A FAMOUS CASE REVIEWED.
----------
THE TRIAL OF WILLIAM BUCHHOLZ.
----------
Three Times Arraigned for the Murder of John H. Schulte – The Prisoner's Admission to a Pinkerton Detective Who Gains His Confidence in Prison. Buchholz's Petition for Pardon from a Life Sentence Fails.
----------
The trial of William Buchholz for the murder of John Henry Schulte at South Norwalk in 1878 was a celebrated case. Attorney Charles F. Bollmann of this city defended Buchholz in the three trials that he had for his life and gained considerable notoriety therefor. The board of pardons which met at Hartford on Monday, December 4, heard Buchholz's petition for pardon from a life sentence in state prison, but it was not granted. Attorney Bollmann, because of his familiarity in the case, was requested to appear for Buchholz at the hearing, but being a state prison director, he felt compelled to decline, and Attorney William A. Wright was selected instead. Mr. Wright requested Mr. Bollmann to prepare a statement of the case for presentation at the hearing. He complied with the request, prepared the paper with great care and at the expenditure of considerable time and read it before the board of pardons. The statement follows:
William Buchholz is in the Connecticut state prison on a life sentence for the murder of John Henry Schulte. The murder occurred on Friday, Dec. 27, 1878, at about 6:45 p.m. in a piece of woods at Roton Hill, South Norwalk, Conn., about 1 2-5 miles south of the South Norwalk railroad depot. Buchholz was put in charge of a constable the day after the murder, but for a week or more thereafter was allowed to go about town in company of his guard and do pretty much as he saw fit.
In connection with Schulte's murder a coroner's inquest was held at South Norwalk which lasted from the night of the murder, Dec. 27, 1878, till Feb. 10, 1879. Justice Craw acted as coroner; six summoned jurors, and the then state's attorney, James Olmstead, assisted him. At the close of the long inquest a verdict was returned that "Schulte was killed by a person or persons known to William Buchholz, and that Buchholz had guilty knowledge of the murder." During the first part of this inquest Lawyer Austin of South Norwalk, acted as Buchholz's counsel; but at an early stage Attorney Charles F. Bollmann, at the suggestion of the German consul general in New York, took charge of the defence, and subsequently, together with Gen. William Randell Smith of South Norwalk, was Buchholz's counsel throughout all the proceedings connected with said murder.
There was no preliminary hearing before a justice, as is customary, after the inquest, – but a bench warrant issued by the state's attorney charged Buchholz with the crime and took him immediately to the Bridgeport jail and to the superior court.
On February 26, 1879, the grand jury returned a true bill in the case. During the deliberations of this body, it reported to the court (Judge Loomis) that its members entertained different opinions in the case and desired to be instructed, "to whom – if a doubt as to probable cause existed – the benefit of that doubt should be given, whether to the prisoner or to the state." After an answer from the court the grand jury reported a "true bill."
The first trial took place at Bridgeport before Judges Park and Sanford and a jury. It lasted from September 9, 1879, till September 20, 1879. It furnished the great sensation, that at the end of the state presentation of the case, to the surprise of everybody but the state attorney, a Pinkerton detective testified to a confession to him by Buchholz in consequence of which the detective was enabled to lay over $86,000 in cash before the court and jury. The jury was out 18 hours and returned a verdict of murder in the first degree.
On Oct. 15, 1879, on a motion in arrest of judgment, and after a lengthy hearing, Judges Park and Sanford set aside the jury's verdict on the ground of misconduct on the part of several jurors. While the case was on trial several jurors had discussed the merits of the case publicly with outsiders and one juror had been to the scene of the murder and had investigated on his own account.
The second trial took place before Judges Park and Loomis and a jury. It commenced Feb. 19, 1880, and ended March 18, 1880, with a disagreement on the part of the jury. The jury was out, (locked in) from the morning of the 15th till noon of the 18th, reported several times that it could not agree, and was finally discharged.
