immobile, so that it seem as if he were a speaking statue, there sits in the witness stand the man about whom this network of evidence is being woven; another living statue who, with arms folded, cheeks blanched and eyes looking straight forward – at times as if gazing into vacancy, and then, as if he saw the shadow of impending fate – seems an object of pity, for there on the stand is the man whom he had trusted as a brother, revealing the secrets of his innermost heart, but who was building a gibbet whereon to hang his confidant. It is a sad spectacle, as well as one intensely dramatic, and there is little wonder that while Ernest Stark was telling his story this afternoon there was a silence reigning in the court-room that was oppressive and could almost be felt. Truly States Attorney Olmstead has given to the public the most sensational case in the annals of criminal jurisprudence in this country. It is positively startling, and the means used to attain the end show the marks of a man of genius, who, once on a criminal's track, will follow him to the death, in order that justice may be done.
The hero in this drama is Ernest Stark, a handsome looking man of thirty five years, German by birth, and whose face and head give evidence of intelligence, and no clue whatever to the profession that the owner follows. In March last Stark came to Bridgeport. and assuming the name of Edward Summers, went to the office of the Adams Express company in that city with a forged order for a money package that had been sent to another address. The company had been notified by telegraph from New York not to deliver the package, but to arrest the party who should call for it. When he went to the office with his forged order he was accordingly arrested, and when brought before the city court was bound over for trial under $500 bonds, his defense being so weak, and his stories so contradictory that it was decided that he must be guilty. All of this was done in good faith and no one of the officials, save State's Attorney Olmstead knew that the whole thing was a "put up job" planned by Allan Pinkerton's detectives with the consent of Mr. Olmstead and the German consul-general, to enable one of their men to get into the jail and worm himself into the confidence of William Buchholz, charged with the murder of John Heinrich Schulte at Norwalk, December 27, 1878. For two months Ed Summers, as he was called, remained in the jail, lodged in a cell, ate prison fare and seemed a man without a friend in the world. He was looked upon by jailor and prisoners as a criminal, associated with criminals, and acted like one being as they are despondent and hopeful at intervals, and talking as they do with one another about the offences with which they are charged. None knew him as Ernest Stark, one of Pinkerton's ablest detectives, who because of this experience in jail has now become one of the most famous detectives in the country. When his name was called in court this afternoon, no one knew who Ernest Stark, was, but when he stepped into the court-room all of the color left Buchholz's face, his eyes dropped, and his features assumed the color and rigidity of those of a marble statue. He knew Ernest Stark, but knew him better as Edward Summers, in whom he had reposed his utmost confidence, and as the one man who could reveal his cherished secret. Cold sweat stood on his brow and the tear sparkled in his eye, but Buchholz is a man of wonderful nerve, and this agitation was over in an instant and but for the death-like pallor, no one would know that Buchholz feared his testimony more than that of any other man.
When Stark took the witness stand he said he was from Philadelphia and was one of Allan Pinkerton's detectives and went to the county jail as a prisoner, where he first formed the acquaintance of Buchholz, the accused. He had known Buchholz for two or three weeks before any allusion whatever was made to the murder of Schulte or his connection with it. The subject, when it came to be alluded to, was first spoken of by Buchholz, and the detective in disguise advised Buchholz not to say anything about the matter to any one but his counsel, refusing at first to have anything to say about it, or hold any conversation about the murder, of which he professed to be profoundly ignorant. He advised Buchholz not to trust him (the witness) as they were perfect strangers and he might betray him. But Buchholz took a particular fancy to the witness, visited him in his cell and used his small kerosene stove to make his coffee on. A kind of friendship grew up between them, growing out of the fact that both were Germans and both suffering imprisonment for crimes of which they protested their innocence. Finally, Buchholz forced the story of the crime with which he was charged on the witness; he began to talk about it, cautiously and in an apparently uninterested manner. Buchholz said suspicion had been directed toward him because he was a servant of the deceased and was with him on the night of the murder. Then the witness bewailed the ill fortune that kept him in jail, because he could not get the $500 bail that was necessary. Buchholz sympathized with him and then said that on the night of the murder the two had been attacked by a party of tramps just as they got over the second fence on their way home. He then detailed to witness the wounds on Schulte's head, and the finding of Schulte's property, with which our readers are familiar. Buchholz said he only recognized one of the assailants, a man about his own size who wore a black silk cap. When the money that Buchholz had had was talked about he told witness several stories as to how he came to have it in his possession, the stories being contradictory, though the principal burden of the theme was that Schulte gave it to him. Buchholz told witness that he had lied at the coroner's jury when he said he got the money from his sister and that he never received anything from her. Witness then told Buchholz that he had heard in jail from a newly-arrived prisoner that the watch that Schulte wore on the night of the murder, had been found, where he, Buchholz, had thrown it. Buchholz said the finding of the watch wouldn't affect him and would make no difference in the case. He said no one knew Schulte's watch but he himself, but that if the watch found was Schulte's he could tell it, if he could once see it. Witness then began to sympathize with Buchholz, and Buchholz returned the sympathy, saying he would do what he could to get his counsel, Mr. Bollman, to work in his (witness's) behalf. He introduced witness to Mr. Bollman, whom witness then engaged as his counsel, Buchholz offering to become surety for the payment of the fees necessary. Buchholz was anxious witness should get bail, get outside and work for him, offering to give him $500 if he would go to South Norwalk in his interest and see several people, particularly Paul Hercher, the liquor dealer, whose testimony he desired to have shaken. He said he would furnish witness money to buy Hercher up and send him out of the country. Buchholz told witness that when he first saw him he thought he was a detective, but that further acquaintance had reassured him and he thought witness was a true friend and one who could be trusted. and he so assured Mr. Bollman, who finally fully agreed with Buchholz. Buchholz told witness he would get some one to go bail for him, and witness agreed that if he should do so he would go to Norwalk and live and work for Buchholz, in return for which Buchholz was to give him some money and take him to Europe with him, where both would live together like brothers on the fat of the land. Witness asked where the money for all this was to come from, and Buchholz said that Schulte's brother was coming from Germany and would take him (Buchholz) back with him, make him overseer of the Schulte estate, and finally give him $60,000 or $70,000. One day, when Buchholz was very despondent, witness tried to cheer him up and told him he should keep up good spirits as he had in the past. Buchholz said all his appearance of calmness was put on, and that he was very uncomfortable, although this did not arise from a trouble of conscience. During their confidence a coolness, which lasted for several days, came up between them, and a renewal of their friendship (?) was brought about by the witness receiving a letter from Buchholz, to which he replied. One day Buchholz came to witness' cell and said he wished he was able to be out of the prison for one night. He said he would give $500 or $5,000 to be out one night and would then "lift Schulte's treasure," the whereabouts of which was his secret. Buchholz was very friendly and said if he was out only one night he could get all the money he and witness would ever want. Buchholz said six hours would suffice for him to get the money and release witness on bail. He said he would come back, as he would not dare to run away for detectives would follow him. Buchholz said that Schulte used to carry his pocketbooks in his inside coat pockets, and also used to wear a leather belt about his waist. He further said there was left on Schulte's body $20,000 in the belt and $3,000 in a roll in his vest pocket. On the day after this conversation Buchholz again referred to his secret, and witness said it was a shame for them to be confined when there was so much money that could be obtained. He then told witness where Schulte kept his money which was all in 1,000 mark notes. Buchholz one night discovered Schulte in his room counting over his money, which he kept in a hole in the floor, entrance to the hole being effected by means of a trap-door which opened with a spring. In them it was stated there was a tin box containing $60,000. A friend of the witness, another detective, was proposed by the witness as a fit one to whom to entrust the secret and allow him to go and get the money and help them both. Buchholz refused, but told witness if he got a life sentence he would tell the witness the hiding place, and make him a present of the money as it would be of no value to him (Buchholz). Later Buchholz said there was one trouble about the money and that was that it was all marked in ink by Schulte and would consequently be hard to dispose of. He said the rest of the money was marked the same as that he took from Schulte's pocketbook. Buchholz wrote down some numbers on a piece of paper one afternoon and said to witness, "If Olmstead saw those figures he would know what they meant." Witness did not remember what the figures were. Buchholz told witness that the money he gave to Hercher was all right, as it had been paid to him by Schulte on the night of the murder. Witness was released from jail on bail May 13, and went back to the jail to call on Buchholz and told him that the Warings proposed to move, as they said the neighbors annoyed them by intimating that they were implicated in the murder. At this time Buchholz said he would tell witness where a portion of the money was hidden. At the same time witness told Buchholz he would be able to take ink marks out of the money by the use of acids. Buchholz hesitated for some time and finally said, one of the pocketbooks is in the barn, and made a sketch of the barn to show witness where it was hidden, on the fly-leaf of a little vocabulary he had in his pocket. Buchholz said the pocket book would be found in the first stall in the barn, on the right side of the stall, as one enters the barn from the Waring's house, and was under the floor. Buchholz said he did not know how much money there was in it, but he thought there was about $600, enough to pay his lawyers, Austin and Smith, and he thought Bollman could wait. It would look bad to have Mr. Smith go out of the case, and so he would have to be paid. On the Sunday morning after the murder, Buchholz told the witness he went to the barn to get his pocketbook that he had hidden in the straw. At first he didn't find it and he was very much frightened, but he finally discovered it and it seemed like a gleam of sunshine breaking through the clouds. He took some $50 and $100 bills out of the pocket-book and afterward put a portion of it back again, and told witness he should never have given any of it to Hercher or any else if he had known it was marked. In talking about counsel. he said if he had had Mr. Bollman as counsel to begin with, instead of Mr. Austin, he would not have been in jail. Buchholz then said to witness, "While you are there you might as well get" – and then, stopping suddenly, added, "but never mind, it's too high up.” Then Buchholz told him the best way to get to and into the barn to get the money. Witness promised to take the money to New York and there remove the ink-marks with the acids. The pocketbook was to be dropped by the witness where it would be picked up and tend to throw suspicion on some one else. This conversation was on the 24th of May, and on the 26th witness and John Curtin, another detective, left Bridgeport and went to South Norwalk, going to the scene of the Schulte murder. Curtin took a place under a tree and witness at once went to the barn and to the stall where Buchholz said he would find the pocketbook. There the witness found the pocketbook as Buchholz said he would do. In the book they found a sum of money which they put into an envelope. He then walked to Five-Mile-River and sent a dispatch to Mr. Pinkerton and took the next train to New York, reporting to the office of the detective agency, where he delivered up the property to the German consul, Dr. Schmecker, who examined the pocketbook in the presence of the witness, and found in it $4,737. On the next day witness came back to Bridgeport and brought back with him $350, which he gave to Buchholz in the presence of Mr. Bollman, the money to be used by Bollman in going to Europe. At this time Buchholz drew up a note for 1,500 marks, which he was to give witness, but Bollman took it away and tore Buchholz's name out of it. When witness paid the money to Buchholz in Bollman's presence he said it was not the Schulte money, but some he had borrowed from a friend, as he had been unable to get the ink-marks out of the money that was found in the barn. Two weeks ago, when Bollman returned from Europe, witness saw him in Buchholz's cell, and Bollman explained that he had got some money from Buchholz's relatives in Europe, and would repay part that he had borrowed. Witness went to New Haven with Mr. Bollman and got $275, receiving also a due bill from Buchholz for $100. After the discovery of the first batch of money and the witness's show of fairness, Buchholz said he would divulge where the rest of the money was hidden, he being urged to do this by witness telling him that a man was to buy the Schulte property on a speculation. Buchholz then told him the other pocketbook was also in the barn, in the northeastern corner of it. Under a bench standing in that corner of the barn was a loose board, and under this a stone, under which the pocketbook was buried. Witness said he would go and get the money, and then throw this, with the other pocketbook, away. Buchholz advised him to throw the two books on the outside of the railroad track opposite the path leading to the Warings. Buchholz also advised the witness to throw a rusty axe along with the pocketbooks, in this place, which was a rendezvous for tramps. He wanted the axe thrown there, because the grand jury had said that Schulte had been killed with a sharp edged instrument. Buchholz was particularly anxious to have the axe have a long handle, and fell in with the suggestion of witness that some old clothes should be thrown there after they had been sprinkled with human blood, which Buchholz said he would furnish either by cutting an artery or saving what came from his nose, which bled frequently; Buchholz said that chicken blood might be used successfully as it was very nearly like human blood.
Buchholz had said to witness that if he betrayed him he would commit suicide in the court room or in the jail, and never would come into the court room a second time. Buchholz further said that if the witness gave him away Buchholz's friends would follow him and have his life, and made numerous other threats against his life. "If you are a detective you could settle me now," said Buchholz to him at one time, "and I should be sent up for theft, but I could be punished for nothing else."
Buchholz said to witness that he had poison in his cell and other ways in which to commit suicide and said if none of these things would suffice he would either dash his brains out against the wall or else jump from the corridor to the floor and so kill himself.
In speaking of hiding the money under the straw, he said that Schulte put it there, but afterward said, "Oh my God, my God, my God, how careless I was to put the money under the straw."
After Buchholz had told witness about where the second pocket-book was hidden, he, in company with Robert A. Pinkerton and Mr. Schmecker, of the German Consul-General's office, went to the Waring barn in the night, between half-past eleven and twelve o'clock. He found some bark lying over the place where the money was hidden. This was removed, and the stone was found. After about an hour's work this was removed, and digging down a short distance his spade brought up some gold and bits of mouldy newspaper. This witness handed to Mr. Pinkerton, there being seven pieces of gold, three 20-mark pieces and four 10-mark pieces, one of them having a hole through it. The spade then struck the pocket-book, which was very mouldy. It was carefully picked up, done up in a handkerchief and placed in an envelope. The barn was put in order as well as possible and the party then walked to Stamford and took the first train to New York, reaching the Windsor hotel at about 5 o'clock in the morning. Then the German consul was sent for, and the party went up to the room, where Mr. Pinkerton delivered the package to the consul-general, who examined it, and found in it 204,000 marks (something over $50,000). All of these, as those in the other package, had private marks on them. All of these notes were of 1000 marks each. There was also found in the pocket-book, cards, letters and passports belonging to John Heinrich Schulte, the murdered man. This latter package was found on May 29.
On the 31st of May witness visited Buchholz, who said the money was Schulte's and asked witness to go and negotiate a portion of the notes even if he had to go to Europe to do so. Of the gold piece with a hole it Buchholz told witness to throw it away into the water somewhere as it was a piece that was given to Schulte on the day of the murder by a banker, who said to Schulte it would make a good watch-charm. Witness thought it foolish to throw the gold away and asked permission to melt it up, which permission Buchholz gave him, the witness refusing to bring it to jail and show it to Buchholz, as he did not dare to be found with it on his person, as it would seem as if he was an accessory to the crime, and might result in his being in the same boat with Buchholz, as he claimed he was followed by detectives who he was afraid thought he knew something about the Schulte tragedy. One of these detectives, Frank Taylor, (who figured in the Alexander-Bassett case,) witness told Buchholz had followed him to New York after he had found the Schulte money and that he (witness) had all he could do to keep out of his way.
At this point the hearing was adjourned and the remainder of the story will be told to-morrow.
Buchholz was carefully searched this afternoon to see that he had no weapons or poison concealed about him and he was placed to-night in another cell prepared for him. He will be watched to see that he makes no attempt at self-destruction.
----------
BRIDGEPORT, September 12. – The story of Ernest Starke, the detective, was resumed at the opening of court this morning. Witness stated that after he had found the money he told Buchholz that he should demand a commission of $10,000 for his services, and told Buchholz that that would leave him $20,000. A short time ago Buchholz told witness that he had just been reading Schiller's "Robbers," and had grown so excited over the exploits of Carl Moore, that he had drawn a knife and plunged it into his right breast, but luckily he had struck a rib and the knife did no harm. He then said that should he ever think it necessary to commit suicide he believed he would have a steady hand.
Buchholz told witness he had never been under the tree where Schulte's watch was found, but gave to witness a minute description of the timepiece that Schulte had carried, which he stated was an open-faced watch very much like the one that witness carried. Buchholz was very particular in describing all the points, and told of the marks on the case which he thought Schulte had made on the case. Subsequently Buchholz gave him a written description of the watch, as witness told him he needed the minute description in order to obtain another watch which was to be used in court to offset any damaging evidence that the discovery of the Schulte watch might bring against him. When Buchholz started to make a written description he stopped short, and said the writing might be used in evidence against him, if witness proved to be a traitor.
Witness had a talk with Buchholz about the clothes that he wore on the night of the murder and which were in possession of the state, and said that there was blood on both the shirt and lapel of his coat, but that the blood came from the wound on his face. Witness said, "Oh that's too thin," and added, "why didn't you cut a gash clear through the cheek." This startled Buchholz who looked embarrassed, and then tried to laugh the matter off as best he could.
Witness said that the accused wanted him to go to Germany and send some anonymous letters to this country, accusing some one else of the murder. Witness told him the idea was impracticable, as it would seem as though the letters came from Mr. Bollman, and he had better have letters come from some place in this country, San Francisco or elsewhere. This talk about the letter came after the conversation had been had about the placing of pocketbooks, an axe and bloody clothing, in some place where it might be found, so that suspicion would be diverted from him. Buchholz's plan was to have an anonymous letter sent to Bollman or Olmstead, telling where these things were hidden and have them discover them, and thus put the state off the right track. Buchholz wanted witness to go to San Francisco, but he refused to do so, on account of the expense but he declined to do this, and said he would write letters and send them to San Francisco to a friend to have him mail them East, which would answer all purposes and save expense. Buchholz gave a description of the spot between the scene of the murder and Five Mile River, where he thought it best to secrete the evidences of the murder, also drawing a diagram of the locality. All these plans being arranged, witness was instructed to send the letter to Mr. Bollman first, and several days in advance of that sent to Mr. Olmstead, as, if Olmstead received his first, he might get the evidence and not give it up. Letters were accordingly composed and sent as Buchholz had advised, witness composing and printing the letter in a disguised hand. These letters were copies of the one which the papers printed a couple of weeks ago. After this had all been done, witness asked Buchholz if Sammy Waring could prove an alibi on the night of the murder, and Buchholz, said he was certain that he would be able to do so, witness telling Buchholz it wouldn't do to throw suspicion on him. The letter from San Francisco to State Attorney Olmstead was produced in court and identified by witness as one that he wrote and had mailed east from San Francisco. Buchholz had told witness that San Francisco was a good place to send the letter from because one of the boarders in the Sonne hotel who heard him say to Grumewald that if he (Buchholz) was in his (Grumewald's) place, he should take Schulte's coat with the money and get out of the way with it. A few days after the receipt of the anonymous letter he went to the spot indicated in the letter and dug it up, but of course found nothing, as nothing had been buried there.
Witness once said to Buchholz it was very fortunate for him that there was no more blood on his clothing. Buchholz was considerably confused at that remark, and said to witness, "I hope you don't think that I am guilty of killing a poor old man like Schulte, one with whom I expected to live always, I would as soon think of killing my own father." Then the conversation was dropped.
When talking about the burial of the Schulte treasure Buchholz at first said that Schulte buried the money, but afterward acknowledged that he buried the pocket-book first found. He insisted, however, that Schulte buried the pocket-book last found, but one day witness said to him: "You were very careless to bury the money where you did, where it will rot and be destroyed in a short time." Buchholz said: "Yes, I – that is, Schulte was very careless." Witness said "well that's all right, I know all about that, so never mind; but you should have planned better in the beginning." Buchholz said "Well I never expected to be in jail and hoped to be where I could get at the buried treasure when I wished to do so, without having any trouble at all."
At one conversation witness had a chat with Buchholz about the coming trial, and Buchholz talked with him for some time about the necessity of fixing the jury in some way, saying that the members could be bought up and that the trial would thus result in nothing. Witness rather objected to this proceeding and said it could not be successfully carried out because the jurors could not be got at, nor was the money they had in hand available for the purpose, as it was not in a condition to be used.
Buchholz in a chat with the witness – who was frequently allowed to go to the jail and have interviews with the prisoner, being sometimes taken there by Bollman, counsel for the defense – referred to Grümewald, Buchholz's former servant. Buchholz advised witness to get Grümewald out of the country in some way or other, as his testimony in relation to the Schulte watch and the talk that Buchholz had had in the Sonne hotel would be damaging to a greater or less degree.
At one conversation while talking about the Schulte money, Buchholz had said he came very nearly telling his lawyers about the location of the money, but was glad he did not, as he presumed they would have eaten up the whole amount in fees.
The witness had a number of conversations with Buchholz about the wounds on Schulte's head and the manner in which they were made, he saying that the wounds were made with an axe, such a one as he requested witness to buy and bury where it might be discovered.
Buchholz at another conversation told witness that in case he appeared in court to testify he would take a chair or whatever else he could reach and throw it at witness and create a scene in court, and perhaps injure the witness, kill him if possible. Buchholz told him this after a dream that he had had which disturbed him considerably. He dreamed that his trial had nearly reached its conclusion when Mr. Olmstead stated he had one more witness, and then brought the witness into court. At this point Buchholz awoke. Witness talked with and quieted Buchholz, who was reassured.
This closed the direct examination and the cross-examination was begun, witness stating that his real name was Ernest Stark, though he had been known by a number of disguises, as his business required, but those names he did not disclose, the court in the interest of himself excusing him from so doing. A long cross-examination followed on the minor points
The Schulte murder trial experienced a dramatic surprise at Bridgeport yesterday when one of Pinkerton's detectives, who had caused himself to be imprisoned in the same jail with Buchholz, showed how he had become intimate with the alleged murderer and wormed from him important details of the terrible crime. The revelations must have been perfectly paralyzing to the prisoner. According to the detective's story Buchholz threatened to commit suicide if the detective "gave him away." Now that the detective has revealed the confidences of Buchholz the authorities will be wise if they take special precautions to prevent the threat of suicide being carried into effect.
YESTERDAY'S THIRD EDITION.
BUCHHOLZ'S FATE.
----------
END OF THE DETECTIVE'S STORY.
----------
The Cross-Examination of Stark and the Testimony of Other Witnesses.
BRIDGEPORT, September 12. – The story of Ernest Stark, the detective, was resumed at the opening of court this morning. Witness stated that after he had found the money he told Buchholz that he should demand a commission of $10,000 for his services, and told Buchholz that that would leave him $20,000. A short time ago Buchholz told witness that he had just been reading Schiller's "Robbers," and had grown so excited over the exploits of Carl Moore, that he had drawn a knife and plunged it into his right breast, but luckily he had struck a rib and the knife did no harm. He then said that should he ever think it necessary to commit suicide he believed he would have a steady hand.