In the third trial Judges Beardsley and Culver presided. It lasted from April 13, 1880, till May 7, 1880. After the charge by Judge Beardsley the jury had the case under consideration for two days and two nights, reported four times that they could not agree, were sent back, asked for instructions on the point of "reasonable doubt" – and as to the difference between first and second degree of murder and the evidence necessary for either – and eventually returned a verdict of murder in the second degree. This ended the long legal contest. Buchholz was sentenced to imprisonment for life in the Connecticut state prison.
The following are the main circumstances surrounding the case: William Buchholz was born in Schwichelt, province of Hanover, Germany, in 1854; his father, a veterinary surgeon, gave him a liberal education. He for a time studied with a view of becoming an agriculturist, then served for four years in the Brunswick Black Hussars, in time of peace, and finally came to the United States. He landed in New York August 17, 1878, (four months before the murder) – put up at the Sonne hotel, an emigrant boarding-house on Pearl street, and for about a month and a half looked for employment, but unsuccessfully.
About six weeks later than Buchholz, viz .: September 27, 1878, John Henry Schulte arrived in New York from Germany and put up at the same hotel where Buchholz was then still stopping. He brought with him from Germany a German servant. Schulte, then about 60 years old, was an old bachelor, a German peasant, who by a series of lucky speculations in land in a district (Westphalia) where new mines were being started and a new railroad was being built, had in a short time become quite rich. He was worth over $500,000. He had an only brother, also a rich land owner in Westphalia.
During the stay of Schulte at the Sonne hotel, in the notorious "Five Points" of New York, his servant made it pretty generally known to those in the hotel that his master carried immense sums of money always on his person, and on one occasion the proprietor and others had seen Schulte transfer a large number of bills from one wallet to another and then place the wallets in his pockets.
This servant had talked to several of the boarders of his intention of leaving Schulte, whom he called crazy, and he secretly left his master just before the latter was about to quit the hotel. Buchholz, on learning this, approached Schulte and was 'by him engaged as servant and travelling companion. Subsequently the following queer contract was drawn up by Schulte and signed by him and his new servant Buchholz. Part of it is as unintelligible in the original German as it is in the English translation. It read as follows:
"The following contract was made to-day between William Buchholz and the "proprietor of baronial estates" H. Schulte of Cologne: Mr. Schulte takes William Buchholz as servant, the same to accompany him wherever he requires to, though Mr. Schulte may travel alone. William Buchholz receives for this a monthly salary of ten marks, for washing three marks also free board and a small room. William Buchholz agrees to occupy towards Mr. Schulte the position which will indicate that Mr. Schulte is his superior. The same has to do some small services as far as it is in his power, which must not be of a degrading nature. He also agree not to make any debts to Mr. Schulte's injury and to be perfectly honest. Theft shall be cause for instant dismissal. Should the parties not be able to agree, they may give one month's notice. Mr. Schulte will be master and be able to accept? of an inferior class, also the man be permitted that his shoe soles may be touched!"
(Under this last part Schulte later on claimed the right to kick Buchholz.)
From October 7, 1878, till Schulte's death, the latter and Buchholz lived on a little farm on Roton Hill, in South Norwalk They shared the same house with a family named Waring, consisting of Mrs. Waring, her grown up son, Sam, and two grown up daughters. Mr. Waring, the elder, did not live there, but lived in New York or its vicinity. This place on Roton Hill Schulte had previously bought, and at the time of the purchase had surprised those present at it by paying $5,000 cash down, and by showing that he carried many times $5,000 on his person. This fact and similar circumstances soon became generally known in South Norwalk, and caused people to talk of the old German as the "walking gold mine."
On the day when the murder occurred, Schulte left his home about 7 o'clock in the morning, telling the Warings and Buchholz that he was going to New York; that he expected to return on the same day, either on the 4 or 6:11 p.m. train, and that he wanted Buchholz to escort him home from the station.
Buchholz spent the entire forenoon in the house with the Waring family, part of the time taking a lesson in English from a teacher by the name of Ellendorf. At noon he escorted Mr. Waring to Five Mile River station and back, then again remained in the house till a little after 3 p. m., when he started for the South Norwalk station in obedience to Schulte's directions. Mrs. Waring had agreed to go with him, but at the last moment she changed her mind, and in spite of the invitations remained at home. Some time before 4 p.m., Buchholz reached the railroad station and remained in the sight of Gustave Pitzer and others from then until after the train, which brought Schulte, had come in, staying partly in Pitzer's rooms, partly in the billiard rooms of Paul Hercher in the same building, in the immediate vicinity of the station. When the 4:04 p.m and 4:18 p.m. trains from New York came in, Buchholz went over to the station, but as neither of them brought Schulte he returned to Hercher's and Pitzer's.
Schulte returned on the 6:11 p.m. train and Buchholz met him at the cars. After a stay of from 10 to 20 minutes at Hercher's restaurant, where the old German treated himself and his servant to a bottle of beer each, both started for home by way of the track. Buchholz carried two hams and a carpet bag containing other things Schulte had bought in New York. The servant walked a short distance ahead – a mode of walking which the old gentleman always enforced with this as well as with his former servants. Thus they were seen by various persons along the track.
At 6:50 p.m., one of the Waring girls being alone in the upper parts of the house, heard loud shouts; they came from the direction of the path which led from the railroad track westerly through a piece of woods and the home lot to Schulte's house and which path was about 1,200 feet long. The girl recognized the voice of Buchholz and called down to her folks below: "Mother, William is shouting." Almost immediately after that Buchholz rushed or fell into the house. In an excited manner and in extremely broken English he gave them to understand that both he and Schulte had been attacked in the piece of woods between the railroad and their house. He hurriedly got his revolver and urged Sam. Waring to hasten into the woods with him to look for Schulte. As Sam., however, inclined to the advice of his mother and sisters to first alarm the neighbors, all five soon started for Mr. Allen's house near by. Here, reenforced by Mr. Allen and one or two more, the men, including Buchholz, started for the path in the woods.
On the path, about half way between the track and Schulte's house they found the dead body of the old German, lying on the back and bleeding from two large wounds in the head. His coats and vests were unbuttoned, the inner coat pocket and pantaloons pockets were turned inside out and two books and several papers were lying scattered near the body. About 60 feet nearer to the house than the body were found the hams which Buchholz had carried; at this spot Buchholz claimed to have been attacked. It was just before he had reached a stone wall at the westerly edge of the woods. About 50 feet north of where the dead body lay, an old revolver and a new pair of light colored overalls were found. The wounds and cuts in the dead man's hat showed that to commit the murder an instrument like a hatchet had been used. Without disturbing the body or its surroundings the entire party left to notify the proper authorities at South Norwalk.
Several hours later Coroner William T. Craw, with six jurors and with Dr. Pardee, followed by quite a number of other persons, arrived at the spot where the murder had been committed and where its victim still lay. By the aid of one or two lanterns, an empty coin-bag, Schulte's diary and other articles lying near the body were picked up and then the body was removed to the house, four or more men carrying at a time, and they changed off with others several times before the house was reached. At first it was doubted whether Buchholz had assisted in carrying, but it was finally proved that he had been the chief carrier. At the house the body was stripped and examined. No other wounds than the two on the head were discovered. Each garment was examined and in an inner vest pocket about $20,000 in German 1,000 mark bills and $900 in United States greenbacks were found, and taken in charge by the foreman of the jury (Mr. Stillson). This sum, which was contained in a large extra strong envelope, was evidently overlooked at the time of the murder and robbery. The absence of the gold watch, of the contents of the coin bag out of which Schulte had made payment at Hercher's that evening, the fact that several pockets had their lining turned inside out, that the diary, several letters and papers and other small valueless articles which Schulte had probably carried in his pockets, were found scattered around the body, that the coats and vest were found unbuttoned and similar circumstances left no doubt that whoever had killed the old man had also, at least partially, robbed the dead body.
The inquest lasted about six weeks. Buchholz testified, as he had stated before, that when he was approaching the stone fence at the westerly edge of the woods and while 60 feet ahead of his master he heard the latter cry out in a terrified manner, "Buchholz, Buchholz," that he then turned, dropped the hams he was carrying to hasten to Schulte, at the same moment saw the outline of a man near him and received a stinging blow or cut on the left side of his face. That he then with the carpet bag still in his hand ran to the house as fast as he could, shouting “Sam." and “help" all the way. His face that evening showed a slight swelling and an insignificant cut or two.