Buchholz told witness he had never been under the tree where Schulte's watch was found, but gave to witness a minute description of the timepiece that Schulte had carried, which he stated was an open-faced watch very much like the one that witness carried. Buchholz was very particular in describing all the points, and told of the marks on the case which he thought Schulte had made on the case. Subsequently Buchholz gave him a written description of the watch, as witness told him he needed the minute description in order to obtain another watch which was to be used in court to offset any damaging evidence that the discovery of the Schulte watch might bring against him. When Buchholz started to make a written description he stopped short, and said the writing might be used in evidence against him, if witness proved to be a traitor.
Witness had a talk with Buchholz about the clothes that he wore on the night of the murder and which were in possession of the state, and said that there was blood on both the shirt and lapel of his coat, but that the blood came from the wound on his face. Witness said, "Oh that's too thin," and added, "why didn't you cut a gash clear through the cheek." This startled Buchholz who looked embarrassed, and then tried to laugh the matter off as best he could.
Witness said that the accused wanted him to go to Germany and send some anonymous letters to this country, accusing some one else of the murder. Witness told him the idea was impracticable, as it would seem as though the letters came from Mr. Bollman, and he had better have letters come from some place in this country, San Francisco or elsewhere. This talk about the letter came after the conversation had been had about the placing of pocketbooks, an axe and bloody clothing, in some place where it might be found, so that suspicion would be diverted from him. Buchholz's plan was to have an anonymous letter sent to Bollman or Olmstead, telling where these things were hidden and have them discover them, and thus put the state off the right track. Buchholz wanted witness to go to San Francisco, but he refused to do so, on account of the expense but he declined to do this, and said he would write letters and send them to San Francisco to a friend to have him mail them East, which would answer all purposes and save expense. Buchholz gave a description of the spot between the scene of the murder and Five Mile River, where he thought it best to secrete the evidences of the murder, also drawing a diagram of the locality. All these plans being arranged, witness was instructed to send the letter to Mr. Bollman first, and several days in advance of that sent to Mr. Olmstead, as, if Olmstead received his first, he might get the evidence and not give it up. Letters were accordingly composed and sent as Buchholz had advised, witness composing and printing the letter in a disguised hand. These letters were copies of the one which the papers printed a couple of weeks ago. After this had all been done, witness asked Buchholz if Sammy Waring could prove an alibi on the night of the murder, and Buchholz said he was certain that he would be able to do so, witness telling Buchholz it wouldn't do to throw suspicion on him. The letter from San Francisco to State Attorney Olmstead was produced in court and identified by witness as one that he wrote and had mailed east from San Francisco. Buchholz had told witness that San Francisco was a good place to send the letter from because one of the boarders in the Sonne hotel who heard him say to Grümewald that if he (Buchholz) was in his (Grümewald's) place, he should take Schulte's coat with the money and get out of the way with it. A few days after the receipt of the anonymous letter he went to the spot indicated in the letter and dug it up, but of course found nothing, as nothing had been buried there.
Witness once said to Buchholz it was very fortunate for him that there was no more blood on his clothing. Buchholz was considerably confused at that remark, and said to witness, "I hope you don't think that I am guilty of killing a poor old man like Schulte, one with whom I expected to live always, I would as soon think of killing my own father." Then the conversation was dropped.
When talking about the burial of the Schulte treasure Buchholz at first said that Schulte buried the money, but afterward acknowledged that he buried the pocket-book first found. He insisted, however, that Schulte buried the pocket-book last found, but one day witness said to him: "You were very careless to bury the money where you did, where it will rot and be destroyed in a short time." Buchholz said: "Yes, I – that is, Schulte was very careless." Witness said "well that's all right, I know all about that, so never mind; but you should have planned better in the beginning." Buchholz said "well I never expected to be in jail and hoped to be where I could get at the buried treasure when I wished to do so, without having any trouble at all."
At one conversation witness had a chat with Buchholz about the coming trial, and Buchholz talked with him for some time about the necessity of fixing the jury in some way, saying that the members could be bought up and that the trial would thus result in nothing. Witness rather objected to this proceeding and said it could not be successfully carried out because the jurors could not be got at, nor was the money they had in hand available for the purpose, as it was not in a condition to be used.
Buchholz in a chat with the witness – who was frequently allowed to go to the jail and have interviews with the prisoner, being sometimes taken there by Bollman, counsel for the defense – referred to Grümewald, Buchholz's former servant. Buchholz advised witness to get Grümewald out of the country in some way or other, as his testimony in relation to the Schulte watch and the talk that Buchholz had had in the Sonne hotel would be damaging to a greater or less degree.
At one conversation while talking about the Schulte money, Buchholz had said he came very nearly telling his lawyers about the location of the money, but was glad he did not. as he presumed they would have eaten up the whole amount in fees.
The witness had a number of conversations with Buchholz about the wounds on Schulte's head and the manner in which they were made, he saying that the wounds were made with an axe, such a one as he requested witness to buy and bury where it might be discovered.
Buchholz at another conversation told witness that in case he appeared in court to testify he would take a chair or whatever else he could reach and throw it at witness and create a scene in court, and perhaps injure the witness, kill him if possible. Buchholz told him this after a dream that he had had which disturbed him considerably. He dreamed that his trial had nearly reached its conclusion when Mr. Olmstead stated he had one more witness, and then brought the witness into court. At this point Buchholz awoke. Witness talked with and quieted Buchholz, who was reassured.
This closed the direct examination and the cross-examination was begun, witness stating that his real name was Ernest Stark, though he had been known by a number of disguises, as his business required, but those names he did not disclose, the court in the interest of himself excusing him from so doing. A long cross-examination followed on the minor points.
[The preceding was also printed in the previous day’s paper, but the following text was not.]
During the cross-examination it came out that Buchholz had told witness that since the murder an uncle of his had died in Germany and left him quite a fortune. On the strength of this story witness offered to lend $350 to Buchholz, and did lend it to him. When the money was handed to Buchholz, Mr. Bollman examined the bills and said "Why those are not on that list," adding "I hope this is none of Schulte's money; if it is I don't want to handle it." Witness assured them it was not Schulte's and asked them, "What do you mean by that list?" No reply was made, though Buchholz and Bollman exchanged looks with one another in a mysterious manner.
General Smith obtained from the witness that he never had seen, conversed with or written to the General, or had any acquaintance with him until Tuesday last, when the trial began. Witness also stated that he had been denounced as a spy and detective to Buchholz by both General Smith and Mr. Bollman, and the latter had repeatedly told witness of his suspicions and convictions in the jail, sometimes in the presence of the prisoner.
Witness said he suggested the burial of the pocket-books, the axe and clothing. At the afternoon hearing the cross-examination of Mr. Stark was suspended in order that other witnesses might be heard.
Mr. Bischoff, the New York banker, who had acted as Schulte's banker, brought into the court a number of bundles containing the recovered money. The packages were opened, and from the first a small pocketbook, the first found in Waring's barn, was produced, and with it a number of envelopes containing United States money, one with 89 $20 bills numbered from 380-99 to 380-183 in the marks that Schulte used on his money. The whole $4,787 was recognized by the witness, Mr. Stark, and the second package, containing the second pocketbook found in the Waring barn and the money that was found in it, 7 gold pieces, 100 marks and 204,000 marks.
Franklin J. Bischoff testified to giving to Mr. Schulte government bills to the amount of $352.50 in exchange for three 500 mark bills. Subsequently he exchanged gold mark pieces to the value of 100 marks for a bill. There were three 20-mark pieces and four 10-mark pieces. Of these, one of the 10-mark pieces was identified by witness because of a hole in it, he having told Schulte it would do for an adornment for his watch chain.
Second Edition
SEALING BUCHHOLZ'S DOOM.
--------
More Strong Circumstantial Evidence Against the Accused Murderer.
BRIDGEPORT, September 12. – The testimony in court this afternoon, after the close of my report published Friday, was of a character which will more certainly fix the proof of the murder of Schulte on poor Buchholz, for the testimony in relation to the money is of such a character as to show conclusively that Schulte could not have hidden the pocketbooks as Buchholz had claimed he did. The prisoner's statements to the detective, Ernest Stark, were to the effect that Schulte hid the money in the barn and that he found it there after the murder, but these statements are disproved by the testimony of the banker who gave Schulte the money on the day of the murder showing that Schulte could not have reached the barn before he was murdered, and that therefore some one else must have hidden the treasure where it was found. Franklin J. Bischoff, a clerk in the banking house where Schulte on the day of the murder, had some German mark notes exchanged for greenbacks, testified that among the notes he gave him was a package containing $500, which was held together by a thin paper band, and marked "$500" in a blue pencil mark. Those who were present when the money contained in the first pocket book was found testified to the finding of just such a bundle, which contained, as Mr. Bischoff said it did, two $100 notes, two $50 notes, and the balance in smaller bills. The wrapper which bound up the package was produced and identified. There were also shown the seven gold pieces, three of the value of 20-marks each and four of 10-marks each, which Mr. Bischoff had given Schulte on the afternoon of the day he was murdered. One of these had a hole through it, and Mr. Bischoff immediately recognized the piece, as it was one he had some conversation with Schulte about, because the firm was not in the habit of paying out mutilated pieces, and Bischoff wished to exchange it, but Schulte said he would keep it and wear it on his watch-chain as a sort of charm. The finding of this piece and the bundle of $500 is conclusive proof that the pocket-books could not have been buried by Schulte, but must have been put where found after the murder.
While the money was being handled in the court-room during the examination of witnesses, in relation thereto, one of the ten-marks gold pieces was lost, and though careful search was made for it, it could not be found anywhere. It was very amusing at this point to witness the action of Stark, the detective, who carefully scrutinized everyone who was near the money, to see if he could discover who had made away with that piece that was wanted to complete the list of monies found in the barn, but even he failed to find where the missing piece had gone to.
The major part of the testimony, this afternoon, was corroborative of the statement of the detective as to what the pocket-books found contained.
Frank Juste, the porter at the Sonne hotel, in New York city, testified as to the way in which Buchholz came to enter Schulte's employ. On the day that Schulte removed from New York to Norwalk, Juste took Schulte and his baggage, a trunk and valise from the hotel to the Grand Central depot. Buchholz, who was stopping at the hotel, asked permission to ride to the depot. This was granted, and on the way there Schulte remarked that the way in which Grümewald, his former servant had left his employ was very annoying to him, and made him much trouble. Buchholz coincided with him, and then offered his services as a servant. He told Schulte he was in New York without employment and without money, waiting for a remittance from Germany which he expected in a short time. When his money came he intended to go to Australia. He told Schulte that while in Germany he was in the army. Schulte told Buchholz that he only paid $3 a month for his servant, and Buchholz replied that working for that sum was better than lying idle in New York, running up a bill. Schulte said he would be in New York the following week, and would then give Buchholz a definite answer; but Buchholz told him he was ready and anxious to go to work at once, and after some further talk Schulte hired him and took him to Norwalk with him that night.
Detective Ernest Stark was recalled after this testimony for the purposes of cross-examination. This elicited nothing of importance excepting that all the conversations he had had with Buchholz in the jail had been in German and that the statements he had given in testimony were his own translations of the conversation. He also stated that Buchholz had in one conversation said to him, "Schulte was killed with an axe," immediately qualifying it by adding "or at least the grand jury said he was." Stark said that Buchholz had never made a statement to him in relation to the manner in which Schulte was killed without qualifying it, something as above.
Robert A. Pinkerton, a son of Allan Pinkerton, who has charge of the agency in New York city, was called to the stand, and testified that he knew Stark, who had been in the employ of his agency for five years, residing during that time in Philadelphia.
At this point the hearing was concluded for the day, the court adjourning at 4:30 until Monday morning, at 10:30, when Pinkerton will tell the story of his connection with the attempts to ferret out the criminal.
THE CASE OF BUCHHOLZ.
---------
TESTIMONY BY THE DETECTIVES.
---------
Evidence of a Cumulative Nature – Drawing the Web Closer About Schulte's Servant.
BRIDGEPORT, September 15. – The trial of Buchholz, the alleged murderer of Schulte, was resumed at eleven o'clock this morning, and the first witness called to the stand was Robert A. Pinkerton, chief of the New York agency, where the detective Stark was employed. The first question asked by States Attorney Olmstead was: "Did it make any difference to Mr. Stark, as to his pay, whether he found any evidence against the prisoner or not?"
This question was objected to by counsel for the defense, and was ruled out by the chief justice as irrelevant and inadmissible.
Detective Pinkerton then resumed his testimony as to the finding of the second pocketbook. He detailed the finding by Stark, first of some old paper, then seven pieces of gold, one of which had a hole through it and then the pocketbook with the paper money. These were all wrapped up in a handkerchief and carried to New York.
On the cross-examination witness said that he was employed at first by the German consul general, as he supposed representing the German government, but afterward it was learned that the consul-general was authorized to employ the witness by Schulte's brother. Subsequently he was employed by the state of Connecticut through State's Attorney Olmstead, at a specified rate per diem. Witness was not at work for the reward offered by the executor of the estate.
Ernest Stark was recalled, and said that Buchholz told him the money contained in the pocket-book just found he had hidden under the straw in the barn, not having had time to put it anywhere else. Buchholz said to him: "Just think what luck I had; I went to the barn the next morning and the straw had been removed. I stood there like one petrified, but looking around I finally spied the pocket-book, and it seemed as if a ray of sunshine had come over me." In the latter conversation Buchholz said he went to the barn and buried the money in the stall on Sunday morning. He had never said that he put the money under the straw, at any other time than on the night of the murder, though he had got the dates mixed as to the time when he buried it in the stall, saying that he had done this both on Saturday and Sunday nights.
A number of envelopes, letters, etc., found in Schultz's pocket-book were introduced into court and identified by both Stark and Pinkerton.
Mr. Stark then translated the various documents found in the pocket-book, the first being the passport of John Henry Schultz, issued by the German government, entitling the bearer to travel until April 23, 1879, through Italy, France and America. There were also a card of Earle's hotel, corner Canal and Center streets, New York city, and a letter addressed to J. H. Schultz. The reception of the latter was objected to by the defense, but was admitted as tending to show the ownership of the pocket-book. The defense took an exception.
After this the lawyers had a lively tilt over the translation of the name Johann Heinrich Schulte into the English, a number of Germans being called and translating the name as John Henry Schulte. Mr. Smith of the counsel for the defense objected to the translation, but these were admitted, the defense taking exception.
Dr. Pardee of South Norwalk, who made the post-mortem examination of the body of Schulte, described the wounds on the skull which caused the death, one being in the center of the back of the head, and the other on the left side of the head near the ear. The bits of bone that was taken from the head were shown in court, and witness thought both wounds were made by a blow that was struck downward and with a heavy instrument, probably an axe.
In the report of Detective Stark's testimony an injustice was inadvertently done to Mr. Bollman. Stark was reported as having said that he told Buchholz in Bollman's presence that he had got only $350 to give him, as he had been unable to get the ink marks out of the money he had found in the first pocketbook that he took from its hiding place in the barn. This was a mistake. The prisoner had this conversation with the detective without the presence of a third party, and Mr. Bollman knew nothing of the discovery of the money until the story was told in court.
Yesterday’s Third Edition
THE CASE OF BUCHHOLZ.
-----------
Drawing the Web Closer About Schulte's Servant.
Dr. Pardee of South Norwalk, who made the post-mortem examination of the body of Schulte, described the wounds on the skull which caused the death, one being in the center of the back of the head, and the other on the left side of the head near the ear. The bits of bone that was taken from the head were shown in court, and witness thought both wounds were made by a blow that was struck downward and with a heavy instrument, probably an axe.
The fatal wounds might have been made with an ordinary axe or hatchet. Witness said the blow on the back of the ear was the one that killed Schulte, in all probability, certainly when combined with the blow which cut off the back part of his head and skull, though this latter was not of necessity as certainly fatal as was the former.
On the cross examination the doctor said he thought that the blow on the top of the head would not of necessity have felled the man to the ground; and that he might possibly have walked three or four rods after the blow was given without falling.
George C. Stillson of South Norwalk said that at the ambush which had been built on the path leading from the railroad to the Waring house he had noticed footsteps on the day after the murder, these steps being behind the ambush, pointing diagonally toward the track and down the path leading thereto. These had the appearance of having been made by a man who had been standing close behind the ambush. Witness identified a lot of rags, which had been found near the body and which when found had blood on it in various spots, which have now faded out.
Dr. W. C. Burke, jr., of South Norwalk, testified to calling the attention of the coroner's jury, Mr. Olmstead and others, to the footsteps in the rear of the ambush. He also made a search all about the premises, and did not find anything in the lot.
The revolver that was found in the lot where he said he had searched, was handed to witness who said that he had examined it under a microscope, and discovered marks which seemed to be blood prints made with a human hand on the barrel and stock. He could not positively swear they were blood as Mr. Olmstead refused to let him take a scale for analysis.
At the afternoon hearing David Dayton testified to Buchholz's having some money in his possession which was marked like that which was found in Schulte's pocket-book. Messrs. Hubbell, Curtis and Smith all testified to having received and handled a $50 bill, which was marked 380-182, in the same way, and with the same ink that Schulte's money was marked.
David Dayton, the constable who had the prisoner in charge for some time, said that Bucholz at one time received a letter which he opened in the presence of the witness, and from which he seemingly took some money. Afterward witness saw some money, one $100 bill, and three $50 bills in Bucholz's possession, and these were marked as the Schulte money was marked. Witness had the prisoner in voluntary custody for several weeks, and during that time he made no attempts to escape nor caused witness any trouble of any kind. No warrant had been served, though the witness had one to use in case of emergency.
SECOND EDITION.
TRIAL OF BUCHHOLZ.
----------
THE BLOOD ON THE FATAL AXE.
----------
Continuation of the Hearing in Bridgeport – More Corroborative Testimony – But Little New Testimony.
BRIDGEPORT, September 15. – The evidence since the close of yesterday's report has been directed to one point, viz :-- to show that Buchholz had in his possession and paid out money that must have been taken from one of Schulte's pocket books, money that bore the fatal "380 - –" series mark in the corner, distinguishing them from all other monies in the world, in all probability. The use of some of this money was shown, and this taken in connection with the fact that all of the money of the dead man was marked in this way, and that none with such marks had been circulated until after his death will be held to be a strong point in the chain of circumstantial evidence that is surrounding the treacherous servant Buchholz.
After the close of the testimony as published in to-day's (Monday's) EVENING REGISTER, Stephen M. Newman testified to visiting the Sonne hotel in New York city, January 2 of the present year, in company with Officer Berger, and paying to the clerk of the hotel two $20 bills which Buchholz had given him in order to pay a board bill. These bills were marked 380-162 and 380-135.
Officer Berger testified that he had received after Schulte's murder two $20 bills from Buchholz to pay a bill at the Sonne hotel that Buchholz had contracted before he entered Schulte's employ. These bills were the same ones that Newman had seen him pay over to the clerk of the Sonne hotel. He also saw Buchholz pay to Mr. Austin, one of the counsel for defense, $170, a $100 bill, one $50 bill, and the rest in smaller bills, all of which he knew were marked, though he did not take the numbers. He was a witness of the receipt of the money. Witness said that during the coroner's inquest the prisoner was in his custody the greater part of the time, and also up to the time that he was committed for trial. On the day after the murder, witness remained with the prisoner from one o'clock in the afternoon till the next morning. He kept a close watch on the prisoner all the while, and he went nowhere after Saturday afternoon, unless the witness knew his whereabouts, excepting when he let him go into the barn once on Sunday. On the night after the murder Buchholz was allowed to sleep in his own room and alone after witness had nailed up the window. Witness remained in the next room all night – the one that Schulte occupied – but did not sleep, sitting with Sam Waring watching Buchholz all the while and going to his room several times during the night to see that he did not escape. Witness was very much troubled by a sharp cross-examination by General Smith. During this it came out that on the Sunday after the murder Buchholz went with witness to Paul Hercher's saloon, and Buchholz bought a box of cigars and a couple of bottles of wine, which he paid for with a $20 bill. The rest of the cross examination was devoted to the doings of witness and Buchholz while they were living together during the coroner's inquest, and developed few points of interest. Berger said that all the while he had care of Buchholz, the accused made no attempt to escape from custody; did not seem to be troubled by the suspicion hanging over him, slept nights as soundly and apparently as peacefully as anyone could.
Constable David Dayton was recalled to say that he saw Hercher give the $40 to Buchholz, and the latter gave the same sum to Berger that was used in paying the bill in the Sonne hotel in New York city.
Franklin Tolles testified to having found a shirt belonging to Buchholz less than a foot from the body of the murdered man, which had been made with a peculiar yoke, and this same yoke was noticeable in the remnants of a shirt that had been found bearing blood stains, and which it was supposed had been used to wipe off the axe.
At this point the hearing was adjourned until to-morrow (Tuesday) at 9 o'clock.
-----------
BRIDGEPORT, September 16. – The uncomfortable and unpleasant court room in this county, which has been productive of colds to many of those who are compelled to be here, begins to appear more as it did during the famous Alexander-Bassett trial, there having been a much larger attendance of ladies during the past two days of the trial than in the early part of the hearing. This morning however the court room presented a deserted appearance, there being considerably less than half the usual attendance, and not more than a dozen ladies. Before the morning had half passed away, however, and as the weather became more fair the ladies began flocking into the room, and at eleven the room was about as well filled as usual.
Buchholz seemed to have recovered from the shock he had received by Stark's testimony, and there is much more color in his face this morning than at any time since the beginning of the trial. He behaves himself very well under the circumstances, and appears more cool and comfortable than one could expect him to do.
This morning P. T. Barnum was in the court room, having arrived home here to remain until his show starts out next season. He has fully recovered from the alleged yellow fever which the alleged news-papers of St. Louis said drove him East, and looks as jolly and pleasant as usual. Although his show still remains on the road, Mr. Barnum has withdrawn for the present from any such active connection with it as would keep him on the road. The weather is too cool for the old gentleman to be away from home – for Barnum is growing old, and begins to show it. Later in the day the Hon. W. D. Bishop came into the room, and sat for some time an interested spectator.
The first witness called was Edward Burger, the officer who obtained from Buchholz at the time of the hearing before the coroner's jury, a statement which had been reduced to writing by Charles Illing, who had acted as interpreter. Mr. Olmstead desired particulars as to the manner in which this statement was obtained, but the defense objected to the testimony, as witness did not understand the language in which it was made by Buchholz and so Mr. Olmstead withdrew from his attempt to get in the statement made by Buchholz as testimony, which witness had stated was made voluntary and without any promise of reward, or under any threats if it was not made. Witness then stated how he found the body and the monies that he found on the body, mainly in marks contained in a pocketbook, and aggregating $20,000 in value. The search which resulted in finding this money was conducted in the house where the body was taken by order of the coroner's jury. Witness found the money in the pockets of Schulte's coat or vest.