Although placed in charge of a constable, Buchholz for a number of days was allowed to move and do as he pleased. He had money and spent it freely, treating his guard and others to drinks, cigars and even a sleigh ride; he also made some purchases in the line of dress, etc., for himself; in doing this he changed several $20 bills. He also sent two $20 bills to the proprietor of the Sonne hotel in New York where he owed $35 for his board. It was ascertained that he had in his possession over $400, mainly in $20 bills. He claimed this money as honestly his own, but the various explanations which he made as to how he got this money were all proved false. Among Schulte's papers was found a list showing the denominations and the numbers of the bills which Schulte owned. All the bills which Buchholz had spent were traced and it was found that their numbers were all contained on Schulte's list.
Not only were the numbers of all the bills spent by Buchholz on that list, but the bills all showed a private heavy ink mark likewise to be seen on the bills still found by the coroner's jury in the vest pocket package, This was practically all the known evidence against Buchholz when the coroner's jury found that "he had guilty knowledge of the murder and that he knew who had committed it." And on this evidence Buchholz was arrested for the crime on a bench warrant and the grand jury found a true bill.
While Buchholz was in the Bridgeport jail awaiting his trial, the, state attorney managed to get into that same jail a shrewd Pinkerton detective, Ernst Stark – then called Ernst Sommers – apparently as a prisoner. By an understanding with the New York Pinkerton office, the manager of Adams Express company at Bridgeport, some time in March, 1879, caused the arrest of Stark on the "fabricated" charge of having attempted to obtain a money package from said company on a forged order. Stark waived a hearing in the Bridgeport police court, and, duping the police, prosecuting attorney, judge and jailer,was bound over and placed in jail, where he was near Buchholz for about two months. This detective, a fellow German – in spite of frequent and strong warnings to Buchholz from his counsel – soon became the warmest friend of Buchholz. To him he confessed that he had stolen from his dead master's body, while assisting in carrying it from the woods to the house in the dark of that night, two wallets filled with money, which Schulte, as Buchholz knew, habitually carried in the skirt pockets of his coat and which the murderers had overlooked in their necessarily hasty search for plunder. That while carrying and supporting the middle of the body he accidentally discovered the presence of the wallets and unseen transferred them to his own overcoat pockets. That when the carrying party approached the barn near Schulte's house, he managed to get relieved and without being observed to slip into the barn. That there he hurriedly took a number of bills (the money about which he had been questioned so much at the inquest), and concealed the rest under the boarded floor of the barn, returning to the party without having been missed. As to the matter of killing Schulte he, however, often and most earnestly protested to the detective that he was entirely innocent; that he had no idea who did the killing, and that the attack on himself had been as real as that on his master.
When at the first trial in Bridgeport the state had apparently finished the presentation of its evidence, and when everything looked hopeful in the extreme for the defense, then to the great surprise of Buchholz, and much more so of his counsel, that detective took the witness stand, told of the statement made to him by the accused and placed before the astonished court and jury over $86,000 in cash money, which he, in consequence of the prisoner's confession to him, had found under the floor of Schulte's barn.
At the opening of the trial the main object of the defence had been to have ruled out as evidence that money list of the old German, and the latter part of Buchholz's testimony about his money, given at the inquest after (unknown to Buchholz) a warrant for his arrest had been placed into the hands of his guard, to be used in case of an emergency. At a hearing before the judges in the absence of a jury, both these points had been decided favorably to the defence, and it then seemed that the state could not possibly make out a case against the accused. But Stark's unexpected testimony had suddenly changed the situation and it now looked as if nothing could save the prisoner.
To Buchholz's counsel the situation was trying in the extreme. There was little time to deliberate and the life of Buchholz probably depended on their action. The cross-examination of Stark already showed the course decided upon. The detective's testimony was made the groundwork for the defence, it was all accepted as true, to him Buchholz had told the whole truth. He had taken part of the money which his escape and his loud calls for help had caused the real murderers to overlook. To substantiate this a number of witnesses were called.