George C. Stillson identified a number of newspapers and other articles which were introduced as those that were found either lying about the body or on the person of the deceased. The very curious contract between Schulte and Buchholz was not to be found among these papers, but a search amongst the mass of stuff that is introduced into court as property of the deceased and the prisoner finally brought it to light. Among the papers were copies of the New York Telegram and the New York Staats Zeitung of December 27, the day of the murder. Witness said that when Schulte was struck he had evidently fallen to the ground on his face, and had lain there in the path and bled considerably and possibly the man had died there, as there was a good-sized pool of blood there. The body had been turned over onto its back, evidently after death, and then robbed as both coats and vest were unbuttoned, the latter being turned back evidently with the intention of allowing the robber to get at the inside of the coat. It was also noticeable that the watch had been taken from the watch chain with care and had not been torn off with force. After the examination of the body in the lot it was taken to the Waring house, where a careful examination of all the clothing was made, it being carefully searched to see that no money was sewed in the clothing. In the right-hand inside pocket of the vest was found a package which looked to him like a package of "superannuated almanacs" and gave no evidence whatever that it was valuable or was money. Witness thought it was of no value, but examined it at the request of the jurors and then found it contained 80,000 marks, or about $20,000. The package bore no resemblance whatever to greenbacks, or American money. This point was brought out in the cross-examination in order to contradict the statement of Berger that the package looked like one made up of national bank notes and so attracted his attention. Witness stated that Berger assisted in carrying the body from the scene of the murder to the house. When the body was being carried into the Waring house the party carrying it stopped in the sink-room, where the bloody footsteps were found, and rested for a moment. This point was also brought out in the cross-examination in order to offset the theory of the state that the bloody footsteps were made by Buchholz.
James M. Lane was called and substantiated the statement of Mr. Stillson as to the finding of the papers about the body, after the murder.
Ernest Stark the detective was called, this time as a translator, and translated the curious contract between Schulte and Buchholz, which showed that Buchholz was engaged as a servant to him at the rate of 13 marks per month ($3) with board and lodging. An attempt was made to introduce the contract between Schulte and Grumewald, which was found near the body, but this was ruled out. The State only desired to introduce it to prove the identity of the body of the deceased. The contract between Schulte and Buchholz was written by the latter, so Detective Stark, who was familiar with the prisoner's hand-writing, had said.
"Do you know that axe?" asked Mr. Olmstead of officer George Arnold, as he held up an axe, and a broken axe-helve.
"I do," said the officer.
"When have you seen it?"
"I found it in the barn of the Waring family, on the Sunday morning after the murder.”
"What was there particular about it?"
"The handle was covered with fingerprints which seem to have been made by some one whose hand was bloody having grasped the helve. There was also blood on the face of the axe."
Then Officer Arnold told of finding it in the center of the floor of the barn, standing against a chopping block. Since he had seen it – if the axe shown was the same one that he saw – it had been cleaned and sharpened, and a new helve put in. [The old helve shown was the one originally in the axe, but which had been broken out, and a new one had been substituted .- ED. REGISTER.]
On the cross-examination Officer Arnold said he could not say whether the marks on the handle were blood or red paint.
Franklin Tolles was called and testified to having seen the axe on the morning after the murder at daybreak. He noticed blood on the handle and on the axe itself, and also noticed on the cutting part a number of chicken feathers, there being feathers on the cutting block and chicken heads on the ground near it.
Edward Berger was recalled and testified to having seen the axe on the day after the murder. There were blood marks on the back of the axe near the upper corner and on both sides, and there was blood on the face of the axe which looked like congealed blood. On the cross-examination witness swore as to the blood he found on the axe and also that there were no chicken feathers on it at all, although there were chicken heads on the ground near the chopping block.
Yesterday’s Third Edition
Trial of Buchholz.
Julius M. Mendorf [Ellendorf] testified that he began giving lessons in English to the prisoner in November last, and gave them to him up to the time of the murder. Buchholz was very attentive, and learned rapidly. On the day of the murder his manner and conduct were as usual, and his attention was close. Witness saw Buchholz at 10 o'clock on the day of the murder. At the time of the murder Buchholz's knowledge of the English language was so slight that he was unable to converse at all.
Mrs. Amelia Waring denied having seen the footprint on the floor and thought the spots of blood came from Schulte's body. On the day of the murder witness claimed that she was going to South Norwalk and Buchholz asked her to go down with him, and told her it would do her good to go down with him. When he got ready to go she had changed her mind and concluded that she would not go with him. This latter evidence was entirely new and elicited a sharp cross-examination.
The first witness this afternoon was Thomas Doran, a telegraph lineman, who said he was working on the Western Union line and that on the 17th of December last he lost a pair of climbers, a pair of vises, a hatchet, a pair of pliers and a coil of wire, No. 8. These he lost about 200 feet south of the Norwalk depot, and has never seen or heard of them since.
Miss Sadie Waring said she was in the sink room with Mr. Allen before the body was brought to the house, but saw no footprint on the floor. On Saturday night an unknown party was seen by her in their yard near the barn, but no one went out of the house to see him. In this testimony she was corroborated by her sister Annie.
Second Edition
THE BUCHHOLZ CASE.
BRIDGEPORT, September 17. – The testimony this afternoon, after the close of the report already published, was corroborative in its character, and was, as it is understood put in to, in a measure, consume time, so that the grand effort of the defense might be saved until to-morrow morning, when it is expected Buchholz will be put on the stand to fully clinch the theory of the defense that Schulte was not murdered by the accused, but was robbed by him after some other party or parties had done the murder, either for purposes of robbery or revenge, probably the latter, and if the defense claim for the former purpose they will also claim that this was done by those who had a grudge against the accused, the reason for which can be gleaned from a perusal of the last clause of Schulte's will, a certified copy of which was introduced in court to-day, and which reads as follows:
LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT.
In case I leave this life permanently ("before my time," literally,) I hereby devise and bequeath my whole estate, both personal and real, credits and debits, to my only surviving brother, the proprietor, F. W. Schulte, of Grossenhalthausen. In case my said brother should die before me, then, and in that case, I leave all my property to my next of kin.
I leave this world conscious of having always acted right, and fulfilling my duty, and not feeling any remorse, by ignoring and annulling in this will, the legal validity and consequences of the decree of the County Court, at Hagen, dated, Dec. 18, 1861, judicially declaring me the father of a bastard, as well as the other decrees rendered against me.
DEC. 5, 1874. JOH HEINR SCHULTE.
After the testimony already reported of to-day's hearing Asa B. Woodward, the judge of probate of the Norwalk district, was called to show that when Hoyt sold the property where the miser lived, to Schulte, a deed was passed which was signed by Johann Heinrich Schulte, the correct and only name of the deceased, who in the indictment against Buchholz is called John Henry Schulte. This deed was ruled out and an exception taken by counsel for the defense. A certified copy of the will above mentioned was introduced signed Joh. Heinr. Schulte, and on this point (as to the name), Walter C. Quintard, administrator on the estate, and Jacob M. Leighton, the agent of the deceased, said he was only known by his German name and never so far as they knew by any other. The papers appointing Mr. Quintard administrator on the estate of Johann Heinrich Schulte, were also admitted to further prove this point.
Charles T. Crawe testified that on Sunday last, in company with Constable Dayton and others, he walked over the same path that Schulte and Buchholz had taken on the night of the murder, and that to pass from the depot to the scene of the murder, a distance of a trifle over a mile and a fifth, at a moderate pace, it took them 25 minutes. William H. Ricards, who saw them walk, said they walked faster than Schulte and Buchholz walked on the night of the murder, when he saw them going down the track, and Constable Dayton testified that he ran from the spot where the murder was committed to the Waring house, as Buchholz alleges he did in one and three quarter minutes.
Constable Dayton, Dr. W. C. Burke, jr., George C. Stillson and Jacob F. Tolles all testified that it was well known, and a matter of common talk in Norwalk, that Schulte always carried very large sums of money in his possession.
Dr. Burke testified to having, on the Saturday after the murder, made a microscopic examination of the axe found in the barn, and that on it he found blood and filaments of chicken feathers and no hair.
Officer Dayton testified that the first time Buchholz was searched was a week after the murder.
---------
BRIDGEPORT, September 18. – When the court opened this morning Edward Berger, the amateur detective, was recalled and testified that Buchholz was not searched until a week after the murder. Mr. Olmstead attempted to introduce the witness in rebuttal to impeach the testimony of Mrs. Waring, in relation to her statements that Buchholz asked her to accompany him to town on the afternoon of the day of the murder, but General Smith objected to the state impeaching its own witness, and Mr. Olmstead desisted from his plan.
With this the defense rested their case, and the audience was very much disappointed because Buchholz was not put on the stand to testify in his own behalf. He was very anxious to do this, but his counsel objected to his testifying, and so he was denied what he considered his privilege and right, as he expressed it, to a lady friend last evening.
Mr. Ellendorf was called to rebut the testimony in regard to the name of the deceased. He said he had never heard the first name of the deceased until after his murder. On the cross-examination he said that the name Johann in German could not be changed by a man when he came to this country, to John without the action of the legislature, and would remain Johann, and could not be changed in any respect, either by the person himself or by others.
George C. Stillson and Paul Hercher were called to testify to the way in which Schulte was commonly known, but neither knew him by his first name before the commission of crime.
This closed the testimony and the trial of William Buchholz was finished.
The opening argument was made by Nelson Taylor, Jr., Mr. Olmstead's assistant, who after the opening, in a very flowery style, gave a legal description of the crime of murder, and then launched out into an analysis of the motives which induced the educated Buchholz to enter the employ of the miser Schulte, and then to murder him, as the state claims he did. He claimed that the state had in their case made a solid wall of facts to offset which the defense had nothing but theories, and theories that had no reasonable or provable foundation in facts.
Mr. Bollman of the counsel for the defense followed, and in opening he said he was about to enter upon the most responsible duty of his life – the argument in defense of a fellow-man charged with the crime of murder. After dealing with the responsibilities of the duties resting upon him and upon the court and jury he entered upon a discussion of the merits of the case. He spoke of the unusual manner in which the case was brought to the attention of the court, without even the shadow of a preliminary hearing. The prisoner, a stranger in this country, was unable to be properly represented before either the coroner's jury or the grand jury and had no opportunity for cross-examination – a right which the prisoner should have had at a preliminary hearing before a lower court. He sharply criticised the action of the states attorney and that of the detective Stark, who was the states attorney's agent, and who went to the prisoner and did all he could to prevent him from stating his full case to his counsel. This had been done under the sanction ot the state, and virtually by the state's sworn officer, a mode of proceeding that was open to the most severe criticism, and one that should be frowned down by every honest man, as it is an attempt to make the prisoner so commit himself that his defense will be shattered before a trial is begun. He next claimed that the state had not shown their foundation stone to be secure, and had not proven that the body found was that of Johann Heinrich Schulte, the German who was murdered. He then dwelt upon the necessity of absolute proof of all claims made by the state, and cautioned the jury against accepting circumstantial evidence against the accused without first thoroughly investigating the circumstances and seeing whether they did not fit equally well the theory of the defense, that the accused is guilty of robbery of the body after the death of Schulte, but not guilty of the crime with which he is charged, and for which he is now on trial – murder. He read a number of authorities to prove that the ground he took – that circumstantial evidence must be construed in favor of the accused rather than the state – was not only tenable, but was the rule as set down by some of the best legal minds in the country.
Mr. Bollman then recited the events of the day of the murder, and the whereabouts of the accused from morning until he met the master on his arrival from New York city, the free, easy and happy way in which he conducted himself going far to prove that the accused had no idea of committing the heinous crime with which he is charged and which he could not have assumed had he been meditating such a deed. He then noted the time of the arrival of Schulte in Norwalk at 6:11. He went to Hercher's saloon where he spent, according to the most unfavorable testimony, at least ten minutes. Then they started for home, and walked down the track at a slow pace. On the way through the woods Schulte and Buchholz were separated for a few moments while the former stepped aside to urinate. Then, while they were separated, and while the accused had both the valise and bundle they had been carrying, in his custody, the attack was made, and Schulte killed, the accused escaping by running away from the two men that had assaulted him, and arriving at the Waring house out of breath and in a terrible state of excitement, not over five minutes after the 6:48 train had passed but a short distance below the barn. The two witnesses of the state who passed over the same path that Buchholz did, and walked more rapidly than did the murdered man and his servant, as testified to by the only person who saw them on the night of the murder, testify that it took them 25 minutes to make the trip to where Schulte was murdered. and that it required them 27 minutes to get to the Waring house. Leaving Hercher's at 6:21 and going home in just the same time as did those who experimented they would have reached the Waring house at just the minute the 6:48 train would have passed the house. This proves conclusively that the accused did not have time to commit the crime with which he is charged, and have reached the Waring house as soon as he did. His action in giving the alarm and assisting in raising a party to go after his, as he then supposed, wounded and robbed master, also disposed of the theory that he was a murderer.
The Trial of Buchholz.
Mr. Bollman then entered upon a description of the defense, which they claimed, and which he thought showed that though the prisoner was guilty of theft, as he undoubtedly was, but not guilty of murder. He claimed that after the old man had been killed, the murderers robbed the body of the yellow pocket-book that was found in the inside coat pocket, and rifled the money-bags that were found in the lots of their contents; abandoning the body, supposing that they had got all of the treasure there was. When Buchholz in company with the others found the body he knew it had been robbed, but knowing the habits of the deceased, and that he carried the bulk of his money in the tail pocket of his coat, he took advantage of an opportunity that offered itself and robbed the garments of the deceased while he was pretending to assist in carrying the body, and that when he let go his hold he went to the barn and temporarily hid what he had obtained until he should have a better opportunity to dispose of his ill-gotten gain, when he should be able to obtain it when he should want it, and where it would be secure from prying eyes. That is the real story of Buchholz's participation in the crime, and he had no participation whatever in the murder. The speaker claimed there had been a conspiracy by some one who committed the murder to throw the suspicion on Buchholz, in which Berger, the Norwalk officer, had participated, he having taken the brush belonging to Buchholz from his clothes while the prisoner was in his custody and thrown it into the lot, where it was found on the Sunday after the murder. The speaker also claimed that all the other articles found in the lot were placed there by some of the conspirators, as also was the watch, alleged to have been Schulte's, and which was found by the side of the main road on the 15th of March last, all for the purpose of throwing suspicion about Buchholz and diverting it from some one else and the real murderers of the poor old German. The claim of the state that the prisoner was a shrewd schemer was denied by the speaker who claimed this was disproved by his imposing such implicit confidence in the detective. Had he been a schemer he would never have done this. He claimed all the plans for the manufacture of testimony were the result of Stark's planning and not of Buchholz. To the detective he gave credit for the firm work he had done, and acknowledged that he had probably told the whole truth in regard to his interview with Buchholz when he was on the witness stand. He charged the state with manufacturing testimony, and said there was not a particle of direct evidence against the accused which showed him to be even an accessory to the crime with which he is charged, while there is everything to show that the facts as to the robbery admitted by the defense are absolutely true. In closing he urged upon the jury fair and honorable treatment of the prisoner and no hasty judgment, but a careful, honest and prayerful analysis of the testimony.
The argument was an exceedingly able one throughout, and Mr. Bollman was very highly complimented upon his able presentation of the case for the defense and the admirable manner in which he made his points throughout.
During the argument, Buckholz, who has thus far stood the ordeal with the best possible grace, broke down and for half an hour gave way to his pent-up feelings in a shower of tears.
This afternoon State Attorney Olmstead and General Smith closed the arguments, but the case will not be given to the jury until to-morrow.
SECOND EDITION.
IS BUCHHOLZ GUILTY?
----------
THE ARGUMENTS PRO AND CON.
----------
Mr. Olmstead's Able Plea for the Conviction of the Prisoner – Mr. Smith's Reply.
BRIDGEPORT, September 19. – Buchholz has appeared more composed and cheerful for the past three or four days and has had a faint color in his cheeks as he did at the beginning of the trial, but which vanished when Stark went on the witness stand against him, this change in his appearance being in great part due to the fact that the testimony has been more in his favor. The court room has been overcrowded with ladies for the past three days and they have filled that portion of the court room which is usually assigned to the members of the bar. After filling this space they put in an appearance in goodly numbers in the seats in the rear of the floor allotted to spectators and also in the spectators gallery. In short, where there is room there is a woman, and some of them have been regular attendants in the court for a week or more.
State Attorney Olmstead talked for four hours yesterday afternoon and an hour longer this morning, and his argument was a labored plea to the jury to convict the prisoner rather than an argument. It was a disappointment to those who heard his brilliant arguments in the Alexander and Bassett cases, and throughout showed that he was over-anxious to convict the prisoner, and depended rather on the appeal to the jurors than a discussion of the evidence. It was in marked contrast to the brilliant manner in which he presented the testimony for the prosecution to the jury. Instead of confining himself to the salient points of the case Mr. Olmstead took up all the minor details of the case, particularly those to which Mr. Bollman referred in his argument and discussed them at great length, while the really vital points in the case – the alleged robbery of the body after the murder – were only touched upon in brief, Mr. Olmstead simply dismissing this point by saying that such a thing was utterly impossible. At twenty minutes of ten this morning Mr. Olmstead said "Gentlemen, I am through." But that was a little joke of his, designed to put the jury in a good humor, for he then made a fervent appeal to the jury to at least find a verdict of guilty in the second degree, if the evidence is not beyond any reasonable doubt equal to the testimony of at least two credible witnesses. After nearly fifteen minutes' talk he closed by asserting that the testimony of at least four credible witnesses.
At the close of Mr. Olmstead's argument Buchholz, who had been listening very attentively throughout, gave way to his feelings to a certain extent and a few tears were noticed rolling down his cheeks, but with wonderful nerve he managed to control himself, and the proud prisoner allowed his tears to dry without recourse to his handkerchief, and when Mr. Olmstead finished, Buchholz had recovered his self-composure.
When General Smith arose to make the closing argument he first put his foot on the chair, and on the rest made by the upper part of his leg, leaned his arm, so as to be perfectly at ease, held a book containing the heads of the arguments. He had on a variation from his usual run of striped shirts, and on the one he wore to-day the stripes of blue shone resplendent. Later in the day, as he became warmed upon his argument, he kicked the chair aside, threw his book down, and walking about in the limited space he had, he proceeded with his argument, following the lead of his predecessor, and making an appeal for mercy and leniency toward the unfortunate young man who could not withstand the temptation to rob the body of a master who has been murdered and partially robbed by the murderers – possibly tramps as the accused has always said. In opening General Smith alluded first to the faulty indictment which had been made against the accused, and under which the accused could not possibly be convicted, as it is made as worthless as blank paper as the name John H. Schulte was not synonymous with that of Johann H. Schulte, the deceased, who was more known by any other than the latter name. He then alluded to the difficulties of the defense, particularly in this case, where there was combined against a single individual not only all the machinery of the state, but all the wealth of the Schulte estate; the power and wealth of the German government, represented by the German consul-general, supplemented by the services of the most subtle and complete detective agency in the country. He characterized the action of the states attorney as injudicious at least, and one that should be condemned, as he combined all his powers to not only deceive and entangle the prisoner, but also to prevent him from refusing confidence in his own attorneys, telling them the truth and enabling them to prepare the defense in a case where the life of the accused was at stake.
General Smith then entered into a discussion of the merits of the case, presenting first the theory of the state, as to the murder, which he presented in such a way as to show what he was pleased to call the absurdities of the state's case, and then repeating with more elaboration the theory of the defense which was yesterday presented by Mr. Bollman, and made a very strong showing. This part of his argument was made in narrative form, and told in a very pleasant way it being intolerated with argumentation explanations which brought out the claims of the defense. His theory of the robbery of the body differed from that of Mr. Buchholz in one respect, he claiming that at least a part of the robbery in all probability occurred at the time that Buchholz, Duigy [Dingee], and Sam Waring went down to the body just after the alarm was given. He read from the testimony of Waring, a witness for the state, to show that when the party arrived at the body that he found a pocket-book, which he described and which he handed to Buchholz and which the latter laid down when he was told to do so, by Mr. Delazen Allen. This he had ample opportunity to do while the party were standing about the body, with the little light that one lantern furnished, and while all were very much excited and rather frightened by the awful tragedy that had been enacted. While he was engaged in reading the report of the testimony from the minutes, Mr. Olmstead interrupted his argument by asking, "Will you read the rest of the testimony in relation to that pocket-book?"
"Certainly I will," replied General Smith, who then read along and stopped to emphasize the testimony by a bit of theorizing.
"Don't misrepresent the testimony," said Mr. Olmstead.
"What," said General Smith, "misrepresent testimony? Mr. Olmstead, you must not sit there and accuse me of willful falsification when I am reading the testimony as reported by the official reporters of the court, which are printed and lie on the table in front of you and from which you can read and see that I am reading correctly. Misrepresent testimony indeed! By and by I will go over your record in this respect, and we will see how you stand before the jury."
The court cautioned Mr. Olmstead that he must not interrupt the argument as he had done several times, and General Smith continued, showing how the second pocket-book was stolen from the body while it was being carried from the scene of the murder to the Waring house. The way in which this might have been done was very cleverly shown by these of a man's coat laid on the table, so as to show how it might have been extracted from the tail pocket of his overcoat. He claimed there was ample opportunity for the accused to have gone into the barn and hidden the money and then have rejoined the party, and he added, "there are many more than one man sitting in this room at the present time who, had they been cognizant of the facts, would have yielded to temptation as did William Buchholz, now accused of murder, because he yielded to temptation." After again alluding to the manner in which the state had pressed their case he said: "Gentlemen have pity on an unfortunate man who yielded to the temptation to obtain by theft a fortune. Because he did this the state by its representative steps in and says you are the murderer. It has been nothing but a persecution of that poor Dutchman. It has been States Attorney Olmstead against William Buchholz, rather than the state of Connecticut against the prisoner, and Mr. Olmstead hasn't given the prisoner a chance."
Yesterday’s Third Edition
The Trial of Buchholz.
General Smith then entered into an analysis of the testimony in its circumstantial character, and asked the jury to treat the circumstantial evidence of the defence in the support of their theory with as much consideration and weight as the entirely circumstantial evidence and vague theory of the state. After this he devoted some time to the matter of the time between 6:21, when Schulte left left Hercher's saloon, and the time 6:48, when Buchholz ran into the Waring house and gave notification of the murder, claiming that it would be impossible for the murder to have been committed in the time intervening between the two events. At this point a recess was taken for dinner.
At the afternoon hearing there was a larger attendance than of any other portion of the trial, there being probably 300 ladies in attendance. They occupied all the available standing and sitting room, and took in the trial as a matter of amusement as they would have done a wedding, christening, horticultural exhibition, funeral, or any other gathering which usually affords not only entertainment but fun to the average female, besides giving them an opportunity to display their dresses and hats, to advantage, which is quite a consideration.
When General Smith resumed his argument he began speaking of the thorough consistency of the theory of the defense that Buchholz was simply a robber and not a murderer – but that the murder had been committed by some other party that was cognizant of the fact that Schulte carried large sums of money on his person and was killed for this; the murderers not wishing to kill Buchholz but preferring to frighten him, wound him a little and then allow him to be suspected, so as to divert suspicion from the real perpetrators of the crime. He then showed by the testimony that the wound on the head which resulted in death could not have been made by an axe, but was in all probability made by the hatchet that was stolen from the telegraph line-man on the 17th of September.