The first servant and others testified that in spite of the $20,900 found in Schulte's vest by the coroner's jury, and $86,000 taken by Buchholz and recovered by Stark, there was still missing the contents of the bag of coins and the contents of a third (yellow) wallet which Schulte habitually carried in his inside coat pocket. Banker Bischoff of New York testified that on the afternoon of the murder, Schulte had received from him and had placed in that yellow wallet $850 in certain bills which were neither among the money discovered by the coroner's jury nor in that shown in court by Stark. It was shown by others that Schulte habitually carried much money in that yellow wallet, and it was claimed that the murderers, owing to Buchholz's escape from them, made only a very hurried search for money and thought they had all when they had the coin bag and the yellow wallet. Also that if Buchholz had committed the murder, he could have taken as much time as he saw fit; he would certainly have found the $20,900 in the inside vest pocket, and would probably not have bothered about the coins. The fact that the assassin or assassins left the sum of more than $20,000 made it appear probable that they likewise overlooked the large sum in the shirt pockets of the dead man – a place where people are not generally supposed to carry their money. "Where is that yellow wallet?" became an important question which was never answered.
But at such short notice, and under the influence and sensation furnished by the detective, the defence could not satisfactorily establish that Buchholz had actually helped to carry the dead body. The few persons then in court who were in a position to shed light on this point did not give very positive testimony. The fact that Buchholz was the last known person to have been with Schulte, and his possession of so much of Schulte's money weighed much against him. The jury was out 18 hours and returned a verdict of murder in the first degree.
The verdict was set aside on account of misconduct on the part of the jury and a second as well as a third trial followed. In them it was fully proved and conceded that Buchholz assisted in carrying home the body of his master and thus had an opportunity to rob the corpse. Entries in Schulte's diary, showing that two attacks had been made on him in Germany, the defence did not succeed to have admitted as evidence. (The diary showed that the second attack was made two days before Schulte started on his final trip to the United States. Shots were fired through the window into his bedroom on his estate at Hagen at night while he was asleep in the room. But having changed the location of his bed the evening before, he was not injured. The diary stated further that the investigation he caused to be made satisfied him that his illegitimate son was the, or of the, firing party). Schulte's will, made Dec. 5, 1874, was read in evidence. It showed, so it was claimed, that Schulte had reason to fear a violent, premature death, also that he had considerable trouble about and with an illegitimate son who had now reached the age of manhood. The will read as follows:
"In case I leave this life before my time, I hereby give my whole estate to my only surviving brother, the proprietor, F. W. Schulte of Grossenholthansen. In case my said brother should die before me, then I leave all my property to my next of kin.
I leave this world, conscious of having always acted right, and fulfilled my duty, and not feeling any remorse for ignoring and annulling in this will, the legal validity and consequences of the decree of the county court at Hagen, dated December 18. 1861, judicially declaring me the father of a bastard, as well as the other decrees rendered against me. December 5, 1874"
"JOH. HEINR. SCHULTE."
There was other testimony. It appeared that Schulte had his home in Germany, partly in Hagen, partly in Cologne. It was proved that Moritz Abel of Cologne, a man having a bad record, landed in New York from Hamburg November 20, 1878, stopped a short time in New York, then in Bridgeport, and four days before the killing of Schulte engaged board at Schaub's boarding house in South Norwalk, close to the station and in plain view of it and the track south of it – the best possible place from which to watch Schulte's movements. Abel had no work or business, and did not look for any. He spent his time mostly in reading the papers and playing cards in the saloon connected with his boarding house. The inquest in the Schulte case was held but a few feet across the street from this young German's boarding house; it naturally drew many spectators, but he never went to it, nor did he ever make it known that the dead man had been his townsman. He eagerly read the newspaper statements concerning the murder, but did not talk about it. In March, 1879, just after the discovery of some evidence, which the defence claimed showed it was "planted," Abel mysteriously disappeared. His name and his suspected connection with the murder soon appeared in many American and European papers, the authorities, particularly in Germany, tried hard to locate him, but all in vain to the present day.