It is thought that the trial will result in a disagreement of the jury, as the defense have made a good impression by their arguments, and have resulted in raising a doubt in the minds of the jury.
SECOND EDITION.
BUCHHOLZ CONVICTED.
-----------
MURDER IN THE FIRST DEGREE.
-----------
After Eighteen Hours Consultation the Jury Bring in a Verdict – All Night in the Court Room – Buchholz Completely Broken Down.
BRIDGEPORT, September 20. – At four o'clock yesterday afternoon Chief Justice Park who has occupied the bench with Judge Sanford, began charging the jury in the case of the State against William Buchholz. The charge occupied an hour and three-quarters, and was delivered in the muffled tones and the drawling manner which is characteristic of the rather ponderous manner of delivery which the chief justice has. He gave a long definition of the crime of homicide in its various branches, defined the laws of the state at some length, and then recited the facts in the case before the jury, dwelling at some length on the amount of testimony required to equal that of two creditable witnesses, which the law requires. He also expounded at some length the difference between a reasonable doubt and a possible doubt in the minds of the jurors. The charge was strongly in favor of the state and showed that the chief justice desired a verdict of murder in the first degree against the accused and took but little stock in the ingenious defense which had been prepared.
The court room was crowded to its utmost capacity all yesterday afternoon, ladies predominating; as many as a hundred of them standing throughout the four hours of the afternoon's hearing. They seemed to evince no fatigue in this rather tiresome manner of gratifying a morbid curiosity, and showed a wonderful ability in standing around, like the articles of vertu displayed on an etagere, and which partake of the ornamental rather than the useful. They certainly enlivened the appearance of the court room, and when the jury left it and the judges had gone to their room they relaxed from the necessary restraint, and as the older people and a majority of the men left the room, the crowd remaining disposed themselves as best they could, so as to derive the greatest possible comfort in the least possible space, while waiting for the verdict. Sitting in little groups, like a family circle, ladies and gentlemen gossiped about the chances of getting a verdict that night, asked all sorts of curious questions and became so charmed with the novelty of the situation and the freedom they could enjoy that the room was filled with a buzzing and humming that was strangely in contrast with the legal proceedings that had been in progress an hour before, when a man had been on trial for his life.
The frequent visits of the sheriff, or some of his deputies, to the jury-room, always created more or less excitement among the throng who ceased their almost incessant buzzing for an instant to remark: "There comes the jury." Just a shade of disappointment passed over their faces when the sheriff came out alone, or shut the door after having perhaps satisfied the wants of the juryman who had called him. This condition of affairs lasted until well into the evening, the audience thinning out gradually as the hours passed by without a word being heard from the jury. The ladies were the first to go, but some of them remained until after midnight, and at one o'clock this morning your representative counted nine of them sitting in the body of the court room, apparently determined to sit it out. They wandered away in pairs however, and by half past one the last remnant of female loveliness had departed, and it wasn't anything to boast of as a sample either. Then the court-room became nothing but a resting-place for a number of men who were either in the court-room from curiosity or because duty compelled them to do so. The former were the greater in number by a large majority, and as the crowd had thinned down, they either loafed about the room, where there was now plenty of room in which to stretch their legs or else occupying a couple of chairs composed themselves for such rest as they could obtain in such an uncomfortable position. The lawyers, officers and reporters, forgetting for the nonce their duties, drifted into a group and either in the court room, or in the judges' anti-room, forgot the excitement attendant upon the trial in a carnival of stories, gossip and small-talk in which Detective Pinkerton "carried off the palm," with his fund of anecdotes.
Early in the evening Buchholz looked pale but more composed than one would suppose a man could, and under such circumstances. Three German ladies who have been very attentive to him during the latter part of the trial, were with him and as the hours passed by and the probability of a disagreement became apparent, he chatted in a pleasant manner, and laughed with them, and seemed like anyone but a man over whose head hung a charge of murder. Late in the night and the early hours of the morning his spirits became very buoyant; he was very jovial, and putting a tube rose in his button-hole, was the observed of all who remained in court through the long hours of the night. At four o'clock this morning he was taken to the jail and allowed to get a little sleep, and at 8:30 this morning he was again brought to court and was very jolly. His lady friends brought him a bag of fruit and a bouquet, and he had a pleasant and familiar conversation with them until the jury brought in the fatal verdict, when he sank into his seat, completely overcome and gave way to a flood of tears, his sobs and groans being heard all over the court-room.
The jury went out at 5:45 and nothing was heard from them until 8 o'clock. At 7 o'clock Sheriff Sanford, by order of the court asked them if they wished their supper sent in, but they replied no, and said if they failed to agree within an hour they would call for supper. At 8 o'clock the sheriff was called, and suppers were ordered for the pause, and from the character of the meal ordered, oyster stews, it was thought by those in court either that the jurors had small appetites, or else did not expect to be long in consultation. In this latter speculation the speculators were wrong however, for not a word was heard from them until 9:30 o'clock this morning. The judges who waited in the ante room of court went home at four o'clock and went to bed, but were back in the court-room long before they were wanted. At 9:30 the knock on the jury door summoned Deputy Sheriff Bartram who admitted the jury to the courtroom. The judges were notified and on their arrival the roll of the jury was called. All answered to their names, and Chief Justice Park asked "Gentleman have you agreed upon a verdict?"
Foreman Robert Wilson replied "We have not."
They were asked if they desired instructions upon any particular point, and after some hesitation, it being apparent that the jury had disagreed and had evidently come in expecting to be discharged, the foreman replied that there was some doubt with some of the panel as to the degree of crime. There were ominous looks toward three of the jurors, and then Judge Park spoke of the able manner in which the case had been presented by the state and for the defense, and thought every point had been touched upon which they could possibly wish information upon. He then read them from the charge of yesterday a number of points relative to the crime of murder in its various forms, spoke of the expense that the trial had been to the state, that in case of a new trial greater expense might have to be incurred and the same facts presented to a new jury. He said that under the circumstances he was not disposed to discharge them, and if there was any point of law on which they wanted especial information he would give it to them.
It was stated that they did not fully comprehend the law in relation to the testimony which in a capital crime was required to be equal to that of two creditable witnesses. The law was read to them, Judge Park made a few explanations, and after plainly charging them to bring in a verdict of murder in the first degree, and telling them that they were judges of the law as well as the fact sent them out for further consultation.
At ten minutes before 12 there was a rap at the door, which was opened, and at five minutes of 12 the jury took their seats in the jury box. They looked sleepy and thoroughly tired out. At precisely 12 o'clock the judges entered the court-room and the clerk called the roll. The twelve answered to their names, and Judge Park asked, "Gentlemen have you agreed upon a verdict?"
The foreman – "We have."
The clerk – "Buchholz, stand up and look upon the foreman. Foreman look upon the prisoner. What is your verdict; guilty or not guilty?"
The foreman and prisoner faced one another. A stillness like that of death prevailed, and in a low but firm voice the foreman answered:
"Guilty of murder in the first degree."
The prisoner broke down in an instant, sank to his seat and burst into a flood of tears, his sobs and groans being audible in every part of the room and touching the hearts of all. Even those who had firmly believed in his guilt, and that his crime was one of the most horrible premeditated murders ever committed in the state.
General Smith asked that the jury be polled, but this request was not complied with, as being contrary to the rules of procedure in this state. He then gave notice of a motion in arrest of judgment, of a motion for a new trial and possibly of a motion in error. This notice was received and counsel for the accused was given until Tuesday noon to file their motion in arrest of judgment and until October 1st to file a motion for a new trial.
This ended the proceeding and the jury was dismissed after being thanked for the manner in which they had performed their duties. The court was then adjourned until Saturday, October 4, at 10:30 a. m. when arguments on the motions made by General Smith will be heard.
As General Smith left the court room he bade Buchholz good-bye, saying, "Good-bye, my boy; keep up good courage. You ain't hung yet."
The jury on the first ballot voted nine for murder in the first degree, one for murder in the second, with two blank ballots. Other ballots are not known, the jury having decided not to divulge them.
Why Buchholz Asks a New Trial.
The motion made by the counsel for Buchholz in arrest of judgment is based on the ground that every juror except Selleck Young talked with one Thomas Bour about the case during the progress of the trial. As to Young, he is alleged to have told a party on the cars that Buchholz was a fool to kill Schulte when he could have robbed him at any time by stealing and remaining away with his clothing. Young, it is also alleged, read the Bridgeport Standard daily throughout the progress of the trial. The motion also alleges the indictment to be insufficient in that the name was not properly given, and furthermore that no definite time as to the date of the murder, alleging that instead of reading, as it does, "December 27, 1878," it should read "in the year 1878," or "Anno Domini, 1878." Arguments are to be heard October 4.
The Grounds for a New Trial.
The grounds upon which a new trial is asked for Buchholz are as follows:
Because the court neglected to charge that no inference or presumption was to be made against the accused from his failure to testify in his own behalf.
That the deceased was incorrectly named in the indictment as John H. Schulte, when his name was really Johann Heinrich Schulte, and that there is, therefore, a fatal variance between the allegations and proof in the matter of the name.
That the court erred in charging the jury concerning the construction of the statute requiring the evidence of two full witnesses or its equivalent as proof of a crime punishable with death.
That the court in charging the jury misstated the claims of the defense as to the manner in which the accused secured possession of Schulte's pocket-books, and when requested by the counsel to correct the misstatement, failed to do so, but merely directed the jury's attention to the evidence.
That the court erred in not mentioning the defense's claim about the words alleged to have been spoken by Schulte to Buchholz the morning of the murder, although stating the state's claim on that point.
That the court erred in permitting the state attorney to peremptorily challenge three of the jury panel, Buchholz having been indicted before the statute which gives the state the right of as many challenges as the defense, had become a law.
That the court erred in admitting the state's expert testimony offered to prove that "John," the name by which the deceased was described in the indictment, was the English translation of "Johann."
The court erred in not charging that the question of whether the hair brush and some other articles found near the scene of the murder belonged to the prisoner was a question of fact for the jury to decide, assuming on the contrary that these articles belonged to the prisoner.
THE BUCHHOLZ JURY.
----------
Testimony Showing the Misdemeanors of those Who Convicted Him.
BRIDGEPORT, October 4. – This afternoon Judges Park and Sanford heard the testimony and arguments on the motion for a stay of proceedings in the case of the State vs. William Buchholz, who, two weeks ago to-day, was found guilty of murder in the first degree, being charged with the murder of John H. Schulte, at South Norwalk on the evening of December 27, 1878. The motion for the stay was made because counsel for the defense alleged that one of the jurymen, John R. Lockwood [Joseph], had at various times during the trial and before a verdict was rendered, talked with various parties in relation to the case, and that Selleck Young had read reports of the trial in the daily papers, and had, together with D. B. Bradley, another juror, taken their meals in a public saloon where they had heard conversations in regard to the trial.