In the forepart of the afternoon of the murder, several reliable witnesses, among them Farmer Stephen Ostrander of South Norwalk and Daniel L. Millard, then principal of a Brooklyn, N.Y., public school, saw three strangers, talking a foreign language, act suspiciously in the woods near the track and within a few hundred feet of the spot where Schulte, only a few hours later was killed. They were putting overalls and poor clothes over better ones; two of them were plainly seen but the third managed to conceal his face and front from both witnesses. The appearance of neither was like that of Buchholz.
Two Messrs. Wilcox, who then lived close to the bridge over the track at a point about 3,400 feet south of the South Norwalk railroad station, testified that two strangers with new overalls on (and corresponding in person and dress with two of the men seen by Messrs. Ostrander and Millard), about 4 p. m. that same day appeared several times on that bridge and from there seemed to watch the trains coming from New York. One of these witnesses called the attention of Young Eli Savage, living near by, to these strangers, and Savage, as well as the Wilcoxs, subsequently testified that the overalls found near the scene of the murder were of the same appearance as those then worn by one of the strangers. On the forenoon of the same day the younger Wilcox had seen the same two strangers, then without overalls, come from the direction of the depot and go down the track toward the Schulte farm.
When the train from New York which was due at South Norwalk at 6:11 p.m., and which brought Schulte, had just passed under said bridge, the same Eli Savage, a dentist's clerk, saw something white flutter from the train and saw a man step out from the bushes near the lower part of the bridge and go toward where he (Savage) had seen something white flutter. Walking on, Savage was asked by this man about the distance to the next stations towards New York. Savage recognized in him one of the strangers pointed out to him before by the Wilcoxs. He still had white overalls on and had in his hand something like a switch or riding whip with which he kept striking his overalls; once he struck the rail with it and there was a metallic sound which impressed Savage that it was wire.
Theodore Stone of South Norwalk, testified that shortly after 7 o'clock on the evening of the murder he saw a stranger run very fast on the track near that bridge – running in a direction from that bridge towards the depot. The defense inferred this was probably Abel.
At Stamford, Conn., about nine miles southerly from South Norwalk, at 10:15 p.m. on the same day, Conductor Edwin M. Hunt (who testified), took on board of his train two strangers, foreigners, and in his opinion Germans, who in person and dress, excepting overalls, seemed to be identical with the strangers testified to by the Wilcoxs' and Ostrander and Millard. They both seemed to have run hard, they were perspiring and out of breath, neither had a ticket, although the ticket office was open, each paid his fare on the train and they separated, each sitting in a different car. When the conductor heard about the murder he promptly gave information about what he knew of these two passengers.
The foregoing statement contains the main facts in the Buchholz case as they appeared to his counsel. The latter claimed that they were sufficient to at least beget in the minds of the jurors that reasonable doubt as to his guilt of the murder which would have warranted an acquittal on that charge. It became evident that in each trial part of the jury, for a time at least, had this doubt, but that part "gave in" to the other part, except in the second trial.
After the judge's charge in the second trial the jury was kept together for three days and three nights, but could not agree and had to be discharged.
In the third trial the jurors were locked up in their room two days and two nights, reported four times that they could not agree, and finally brought in a verdict of murder in the second degree, which meant imprisonment for life.
There is good reason to believe that this agreement was finally reached, because that part of the jury which was most favorable to Buchholz, became convinced that, in case of an acquittal or another disagreement, the prisoner would then be charged with the confessed robbery and receive the maximum penalty, 20 years' imprisonment, for that crime, and that there was little practical difference between imprisonment for 20 years and for life.
----------
Within a few days of Schulte's death, an uncle of Buchholz died at Schwichelt leaving Buchholz a legacy of 3,000 thalers, (about $2,100.) This, by the will, was payable a year after the uncle's death, and the executor at first declined to pay it sooner. To overcome this difficulty and to have this money of Buchholz here in time to be of benefit to him in his trials, he assigned this legacy to one of his counsel, who went to Germany and succeeded in bringing with him the money, and with this the expenses of the defence were defrayed.