In relation to the charges against Joseph R. Lockwood, Charles E. Wilmot, the town clerk, stated to the court that he had a conversation with Lockwood on the Thursday before the trial closed, and that Lockwood had spoken admiringly of the cool and collected manner in which Stark had testified; Frank P. Norman and Michael Sheridan had heard the conversation. Mrs. Jane L. Richardson testified that she heard Mr. Lockwood have a conversation in a horse car with another gentleman about the case, during which he stated to his companion, who had asked about the minds of the jury, "I made up my mind, the second day of the court, and I presume the rest of them have done so by this time." It was shown in testimony that the juryman had had a long conversation in Green's eating saloon with one Thomas Bour, in which Lockwood expressed an admiration for Mr. Bollman as an attorney, and talked for some time about the details of the case. Bour spoke of the necessity of having the testimony of two eye witnesses to convict a man of murder, and Lockwood said there was no necessity in a case like this, because the evidence was so strong that it was an easy matter to form an opinion. Constable David Dayton, Dr. Moses Pardee, Dr. W. O. Burke, jr., and Moses Pelham, all of South Norwalk, testified that they took their meals at Lee's dining saloon in a small room, where Jurors Young and Bradley ate, and that on several occasions there was talk about the trial, in the presence of the jurors, who made no objection to it. On one occasion attention was called to the impropriety, and Mr. Young replied, "I had a little rather you wouldn't talk about the trial," while Mr. Bradley said, "I can put cotton wool in my ears."
To offset this the state called the jurors, and Messrs, Young and Bradley testified that they never heard anything of the conversation that took place in the dining saloon where they ate. Mr. Lockwood acknowledged that he had had conversations as alleged, but claimed that he said nothing about having made up his mind before the case had been given to the jury. His conversations, he said, had been about the spectators and minor incidents in the court room and not at all about the case, or his opinion as to the guilt of the prisoners. This closed the testimony, which occupied nearly four hours in presentation.
General Smith first began by placing before the court the position of his client, poor and friendless, who came to the court charged with a capital crime, for a trial before a fair and impartial jury. The prisoner, a stranger in a strange land, came to court to find that he had been made a dupe of by the machinery of the state, which had put a man into collision with the accused and who under the guise of friendship wormed his way into the confidence of the prisoner and obtained his secret from him, that man being paid from the treasury of the state for his devilish work of worming into the man's friendship and then deceiving the counsel of the prisoner. He then spoke at some length of the necessity of a trial by a fair and impartial jury, men who are not professional jurymen and those who will abide by their oaths as jurymen, and not talk with anyone and everyone of the cases brought before them, or listen to the talk made by anyone in relation to the case on trial. If a man’s life is to be trusted in the hands of professional jurymen who either know how to get on a panel and get their $2 or $3 per day or innocently and casually run against a sheriff when he is out looking for talesmen, then the legislature should be asked to make a law which should compel the juryman to be kept where he cannot be prejudiced by outside influences. If this is not done, where can the poor man who is accused of crime obtain any justice or any chance for his life unless, as has been done in this case, kind friends having seen that the prisoner had been tried by a prejudiced and partial jury, inform his counsel of the fact and so give him the ground-work on which to base his application for such a trial as the sixth section of the constitution provides he may and shall have. In concluding he gave a number of authorities he desired the court to examine, touching on the points of tampering with the jury, and the misdemeanor of members of a jury. He made an earnest appeal to the court for justice in this case, and an honest trial which he had not had, owing to the fact that he had been tried by a chattering jury, whom it has been shown were talking to the general public, and had made up their minds before the trial was completed. He closed by defying the counsel for the state to find any decision by any court in the state which will substantiate their claim, and which will not clearly bear out the claims of the defense, and prove that the verdict should be overthrown and a new trial ordered.
Mr. Olmsted made no argument, merely offering the authorities in substantiation of his claim that the jurors had not in any way violated their oaths, and had not talked so as to invalidate the verdict they had given. He said the judges would be compelled to find either that the jurors had told the truth, or else that they had committed perjury willfully and maliciously, and he did not believe that any of the panel were men who would be guilty of any such crime, or men who would in anyway violate their oaths as jurymen.
Chief Justice Park after consultation, stated that the court would be unable to consult the authorities at present, and as they would be engaged after the early part of next week, he ordered the court adjourned to the morning of the 15th at 6 p. m., when judgment will be rendered.
THE SCHULTE MURDER.
----------
Story of the Finding of the Hatchet Thought to be the Fatal Weapon.
At the recent trial of Buchholz for the murder of John H. Schulte, a telegraph operator in Norwalk testified that a hatchet, a wrench, a vice, a pair of creepers and a coil of wire were stolen from him on the 16th day of December, eleven days before the murder; none of them have been found and the presumption in the minds of many was that the hatchet was used in the fatal assault on the miser of Roton Hill. Since the trial a hatchet was found in a tree near the barn in which Detective Stark found the stolen money, concealed there by Buchholz. The circumstances of the finding of the hatchet by Benj. M. Ayers, a real estate agent of Norwalk, are thus detailed: He was lead to search for the weapon as he did from reading the testimony of Stark, the detective, that Buchholz told him that "while he was at the barn he might as well – but that's too high up – you might get swimmy." From this he inferred that something might be concealed in the trees in the vicinity of the scene of the murder. On the nineteenth of September, Mr. Ayers, in company with a man and boy, went to the place where Schulte was killed, and after a short examination of the trees in the vicinity, Mr. Ayers discovered a squirrel's nest in one of them. This he examined, but found nothing. The next search was in a birch tree about forty feet north of the ambush, and about fifteen feet west of the path – near the point where the path crosses a sort of a miry gully or brook, and where blood was found on the stones. What attracted attention to this tree were notches cut into its trunk – five on one side and two on the other. Mr. Ayers attempted to go up first himself, but the lower limb gave way, and he sent up the boy, who went to almost the very top. The motion to the tree caused by his rising from one branch to another, just as he reached the highest point, dislodged the hatchet, and it fell to the ground. Mr. Ayers then went up and found where the hatchet had been placed in the crotch of some branches, and adhering to the spot was a short gray or bleached hair, and he also found another hair sticking to the hatchet. By adjusting the instrument to the place from which it had been dislodged, he found that while the upper and side surfaces of the weapon showed only rust and exposure, the under and sheltered portion of the head of the hatchet had marks on it which he believes to be blood.
The Buchholz trial for the murder of Schulte must be re-tried. The court has decided that the proceedings were vitiated because a juror conversed with an outsider during the trial of the case. This result is extremely unfortunate. It suggests one thing, however, and that is whether the laws regarding jurors in capital cases do not need a marked revision. If a verdict for the state, which has cost $10,000, more or less, can be destroyed because a juror converses with or is talked to by somebody regarding the case, then a common-sense view requires that the jurors should be kept in custody during the entire period of their deliberations. No juror should be permitted to run at large. The jury should be kept together, and under the oversight of the proper officers of the court, or else justice becomes a farce. In other states juries are quarantined against the outside public. A similar rule should prevail here, or else the rule which vitiates a verdict, because jurors talk about or are talked to about the case, should be abolished.
BUCHHOLZ'S GOOD LUCK.
----------
HE IS TO HAVE ANOTHER TRIAL.
----------
Because One of the Jurors Who Tried the Case Talked About it Before the Verdict Was Rendered – How the Prisoner Received the Announcement – His Lady Friend.
BRIDGEPORT, Oct. 16. – Last evening Jailer Wells brought Buchholz down from the jail to the superior court room. Six o'clock was the hour set for the decision upon the motion of arrest made by Buchholz's counsel just three weeks previous. The handcuffs were taken off the prisoner's wrists and he was given the freedom of the dock, while waiting for Chief-Justice Park and Judge Sanford to appear upon the bench and render their decision whether he should hang for the murder of John H. Schulte or be given another trial. He was neatly dressed in a suit of black which he wore during his trial in September, and though a trifle pale, did not show any of the terrible anxiety which the most stolid criminal must feel when waiting for a decision which will either sentence him to death or give him another chance for life. A letter was handed him and he read it slowly. Occasionally he glanced across the room to where a young German widow was sitting – presumably she was the writer of the letter. She was there the moment the court room opened and her face is familiar to all habitues of the place during the Buchholz trial; she has become infatuated with the condemned prisoner and most of the bouquets and billet doux that have cheered his cell have come from her. The court officials say it is a desperate case of love. During the long wait for the appearance of the judges the young lady sat in her seat with her eyes on the floor; but just before the judges came upon the bench she and her male companion, who looked as if he might have been a brother, left the room, probably with the intention of returning again in time to hear the decision.
Chief-Justice Park and Judge Sanford arrived in Bridgeport on the six o'clock train from New Haven, and came at once to the court house. They retired to the judge's room, and after a short consultation with State's Attorney Olmstead and General W. R. Smith, the prisoner's senior counsel, remained by themselves for two hours and a quarter. Neither they nor the lawyers who had gathered in the court room to witness the proceedings had had their supper, and the long delay excited much comment. It had been the intention of the judges to return to New Haven at 7:22; if they waited over that train, they must stay until one of the owl trains, or else remain in Bridgeport over night. Mr. Bollman, of the counsel for the defense, also expected to return by that train, but was compelled to wait over by the delay. When the hands of the clock indicated eight o'clock, and still the judges did not appear, it was rumored that they, like the jury in the case, had disagreed, and were going to hold another all night session; even State's Attorney Olmstead began to be worried; his train went at nine. It appeared strange that having had three weeks to decide the matter, the judges should need further time for consultation.
At twenty minutes past eight o'clock the judges appeared. Court was opened by the sheriff. Then came a long pause, during which every one held their breath. Buchholz gazed steadfastly at the judges, as if trying to read their faces. Then Chief Justice Park began speaking very deliberately and not raising his eyes from the palm-leaf fan which he held in his hand. "We have considered this motion for an arrest of judgment", he said "with a great deal of care knowing the great responsibility which rests upon us in deciding this matter. The constitution of the state guarantees to every man accused of a crime, a fair trial before a court and an impartial jury, and the fact is that in this case one of the jurors conversed in the cars, conversed in the town clerk's office, conversed in saloons, about this case and while it was on trial. He held a discussion to some extent with a man who took the part of the accused in the discussion against what the juror said. The juror argued to some extent in favor of his guilt, while the man to some extent argued his innocence. We have to consider whether the juror was competent to act on this case. We have come to the conclusion that he was not, and to set aside the verdict in this case, and to order a new trial. The verdict is set aside and a new trial ordered."
"You may adjourn court" said Judge Sanford, and the judge and spectator retired, a few gathering about Buchholz for a moment to congratulate him or his counsel, but the prisoner was handcuffed almost immediately and taken from the room. During the remarks of the chief justice he had intently eyed the speaker until the decision that one of the jurors was deemed incompetent was announced. Then his head dropped, the blood came into his face and his eyes filled with tears; when the judge had concluded he was wiping his eyes with his handkerchief. While the handcuffs were being put on his wrists he glanced hurriedly over the court room as if looking for his lady friend, but she had gone before the decision was announced.
Had the motion in arrest been denied by the court the lawyers for the defense would have relied upon the two other motions which they had made – one a motion for a new trial and the other a motion in error. The motion in arrest was based simply on the alleged misconduct of the juror Joseph Lockwood who was so foolish as to talk about the case while it was on trial; the motion for a new trial was based upon the same ground as well as the claim that the court wrongly charged the jury in several instances, particularly in regard to the name of the deceased – whether it was John H. Schulte or Johann H. Schulte. The motion in error rested upon an alleged error in the indictment in regard to a matter of time. Mr. Lockwood's misconduct consisted in conversing rather freely about the case in spite of the caution of the court. It was shown that at one time he stated that he had pretty much made up his mind, and believed that most of the other jurors had done the same, as early as the second day of the trial. He admitted having conversed about the case to many, but attempted to show that the witnesses to his offences overstated the facts; that he did not go so far as to express an opinion. But the witnesses were evidently disinterested ones, and the court seems to have come to the conclusion that his offence was sufficient to amount to a disqualification.